arXiv++ Combinatorics

Permutation Mastermind is a version of the classical mastermind game in which the number of positions $n$ is equal to the number of colors $k$, and repetition of colors is not allowed, neither in the codeword nor in the queries. In this paper we solve the main open question from Glazik, Jäger, Schiemann and Srivastav (2021), who asked whether their bound of $O(n^{1.525})$ for the static version can be improved to $O(n \log n)$, which would be best possible. By using a simple probabilistic argument we show that this is indeed the case.

We design a randomized algorithm that finds a Hamilton cycle in $\mathcal{O}(n)$ time with high probability in a random graph $G_{n,p}$ with edge probability $p\ge C \log n / n$. This closes a gap left open in a seminal paper by Angluin and Valiant from 1979.

Consider the following simple coloring algorithm for a graph on $n$ vertices. Each vertex chooses a color from $\{1, \dotsc, Δ(G) + 1\}$ uniformly at random. While there exists a conflicted vertex choose one such vertex uniformly at random and recolor it with a randomly chosen color. This algorithm was introduced by Bhartia et al. [MOBIHOC'16] for channel selection in WIFI-networks. We show that this algorithm always converges to a proper coloring in expected $O(n \log Δ)$ steps, which is optimal and proves a conjecture of Chakrabarty and Supinski [SOSA'20].

Since first introduced by Sudakov and Vu in 2008, the study of resilience problems in random graphs received a lot of attention in probabilistic combinatorics. Of particular interest are resilience problems of spanning structures. It is known that for spanning structures which contain many triangles, local resilience cannot prevent an adversary from destroying all copies of the structure by removing a negligible amount of edges incident to every vertex. In this paper we generalise the notion of local resilience to $H$-resilience and demonstrate its usefulness on the containment problem of the square of a Hamilton cycle. In particular, we show that there exists a constant $C > 0$ such that if $p \geq C\log^3 n/\sqrt{n}$ then w.h.p. in every subgraph $G$ of a random graph $G_{n, p}$ there exists the square of a Hamilton cycle, provided that every vertex of $G$ remains on at least a $(4/9 + o(1))$-fraction of its triangles from $G_{n, p}$. The constant $4/9$ is optimal and the value of $p$ slightly improves on the best-known appearance threshold of such a structure and is optimal up to the logarithmic factor.

Let $\{G_i\}$ be the random graph process: starting with an empty graph $G_0$ with $n$ vertices, in every step $i \geq 1$ the graph $G_i$ is formed by taking an edge chosen uniformly at random among the non-existing ones and adding it to the graph $G_{i - 1}$. The classical `hitting-time' result of Ajtai, Komlós, and Szemerédi, and independently Bollobás, states that asymptotically almost surely the graph becomes Hamiltonian as soon as the minimum degree reaches $2$, that is if $δ(G_i) \ge 2$ then $G_i$ is Hamiltonian. We establish a resilience version of this result. In particular, we show that the random graph process almost surely creates a sequence of graphs such that for $m \geq (\tfrac{1}{6} + o(1))n\log n$ edges, the $2$-core of the graph $G_m$ remains Hamiltonian even after an adversary removes $(\tfrac{1}{2} - o(1))$-fraction of the edges incident to every vertex. A similar result is obtained for perfect matchings.

The famous Pósa-Seymour conjecture, confirmed in 1998 by Komlós, Sárközy, and Szemerédi, states that for any $k \geq 2$, every graph on $n$ vertices with minimum degree $kn/(k + 1)$ contains the $k$-th power of a Hamilton cycle. We extend this result to a sparse random setting. We show that for every $k \geq 2$ there exists $C > 0$ such that if $p \geq C(\log n/n)^{1/k}$ then w.h.p. every subgraph of a random graph $G_{n, p}$ with minimum degree at least $(k/(k + 1) + o(1))np$, contains the $k$-th power of a cycle on at least $(1 - o(1))n$ vertices, improving upon the recent results of Noever and Steger for $k = 2$, as well as Allen et al. for $k \geq 3$. Our result is almost best possible in three ways: for $p \ll n^{-1/k}$ the random graph $G_{n, p}$ w.h.p. does not contain the $k$-th power of any long cycle; there exist subgraphs of $G_{n, p}$ with minimum degree $(k/(k + 1) + o(1))np$ and $Ω(p^{-2})$ vertices not belonging to triangles; there exist subgraphs of $G_{n, p}$ with minimum degree $(k/(k + 1) - o(1))np$ which do not contain the $k$-th power of a cycle on $(1 - o(1))n$ vertices.

