arXiv++ Combinatorics

We consider the probability that the random signed sum $ξ_1 v_1 + \dotsb + ξ_n v_n$ lies within a given distance $r$ of the origin, where $v_1,\dotsc,v_n \in \mathbb{R}^d$ are fixed unit vectors and $ξ_1,\dotsc,ξ_n$ are independently and uniformly distributed on $\{-1,+1\}$. In particular, our results demonstrate that, for certain values of $r$, the infimum of this probability is very sensitive to the parity of $n$. We prove that, for any $d\geq 3$, there is some $\varepsilon = \varepsilon(d) > 0$ such that for any $n \not\equiv d \mod 2$ and unit vectors $v_1,\dotsc,v_n\in \mathbb{R}^d$, there are signs $η_1,\dotsc,η_n \in \{-1,+1\}$ such that $\|\sum_{i=1}^n η_i v_i\| \leq \sqrt{d - \varepsilon}$, and so $\mathbb{P}(\| ξ_1 v_1 + \dotsb + ξ_n v_n \| \leq \sqrt{d-\varepsilon}) > 0$. This is in contrast to the case of $n\equiv d \mod 2$, wherein the above probability can be zero. More is known if $d=2$ and $n$ is odd, and in this case we present a construction demonstrating that $\mathbb{P}(\|ξ_1 v_1 + \dotsb + ξ_n v_n\| \leq 1)$ can decay exponentially as $n$ increases.

The semirandom graph process constructs a graph $G$ in a series of rounds, starting with the empty graph on $n$ vertices. In each round, a player is offered a vertex $v$ chosen uniformly at random, and chooses an edge on $v$ to add to $G$. The player's aim is to make $G$ satisfy some property as quickly as possible. Our interest is in the property that $G$ contain a given $n$-vertex graph $H$ with maximum degree $Δ$. In 2021, Ben-Eliezer, Gishboliner, Hefetz and Krivelevich showed that there is a semirandom strategy that achieves this, with probability tending to 1 as $n$ tends to infinity, in $(1 + o_Δ(1)) \frac{3 Δn}{2}$ rounds, where $o_Δ(1)$ is a function that tends to $0$ as $Δ$ tends to infinity. We improve this to $(1 + o_Δ(1)) \frac{Δn}{2}$, which can be seen to be asymptotically optimal in $Δ$. We show the same result for a variant of the semirandom graph process, namely the semirandom tree process introduced by Burova and Lichev, where in each round the player is offered the edge set of a uniformly chosen tree on $n$ vertices, and chooses one edge to keep.

We analyse the performance of Belief Propagation Guided Decimation, a physics-inspired message passing algorithm, on the random $k$-XORSAT problem. Specifically, we derive an explicit threshold up to which the algorithm succeeds with a strictly positive probability $Ω(1)$ that we compute explicitly, but beyond which the algorithm with high probability fails to find a satisfying assignment. In addition, we analyse a thought experiment called the decimation process for which we identify a (non-) reconstruction and a condensation phase transition. The main results of the present work confirm physics predictions from [RTS: J. Stat. Mech. 2009] that link the phase transitions of the decimation process with the performance of the algorithm, and improve over partial results from a recent article [Yung: Proc. ICALP 2024].

We study the 2-offer semirandom 3-uniform hypergraph model on $n$ vertices. At each step, we are presented with 2 uniformly random vertices. We choose any other vertex, thus creating a hyperedge of size 3. We show a strategy that constructs a perfect matching, and another that constructs a loose Hamilton cycle, both succeeding asymptotically almost surely within $Θ(n)$ steps. Both results extend to $s$-uniform hypergraphs. The challenges with hypergraphs, and our methods, are qualitatively different from what has been seen for semirandom graphs. Much of our analysis is done on an auxiliary graph that is a uniform $k$-out subgraph of a random bipartite graph, and this tool may be useful in other contexts.

We show that with high probability we can build a Hamilton cycle after at most $1.85 n$ rounds in a particular semi-random model. In this model, in one round, we are given a {uniform random} $v\in[n]$ and then we can add an {arbitrary} edge $\{v,w\}$. Our result improves on $2.016 n$ in a recent paper of Gao, MacRury, and Pralat.

The Ising antiferromagnet is an important statistical physics model with close connections to the {\sc Max Cut} problem. Combining spatial mixing arguments with the method of moments and the interpolation method, we pinpoint the replica symmetry breaking phase transition predicted by physicists. Additionally, we rigorously establish upper bounds on the {\sc Max Cut} of random regular graphs predicted by Zdeborová and Boettcher [Journal of Statistical Mechanics 2010]. As an application we prove that the information-theoretic threshold of the disassortative stochastic block model on random regular graphs coincides with the Kesten-Stigum bound.

