arXiv++ Combinatorics

Random K-out graphs are used in several applications including modeling by sensor networks secured by the random pairwise key predistribution scheme, and payment channel networks. The random K-out graph with $n$ nodes is constructed as follows. Each node draws an edge towards $K$ distinct nodes selected uniformly at random. The orientation of the edges is then ignored, yielding an undirected graph. An interesting property of random K-out graphs is that they are connected almost surely in the limit of large $n$ for any $K \geq2$. This means that they attain the property of being connected very easily, i.e., with far fewer edges ($O(n)$) as compared to classical random graph models including Erdős-Rényi graphs ($O(n \log n)$). This work aims to reveal to what extent the asymptotic behavior of random K-out graphs being connected easily extends to cases where the number $n$ of nodes is small. We establish upper and lower bounds on the probability of connectivity when $n$ is finite. Our lower bounds improve significantly upon the existing results, and indicate that random K-out graphs can attain a given probability of connectivity at much smaller network sizes than previously known. We also show that the established upper and lower bounds match order-wise; i.e., further improvement on the order of $n$ in the lower bound is not possible. In particular, we prove that the probability of connectivity is $1-Θ({1}/{n^{K^2-1}})$ for all $K \geq 2$. Through numerical simulations, we show that our bounds closely mirror the empirically observed probability of connectivity.

Random graphs are an important tool for modelling and analyzing the underlying properties of complex real-world networks. In this paper, we study a class of random graphs known as the inhomogeneous random K-out graphs which were recently introduced to analyze heterogeneous sensor networks secured by the pairwise scheme. In this model, first, each of the $n$ nodes is classified as type-1 (respectively, type-2) with probability $0<μ<1$ (respectively, $1-μ)$ independently from each other. Next, each type-1 (respectively, type-2) node draws 1 arc towards a node (respectively, $K_n$ arcs towards $K_n$ distinct nodes) selected uniformly at random, and then the orientation of the arcs is ignored. From the literature on homogeneous K-out graphs wherein all nodes select $K_n$ neighbors (i.e., $μ=0$), it is known that when $K_n \geq2$, the graph is $K_n$-connected asymptotically almost surely (a.a.s.) as $n$ gets large. In the inhomogeneous case (i.e., $μ>0$), it was recently established that achieving even 1-connectivity a.a.s. requires $K_n=ω(1)$. Here, we provide a comprehensive set of results to complement these existing results. First, we establish a sharp zero-one law for $k$-connectivity, showing that for the network to be $k$-connected a.a.s., we need to set $K_n = \frac{1}{1-μ}(\log n +(k-2)\log\log n + ω(1))$ for all $k=2, 3, \ldots$. Despite such large scaling of $K_n$ being required for $k$-connectivity, we show that the trivial condition of $K_n \geq 2$ for all $n$ is sufficient to ensure that inhomogeneous K-out graph has a connected component of size $n-O(1)$ whp.

In this paper, we investigate the secure connectivity of wireless sensor networks utilizing the heterogeneous random key predistribution scheme, where each sensor node is classified as class-$i$ with probability $μ_i$ for $i=1,\ldots,r$ with $μ_i>0$ and $\sum_{i=1}^r μ_i=1$. A class-$i$ sensor is given $K_i$ cryptographic keys selected uniformly at random from a key pool of size $P$. After deployment, two nodes can communicate securely if they share at least one cryptographic key. We consider the wireless connectivity of the network using a heterogeneous on-off channel model, where the channel between a class-$i$ node and a class-$j$ node is on (respectively, off) with probability $α_{ij}$ (respectively, $1-α_{ij}$) for $i,j=1,\ldots,r$. Collectively, two sensor nodes are adjacent if they i) share a cryptographic key and ii) have a wireless channel in between that is on. We model the overall network using a composite random graph obtained by the intersection of inhomogeneous random key graphs (IRKG) $\mathbb{K}(n;\pmbμ,\pmb{K},P)$ with inhomogeneous Erdős-Rényi graphs (IERG) $\mathbb{G}(n;\pmbμ, \pmbα)$. The former graph is naturally induced by the heterogeneous random key predistribution scheme, while the latter is induced by the heterogeneous on-off channel model. More specifically, two nodes are adjacent in the composite graph if they are i) adjacent in the IRKG i.e., share a cryptographic key and ii) adjacent in the IERG, i.e., have an available wireless channel. We investigate the connectivity of the composite random graph and present conditions (in the form of zero-one laws) on how to scale its parameters so that it i) has no secure node which is isolated and ii) is securely connected, both with high probability when the number of nodes gets large. We also present numerical results to support these zero-one laws in the finite-node regime.

We study the secure and reliable connectivity of wireless sensor networks under the heterogeneous pairwise key predistribution scheme. This scheme was recently introduced as an extension of the random pairwise key predistribution scheme of Chan et al. to accommodate networks where the constituent sensors have different capabilities or requirements for security and connectivity. For simplicity, we consider a heterogeneous network where each of the $n$ sensors is classified as type-1 (respectively, type-2) with probability $μ$ (respectively, $1-μ)$ where $0<μ<1$. Each type-1 (respectively, type-2) node selects 1 (respectively, $K_n$) other nodes uniformly at random to be paired with; according to the pairwise scheme each pair is then assigned a unique pairwise key so that they can securely communicate with each other. We establish critical conditions on $n, μ$, and $K_n$ such that the resulting network has minimum node degree of at least $k$ with high probability in the limit of large network size. Our result constitutes a zero-one law for the minimum node degree of the recently introduced inhomogeneous random K-out graph model. This constitutes a crucial step towards establishing a similar zero-one law for the $k$-connectivity of the graph; i.e., for the property that the network remains connected despite the failure of any $k-1$ nodes or links. We present numerical results that indicate the usefulness of our results in selecting the parameters of the scheme in practical settings with finite number of sensors.

