arXiv++ Combinatorics

We prove that, for arbitrarily small positive $\varepsilon$, there is a finite planar point set $P$ such that every $\varepsilon$-net for the range space induced on $P$ by straight lines has cardinality $Ω\bigl(1/\varepsilon \cdot \log(1/\varepsilon)\bigr)$. This matches the classical upper bound for range spaces with bounded VC-dimension due to Haussler and Welzl and confirms a prediction of Alon.

Even though entropy methods have been used in combinatorics for at least five decades, only in recent years has their use really proliferated. There are now tens, if not hundreds, of combinatorial papers that crucially rely on the notion of entropy and exploit the various powerful identities and inequalities relating entropies. In this short survey article, we give a selective overview of these works and discuss several of them in more detail, outlining some of the key ideas.

Let $G_{n,p}$ be the binomial random graph of density $p$ and let $X_H$ be the number of copies of a fixed graph $H$ in $G_{n,p}$. We prove asymptotically tight bounds on the logarithmic upper-tail probability of $X_H$ whenever $H$ is a connected, irregular graph with maximum degree $Δ\ge 2$ and $p \ge n^{-1/Δ- \varepsilon_H} (\log n)^{ω(1)}$ for an explicit $\varepsilon_H >0$. These bounds are expressed in terms of a new variational problem that generalises the combinatorial optimisation problem arising from the naïve mean-field approximation. This new variational problem includes an entropy term that corresponds to the large number of embeddings of certain highly structured graphs in $K_n$. For a certain class of irregular graphs $H$ that we call stable, we show that this description of the upper-tail probability is valid in a range of densities that is optimal up to a poly($\log\log n$) factor. For a further subclass of stable graphs, which includes all irregular complete bipartite graphs, we show that this range of densities is optimal up to a multiplicative constant.

A $0/1$-polytope in $\mathbb{R}^n$ is the convex hull of a subset of $\{0,1\}^n$. The graph of a polytope $P$ is the graph whose vertices are the zero-dimensional faces of $P$ and whose edges are the one-dimensional faces of $P$. A conjecture of Mihail and Vazirani states that the edge expansion of the graph of every $0/1$-polytope is at least one. We study a random version of the problem, where the polytope is generated by selecting vertices of $\{0,1\}^n$ independently at random with probability $p\in (0,1)$. Improving earlier results, we show that, for any $p\in (0,1)$, with high probability the edge expansion of the random $0/1$-polytope is bounded from below by an absolute constant.

Let $X$ be the number of $k$-term arithmetic progressions contained in the $p$-biased random subset of the first $N$ positive integers. We give asymptotically sharp estimates on the logarithmic upper-tail probability $\log \Pr(X \ge E[X] + t)$ for all $Ω(N^{-2/k}) \le p \ll 1$ and all $t \gg \sqrt{Var(X)}$, excluding only a few boundary cases. In particular, we show that the space of parameters $(p,t)$ is partitioned into three phenomenologically distinct regions, where the upper-tail probabilities either resemble those of Gaussian or Poisson random variables, or are naturally described by the probability of appearance of a small set that contains nearly all of the excess $t$ progressions. We employ a variety of tools from probability theory, including classical tilting arguments and martingale concentration inequalities. However, the main technical innovation is a combinatorial result that establishes a stronger version of `entropic stability' for sets with rich arithmetic structure.

The hypergraph container lemma is a powerful tool in probabilistic combinatorics that has found many applications since it was first proved a decade ago. Roughly speaking, it asserts that the family of independent sets of every uniform hypergraph can be covered by a small number of almost-independent sets, called containers. In this article, we formulate and prove two new versions of the lemma that display the following three attractive features. First, they both admit short and simple proofs that have surprising connections to other well-studied topics in probabilistic combinatorics. Second, they use alternative notions of almost-independence in order to describe the containers. Third, they yield improved dependence of the number of containers on the uniformity of the hypergraph, hitting a natural barrier for second-moment-type approaches.