Consider a complete graph $K_n$ with edge weights drawn independently from a uniform distribution $U(0,1)$. The weight of the shortest (minimum-weight) path $P_1$ between two given vertices is known to be $\ln n / n$, asymptotically. Define a second-shortest path $P_2$ to be the shortest path edge-disjoint from $P_1$, and consider more generally the shortest path $P_k$ edge-disjoint from all earlier paths. We show that the cost $X_k$ of $P_k$ converges in probability to $2k/n+\ln n/n$ uniformly for all $k \leq n-1$. We show analogous results when the edge weights are drawn from an exponential distribution. The same results characterise the collectively cheapest $k$ edge-disjoint paths, i.e., a minimum-cost $k$-flow. We also obtain the expectation of $X_k$ conditioned on the existence of $P_k$.

In a complete graph $K_n$ with edge weights drawn independently from a uniform distribution $U(0,1)$ (or alternatively an exponential distribution $\operatorname{Exp}(1)$), let $T_1$ be the MST (the spanning tree of minimum weight) and let $T_k$ be the MST after deletion of the edges of all previous trees $T_i$, $i<k$. We show that each tree's weight $w(T_k)$ converges in probability to a constant $γ_k$ with $2k-2\sqrt k <γ_k<2k+2\sqrt k$, and we conjecture that $γ_k = 2k-1+o(1)$. The problem is distinct from that of Frieze and Johansson (2018), finding $k$ MSTs of combined minimum weight, and for $k=2$ ours has strictly larger cost. Our results also hold (and mostly are derived) in a multigraph model where edge weights for each vertex pair follow a Poisson process; here we additionally have $\mathbb E(w(T_k)) \to γ_k$. Thinking of an edge of weight $w$ as arriving at time $t=n w$, Kruskal's algorithm defines forests $F_k(t)$, each initially empty and eventually equal to $T_k$, with each arriving edge added to the first $F_k(t)$ where it does not create a cycle. Using tools of inhomogeneous random graphs we obtain structural results including that $C_1(F_k(t))/n$, the fraction of vertices in the largest component of $F_k(t)$, converges in probability to a function $ρ_k(t)$, uniformly for all $t$, and that a giant component appears in $F_k(t)$ at a time $t=σ_k$. We conjecture that the functions $ρ_k$ tend to time translations of a single function, $ρ_k(2k+x)\toρ_\infty(x)$ as $k \to \infty$, uniformly in $x\in \mathbb R$. Simulations and numerical computations give estimated values of $γ_k$ for small $k$, and support the conjectures just stated.

We consider "unconstrained" random $k$-XORSAT, which is a uniformly random system of $m$ linear non-homogeneous equations in $\mathbb{F}_2$ over $n$ variables, each equation containing $k \ge 3$ variables, and also consider a "constrained" model where every variable appears in at least two equations. Dubois and Mandler proved that $m/n=1$ is a sharp threshold for satisfiability of constrained 3-XORSAT, and analyzed the 2-core of a random 3-uniform hypergraph to extend this result to find the threshold for unconstrained 3-XORSAT. We show that $m/n=1$ remains a sharp threshold for satisfiability of constrained $k$-XORSAT for every $k \ge 3$, and we use standard results on the 2-core of a random $k$-uniform hypergraph to extend this result to find the threshold for unconstrained $k$-XORSAT. For constrained $k$-XORSAT we narrow the phase transition window, showing that $n-m \to \infty$ implies almost-sure satisfiability, while $m-n \to \infty$ implies almost-sure unsatisfiability.

We consider "unconstrained" random $k$-XORSAT, which is a uniformly random system of $m$ linear non-homogeneous equations in $\mathbb{F}_2$ over $n$ variables, each equation containing $k \geq 3$ variables, and also consider a "constrained" model where every variable appears in at least two equations. Dubois and Mandler proved that $m/n=1$ is a sharp threshold for satisfiability of constrained 3-XORSAT, and analyzed the 2-core of a random 3-uniform hypergraph to extend this result to find the threshold for unconstrained 3-XORSAT. We show that $m/n=1$ remains a sharp threshold for satisfiability of constrained $k$-XORSAT for every $k\ge 3$, and we use standard results on the 2-core of a random $k$-uniform hypergraph to extend this result to find the threshold for unconstrained $k$-XORSAT. For constrained $k$-XORSAT we narrow the phase transition window, showing that $m-n \to -\infty$ implies almost-sure satisfiability, while $m-n \to +\infty$ implies almost-sure unsatisfiability.

