arXiv++ Combinatorics

The last two decades have witnessed a growing trend towards proving sparse random analogues of combinatorial theorems. One unified approach to proving such theorems, formalised by Conlon and Gowers [Ann. of Math. 2016], involves establishing a 'transference principle' which allows one to translate between robust properties in the dense setting and the sparse $p$-random setting, provided $p$ is not too small. Our results provide a more general transference theorem, extending the results of Conlon and Gowers and also those of Schacht [Ann. of Math. 2016]. Among a variety of other applications, we use this to obtain a sparse counting lemma for graphs and hypergraphs which are not necessarily strictly balanced. Our method achieves asymptotically optimal bounds on the probability $p$, and the probability of success.

The celebrated Bollobás-Eldridge-Catlin packing conjecture states that every $n$-vertex graph $G$ with minimum degree at least $\big(1-\frac{1}{Δ+1}\big) n$ contains every $n$-vertex graph $H$ of maximum degree at most $Δ$. Despite considerable attention, the conjecture remains widely open. We show that for bipartite $H$ this threshold can be greatly improved: there is an absolute constant $c>0$ such that every $n$-vertex graph $G$ with minimum degree at least $ \big(1-c\frac{\logΔ}Δ\big)n $ contains every $n$-vertex bipartite graph $H$ of maximum degree at most $Δ$, provided $Δ$ is not too large compared to $n$. Moreover, we prove that this logarithmic improvement is best possible up to the value of the constant.

A graph $Γ$ is said to be universal for a class of graphs $\mathcal{H}$ if $Γ$ contains a copy of every $H \in \mathcal{H}$ as a subgraph. The number of edges required for a host graph $Γ$ to be universal for the class of $D$-degenerate graphs on $n$ vertices has been shown to be $O(n^{2-1/D}(\log n)^{2/D}(\log\log n)^{5})$. We generalise this result to $r$-uniform hypergraphs, showing the following. Given $D, r \ge 2$ and $n$ sufficiently large, there exists a constant $C = C(D, r)$ such that there exists a graph with at most \[Cn^{r-1/D}(\log n)^{2/D}(\log\log n)^{2r+1}\] edges which is universal for the class of $D$-degenerate $r$-uniform hypergraphs on $n$ vertices. This is tight up to the polylogarithmic term.

We prove a robust version of a graph embedding theorem of Sauer and Spencer. To state this sparser analogue, we define $G(p)$ to be a random subgraph of $G$ obtained by retaining each edge of $G$ independently with probability $p \in [0,1]$, and let $m_1(H)$ be the maximum $1$-density of a graph $H$. We show that for any constant $Δ$ and $γ> 0$, if $G$ is an $n$-vertex host graph with minimum degree $δ(G) \geq (1 - 1/2Δ+ γ)n$ and $H$ is an $n$-vertex graph with maximum degree $Δ(H) \leq Δ$, then for $p \geq Cn^{-1/m_1(H)}\log n$, the random subgraph $G(p)$ contains a copy of $H$ with high probability. Our value for $p$ is optimal up to a log-factor. In fact, we prove this result for a more general minimum degree condition on $G$, by introducing an \emph{extension threshold} $δ_{\rm e}(Δ)$, such that the above result holds for graphs $G$ with ${δ(G) \geq (δ_{\rm e}(Δ) + γ)n}$. We show that $δ_{\rm e}(Δ) \leq (2Δ-1)/2Δ$, and further conjecture that $δ_{\rm e}(Δ)$ equals $Δ/(Δ+1)$, which matches the minimum degree condition on $G$ in the Bollobás-Eldridge-Catlin Conjecture. A main tool in our proof is a vertex-spread version of the blow-up lemma of Allen, Böttcher, Hàn, Kohayakawa, and Person, which we believe to be of independent interest.