In this short note, we establish an edge-isoperimetric inequality for arbitrary product graphs. Our inequality is sharp for subsets of many different sizes in every product graph. In particular, it implies that the $2^d$-element sets with smallest edge-boundary in the hypercube are subcubes and is only marginally weaker than the Bollobás$\unicode{x2013}$Leader edge-isoperimetric inequalities for grids and tori. Additionally, it improves two edge-isoperimetric inequalities for products of regular graphs proved by Erde, Kang, Krivelevich, and the first author and answers two questions about edge-isoperimetry in powers of regular graphs raised in their work.

We prove that the family of largest cuts in the binomial random graph exhibits the following stability property: If $1/n \ll p = 1-Ω(1)$, then, with high probability, there is a set of $n - o(n)$ vertices that is partitioned in the same manner by all maximum cuts of $G_{n,p}$. Moreover, the analogous statement remains true when one replaces maximum cuts with nearly-maximum cuts. We then demonstrate how one can use this statement as a tool for showing that certain properties of $G_{n,p}$ that hold in a fixed balanced cut hold simultaneously in all maximum cuts. We provide two example applications of this tool. First, we prove that maximum cuts in $G_{n,p}$ typically partition the neighbourhood of every vertex into nearly equal parts; this resolves a conjecture of DeMarco and Kahn for all but a narrow range of densities $p$. Second, for all edge-critical, nonbipartite, and strictly 2-balanced graphs $H$, we prove a lower bound on the threshold density $p$ above which every largest $H$-free subgraph of $G_{n,p}$ is $(χ(H)-1)$-partite. Our lower bound exactly matches the upper bound on this threshold recently obtained by the first two authors.

Let $H$ be a graph with $χ(H) = r+1$. Simonovits's theorem states that, if $H$ is edge-critical, the unique largest $H$-free subgraph of $K_n$ is its largest $r$-partite subgraph, provided that $n$ is sufficiently large. We show that the same holds with $K_n$ replaced by the binomial random graph $G_{n,p}$ whenever $H$ is also strictly $2$-balanced and $p \ge (θ_H+o(1)) n^{-\frac{1}{m_2(H)}} (\log n)^{\frac{1}{e_H-1}}$ for some explicit constant $θ_H$, which we believe to be optimal. This (partially) resolves a conjecture of DeMarco and Kahn.

Let us say that a graph $G$ is Ramsey for a tuple $(H_1,\dots,H_r)$ of graphs if every $r$-coloring of the edges of $G$ contains a monochromatic copy of $H_i$ in color $i$, for some $i \in [r]$. A famous conjecture of Kohayakawa and Kreuter, extending seminal work of Rödl and Ruciński, predicts the threshold at which the binomial random graph $G_{n,p}$ becomes Ramsey for $(H_1,\dots,H_r)$ asymptotically almost surely. In this paper, we resolve the Kohayakawa-Kreuter conjecture for almost all tuples of graphs. Moreover, we reduce its validity to the truth of a certain deterministic statement, which is a clear necessary condition for the conjecture to hold. All of our results actually hold in greater generality, when one replaces the graphs $H_1,\dots,H_r$ by finite families $\mathcal{H}_1,\dots,\mathcal{H}_r$. Additionally, we pose a natural (deterministic) graph-partitioning conjecture, which we believe to be of independent interest, and whose resolution would imply the Kohayakawa-Kreuter conjecture.

Given a family of graphs $\mathcal{F}$ and an integer $r$, we say that a graph is $r$-Ramsey for $\mathcal{F}$ if any $r$-colouring of its edges admits a monochromatic copy of a graph from $\mathcal{F}$. The threshold for the classic Ramsey property in the binomial random graph, where $\mathcal{F}$ consists of one graph, was located in the celebrated work of Rödl and Ruciński. In this paper, we offer a twofold generalisation to the Rödl--Ruciński theorem. First, we show that the list-colouring version of the property has the same threshold. Second, we extend this result to finite families $\mathcal{F}$, where the threshold statements might also diverge. This also confirms further special cases of the Kohayakawa--Kreuter conjecture. Along the way, we supply a short(-ish), self-contained proof of the $0$-statement of the Rödl--Ruciński theorem.