A celebrated result of Rödl and Ruciński states that for every graph $F$, which is not a forest of stars and paths of length $3$, and fixed number of colours $r\ge 2$ there exist positive constants $c, C$ such that for $p \leq cn^{-1/m_2(F)}$ the probability that every colouring of the edges of the random graph $G(n,p)$ contains a monochromatic copy of $F$ is $o(1)$ (the "0-statement"), while for $p \geq Cn^{-1/m_2(F)}$ it is $1-o(1)$ (the "1-statement"). Here $m_2(F)$ denotes the $2$-density of $F$. On the other hand, the case where $F$ is a forest of stars has a coarse threshold which is determined by the appearance of a certain small subgraph in $G(n, p)$. Recently, the natural extension of the 1-statement of this theorem to $k$-uniform hypergraphs was proved by Conlon and Gowers and, independently, by Friedgut, Rödl and Schacht. In particular, they showed an upper bound of order $n^{-1/m_k(F)}$ for the $1$-statement, where $m_k(F)$ denotes the $k$-density of $F$. Similarly as in the graph case, it is known that the threshold for star-like hypergraphs is given by the appearance of small subgraphs. In this paper we show that another type of thresholds exists if $k \ge 4:$ there are $k$-uniform hypergraphs for which the threshold is determined by the asymmetric Ramsey problem in which a different hypergraph has to be avoided in each colour-class. Along the way we obtain a general bound on the $1$-statement for asymmetric Ramsey properties in random hypergraphs. This extends the work of Kohayakawa and Kreuter, and of Kohayakawa, Schacht and Spöhel who showed a similar result in the graph case. We prove the corresponding 0-statement for hypergraphs satisfying certain balancedness conditions.

One of the easiest randomized greedy optimization algorithms is the following evolutionary algorithm which aims at maximizing a boolean function $f:\{0,1\}^n \to {\mathbb R}$. The algorithm starts with a random search point $ξ\in \{0,1\}^n$, and in each round it flips each bit of $ξ$ with probability $c/n$ independently at random, where $c>0$ is a fixed constant. The thus created offspring $ξ'$ replaces $ξ$ if and only if $f(ξ') \ge f(ξ)$. The analysis of the runtime of this simple algorithm on monotone and on linear functions turned out to be highly non-trivial. In this paper we review known results and provide new and self-contained proofs of partly stronger results.

In 1962, Pósa conjectured that a graph $G=(V, E)$ contains a square of a Hamiltonian cycle if $δ(G)\ge 2n/3$. Only more than thirty years later Komlós, Sárkőzy, and Szemerédi proved this conjecture using the so-called Blow-Up Lemma. Here we extend their result to a random graph setting. We show that for every $ε> 0$ and $p=n^{-1/2+ε}$ a.a.s. every subgraph of $G_{n,p}$ with minimum degree at least $(2/3+ε)np$ contains the square of a cycle on $(1-o(1))n$ vertices. This is almost best possible in three ways: (1) for $p\ll n^{-1/2}$ the random graph will not contain any square of a long cycle (2) one cannot hope for a resilience version for the square of a spanning cycle (as deleting all edges in the neighborhood of single vertex destroys this property) and (3) for $c<2/3$ a.a.s. $G_{n,p}$ contains a subgraph with minimum degree at least $cnp$ which does not contain the square of a path on $(1/3+c)n$ vertices.

A random jigsaw puzzle is constructed by arranging $n^2$ square pieces into an $n \times n$ grid and assigning to each edge of a piece one of $q$ available colours uniformly at random, with the restriction that touching edges receive the same colour. We show that if $q = o(n)$ then with high probability such a puzzle does not have a unique solution, while if $q \ge n^{1 + \varepsilon}$ for any constant $\varepsilon > 0$ then the solution is unique. This solves a conjecture of Mossel and Ross (Shotgun assembly of labeled graphs, arXiv:1504.07682).

In an Achlioptas process, starting with a graph that has n vertices and no edge, in each round $d \geq 1$ edges are drawn uniformly at random, and using some rule exactly one of them is chosen and added to the evolving graph. For the class of Achlioptas processes we investigate how much impact the rule has on one of the most basic properties of a graph: connectivity. Our main results are twofold. First, we study the prominent class of bounded size rules, which select the edge to add according to the component sizes of its vertices, treating all sizes larger than some constant equally. For such rules we provide a fine analysis that exposes the limiting distribution of the number of rounds until the graph gets connected, and we give a detailed picture of the dynamics of the formation of the single component from smaller components. Second, our results allow us to study the connectivity transition of all Achlioptas processes, in the sense that we identify a process that accelerates it as much as possible.

Bootstrap percolation is a prominent framework for studying the spreading of activity on a graph. We begin with an initial set of active vertices. The process then proceeds in rounds, and further vertices become active as soon as they have a certain number of active neighbors. A recurring feature in bootstrap percolation theory is an `all-or-nothing' phenomenon: either the size of the starting set is so small that the process stops very soon, or it percolates (almost) completely. Motivated by several important phenomena observed in various types of real-world networks we propose in this work a variant of bootstrap percolation that exhibits a vastly different behavior. Our graphs have two types of vertices: some of them obstruct the diffusion, while the others facilitate it. We study the effect of this setting by analyzing the process on Erdős-Rényi random graphs. Our main findings are two-fold. First we show that the presence of vertices hindering the diffusion does not result in a stable behavior: tiny changes in the size of the starting set can dramatically influence the size of the final active set. In particular, the process is non-monotone: a larger starting set can result in a smaller final set. In the second part of the paper we show that this phenomenom arises from the round-based approach: if we move to a continuous time model in which every edge draws its transmission time randomly, then we gain stability, and the process stops with an active set that contains a non-trivial constant fraction of all vertices. Moreover, we show that in the continuous time model percolation occurs significantly faster compared to the classical round-based model. Our findings are in line with empirical observations and demonstrate the importance of introducing various types of vertex behaviors in the mathematical model.

