arXiv++ Combinatorics

The last two decades have witnessed a growing trend towards proving sparse random analogues of combinatorial theorems. One unified approach to proving such theorems, formalised by Conlon and Gowers [Ann. of Math. 2016], involves establishing a 'transference principle' which allows one to translate between robust properties in the dense setting and the sparse $p$-random setting, provided $p$ is not too small. Our results provide a more general transference theorem, extending the results of Conlon and Gowers and also those of Schacht [Ann. of Math. 2016]. Among a variety of other applications, we use this to obtain a sparse counting lemma for graphs and hypergraphs which are not necessarily strictly balanced. Our method achieves asymptotically optimal bounds on the probability $p$, and the probability of success.

We consider the problem of minimizing the number of monochromatic subgraphs of a random graph, when each node of the host graph is assigned one of the two colors. Using a recently discovered contiguity between appearance of strictly balanced subgraphs $F$ in a random graph, and random hypergraphs where copies of $F$ are generated independently, we show that the minimum value converges to a limit, when the expected number of copies of $F$ is linear in the number of nodes $|V|$. Furthermore, using the connections with mean field spin glass models, we obtain an asymptotic expression for this limit as the normalized expected number of copies of $F$ and the size of $F$ diverge to infinity.

Let $F$ be a strictly $1$-balanced $k$-graph on $s$ vertices with $t$ edges and $δ_{F,d}^T$ be the infimum of $δ>0$ such that for every $α>0$ and sufficiently large $n\in \mathbb{N}$, every $k$-graph system $\mathbf H=\{H_{1}, H_{2}, \dots ,H_{tn}\}$ on the same $sn$ vertices with $δ_d(H_i)\ge (δ+α)\binom{sn-d}{k-d}$, $i\in [tn]$ contains a transversal $F$-factor, that is, an $F$-factor consisting of exactly one edge from each $H_i$. In this paper we prove the following result. Let $\mathbf{H} =\{H_{1}, H_{2}, \dots ,H_{tn}\}$ be a $k$-graph system where each $H_{i}$ is an $sn$-vertex $k$-graph with $δ_d(H_i)\ge (δ_{F,d}^T+α)\binom{sn-d}{k-d}$. Then with high probability $\mathbf{H}(p) :=\{H_{1}(p), H_{2}(p), \dots ,H_{tn}(p)\}$ contains a transversal $F$-factor, where $H_i(p)$ is a random subhypergraph of $H_i$ and $p=Ω(n^{-1/d_1(F)-1}(\log n)^{1/t})$. This extends a recent result by Kelly, Müyesser and Pokrovskiy, and independently by Joos, Lang and Sanhueza-Matamala. Moreover, the assumption on $p$ is best possible up to a constant. Along the way, we also obtain a spread version of a result of Pikhurko on perfect matchings in $k$-partite $k$-graphs.

We consider the upper tail large deviations of subgraph counts for irregular graphs $\mathrm{H}$ in $\mathbb{G}(n,p)$, the sparse Erdős-Rényi graph on $n$ vertices with edge connectivity probability $p \in (0,1)$. For $n^{-1/Δ} \ll p \ll 1$, where $Δ$ is the maximum degree of $\mathrm{H}$, we derive the upper tail large deviations for any irregular graph $\mathrm{H}$. On the other hand, we show that for $p$ such that $1 \ll n^{v_{\mathrm{H}}} p^{e_{\mathrm{H}}} \ll (\log n)^{α^{*}_{\mathrm{H}}/\left(α^{*}_{\mathrm{H}}-1\right)}$, where $v_{\mathrm{H}}$ and $e_{\mathrm{H}}$ denote the number of vertices and edges of $\mathrm{H}$, and $α^*_{\mathrm{H}}$ denotes the fractional independence number, the upper tail large deviations of the number of unlabelled copies of $\mathrm{H}$ in $\mathbb{G}(n,p)$ is given by that of a sequence of Poisson random variables with diverging mean, for any strictly balanced graph $\mathrm{H}$. Restricting to the $r$-armed star graph we further prove a localized behavior in the intermediate range of $p$ (left open by the above two results) and show that the mean-field approximation is asymptotically tight for the logarithm of the upper tail probability. This work further identifies the typical structures of $\mathbb{G}(n,p)$ conditioned on upper tail rare events in the localized regime.