Motivated by the investigation of sharpness of thresholds for Ramsey properties in random graphs, Friedgut, Kohayakawa, Rödl, Ruciński and Tetali introduced two variants of a single-player game whose goal is to colour the edges of a~random graph, in an online fashion, so as not to create a monochromatic triangle. In the two-round variant of the game, the player is first asked to find a triangle-free colouring of the edges of a random graph $G_1$ and then extend this colouring to a triangle-free colouring of the union of $G_1$ and another (independent) random graph $G_2$, which is disclosed to the player only after they have coloured $G_1$. Friedgut et al.\ analysed this variant of the online Ramsey game in two instances: when $G_1$ has $Θ(n^{4/3})$ edges and when the number of edges of $G_1$ is just below the threshold above which a random graph typically no longer admits a triangle-free colouring, which is located at $Θ(n^{3/2})$. The two-round Ramsey game has been recently revisited by Conlon, Das, Lee and Mészáros, who generalised the result of Friedgut at al.\ from triangles to all strictly $2$-balanced graphs. We extend the work of Friedgut et al.\ in an orthogonal direction and analyse the triangle case of the two-round Ramsey game at all intermediate densities. More precisely, for every $n^{-4/3} \ll p \ll n^{-1/2}$, with the exception of $p = Θ(n^{-3/5})$, we determine the threshold density $q$ at which it becomes impossible to extend any triangle-free colouring of a typical $G_1 \sim G_{n,p}$ to a triangle-free colouring of the union of $G_1$ and $G_2 \sim G_{n,q}$. An interesting aspect of our result is that this threshold density $q$ `jumps' by a polynomial quantity as $p$ crosses a `critical' window around $n^{-3/5}$.

We prove that for every non-trivial hereditary family of graphs ${\cal P}$ and for every fixed $p \in (0,1)$, the maximum possible number of edges in a subgraph of the random graph $G(n,p)$ which belongs to ${\cal P}$ is, with high probability, $$ \left(1-\frac{1}{k-1}+o(1)\right)p{n \choose 2}, $$ where $k$ is the minimum chromatic number of a graph that does not belong to ${\cal P}$.

In this work, we develop a unified framework for establishing sharp threshold results for various Ramsey properties. To achieve this, we view such properties as non-colourability of auxiliary hypergraphs. Our main technical result gives sufficient conditions on a sequence of such hypergraphs that guarantee that this non-colourability property has a sharp threshold in subhypergraphs induced by random subsets of the vertices. Furthermore, we verify these conditions in several cases of interest. In the classical setting of Ramsey theory for graphs, we show that the property of being Ramsey for a graph $H$ in $r$ colours has a sharp threshold in $G_{n,p}$, for all $r \ge 2$ and all $H$ in a class of graphs that includes all cliques and cycles. In the arithmetic setting, we establish sharpness of thresholds for the properties corresponding to van der Waerden's theorem and Schur's theorem, also in any number of colours.

This work studies the typical structure of sparse $H$-free graphs, that is, graphs that do not contain a subgraph isomorphic to a given graph $H$. Extending the seminal result of Osthus, Prömel, and Taraz that addressed the case where $H$ is an odd cycle, Balogh, Morris, Samotij, and Warnke proved that, for every $r \ge 3$, the structure of a random $K_{r+1}$-free graph with $n$ vertices and $m$ edges undergoes a phase transition when $m$ crosses an explicit (sharp) threshold function $m_r(n)$. They conjectured that a similar threshold phenomenon occurs when $K_{r+1}$ is replaced by any strictly $2$-balanced, edge-critical graph $H$. In this paper, we resolve this conjecture. In fact, we prove that the structure of a typical $H$-free graph undergoes an analogous phase transition for every $H$ in a family of vertex-critical graphs that includes all edge-critical graphs.

We show that the naive mean-field approximation correctly predicts the leading term of the logarithmic lower tail probabilities for the number of copies of a given subgraph in $G(n,p)$ and of arithmetic progressions of a given length in random subsets of the integers in the entire range of densities where the mean-field approximation is viable. Our main technical result provides sufficient conditions on the maximum degrees of a uniform hypergraph $\mathcal{H}$ that guarantee that the logarithmic lower tail probabilities for the number of edges induced by a binomial random subset of the vertices of $\mathcal{H}$ can be well-approximated by considering only product distributions. This may be interpreted as a weak, probabilistic version of the hypergraph container lemma that is applicable to all sparser-than-average (and not only independent) sets.

