arXiv++ Combinatorics

We study a distributed consensus problem on a complete communication network of $n$ vertices, each holding one of two opinions. The vertices communicate in rounds, possibly in the presence of adversarial noise, and exchange information until they all agree on a single opinion. We consider a general class of protocols, where the vertices randomly sample neighbors and update their own opinion according to an update function $f$ depending on the sampled opinions. A prominent example is the $k$-maj protocol, where every vertex adopts the majority opinion of $k$ randomly sampled neighbors. We consider the runtime $R_n$ that is the number of rounds until all vertices agree on the same opinion, which we call the dominating opinion $D_n$. In our main result we describe the limiting distributions of these two key quantities for a large class of update functions $f$, for arbitrary initial configurations and under the presence of an adversary who may alter the opinions of up to $o(\sqrt{n})$ vertices in each round. We show that there are $f$-specific constants $γ, m > 0$ such that $R_n$ centers around $μ_n = \frac{1}{2}\log_γn + \log_m\ln n$, and we describe the asymptotic distribution of $R_n - μ_n$. In particular, we show that it does not converge, and that it becomes asymptotically periodic both in the $\log n$ as well as the $\log\log n$ scale. Applied to $k$-maj, our results show, among other things, that $γ_{k\text{-maj}} = \binom{k-1}{\lfloor k/2 \rfloor}2^{1-k}k \sim ({2k}/π)^{1/2}$.

A graph $G$ is universal for a class of graphs $\mathcal{C}$, if, up to isomorphism, $G$ contains every graph in $\mathcal{C}$ as a subgraph. In 1978, Chung and Graham asked for the minimal number $s(n)$ of edges in a graph with $n$ vertices that is universal for all trees with $n$ vertices. The currently best bounds assert that $n\ln n-O(n)\le s(n) \le C n\ln n+O(n)$, where $C = \frac{14}{5\ln 2} \approx 4.04$. Here, we improve the upper bound to $c n\ln n + O(n)$, where $c = \frac{19}{6\ln 3} \approx 2.88$. We develop in the proof a strategy that, broadly speaking, is based on separating trees into three parts, thus enabling us to embed them in a structure that originates from ternary trees. Our method also applies to graphs that are close to being trees, measured by their treewidth. Let $s_w(n)$ be the minimum number of edges in a $n$-vertex graph that is universal for graphs with treewidth $w$. By performing a graph blow-up to our universal structure and counting necessary edges carefully, we establish that $nw \ln(n/w) -O(nw) \leq s_w(n) \leq \frac{19}{6\ln3} n (w+1) \ln(n/w) + O(nw)$.

We consider a synchronous process of particles moving on the vertices of a graph $G$, introduced by Cooper, McDowell, Radzik, Rivera and Shiraga (2018). Initially, $M$ particles are placed on a vertex of $G$. In subsequent time steps, all particles that are located on a vertex inhabited by at least two particles jump independently to a neighbour chosen uniformly at random. The process ends at the first step when no vertex is inhabited by more than one particle; we call this (random) time step the dispersion time. In this work we study the case where $G$ is the complete graph on $n$ vertices and the number of particles is $M=n/2+αn^{1/2} + o(n^{1/2})$, $α\in \mathbb{R}$. This choice of $M$ corresponds to the critical window of the process, with respect to the dispersion time. We show that the dispersion time, if rescaled by $n^{-1/2}$, converges in $p$-th mean, as $n\rightarrow \infty$ and for any $p \in \mathbb{R}$, to a continuous and almost surely positive random variable $T_α$. We find that $T_α$ is the absorption time of a standard logistic branching process, thoroughly investigated by Lambert (2005), and we determine its expectation. In particular, in the middle of the critical window we show that $\mathbb{E}[T_0] = π^{3/2}/\sqrt{7}$, and furthermore we formulate explicit asymptotics when $|α|$ gets large that quantify the transition into and out of the critical window. We also study the (random) total number of jumps that are performed by the particles until the dispersion time is reached. In particular, we prove that it centers around $\frac{2}{7}n\ln n$ and that it has variations linear in $n$, whose distribution we can describe explicitly.