Let $k\geq 2$ and fix a $k$-uniform hypergraph $\mathcal{F}$. Consider the random process that, starting from a $k$-uniform hypergraph $\mathcal{H}$ on $n$ vertices, repeatedly deletes the edges of a copy of $\mathcal{F}$ chosen uniformly at random and terminates when no copies of $\mathcal{F}$ remain. Let $R(\mathcal{H},\mathcal{F})$ denote the number of edges that are left after termination. We show that $R(\mathcal{H},\mathcal{F})=n^{k-1/ρ\pm o(1)}$, where $ρ:=(\lvert E(\mathcal{F})\rvert-1)/(\lvert V(\mathcal{F})\rvert -k)$, holds with high probability provided that $\mathcal{F}$ is strictly $k$-balanced and $\mathcal{H}$ is sufficiently dense with pseudorandom properties. Since we may in particular choose $\mathcal{F}$ and $\mathcal{H}$ to be complete graphs, this confirms the major folklore conjecture in the area in a very strong form.

Let $F$ be a graph on $r$ vertices and let $G$ be a graph on $n$ vertices. Then an $F$-factor in $G$ is a subgraph of $G$ composed of $n/r$ vertex-disjoint copies of $F$, if $r$ divides $n$. In other words, an $F$-factor yields a partition of the $n$ vertices of $G$. The study of such $F$-factors in the Erdős-Rényi random graph dates back to Erdős himself. Decades later, in 2008, Johansson, Kahn and Vu established the thresholds for the existence of an $F$-factor for strictly 1-balanced $F$ -- up to the leading constant. The sharp thresholds, meaning the leading constants, were obtained only recently by Riordan and Heckel, but only for complete graphs $F=K_r$ and for so-called nice graphs. Their results rely on sophisticated couplings that utilize the recent, celebrated solution of Shamir's problem by Kahn. We extend the couplings by Riordan and Heckel to any strictly 1-balanced $F$ and thereby obtain the sharp threshold for the existence of an $F$-factor. In particular, we confirm the thirty year old conjecture by Rucínski that this sharp threshold indeed coincides with the sharp threshold for the disappearance of the last vertices which are not contained in a copy of $F$.

The edge space $\mathcal{E}(G)$ of a graph $G$ is the vector space $\mathbb{F}_2^{E(G)}$ with members naturally identified with subgraphs of $G$, and the $H$-space is the subspace $\mathcal{C}_H(G)$ of $ \mathcal{E}(G)$ spanned by copies of the graph $H$. We are interested in when the random graph $G = G_{n,p}$ is likely to satisfy \[\mathcal{C}_H(G) = \mathcal{W}_H(G),\] where $\mathcal{W}_H(G)$ takes one of four natural values, depending on the value of $\mathcal{C}_H(K_n)$. We show that for strictly $2$-balanced $H$, w.h.p. the above equality holds whenever every edge of $G$ is in a copy of $H$.

Consider the random $u$-uniform hypergraph (or $u$-graph) process on $n$ vertices, where $n$ is divisible by $r>u\ge 2$. It was recently shown that with high probability, as soon as every vertex is covered by a copy of the complete $u$-graph $K_r$, it also contains a $K_r$-factor (RSA, Vol. 65 II, Sept. 2024). The hitting time result is obtained using a process coupling, which is based on the proof of the corresponding sharp threshold result (RSA, Vol. 61 IV, Dec. 2022). The latter, however, was not only derived for complete $u$-graphs, but for a broader class of so-called nice $u$-graphs. The purpose of this article is to extend the process coupling for complete $u$-graphs to the full scope of the sharp threshold result: nice $u$-graphs. As a byproduct, we obtain the extension of the hitting time result to nice $u$-graphs. Since the relevant combinatorial bounds in the proof for the $K_r$-case cannot be generalized, we introduce new arguments that do not only apply to nice u-graphs, but will be relevant for the broader class of strictly 1-balanced u-graphs. Further, we show how the remainder of the process coupling for the $K_r$-case can be utilized in a black-box manner for any u-graph. These advances pave the way for future generalizations.