In this paper we introduce a general framework for proving lower bounds for various Ramsey type problems within random settings. The main idea is to view the problem from an algorithmic perspective: we aim at providing an algorithm that finds the desired colouring with high probability. Our framework allows to reduce the probabilistic problem of whether the Ramsey property at hand holds for random (hyper)graphs with edge probability $p$ to a deterministic question of whether there exists a finite graph that forms an obstruction. In the second part of the paper we apply this framework to address and solve various open problems. In particular, we extend the result of Bohman, Frieze, Pikhurko and Smyth (2010) for bounded anti-Ramsey problems in random graphs to the case of $2$ colors and to hypergraph cliques. As a corollary, this proves a matching lower bound for the result of Friedgut, Rödl and Schacht (2010) and, independently, Conlon and Gowers (2014+) for the classical Ramsey problem for hypergraphs in the case of cliques. Finally, we provide matching lower bounds for a proper-colouring version of anti-Ramsey problems introduced by Kohayakawa, Konstadinidis and Mota~(2014) in the case of cliques and cycles.

Suppose that two players take turns coloring the vertices of a given graph G with k colors. In each move the current player colors a vertex such that neighboring vertices get different colors. The first player wins this game if and only if at the end, all the vertices are colored. The game chromatic number $χ_g(G)$ is defined as the smallest k for which the first player has a winning strategy. Recently, Bohman, Frieze and Sudakov [Random Structures and Algorithms 2008] analysed the game chromatic number of random graphs and obtained lower and upper bounds of the same order of magnitude. In this paper we improve existing results and show that with high probability, the game chromatic number $χ_g(G_{n,p})$ of dense random graphs is asymptotically twice as large as the ordinary chromatic number $χ(G_{n,p})$.

A classical theorem of Ghouila-Houri from 1960 asserts that every directed graph on $n$ vertices with minimum out-degree and in-degree at least $n/2$ contains a directed Hamilton cycle. In this paper we extend this theorem to a random directed graph ${\mathcal D}(n,p)$, that is, a directed graph in which every ordered pair $(u,v)$ becomes an arc with probability $p$ independently of all other pairs. Motivated by the study of resilience of properties of random graphs, we prove that if $p \gg \log n/\sqrt{n}$, then a.a.s. every subdigraph of ${\mathcal D}(n,p)$ with minimum out-degree and in-degree at least $(1/2 + o(1)) n p$ contains a directed Hamilton cycle. The constant $1/2$ is asymptotically best possible. Our result also strengthens classical results about the existence of directed Hamilton cycles in random directed graphs.

We study the Maker-Breaker $H$-game played on the edge set of the random graph $G_{n,p}$. In this game two players, Maker and Breaker, alternately claim unclaimed edges of $G_{n,p}$, until all the edges are claimed. Maker wins if he claims all the edges of a copy of a fixed graph $H$; Breaker wins otherwise. In this paper we show that, with the exception of trees and triangles, the threshold for an $H$-game is given by the threshold of the corresponding Ramsey property of $G_{n,p}$ with respect to the graph $H$.

In 1976 Erdos, Kleitman and Rothschild determined the number of graphs without a clique of size $\ell$. In this note we extend their result to the case of forbidden cliques of increasing size. More precisely we prove that for $\ell_n \le \frac12(\log n)^{1/4}$ there are $$2^{(1-1/(\ell_n-1))n^2/2+o(n^2/\ell_n)}$$ $K_{\ell_n}$-free graphs of order $n$. Our proof is based on the recent hypergraph container theorems of Saxton, Thomason and Balogh, Morris, Samotij, in combination with a theorem of Lovasz and Simonovits.

We prove that there is a constant $c >0$, such that whenever $p \ge n^{-c}$, with probability tending to 1 when $n$ goes to infinity, every maximum triangle-free subgraph of the random graph $G_{n,p}$ is bipartite. This answers a question of Babai, Simonovits and Spencer (Journal of Graph Theory, 1990). The proof is based on a tool of independent interest: we show, for instance, that the maximum cut of almost all graphs with $M$ edges, where $M >> n$, is ``nearly unique''. More precisely, given a maximum cut $C$ of $G_{n,M}$, we can obtain all maximum cuts by moving at most $O(\sqrt{n^3/M})$ vertices between the parts of $C$.

Let $G=(V,E)$ be a complete $n$-vertex graph with distinct positive edge weights. We prove that for $k\in\{1,2,...,n-1\}$, the set consisting of the edges of all minimum spanning trees (MSTs) over induced subgraphs of $G$ with $n-k+1$ vertices has at most $nk-\binom{k+1}{2}$ elements. This proves a conjecture of Goemans and Vondrak \cite{GV2005}. We also show that the result is a generalization of Mader's Theorem, which bounds the number of edges in any edge-minimal $k$-connected graph.