arXiv++ Combinatorics

We prove an $\mathrm{MSO}_2$ zero-one law for a very sparse Erdős-Rényi graph after pruning by component order. Let $p_n=c_n/n$, where $c_n\to0$, and delete every component of order less than $f(n)$, where $f(n)\to\infty$. If \[ f(n)\bigl(\log f(n)+\log(1/c_n)\bigr)=o(\log n), \] then the resulting graph satisfies a zero-one law for $\mathrm{MSO}_2$, with quantification over sets of vertices and sets of edges. The proof combines uniform component counts, an MSO Feferman-Vaught decomposition for disjoint unions, and semilinearity of the order spectra of MSO-definable classes of finite trees. We also show that the term $f(n)\log f(n)$ cannot simply be omitted: star components can occur at first-order-visible Poisson thresholds. We further establish first-order limit laws for bond percolation on the discrete torus $T_L^d$. In the two-sided subpolynomial regime, pruning below a sufficiently slow threshold yields a zero-one law. For the unpruned model in either one-sided polynomial regime, the reciprocal exponents $α=1/k$ are precisely the critical scales. At such a scale, an extended limit of $N p_N^k$ or $N q_N^k$ equal to $0$ or $\infty$ gives a zero-one law; a positive finite limit gives a convergence law but not a zero-one law; and the absence of an extended limit gives failure of convergence. Finally, $\mathrm{MSO}_1$ already detects the parity of the torus side length through bipartiteness, producing a natural obstruction to monadic convergence in a near-deterministic regime.

Concentration results say that a sequence of random variables becomes progressively concentrated around the mean. Such results are common in the study of functions of random graphs. We introduce a real-valued logic with various aggregate operators on graphs, including summation, and prove that every term in the language, seen as a random variable on random graphs within the classical Erdős-Rényi random graph model, is concentrated. We prove this for dense and sparse variants of Erdős-Rényi graphs. On the one hand, our results extend the line of work originating with Fagin and Glebskii et al. on zero-one laws for dense random graphs, as well as the zero-one law of Shelah and Spencer for sparse random graphs. On the other hand, they can be seen as a meta-theorem for inferring concentration results on random graphs, and we give examples of such applications.

A step-graphon has the strong (resp., weak) $H$-property if a directed, random graph sampled from it has a Hamilton cycle (resp., a node-wise disjoint cycle cover) asymptotically almost surely. The weak/strong $H$-property is essentially a zero-one property. We identify key objects associated with the step-graphon that matter for the zero-one law and provide a complete characterization.

We study the problem of distinguishing between two independent samples $\mathbf{G}_n^1,\mathbf{G}_n^2$ of a binomial random graph $G(n,p)$ by first order (FO) sentences. Shelah and Spencer proved that, for a constant $α\in(0,1)$, $G(n,n^{-α})$ obeys FO zero-one law if and only if $α$ is irrational. Therefore, for irrational $α\in(0,1)$, any fixed FO sentence does not distinguish between $\mathbf{G}_n^1,\mathbf{G}_n^2$ with asymptotical probability 1 (w.h.p.) as $n\to\infty$. We show that the minimum quantifier depth $\mathbf{k}_α$ of a FO sentence $\varphi=\varphi(\mathbf{G}_n^1,\mathbf{G}_n^2)$ distinguishing between $\mathbf{G}_n^1,\mathbf{G}_n^2$ depends on how closely $α$ can be approximated by rationals: (1) for all non-Liouville $α\in(0,1)$, $\mathbf{k}_α=Ω(\ln\ln\ln n)$ w.h.p.; (2) there are irrational $α\in(0,1)$ with $\mathbf{k}_α$ that grow arbitrarily slowly w.h.p.; (3) $\mathbf{k}_α=O_p(\frac{\ln n}{\ln\ln n})$ for all $α\in(0,1)$. The main ingredients in our proofs are a novel randomized algorithm that generates asymmetric strictly balanced graphs as well as a new method to study symmetry groups of randomly perturbed graphs.