Given a graph G, a colouring is an assignment of colours to the vertices of G so that no two adjacent vertices are coloured the same. If all colour classes have size at most t, then we call the colouring t-bounded, and the t-bounded chromatic number of G, denoted by $χ_t(G)$, is the minimum number of colours in such a colouring. Every colouring of G is then $α(G)$-bounded, where $α(G)$ denotes the size of a largest independent set. We study colourings of the random graph G(n, 1/2) and of the corresponding uniform random graph G(n,m) with $m=\left \lfloor \frac 12 {n \choose 2} \right \rfloor$. We show that $χ_t(G(n,m))$ is maximally concentrated on at most two explicit values for $t = α(G(n,m))-2$. This behaviour stands in stark contrast to that of the normal chromatic number, which was recently shown not to be concentrated on any sequence of intervals of length $n^{1/2-o(1)}$. Moreover, when $t = α(G_{n, 1/2})-1$ and if the expected number of independent sets of size $t$ is not too small, we determine an explicit interval of length $n^{0.99}$ that contains $χ_t(G_{n,1/2})$ with high probability. Both results have profound consequences: the former is at the core of the intriguing Zigzag Conjecture on the distribution of $χ(G_{n, 1/2})$ and justifies one of its main hypotheses, while the latter is an important ingredient in the proof of a non-concentration result for $χ(G_{n,1/2})$ that is conjectured to be optimal. These two results are consequences of a more general statement. We consider a class of colourings that we call tame, and provide tight bounds for the probability of existence of such colourings via a delicate second moment argument. We then apply those bounds to the two aforementioned cases. As a further consequence of our main result, we prove two-point concentration of the equitable chromatic number of G(n,m).

We consider a synchronous process of particles moving on the vertices of a graph $G$, introduced by Cooper, McDowell, Radzik, Rivera and Shiraga (2018). Initially, $M$ particles are placed on a vertex of $G$. At the beginning of each time step, for every vertex inhabited by at least two particles, each of these particles moves independently to a neighbour chosen uniformly at random. The process ends at the first step when no vertex is inhabited by more than one particle. Cooper et al. showed that when the underlying graph is the complete graph on~$n$ vertices, then there is a phase transition when the number of particles $M = n/2$. They showed that if $M<(1-\varepsilon)n/2$ for some fixed $\varepsilon>0$, then the process finishes in a logarithmic number of steps, while if $M>(1+\varepsilon)n/2$, an exponential number of steps are required with high probability. Here we provide a thorough asymptotic analysis of the dispersion time around criticality, where $\varepsilon = o(1)$, and describe the transition from logarithmic to exponential time. As a consequence of our results we establish, for example, that the dispersion time is in probability and in expectation in $Θ(n^{1/2})$ when $|\varepsilon| = O(n^{-1/2})$, and provide qualitative bounds for its tail behavior.

We develop a simple and unified approach to investigate several aspects of the cluster statistics of random expansive (multi-)sets. In particular, we determine the limiting distribution of the size of the smallest and largest clusters, we establish all moments of the distribution of the number of clusters, and we prove a local limit theorem for that distribution. Our proofs combine effectively two simple ingredients: an application of the saddle-point method through the well-known framework of $H$-admissibility, and an ingenious idea by Erdős and Lehner that utilizes the elementary inclusion/exclusion principle.

There is a vast body of recent literature on the reliability of communication through noisy channels, the recovery of community structures in the stochastic block model, the limiting behavior of the free entropy in spin glasses and the solution space structure of constraint satisfaction problems. At first glance, these topics ranging across several disciplines might seem unrelated. However, taking a closer look, structural similarities can be easily identified. Factor graphs exploit these similarities to model the aforementioned objects and concepts in a unified manner. In this contribution we discuss the asymptotic average case behavior of several quantities, where the average is taken over sparse Erdős-Rényi type (hyper-) graphs with positive weights, under certain assumptions. For one, we establish the limit of the mutual information, which is used in coding theory to measure the reliability of communication. We also determine the limit of the relative entropy, which can be used to decide if weak recovery is possible in the stochastic block model. Further, we prove the conjectured limit of the quenched free entropy over the planted ensemble, which we use to obtain the preceding limits. Finally, we describe the asymptotic behavior of the quenched free entropy (over the null model) in terms of the limiting relative entropy.