Given a family $\mathcal{H}$ of graphs, a graph $G$ is called $\mathcal{H}$-universal if $G$ contains every graph of $\mathcal{H}$ as a subgraph. Following the extensive research on universal graphs of small size for bounded-degree graphs, Alon asked what is the minimum number of edges that a graph must have to be universal for the class of all $n$-vertex graphs that are $D$-degenerate. In this paper, we answer this question up to a factor that is polylogarithmic in $n.$

Answering a question by Letzter and Snyder, we prove that for large enough $k$ any $n$-vertex graph $G$ with minimum degree at least $\frac{1}{2k-1}n$ and without odd cycles of length less than $2k+1$ is $3$-colourable. In fact, we prove a stronger result that works with a slightly smaller minimum degree.

We prove asymptotically optimal bounds on the number of edges a graph $G$ must have in order that any $r$-colouring of $E(G)$ has a colour class which contains every $D$-degenerate graph on $n$ vertices with bounded maximum degree. We also improve the upper bounds on the number of edges $G$ must have in order that any $r$-colouring of $E(G)$ has a colour class which contains every $n$-vertex graph with maximum degree $Δ$, for each $Δ\ge 4$. In both cases, we show that a binomial random graph with $Cn$ vertices and a suitable edge probability is likely to provide the desired $G$.

For a graph $G$ and $p\in[0,1]$, we denote by $G_p$ the random sparsification of $G$ obtained by keeping each edge of $G$ independently, with probability $p$. We show that there exists a $C>0$ such that if $p\geq C(\log n)^{1/3}n^{-2/3}$ and $G$ is an $n$-vertex graph with $n\in 3\mathbb{N}$ and $δ(G)\geq \tfrac{2n}{3}$, then with high probability $G_p$ contains a triangle factor. Both the minimum degree condition and the probability condition, up to the choice of $C$, are tight. Our result can be viewed as a common strengthening of the seminal theorems of Corrádi and Hajnal, which deals with the extremal minimum degree condition for containing triangle factors (corresponding to $p=1$ in our result), and Johansson, Kahn and Vu, which deals with the threshold for the appearance of a triangle factor in $G(n,p)$ (corresponding to $G=K_n$ in our result). It also implies a lower bound on the number of triangle factors in graphs with minimum degree at least $\tfrac{2n}{3}$ which gets close to the truth.

Lehel conjectured in the 1970s that every red and blue edge-coloured complete graph can be partitioned into two monochromatic cycles. This was confirmed in 2010 by Bessy and Thomassé. However, the host graph $G$ does not have to be complete. It it suffices to require that $G$ has minimum degree at least $3n/4$, where $n$ is the order of $G$, as was shown recently by Letzter, confirming a conjecture of Balogh, Barát, Gerbner, Gyárfás and Sárközy. This degree condition is asymptotically tight. Here we continue this line of research, by proving that for every red and blue edge-colouring of an $n$-vertex graph of minimum degree at least $2n/3 + o(n)$, there is a partition of the vertex set into three monochromatic cycles. This approximately verifies a conjecture of Pokrovskiy and is essentially tight.

We investigate the appearance of the square of a Hamilton cycle in the model of randomly perturbed graphs, which is, for a given $α\in (0,1)$, the union of any $n$-vertex graph with minimum degree $αn$ and the binomial random graph $G(n,p)$. This is known when $α> 1/2$, and we determine the exact perturbed threshold probability in all the remaining cases, i.e., for each $α\le 1/2$. We demonstrate that, as $α$ ranges over the interval $(0,1)$, the threshold performs a countably infinite number of `jumps'. Our result has implications on the perturbed threshold for $2$-universality, where we also fully address all open cases.

We prove that there is $c>0$ such that for all sufficiently large $n$, if $T_1,\dots,T_n$ are any trees such that $T_i$ has $i$ vertices and maximum degree at most $cn/\log n$, then $\{T_1,\dots,T_n\}$ packs into $K_n$. Our main result actually allows to replace the host graph $K_n$ by an arbitrary quasirandom graph, and to generalize from trees to graphs of bounded degeneracy that are rich in bare paths, contain some odd degree vertices, and only satisfy much less stringent restrictions on their number of vertices.