For a sequence of random structures with $n$-element domains over a relational signature, we define its first order (FO) complexity as a certain subset in the Banach space $\ell^{\infty}/c_0$. The well-known FO zero-one law and FO convergence law correspond to FO complexities equal to $\{0,1\}$ and a subset of $\mathbb{R}$, respectively. We present a hierarchy of FO complexity classes, introduce a stochastic FO reduction that allows to transfer complexity results between different random structures, and deduce using this tool several new logical limit laws for binomial random structures. Finally, we introduce a conditional distribution on graphs, subject to a FO sentence $\varphi$, that generalises certain well-known random graph models, show instances of this distribution for every complexity class, and prove that the set of all $\varphi$ validating 0--1 law is not recursively enumerable.

We introduce a general random model of a combinatorial optimization problem with geometric structure that encapsulates both linear programming and integer linear programming. Let $Q$ be a bounded set called the feasible set, $E$ be an arbitrary set called the constraint set, and $A$ be a random linear transform. We define and study the $\ell^q$-margin, $M_q := d_q(AQ, E)$. The margin quantifies the feasibility of finding $y \in AQ$ satisfying the constraint $y \in E$. Our contribution is to establish strong concentration of the margin for any $q \in (2,\infty]$, assuming only that $E$ has permutation symmetry. The case of $q = \infty$ is of particular interest in applications -- specifically to combinatorial ``balancing'' problems -- and is markedly out of the reach of the classical isoperimetric and concentration-of-measure tools that suffice for $q \le 2$. Generality is a key feature of this result: we assume permutation symmetry of the constraint set and nothing else. This allows us to encode many optimization problems in terms of the margin, including random versions of: the closest vector problem, integer linear feasibility, perceptron-type problems, $\ell^q$-combinatorial discrepancy for $2 \le q \le \infty$, and matrix balancing. Concentration of the margin implies a host of new sharp threshold results in these models, and also greatly simplifies and extends some key known results.

A random permutation $Π_n$ of $\{1,\dots,n\}$ follows the $\DeclareMathOperator{\Mallows}{Mallows}\Mallows(n,q)$ distribution with parameter $q>0$ if $\mathbb{P} ( Π_n = π)$ is proportional to $\DeclareMathOperator{\inv}{inv} q^{\inv(π)}$ for all $π$. Here $\DeclareMathOperator{\inv}{inv} \inv(π) := |\{ i<j : π(i)> π(j) \}|$ denotes the number of inversions of $π$. We consider properties of permutations that can be expressed by the sentences of two different logical languages. Namely, the theory of one bijection ($\mathsf{TOOB}$), which describes permutations via a single binary relation, and the theory of two orders ($\mathsf{TOTO}$), where we describe permutations by two total orders. We say that the convergence law holds with respect to one of these languages if, for every sentence $φ$ in the language, the probability $\mathbb{P} (Π_n\text{ satisfies } φ)$ converges to a limit as $n\to\infty$. If moreover that limit is in the set $\{0,1\}$ for all sentences, then the zero-one law holds. We will show that with respect to $\mathsf{TOOB}$ the $\Mallows(n,q)$ distribution satisfies the zero-one law when $0<q<1$ is fixed, and for fixed $q>1$ the convergence law fails. (In the case when $q=1$ Compton has shown the convergence law holds but not the zero-one law.) We will prove that with respect to $\mathsf{TOTO}$ the $\Mallows(n,q)$ distribution satisfies the convergence law but not the zero-one law for any fixed $q\neq 1$, and that if $q=q(n)$ satisfies $1 - 1/\log^*n < q < 1 + 1/\log^*n$ then $\Mallows(n,q)$ fails the convergence law. Here $\log^*$ denotes the discrete inverse of the tower function.