Consider a non-negative sequence $c_n = h(n) \cdot n^{α-1} \cdot ρ^{-n}$, where $h$ is slowly varying, $α>0$, $0<ρ<1$ and $n\in\mathbb{N}$. We investigate the coefficients of $G(x,y) = \prod_{k\ge1}(1-x^ky)^{-c_k}$, which is the bivariate generating series of the multiset construction of combinatorial objects. By a powerful blend of probabilistic methods based on the Boltzmann model and analytic techniques exploiting the well-known saddle-point method we determine the number of multisets of total size $n$ with $N$ components, that is, the coefficient of $x^ny^N$ in $G(x,y)$, asymptotically as $n\to\infty$ and for all ranges of $N$. Our results reveal a phase transition in the structure of the counting formula that depends on the ratio $n/N$ and that demonstrates a prototypical passage from a bivariate local limit to an univariate one.

Various combinatorial classes such as outerplanar graphs and maps, series-parallel graphs, substitution-closed classes of permutations and many more allow bijective encodings by so-called enriched trees, which are rooted trees with additional structure on the offspring of each node. Using this universal description we develop sampling procedures that uniformly generate objects from this classes with a given size $n$ in expected time $O(n)$.The key ingredient is a representation of enriched trees in terms of decorated Bienaymé--Galton--Watson trees, which allows us to develop a novel combination of Devroye's efficient sampler for trees (Devroye, 2012) with Boltzmann sampling techniques. Additionally, we construct expected linear time samplers for critical Bienaymé--Galton--Watson trees having exactly $n$ (out of $\ge n$ total) nodes with outdegree in some fixed set, enabling uniform generation for many combinatorial classes such as dissections of polygons.

For a given combinatorial class $\mathcal{C}$ we study the class $\mathcal{G} = \mathrm{MSET}(\mathcal{C})$ satisfying the multiset construction, that is, any object in $\mathcal{G}$ is uniquely determined by a set of $\mathcal{C}$-objects paired with their multiplicities. For example, $\mathrm{MSET}(\mathbb{N})$ is (isomorphic to) the class of number partitions of positive integers, a prominent and well-studied case. The multiset construction appears naturally in the study of unlabelled objects, for example graphs or various structures related to number partitions. Our main result establishes the asymptotic size of the set $\mathcal{G}_{n,N}$ that contains all multisets in $\mathcal{G}$ having size $n$ and being comprised of $N$ objects from $\mathcal{C}$, as $n$ \emph{and} $N$ tend to infinity and when the counting sequence of $\mathcal{C}$ is governed by subexponential growth; this is a particularly important setting in combinatorial applications. Moreover, we study the component distribution of random objects from $\mathcal{G}_{n,N}$ and we discover a phenomenon that we baptise \emph{extreme condensation}: taking away the largest component as well as all the components of the smallest possible size, we are left with an object which converges in distribution as $n,N\to\infty$. The distribution of the limiting object is also retrieved. Moreover and rather surprisingly, in stark contrast to analogous results for labelled objects, the results here hold uniformly in $N$.

Random factor graphs provide a powerful framework for the study of inference problems such as decoding problems or the stochastic block model. Information-theoretically the key quantity of interest is the mutual information between the observed factor graph and the underlying ground truth around which the factor graph was created; in the stochastic block model, this would be the planted partition. The mutual information gauges whether and how well the ground truth can be inferred from the observable data. For a very general model of random factor graphs we verify a formula for the mutual information predicted by physics techniques. As an application we prove a conjecture about low-density generator matrix codes from [Montanari: IEEE Transactions on Information Theory 2005]. Further applications include phase transitions of the stochastic block model and the mixed $k$-spin model from physics.

The chromatic number $χ(G)$ of a graph $G$, that is, the smallest number of colors required to color the vertices of $G$ so that no two adjacent vertices are assigned the same color, is a classic and extensively studied parameter. Here we consider the case where $G$ is a random block graph, also known as the stochastic block model. The vertex set is partitioned into $k\in\mathbb{N}$ parts $V_1, \dotsc, V_k$, and for each $1 \le i\le j\le k$, two vertices $u \in V_i, v\in V_j$ are connected by an edge with some probability $p_{ij} \in (0,1)$ independently. Our main result pins down the typical asymptotic value of $χ(G)$ and establishes the distribution of the sizes of the color classes in optimal colorings. We discover that in contrast to the case of a binomial random graph $G(n,p)$, that corresponds to $k=1$ in our model, where the average size of a color class in an (almost) optimal coloring essentially coincides with the independence number, the block model reveals a more diverse picture: the "average" class in an optimal coloring is a convex combination of several types of independent sets that vary in total size as well as in the size of their intersection with each $V_i$, $1\le i \le k$.