We study the problem of finding pairwise vertex-disjoint copies of the $\ell$-vertex cycle $C_\ell$ in the randomly perturbed graph model, which is the union of a deterministic $n$-vertex graph $G$ and the binomial random graph $G(n,p)$. For $\ell \ge 3$ we prove that asymptotically almost surely $G \cup G(n,p)$ contains $\min \{δ(G), \lfloor n/\ell \rfloor \}$ pairwise vertex-disjoint cycles $C_\ell$, provided $p \ge C \log n/n$ for $C$ sufficiently large. Moreover, when $δ(G) \geαn$ with $0<α\le 1/\ell$ and $G$ is not `close' to the complete bipartite graph $K_{αn,(1-α) n}$, then $p \ge C/n$ suffices to get the same conclusion. This provides a stability version of our result. In particular, we conclude that $p \ge C/n$ suffices when $α>1/\ell$ for finding $\lfloor n/\ell \rfloor$ cycles $C_\ell$. Our results are asymptotically optimal. They can be seen as an interpolation between the Johansson--Kahn--Vu Theorem for $C_\ell$-factors and the resolution of the El-Zahar Conjecture for $C_\ell$-factors by Abbasi.

We study the problem of finding pairwise vertex-disjoint triangles in the randomly perturbed graph model, which is the union of any $n$-vertex graph $G$ satisfying a given minimum degree condition and the binomial random graph $G(n,p)$. We prove that asymptotically almost surely $G \cup G(n,p)$ contains at least $\min\{δ(G), \lfloor n/3 \rfloor\}$ pairwise vertex-disjoint triangles, provided $p \ge C \log n/n$, where $C$ is a large enough constant. This is a perturbed version of an old result of Dirac. Our result is asymptotically optimal and answers a question of Han, Morris, and Treglown [RSA, 2021, no. 3, 480--516] in a strong form. We also prove a stability version of our result, which in the case of pairwise vertex-disjoint triangles extends a result of Han, Morris, and Treglown [RSA, 2021, no. 3, 480--516]. Together with a result of Balogh, Treglown, and Wagner [CPC, 2019, no. 2, 159--176] this fully resolves the existence of triangle factors in randomly perturbed graphs. We believe that the methods introduced in this paper are useful for a variety of related problems: we discuss possible generalisations to clique factors, cycle factors, and $2$-universality.

The bandwidth theorem [Mathematische Annalen, 343(1):175--205, 2009] states that any $n$-vertex graph $G$ with minimum degree $(\frac{k-1}{k}+o(1))n$ contains all $n$-vertex $k$-colourable graphs $H$ with bounded maximum degree and bandwidth $o(n)$. In [arXiv:1612.00661] a random graph analogue of this statement is proved: for $p\gg (\frac{\log n}{n})^{1/Δ}$ a.a.s. each spanning subgraph $G$ of $G(n,p)$ with minimum degree $(\frac{k-1}{k}+o(1))pn$ contains all $n$-vertex $k$-colourable graphs $H$ with maximum degree $Δ$, bandwidth $o(n)$, and at least $C p^{-2}$ vertices not contained in any triangle. This restriction on vertices in triangles is necessary, but limiting. In this paper we consider how it can be avoided. A special case of our main result is that, under the same conditions, if additionally all vertex neighbourhoods in $G$ contain many copies of $K_Δ$ then we can drop the restriction on $H$ that $Cp^{-2}$ vertices should not be in triangles.

We prove that one can perfectly pack degenerate graphs into complete or dense $n$-vertex quasirandom graphs, provided that all the degenerate graphs have maximum degree $o(\frac{n}{\log n})$, and in addition $Ω(n)$ of them have at most $(1-Ω(1))n$ vertices and $Ω(n)$ leaves. This proves Ringel's conjecture and the Gyárfás Tree Packing Conjecture for all but an exponentially small fraction of trees (or sequences of trees, respectively).