Random graphs are an important tool for modelling and analyzing the underlying properties of complex real-world networks. In this paper, we study a class of random graphs known as the inhomogeneous random K-out graphs which were recently introduced to analyze heterogeneous sensor networks secured by the pairwise scheme. In this model, first, each of the $n$ nodes is classified as type-1 (respectively, type-2) with probability $0<μ<1$ (respectively, $1-μ)$ independently from each other. Next, each type-1 (respectively, type-2) node draws 1 arc towards a node (respectively, $K_n$ arcs towards $K_n$ distinct nodes) selected uniformly at random, and then the orientation of the arcs is ignored. From the literature on homogeneous K-out graphs wherein all nodes select $K_n$ neighbors (i.e., $μ=0$), it is known that when $K_n \geq2$, the graph is $K_n$-connected asymptotically almost surely (a.a.s.) as $n$ gets large. In the inhomogeneous case (i.e., $μ>0$), it was recently established that achieving even 1-connectivity a.a.s. requires $K_n=ω(1)$. Here, we provide a comprehensive set of results to complement these existing results. First, we establish a sharp zero-one law for $k$-connectivity, showing that for the network to be $k$-connected a.a.s., we need to set $K_n = \frac{1}{1-μ}(\log n +(k-2)\log\log n + ω(1))$ for all $k=2, 3, \ldots$. Despite such large scaling of $K_n$ being required for $k$-connectivity, we show that the trivial condition of $K_n \geq 2$ for all $n$ is sufficient to ensure that inhomogeneous K-out graph has a connected component of size $n-O(1)$ whp.

We establish an approximate zero-one law for sentences of continuous logic over finite metric spaces of diameter at most $1$. More precisely, we axiomatize a complete metric theory $T_{\mathrm{as}}$ such that, given any sentence $σ$ in the language of pure metric spaces and any $ε>0$, the probability that the difference of the value of $σ$ in a random metric space of size $n$ and the value of $σ$ in any model of $T_{\mathrm{as}}$ is less than $ε$ approaches $1$ as $n$ approaches infinity. We also establish some model-theoretic properties of the theory $T_{\mathrm{as}}$.

Security is an important issue in wireless sensor networks (WSNs), which are often deployed in hostile environments. The q-composite key predistribution scheme has been recognized as a suitable approach to secure WSNs. Although the q-composite scheme has received much attention in the literature, there is still a lack of rigorous analysis for secure WSNs operating under the q-composite scheme in consideration of the unreliability of links. One main difficulty lies in analyzing the network topology whose links are not independent. Wireless links can be unreliable in practice due to the presence of physical barriers between sensors or because of harsh environmental conditions severely impairing communications. In this paper, we resolve the difficult challenge and investigate k-connectivity in secure WSNs operating under the q-composite scheme with unreliable communication links modeled as independent on/off channels, where k-connectivity ensures connectivity despite the failure of any (k - 1) sensors or links, and connectivity means that any two sensors can find a path in between for secure communication. Specifically, we derive the asymptotically exact probability and a zero-one law for k-connectivity. We further use the theoretical results to provide design guidelines for secure WSNs. Experimental results also confirm the validity of our analytical findings.