We study the popular randomized rumour spreading protocol Push. Initially, a node in a graph possesses some information, which is then spread in a round based manner. In each round, each informed node chooses uniformly at random one of its neighbours and passes the information to it. The central quantity to investigate is the Runtime, that is, the number of rounds needed until every node has received the information. The Push protocol and variations of it have been studied extensively. Here we study the case where the underlying graph is complete with $n$ nodes. Even in this most basic setting, specifying the limiting distribution of the runtime as well as determining related quantities, like its expectation, have remained open problems since the protocol was introduced. In our main result we describe the limiting distribution of the runtime. We show that it does not converge, and that it becomes, after the appropriate normalization, asymptotically periodic both on the $\log_2n$ as well as on the $\ln n$ scale. In particular, the limiting distribution converges only if we restrict ourselves to suitable subsequences of $\mathbb N$, where simultaneously $\log_2 n-\lfloor\log_2n\rfloor\to x$ and $\ln n-\lfloor\ln n\rfloor\to y$ for some fixed $x,y\in [0,1)$. On such subsequences we show that the expected runtime is $\log_2 n+\ln n+h(x,y)+o(1)$, where $h$ is explicitly given and numerically $|\sup h - \inf h| \approx 2\cdot 10^{-4}$.

In this work we consider three well-studied broadcast protocols: Push, Pull and Push&Pull. A key property of all these models, which is also an important reason for their popularity, is that they are presumed to be very robust, since they are simple, randomized, and, crucially, do not utilize explicitly the global structure of the underlying graph. While sporadic results exist, there has been no systematic theoretical treatment quantifying the robustness of these models. Here we investigate this question with respect to two orthogonal aspects: (adversarial) modifications of the underlying graph and message transmission failures. We explore in particular the following notion of Local Resilience: beginning with a graph, we investigate up to which fraction of the edges an adversary has to be allowed to delete at each vertex, so that the protocols need significantly more rounds to broadcast the information. Our main findings establish a separation among the three models. It turns out that Pull is robust with respect to all parameters that we consider. On the other hand, Push may slow down significantly, even if the adversary is allowed to modify the degrees of the vertices by an arbitrarily small positive fraction only. Finally, Push&Pull is robust when no message transmission failures are considered, otherwise it may be slowed down. On the technical side, we develop two novel methods for the analysis of randomized rumour spreading protocols. First, we exploit the notion of self-bounding functions to facilitate significantly the round-based analysis: we show that for any graph the variance of the growth of informed vertices is bounded by its expectation, so that concentration results follow immediately. Second, in order to control adversarial modifications of the graph we make use of a powerful tool from extremal graph theory, namely Szemerèdi's Regularity Lemma.

In the last two decades the study of random instances of constraint satisfaction problems (CSPs) has flourished across several disciplines, including computer science, mathematics and physics. The diversity of the developed methods, on the rigorous and non-rigorous side, has led to major advances regarding both the theoretical as well as the applied viewpoints. Based on a ceteris paribus approach in terms of the density evolution equations known from statistical physics, we focus on a specific prominent class of regular CSPs, the so-called occupation problems. The regular $r$-in-$k$ occupation problems resemble a basis of this class. By now, out of these CSPs only the satisfiability threshold - the largest degree for which the problem admits asymptotically a solution - for the $1$-in-$k$ occupation problem has been rigorously established. Here we determine the satisfiability threshold of the $2$-in-$k$ occupation problem for all $k$. In the proof we exploit the connection of an associated optimization problem regarding the overlap of satisfying assignements to a fixed point problem inspired by belief propagation, a message passing algorithm developed for solving such CSPs.