We study the model $G_α\cup G(n,p)$ of randomly perturbed dense graphs, where $G_α$ is any $n$-vertex graph with minimum degree at least $αn$ and $G(n,p)$ is the binomial random graph. We introduce a general approach for studying the appearance of spanning subgraphs in this model using absorption. This approach yields simpler proofs of several known results. We also use it to derive the following two new results. For every $α>0$ and $Δ\ge 5$, and every $n$-vertex graph $F$ with maximum degree at most $Δ$, we show that if $p=ω(n^{-2/(Δ+1)})$ then $G_α\cup G(n,p)$ with high probability contains a copy of $F$. The bound used for $p$ here is lower by a $\log$-factor in comparison to the conjectured threshold for the general appearance of such subgraphs in $G(n,p)$ alone, a typical feature of previous results concerning randomly perturbed dense graphs. We also give the first example of graphs where the appearance threshold in $G_α\cup G(n,p)$ is lower than the appearance threshold in $G(n,p)$ by substantially more than a $\log$-factor. We prove that, for every $k\geq 2$ and $α>0$, there is some $η>0$ for which the $k$th power of a Hamilton cycle with high probability appears in $G_α\cup G(n,p)$ when $p=ω(n^{-1/k-η})$. The appearance threshold of the $k$th power of a Hamilton cycle in $G(n,p)$ alone is known to be $n^{-1/k}$, up to a $\log$-term when $k=2$, and exactly for $k>2$.

We solve a problem of Krivelevich, Kwan and Sudakov [SIAM Journal on Discrete Mathematics 31 (2017), 155-171] concerning the threshold for the containment of all bounded degree spanning trees in the model of randomly perturbed dense graphs. More precisely, we show that, if we start with a dense graph $G_α$ on $n$ vertices with $δ(G_α)\ge αn$ for $α>0$ and we add to it the binomial random graph $G(n,C/n)$, then with high probability the graph $G_α\cup G(n,C/n)$ contains copies of all spanning trees with maximum degree at most $Δ$ simultaneously, where $C$ depends only on $α$ and $Δ$.

We prove that for each $D\ge 2$ there exists $c>0$ such that whenever $b\le c\big(\tfrac{n}{\log n}\big)^{1/D}$, in the $(1:b)$ Maker-Breaker game played on $E(K_n)$, Maker has a strategy to guarantee claiming a graph $G$ containing copies of all graphs $H$ with $v(H)\le n$ and $Δ(H)\le D$. We show further that the graph $G$ guaranteed by this strategy also contains copies of any graph $H$ with bounded maximum degree and degeneracy at most $\tfrac{D-1}{2}$. This lower bound on the threshold bias is sharp up to the $\log$-factor when $H$ consists of $\tfrac{n}{3}$ vertex-disjoint triangles or $\tfrac{n}{4}$ vertex-disjoint $K_4$-copies.

Given $D$ and $γ>0$, whenever $c>0$ is sufficiently small and $n$ sufficiently large, if $\mathcal{G}$ is a family of $D$-degenerate graphs of individual orders at most $n$, maximum degrees at most $\tfrac{cn}{\log n}$, and total number of edges at most $(1-γ)\binom{n}{2}$, then $\mathcal{G}$ packs into the complete graph $K_{n}$. Our proof proceeds by analysing a natural random greedy packing algorithm. This version of the manuscript corrects a small error that appeared in the published version [Adv Math, 354 (2019), 106739].

In recent years there has been much progress in graph theory on questions of the following type. What is the threshold for a certain large substructure to appear in a random graph? When does a random graph contain all structures from a given family? And when does it contain them so robustly that even an adversary who is allowed to perturb the graph cannot destroy all of them? I will survey this progress, and highlight the vital role played by some newly developed methods, such as the sparse regularity method, the absorbing method, and the container method. I will also mention many open questions that remain in this area.