We study the problem of distinguishing between two independent samples $\mathbf{G}_n^1,\mathbf{G}_n^2$ of a binomial random graph $G(n,p)$ by first order (FO) sentences. Shelah and Spencer proved that, for a constant $α\in(0,1)$, $G(n,n^{-α})$ obeys FO zero-one law if and only if $α$ is irrational. Therefore, for irrational $α\in(0,1)$, any fixed FO sentence does not distinguish between $\mathbf{G}_n^1,\mathbf{G}_n^2$ with asymptotical probability 1 (w.h.p.) as $n\to\infty$. We show that the minimum quantifier depth $\mathbf{k}_α$ of a FO sentence $\varphi=\varphi(\mathbf{G}_n^1,\mathbf{G}_n^2)$ distinguishing between $\mathbf{G}_n^1,\mathbf{G}_n^2$ depends on how closely $α$ can be approximated by rationals: (1) for all non-Liouville $α\in(0,1)$, $\mathbf{k}_α=Ω(\ln\ln\ln n)$ w.h.p.; (2) there are irrational $α\in(0,1)$ with $\mathbf{k}_α$ that grow arbitrarily slowly w.h.p.; (3) $\mathbf{k}_α=O_p(\frac{\ln n}{\ln\ln n})$ for all $α\in(0,1)$. The main ingredients in our proofs are a novel randomized algorithm that generates asymmetric strictly balanced graphs as well as a new method to study symmetry groups of randomly perturbed graphs.

We prove that the family of largest cuts in the binomial random graph exhibits the following stability property: If $1/n \ll p = 1-Ω(1)$, then, with high probability, there is a set of $n - o(n)$ vertices that is partitioned in the same manner by all maximum cuts of $G_{n,p}$. Moreover, the analogous statement remains true when one replaces maximum cuts with nearly-maximum cuts. We then demonstrate how one can use this statement as a tool for showing that certain properties of $G_{n,p}$ that hold in a fixed balanced cut hold simultaneously in all maximum cuts. We provide two example applications of this tool. First, we prove that maximum cuts in $G_{n,p}$ typically partition the neighbourhood of every vertex into nearly equal parts; this resolves a conjecture of DeMarco and Kahn for all but a narrow range of densities $p$. Second, for all edge-critical, nonbipartite, and strictly 2-balanced graphs $H$, we prove a lower bound on the threshold density $p$ above which every largest $H$-free subgraph of $G_{n,p}$ is $(χ(H)-1)$-partite. Our lower bound exactly matches the upper bound on this threshold recently obtained by the first two authors.

Let $H$ be a graph with $χ(H) = r+1$. Simonovits's theorem states that, if $H$ is edge-critical, the unique largest $H$-free subgraph of $K_n$ is its largest $r$-partite subgraph, provided that $n$ is sufficiently large. We show that the same holds with $K_n$ replaced by the binomial random graph $G_{n,p}$ whenever $H$ is also strictly $2$-balanced and $p \ge (θ_H+o(1)) n^{-\frac{1}{m_2(H)}} (\log n)^{\frac{1}{e_H-1}}$ for some explicit constant $θ_H$, which we believe to be optimal. This (partially) resolves a conjecture of DeMarco and Kahn.

For graphs $G, H_1,\dots,H_r$, write $G \to (H_1, \ldots, H_r)$ to denote the property that whenever we $r$-colour the edges of $G$, there is a monochromatic copy of $H_i$ in colour $i$ for some $i \in \{1,\dots,r\}$. Mousset, Nenadov and Samotij proved an upper bound on the threshold function for the property that $G_{n,p} \to (H_1,\dots,H_r)$, thereby resolving the $1$-statement of the Kohayakawa--Kreuter conjecture. We reduce the $0$-statement of the Kohayakawa--Kreuter conjecture to a natural deterministic colouring problem and resolve this problem for almost all cases, which in particular includes (but is not limited to) when $H_2$ is strictly $2$-balanced and either has density greater than $2$ or is not bipartite. In addition, we extend our reduction to hypergraphs, proving the colouring problem in almost all cases there as well.