In this paper, we investigate the secure connectivity of wireless sensor networks utilizing the heterogeneous random key predistribution scheme, where each sensor node is classified as class-$i$ with probability $μ_i$ for $i=1,\ldots,r$ with $μ_i>0$ and $\sum_{i=1}^r μ_i=1$. A class-$i$ sensor is given $K_i$ cryptographic keys selected uniformly at random from a key pool of size $P$. After deployment, two nodes can communicate securely if they share at least one cryptographic key. We consider the wireless connectivity of the network using a heterogeneous on-off channel model, where the channel between a class-$i$ node and a class-$j$ node is on (respectively, off) with probability $α_{ij}$ (respectively, $1-α_{ij}$) for $i,j=1,\ldots,r$. Collectively, two sensor nodes are adjacent if they i) share a cryptographic key and ii) have a wireless channel in between that is on. We model the overall network using a composite random graph obtained by the intersection of inhomogeneous random key graphs (IRKG) $\mathbb{K}(n;\pmbμ,\pmb{K},P)$ with inhomogeneous Erdős-Rényi graphs (IERG) $\mathbb{G}(n;\pmbμ, \pmbα)$. The former graph is naturally induced by the heterogeneous random key predistribution scheme, while the latter is induced by the heterogeneous on-off channel model. More specifically, two nodes are adjacent in the composite graph if they are i) adjacent in the IRKG i.e., share a cryptographic key and ii) adjacent in the IERG, i.e., have an available wireless channel. We investigate the connectivity of the composite random graph and present conditions (in the form of zero-one laws) on how to scale its parameters so that it i) has no secure node which is isolated and ii) is securely connected, both with high probability when the number of nodes gets large. We also present numerical results to support these zero-one laws in the finite-node regime.

We study the secure and reliable connectivity of wireless sensor networks under the heterogeneous pairwise key predistribution scheme. This scheme was recently introduced as an extension of the random pairwise key predistribution scheme of Chan et al. to accommodate networks where the constituent sensors have different capabilities or requirements for security and connectivity. For simplicity, we consider a heterogeneous network where each of the $n$ sensors is classified as type-1 (respectively, type-2) with probability $μ$ (respectively, $1-μ)$ where $0<μ<1$. Each type-1 (respectively, type-2) node selects 1 (respectively, $K_n$) other nodes uniformly at random to be paired with; according to the pairwise scheme each pair is then assigned a unique pairwise key so that they can securely communicate with each other. We establish critical conditions on $n, μ$, and $K_n$ such that the resulting network has minimum node degree of at least $k$ with high probability in the limit of large network size. Our result constitutes a zero-one law for the minimum node degree of the recently introduced inhomogeneous random K-out graph model. This constitutes a crucial step towards establishing a similar zero-one law for the $k$-connectivity of the graph; i.e., for the property that the network remains connected despite the failure of any $k-1$ nodes or links. We present numerical results that indicate the usefulness of our results in selecting the parameters of the scheme in practical settings with finite number of sensors.

For any fixed positive integer $k$, let $α_{k}$ denote the smallest $α\in (0,1)$ such that the random graph sequence $\left\{G\left(n, n^{-α}\right)\right\}$ does not satisfy the zero-one law for the set $\mathcal{E}_{k}$ of all existential first order sentences that are of quantifier depth at most $k$. This paper finds upper and lower bounds on $α_{k}$, showing that as $k \rightarrow \infty$, we have $α_{k} = \left(k - 2 - t(k)\right)^{-1}$ for some function $t(k) = Θ(k^{-2})$. We also establish the precise value of $α_{k}$ when $k = 4$.

In this paper, we prove that for every positive $\varepsilon$, there exists an $α\in(1/(k-1),1/(k-1)+\varepsilon)$ such that the binomial random graph $G(n,n^{-α})$ does not obey 0-1 law w.r.t. first order sentences with k variables. In contrast, for every $α\in(0,1/(k-1)]$, $G(n,n^{-α})$ obeys 0-1 law w.r.t. this logic.

In 2001, J.-M. Le Bars disproved the zero-one law (that says that every sentence from a certain logic is either true asymptotically almost surely (a.a.s.), or false a.a.s.) for existential monadic second order sentences (EMSO) about undirected graphs. He proved that there exists an EMSO sentence $φ$ such that ${\sf P}(G_n \modelsφ)$ does not converge as $n\to\infty$ (here, the probability distribution is uniform over the set of all graphs on the labeled set of vertices $\{1, \dots, n\}$). In the same paper, he conjectured that, for EMSO sentences with 2 first order variables, the zero-one law holds. In this paper, we disprove this conjecture.