The collection $\mathcal{M}_n$ of all metric spaces on $n$ points whose diameter is at most $2$ can naturally be viewed as a compact convex subset of $\mathbb{R}^{\binom{n}{2}}$, known as the metric polytope. In this paper, we study the metric polytope for large $n$ and show that it is close to the cube $[1,2]^{\binom{n}{2}} \subseteq \mathcal{M}_n$ in the following two senses. First, the volume of the polytope is not much larger than that of the cube, with the following quantitative estimates: \[ \left(\tfrac{1}{6}+o(1)\right)n^{3/2} \le \log \mathrm{Vol}(\mathcal{M}_n)\le O(n^{3/2}). \] Second, when sampling a metric space from $\mathcal{M}_n$ uniformly at random, the minimum distance is at least $1 - n^{-c}$ with high probability, for some $c > 0$. Our proof is based on entropy techniques. We discuss alternative approaches to estimating the volume of $\mathcal{M}_n$ using exchangeability, Szemerédi's regularity lemma, the hypergraph container method, and the Kővári--Sós--Turán theorem.

We prove a new, efficient version of the hypergraph container theorems that is suited for hypergraphs with large uniformities. The main novelty is a refined approach to constructing containers that employs simple ideas from high-dimensional convex geometry. The existence of smaller families of containers for independent sets in such hypergraphs, which is guaranteed by the new theorem, allows us to improve upon the best currently known bounds for several problems in extremal graph theory, discrete geometry, and Ramsey theory.

Let $ε_1, \dotsc, ε_n$ be i.i.d. Rademacher random variables taking values $\pm 1$ with probability $1/2$ each. Given an integer vector $\boldsymbol{a} = (a_1, \dotsc, a_n)$, its concentration probability is the quantity $ρ(\boldsymbol{a}):=\sup_{x\in \mathbb{Z}}\Pr(ε_1 a_1+\dots+ε_n a_n = x)$. The Littlewood-Offord problem asks for bounds on $ρ(\boldsymbol{a})$ under various hypotheses on $\boldsymbol{a}$, whereas the inverse Littlewood-Offord problem, posed by Tao and Vu, asks for a characterization of all vectors $\boldsymbol{a}$ for which $ρ(\boldsymbol{a})$ is large. In this paper, we study the associated counting problem: How many integer vectors $\boldsymbol{a}$ belonging to a specified set have large $ρ(\boldsymbol{a})$? The motivation for our study is that in typical applications, the inverse Littlewood-Offord theorems are only used to obtain such counting estimates. Using a more direct approach, we obtain significantly better bounds for this problem than those obtained using the inverse Littlewood--Offord theorems of Tao and Vu and of Nguyen and Vu. Moreover, we develop a framework for deriving upper bounds on the probability of singularity of random discrete matrices that utilizes our counting result. To illustrate the methods, we present the first `exponential-type' (i.e., $\exp(-n^c)$ for some positive constant $c$) upper bounds on the singularity probability for the following two models: (i) adjacency matrices of dense signed random regular digraphs, for which the previous best known bound is $O(n^{-1/4})$ due to Cook; and (ii) dense row-regular $\{0,1\}$-matrices, for which the previous best known bound is $O_{C}(n^{-C})$ for any constant $C>0$ due to Nguyen.

Suppose that $X$ is a bounded-degree polynomial with nonnegative coefficients on the $p$-biased discrete hypercube. Our main result gives sharp estimates on the logarithmic upper tail probability of $X$ whenever an associated extremal problem satisfies a certain entropic stability property. We apply this result to solve two long-standing open problems in probabilistic combinatorics: the upper tail problem for the number of arithmetic progressions of a fixed length in the $p$-random subset of the integers and the upper tail problem for the number of cliques of a fixed size in the random graph $G_{n,p}$. We also make significant progress on the upper tail problem for the number of copies of a fixed regular graph $H$ in $G_{n,p}$. To accommodate readers who are interested in learning the basic method, we include a short, self-contained solution to the upper tail problem for the number of triangles in $G_{n,p}$ for all $p=p(n)$ satisfying $n^{-1}\log n\ll p \ll 1$.