It is well known that there is a sharp density threshold for a random $r$-SAT formula to be satisfiable, and a similar, smaller, threshold for it to be satisfied by the pure literal rule. Also, above the satisfiability threshold, where a random formula is with high probability (whp) unsatisfiable, the unsatisfiability is whp due to a large "minimal unsatisfiable subformula" (MUF). By contrast, we show that for the (rare) unsatisfiable formulae below the pure literal threshold, the unsatisfiability is whp due to a unique MUF with smallest possible "excess", failing this whp due to a unique MUF with the next larger excess, and so forth. In the same regime, we give a precise asymptotic expansion for the probability that a formula is unsatisfiable, and efficient algorithms for satisfying a formula or proving its unsatisfiability. It remains open what happens between the pure literal threshold and the satisfiability threshold. We prove analogous results for the $k$-core and $k$-colorability thresholds for a random graph, or more generally a random $r$-uniform hypergraph.

Let $G=(V,E)$ be a complete $n$-vertex graph with distinct positive edge weights. We prove that for $k\in\{1,2,...,n-1\}$, the set consisting of the edges of all minimum spanning trees (MSTs) over induced subgraphs of $G$ with $n-k+1$ vertices has at most $nk-\binom{k+1}{2}$ elements. This proves a conjecture of Goemans and Vondrak \cite{GV2005}. We also show that the result is a generalization of Mader's Theorem, which bounds the number of edges in any edge-minimal $k$-connected graph.

We prove that a random 3-SAT instance with clause-to-variable density less than 3.52 is satisfiable with high probability. The proof comes through an algorithm which selects (and sets) a variable depending on its degree and that of its complement.

Given a 2-SAT formula $F$ consisting of $n$ variables and $\cn$ random clauses, what is the largest number of clauses $\max F$ satisfiable by a single assignment of the variables? We bound the answer away from the trivial bounds of $(3/4)cn$ and $cn$. We prove that for $c<1$, the expected number of clauses satisfiable is $\cn-Θ(1/n)$; for large $c$, it is $((3/4)c + Θ(\sqrt{c}))n$; for $c = 1+\eps$, it is at least $(1+\eps-O(\eps^3))n$ and at most $(1+\eps-Ω(\eps^3/\ln \eps))n$; and in the ``scaling window'' $c= 1+Θ(n^{-1/3})$, it is $cn-Θ(1)$. In particular, just as the decision problem undergoes a phase transition, our optimization problem also undergoes a phase transition at the same critical value $c=1$. Nearly all of our results are established without reference to the analogous propositions for decision 2-SAT, and as a byproduct we reproduce many of those results, including much of what is known about the 2-SAT scaling window. We consider ``online'' versions of MAX-2-SAT, and show that for one version, the obvious greedy algorithm is optimal. We can extend only our simplest MAX-2-SAT results to MAX-k-SAT, but we conjecture a ``MAX-k-SAT limiting function conjecture'' analogous to the folklore satisfiability threshold conjecture, but open even for $k=2$. Neither conjecture immediately implies the other, but it is natural to further conjecture a connection between them. Finally, for random MAXCUT (the size of a maximum cut in a sparse random graph) we prove analogous results.

We introduce a new graph polynomial in two variables. This ``interlace'' polynomial can be computed in two very different ways. The first is an expansion analogous to the state space expansion of the Tutte polynomial; the significant differences are that our expansion is over vertex rather than edge subsets, and the rank and nullity employed are those of an adjacency matrix rather than an incidence matrix. The second computation is by a three-term reduction formula involving a graph pivot; the pivot arose previously in the study of interlacement and Euler circuits in four-regular graphs. We consider a few properties and specializations of the two-variable interlace polynomial. One specialization, the ``vertex-nullity interlace polynomial'', is the single-variable interlace graph polynomial we studied previously, closely related to the Tutte-Martin polynomial on isotropic systems previously considered by Bouchet. Another, the ``vertex-rank interlace polynomial'', is equally interesting. Yet another specialization of the two-variable polynomial is the independent-set polynomial.

Motivated by circle graphs, and the enumeration of Euler circuits, we define a one-variable ``interlace polynomial'' for any graph. The polynomial satisfies a beautiful and unexpected reduction relation, quite different from the cut and fuse reduction characterizing the Tutte polynomial. It emerges that the interlace graph polynomial may be viewed as a special case of the Martin polynomial of an isotropic system, which underlies its connections with the circuit partition polynomial and the Kauffman brackets of a link diagram. The graph polynomial, in addition to being perhaps more broadly accessible than the Martin polynomial for isotropic systems, also has a two-variable generalization that is unknown for the Martin polynomial. We consider extremal properties of the interlace polynomial, its values for various special graphs, and evaluations which relate to basic graph properties such as the component and independence numbers.