Spectrum of a first order sentence is the set of all $α$ such that $G(n, n^{-α})$ does not obey zero-one law w.r.t. this sentence. We have proved that the minimal number of quantifier alternations of a first order sentence with an infinite spectrum equals 3. We have also proved that the spectrum of a first order sentence with a quantifier depth 4 has no limit points except possibly the points 1/2 and 3/5.

In this paper, we study zero-one laws for the Erdős--Rényi random graph model $G(n,p)$ in the case when $p = n^{-α}$ for $α>0$. For a given class $\mathcal{K}$ of logical sentences about graphs and a given function $p=p(n)$, we say that $G(n,p)$ obeys the zero-one law (w.r.t. the class $\mathcal{K}$) if each sentence $\varphi\in\mathcal{K}$ either a.a.s. true or a.a.s. false for $G(n,p)$. In this paper, we consider first order properties and monadic second order properties of bounded \textit{quantifier depth} $k$, that is, the length of the longest chain of nested quantifiers in the formula expressing the property. Zero-one laws for properties of quantifier depth $k$ we call the \textit{zero-one $k$-laws}. The main results of this paper concern the zero-one $k$-laws for monadic second order properties (MSO properties). We determine all values $α>0$, for which the zero-one $3$-law for MSO properties does not hold. We also show that, in contrast to the case of the $3$-law, there are infinitely many values of $α$ for which the zero-one $4$-law for MSO properties does not hold. To this end, we analyze the evolution of certain properties of $G(n,p)$ that may be of independent interest.

In this work limit probabilities of first-order properties of the random $s$-uniform hypergraph in the binomial model $G^{s}(n,p)$ are studied. We give a complete discription of all positive $α$ such that $G^{s}(n,n^{-α})$ obeys Zero-One Law. Moreover, for any rational $ρ\geq 1/(s-1)$ we prove the existence of a strictly balanced $s$-uniform hypergraph with the density $ρ$.

Random intersection graphs have received much interest and been used in diverse applications. They are naturally induced in modeling secure sensor networks under random key predistribution schemes, as well as in modeling the topologies of social networks including common-interest networks, collaboration networks, and actor networks. Simply put, a random intersection graph is constructed by assigning each node a set of items in some random manner and then putting an edge between any two nodes that share a certain number of items. Broadly speaking, our work is about analyzing random intersection graphs, and models generated by composing it with other random graph models including random geometric graphs and Erdős-Rényi graphs. These compositional models are introduced to capture the characteristics of various complex natural or man-made networks more accurately than the existing models in the literature. For random intersection graphs and their compositions with other random graphs, we study properties such as ($k$-)connectivity, ($k$-)robustness, and containment of perfect matchings and Hamilton cycles. Our results are typically given in the form of asymptotically exact probabilities or zero-one laws specifying critical scalings, and provide key insights into the design and analysis of various real-world networks.

Random intersection graphs have received much attention for nearly two decades, and currently have a wide range of applications ranging from key predistribution in wireless sensor networks to modeling social networks. In this paper, we investigate the strengths of connectivity and robustness in a general random intersection graph model. Specifically, we establish sharp asymptotic zero-one laws for $k$-connectivity and $k$-robustness, as well as the asymptotically exact probability of $k$-connectivity, for any positive integer $k$. The $k$-connectivity property quantifies how resilient is the connectivity of a graph against node or edge failures. On the other hand, $k$-robustness measures the effectiveness of local diffusion strategies (that do not use global graph topology information) in spreading information over the graph in the presence of misbehaving nodes. In addition to presenting the results under the general random intersection graph model, we consider two special cases of the general model, a binomial random intersection graph and a uniform random intersection graph, which both have numerous applications as well. For these two specialized graphs, our results on asymptotically exact probabilities of $k$-connectivity and asymptotic zero-one laws for $k$-robustness are also novel in the literature.