Motivated by the investigation of sharpness of thresholds for Ramsey properties in random graphs, Friedgut, Kohayakawa, Rödl, Ruciński and Tetali introduced two variants of a single-player game whose goal is to colour the edges of a~random graph, in an online fashion, so as not to create a monochromatic triangle. In the two-round variant of the game, the player is first asked to find a triangle-free colouring of the edges of a random graph $G_1$ and then extend this colouring to a triangle-free colouring of the union of $G_1$ and another (independent) random graph $G_2$, which is disclosed to the player only after they have coloured $G_1$. Friedgut et al.\ analysed this variant of the online Ramsey game in two instances: when $G_1$ has $Θ(n^{4/3})$ edges and when the number of edges of $G_1$ is just below the threshold above which a random graph typically no longer admits a triangle-free colouring, which is located at $Θ(n^{3/2})$. The two-round Ramsey game has been recently revisited by Conlon, Das, Lee and Mészáros, who generalised the result of Friedgut at al.\ from triangles to all strictly $2$-balanced graphs. We extend the work of Friedgut et al.\ in an orthogonal direction and analyse the triangle case of the two-round Ramsey game at all intermediate densities. More precisely, for every $n^{-4/3} \ll p \ll n^{-1/2}$, with the exception of $p = Θ(n^{-3/5})$, we determine the threshold density $q$ at which it becomes impossible to extend any triangle-free colouring of a typical $G_1 \sim G_{n,p}$ to a triangle-free colouring of the union of $G_1$ and $G_2 \sim G_{n,q}$. An interesting aspect of our result is that this threshold density $q$ `jumps' by a polynomial quantity as $p$ crosses a `critical' window around $n^{-3/5}$.

We consider the binomial random set model $[n]_p$ where each element in $\{1,\dots,n\}$ is chosen independently with probability $p:=p(n)$. We show that for essentially all regimes of $p$ and very general conditions for a matrix $A$ and a column vector $\mathbf{b}$, the count of specific integer solutions to the system of linear equations $A\mathbf{x} = \mathbf{b}$ with the entries of $\mathbf{x}$ in $[n]_p$ follows a (conveniently rescaled) normal limiting distribution. This applies among others to the number of solutions with every variable having a different value, as well as to a broader class of so-called non-trivial solutions in homogeneous strictly balanced systems. Our proof relies on the delicate linear algebraic study both of the subjacent matrices and the corresponding ranks of certain submatrices, together with the application of the method of moments in probability theory.

This work studies the typical structure of sparse $H$-free graphs, that is, graphs that do not contain a subgraph isomorphic to a given graph $H$. Extending the seminal result of Osthus, Prömel, and Taraz that addressed the case where $H$ is an odd cycle, Balogh, Morris, Samotij, and Warnke proved that, for every $r \ge 3$, the structure of a random $K_{r+1}$-free graph with $n$ vertices and $m$ edges undergoes a phase transition when $m$ crosses an explicit (sharp) threshold function $m_r(n)$. They conjectured that a similar threshold phenomenon occurs when $K_{r+1}$ is replaced by any strictly $2$-balanced, edge-critical graph $H$. In this paper, we resolve this conjecture. In fact, we prove that the structure of a typical $H$-free graph undergoes an analogous phase transition for every $H$ in a family of vertex-critical graphs that includes all edge-critical graphs.

As introduced by Bollobás, a graph $G$ is weakly $H$-saturated if the complete graph $K_n$ is obtained by iteratively completing copies of $H$ minus an edge. For all graphs $H$, we obtain an asymptotic lower bound for the critical threshold $p_c$, at which point the Erdős--Rényi graph ${\mathcal G}_{n,p}$ is likely to be weakly $H$-saturated. We also prove an upper bound for $p_c$, for all $H$ which are, in a sense, strictly balanced. In particular, we improve the upper bound by Balogh, Bollob{á}s and Morris for $H=K_r$, and we conjecture that this is sharp up to constants.