We consider graph classes $\mathcal G$ in which every graph has components in a class $\mathcal{C}$ of connected graphs. We provide a framework for the asymptotic study of $\lvert\mathcal{G}_{n,N}\rvert$, the number of graphs in $\mathcal{G}$ with $n$ vertices and $N:=\lfloorλn\rfloor$ components, where $λ\in(0,1)$. Assuming that the number of graphs with $n$ vertices in $\mathcal{C}$ satisfies \begin{align*} \lvert \mathcal{C}_n\rvert\sim b n^{-(1+α)}ρ^{-n}n!, \quad n\to \infty \end{align*} for some $b,ρ>0$ and $α>1$ -- a property commonly encountered in graph enumeration -- we show that \begin{align*} \lvert\mathcal{G}_{n,N}\rvert\sim c(λ) n^{f(λ)} (\log n)^{g(λ)} ρ^{-n}h(λ)^{N}\frac{n!}{N!}, \quad n\to \infty \end{align*} for explicitly given $c(λ),f(λ),g(λ)$ and $h(λ)$. These functions are piecewise continuous with a discontinuity at a critical value $λ^{*}$, which we also determine. The central idea in our approach is to sample objects of $\cal G$ randomly by so-called Boltzmann generators in order to translate enumerative problems to the analysis of iid random variables. By that we are able to exploit local limit theorems and large deviation results well-known from probability theory to prove our claims. The main results are formulated for generic combinatorial classes satisfying the SET-construction.

Given a hypergraph $Γ=(Ω,\mathcal{X})$ and a sequence $\mathbf{p} = (p_ω)_{ω\in Ω}$ of values in $(0,1)$, let $Ω_{\mathbf{p}}$ be the random subset of $Ω$ obtained by keeping every vertex $ω$ independently with probability $p_ω$. We investigate the general question of deriving fine (asymptotic) estimates for the probability that $Ω_{\mathbf{p}}$ is an independent set in $Γ$, which is an omnipresent problem in probabilistic combinatorics. Our main result provides a sequence of upper and lower bounds on this probability, each of which can be evaluated explicitly in terms of the joint cumulants of small sets of edge indicator random variables. Under certain natural conditions, these upper and lower bounds coincide asymptotically, thus giving the precise asymptotics of the probability in question. We demonstrate the applicability of our results with two concrete examples: subgraph containment in random (hyper)graphs and arithmetic progressions in random subsets of the integers.

We study the Moran process as adapted by Lieberman, Hauert and Nowak. This is a model of an evolving population on a graph or digraph where certain individuals, called "mutants" have fitness r and other individuals, called non-mutants have fitness 1. We focus on the situation where the mutation is advantageous, in the sense that r>1. A family of digraphs is said to be strongly amplifying if the extinction probability tends to 0 when the Moran process is run on digraphs in this family. The most-amplifying known family of digraphs is the family of megastars of Galanis et al. We show that this family is optimal, up to logarithmic factors, since every strongly-connected n-vertex digraph has extinction probability Omega(n^(-1/2)). Next, we show that there is an infinite family of undirected graphs, called dense incubators, whose extinction probability is O(n^(-1/3)). We show that this is optimal, up to constant factors. Finally, we introduce sparse incubators, for varying edge density, and show that the extinction probability of these graphs is O(n/m), where m is the number of edges. Again, we show that this is optimal, up to constant factors.

Pólya trees are rooted trees considered up to symmetry. We establish the convergence of large uniform random Pólya trees with arbitrary degree restrictions to Aldous' Continuum Random Tree with respect to the Gromov-Hausdorff metric. Our proof is short and elementary, and it shows that the global shape of a random Pólya tree is essentially dictated by a large Galton-Watson tree that it contains. We also derive sub-Gaussian tail bounds for both the height and the width, which are optimal up to constant factors in the exponent.

We study the uniform random graph $\mathsf{C}_n$ with $n$ vertices drawn from a subcritical class of connected graphs. Our main result is that the rescaled graph $\mathsf{C}_n / \sqrt{n}$ converges to the Brownian Continuum Random Tree $\mathcal{T}_{\mathsf{e}}$ multiplied by a constant scaling factor that depends on the class under consideration. In addition, we provide subgaussian tail bounds for the diameter $\text{D}(\mathsf{C}_n)$ and height $\text{H}(\mathsf{C}_n^\bullet)$ of the rooted random graph $\mathsf{C}_n^\bullet$. We give analytic expressions for the scaling factor of several classes, including for example the prominent class of outerplanar graphs. Our methods also enable us to study first passage percolation on $\mathsf{C}_n$, where we show the convergence to $\mathcal{T}_{\mathsf{e}}$ under an appropriate rescaling.