We consider rooted subgraphs in random graphs, i.e., extension counts such as (i) the number of triangles containing a given vertex or (ii) the number of paths of length three connecting two given vertices. In 1989, Spencer gave sufficient conditions for the event that, with high probability, these extension counts are asymptotically equal for all choices of the root vertices. For the important strictly balanced case, Spencer also raised the fundamental question as to whether these conditions are necessary. We answer this question by a careful second moment argument, and discuss some intriguing problems that remain open.

A well-known result of Rödl and Ruciński states that for any graph $H$ there exists a constant $C$ such that if $p \geq C n^{- 1/m_2(H)}$, then the random graph $G_{n,p}$ is a.a.s. $H$-Ramsey, that is, any $2$-colouring of its edges contains a monochromatic copy of $H$. Aside from a few simple exceptions, the corresponding $0$-statement also holds, that is, there exists $c>0$ such that whenever $p\leq cn^{-1/m_2(H)}$ the random graph $G_{n,p}$ is a.a.s. not $H$-Ramsey. We show that near this threshold, even when $G_{n,p}$ is not $H$-Ramsey, it is often extremely close to being $H$-Ramsey. More precisely, we prove that for any constant $c > 0$ and any strictly $2$-balanced graph $H$, if $p \geq c n^{-1/m_2(H)}$, then the random graph $G_{n,p}$ a.a.s. has the property that every $2$-edge-colouring without monochromatic copies of $H$ cannot be extended to an $H$-free colouring after $ω(1)$ extra random edges are added. This generalises a result by Friedgut, Kohayakawa, Rödl, Ruciński and Tetali, who in 2002 proved the same statement for triangles, and addresses a question raised by those authors. We also extend a result of theirs on the three-colour case and show that these theorems need not hold when $H$ is not strictly $2$-balanced.

A word $u$ is a scattered factor of $w$ if $u$ can be obtained from $w$ by deleting some of its letters. That is, there exist the (potentially empty) words $u_1,u_2,..., u_n$, and $v_0,v_1,..,v_n$ such that $u = u_1u_2...u_n$ and $w = v_0u_1v_1u_2v_2...u_nv_n$. We consider the set of length-$k$ scattered factors of a given word w, called here $k$-spectrum and denoted $\ScatFact_k(w)$. We prove a series of properties of the sets $\ScatFact_k(w)$ for binary strictly balanced and, respectively, $c$-balanced words $w$, i.e., words over a two-letter alphabet where the number of occurrences of each letter is the same, or, respectively, one letter has $c$-more occurrences than the other. In particular, we consider the question which cardinalities $n= |\ScatFact_k(w)|$ are obtainable, for a positive integer $k$, when $w$ is either a strictly balanced binary word of length $2k$, or a $c$-balanced binary word of length $2k-c$. We also consider the problem of reconstructing words from their $k$-spectra.

Given a hypergraph $\mathcal{H}$, the $\mathcal{H}$-bootstrap process starts with an initial set of infected vertices of $\mathcal{H}$ and, at each step, a healthy vertex $v$ becomes infected if there exists a hyperedge of $\mathcal{H}$ in which $v$ is the unique healthy vertex. We say that the set of initially infected vertices percolates if every vertex of $\mathcal{H}$ is eventually infected. We show that this process exhibits a sharp threshold when $\mathcal{H}$ is a hypergraph obtained by randomly sampling hyperedges from an approximately $d$-regular $r$-uniform hypergraph satisfying some mild degree and codegree conditions; this confirms a conjecture of Morris. As a corollary, we obtain a sharp threshold for a variant of the graph bootstrap process for strictly $2$-balanced graphs which generalises a result of Korándi, Peled and Sudakov. Our approach involves an application of the differential equations method.