We propose inhomogeneous random K-out graphs $\mathbb{H}(n; \pmbμ, \pmb{K}_n)$, where each of the $n$ nodes is assigned to one of $r$ classes independently with a probability distribution $\pmbμ = \{μ_1, \ldots, μ_r\}$. In particular, each node is classified as class-$i$ with probability $μ_i>0$, independently. Each class-$i$ node selects $K_{i,n}$ distinct nodes uniformly at random from among all other nodes. A pair of nodes are adjacent in $\mathbb{H}(n; \pmbμ, \pmb{K}_n)$ if at least one selects the other. Without loss of generality, we assume that $K_{1,n} \leq K_{2,n} \leq \ldots \leq K_{r,n}$. Earlier results on homogeneous random K-out graphs $\mathbb{H}(n; K_n)$, where all nodes select the same number $K$ of other nodes, reveal that $\mathbb{H}(n; K_n)$ is connected with high probability (whp) if $K_n \geq 2$ which implies that $\mathbb{H}(n; \pmbμ, \pmb{K}_n)$ is connected whp if $K_{1,n} \geq 2$. In this paper, we investigate the connectivity of inhomogeneous random K-out graphs $\mathbb{H}(n; \pmbμ, \pmb{K}_n)$ for the special case when $K_{1,n}=1$, i.e., when each class-$1$ node selects only one other node. We show that $\mathbb{H}\left(n;\pmbμ,\pmb{K}_n\right)$ is connected whp if $K_{r,n}$ is chosen such that $\lim_{n \to \infty} K_{r,n} = \infty$. However, any bounded choice of the sequence $K_{r,n}$ gives a positive probability of $\mathbb{H}\left(n;\pmbμ,\pmb{K}_n\right)$ being not connected. Simulation results are provided to validate our results in the finite node regime.

Random intersection graphs have received much interest and been used in diverse applications. They are naturally induced in modeling secure sensor networks under random key predistribution schemes, as well as in modeling the topologies of social networks including common-interest networks, collaboration networks, and actor networks. Simply put, a random intersection graph is constructed by assigning each node a set of items in some random manner and then putting an edge between any two nodes that share a certain number of items. Broadly speaking, our work is about analyzing random intersection graphs, and models generated by composing it with other random graph models including random geometric graphs and Erdős-Rényi graphs. These compositional models are introduced to capture the characteristics of various complex natural or man-made networks more accurately than the existing models in the literature. For random intersection graphs and their compositions with other random graphs, we study properties such as ($k$-)connectivity, ($k$-)robustness, and containment of perfect matchings and Hamilton cycles. Our results are typically given in the form of asymptotically exact probabilities or zero-one laws specifying critical scalings, and provide key insights into the design and analysis of various real-world networks.

Random $s$-intersection graphs have recently received considerable attention in a wide range of application areas. In such a graph, each vertex is equipped with a set of items in some random manner, and any two vertices establish an undirected edge in between if and only if they have at least $s$ common items. In particular, in a uniform random $s$-intersection graph, each vertex independently selects a fixed number of items uniformly at random from a common item pool, while in a binomial random $s$-intersection graph, each item in some item pool is independently attached to each vertex with the same probability. For binomial/uniform random $s$-intersection graphs, we establish threshold functions for perfect matching containment, Hamilton cycle containment, and $k$-robustness, where $k$-robustness is in the sense of Zhang and Sundaram [IEEE Conf. on Decision & Control '12]. We show that these threshold functions resemble those of classical Erdős-Rényi graphs, where each pair of vertices has an undirected edge independently with the same probability.

Random key graphs represent topologies of secure wireless sensor networks that apply the seminal Eschenauer-Gligor random key predistribution scheme to secure communication between sensors. These graphs have received much attention and also been used in diverse application areas beyond secure sensor networks; e.g., cryptanalysis, social networks, and recommender systems. Formally, a random key graph with $n$ nodes is constructed by assigning each node $X_n$ keys selected uniformly at random from a pool of $Y_n$ keys and then putting an undirected edge between any two nodes sharing at least one key. Considerable progress has been made in the literature to analyze connectivity and $k$-connectivity of random key graphs, where $k$-connectivity of a graph ensures connectivity even after the removal of $k$ nodes or $k$ edges. Yet, it still remains an open question for $k$-connectivity in random key graphs under $X_n \geq 2$ and $X_n = o(\sqrt{\ln n})$ (the case of $X_n=1$ is trivial). In this paper, we answer the above problem by providing an exact analysis of $k$-connectivity in random key graphs under $X_n \geq 2$.

One-dimensional geometric random graphs are constructed by distributing $n$ nodes uniformly and independently on a unit interval and then assigning an undirected edge between any two nodes that have a distance at most $r_n$. These graphs have received much interest and been used in various applications including wireless networks. A threshold of $r_n$ for connectivity is known as $r_n^{*} = \frac{\ln n}{n}$ in the literature. In this paper, we prove that a threshold of $r_n$ for the absence of isolated node is $\frac{\ln n}{2 n}$ (i.e., a half of the threshold $r_n^{*}$). Our result shows there is a curious gap between thresholds of connectivity and the absence of isolated node in one-dimensional geometric random graphs; in particular, when $r_n$ equals $\frac{c\ln n}{ n}$ for a constant $c \in( \frac{1}{2}, 1)$, a one-dimensional geometric random graph has no isolated node but is not connected. This curious gap in one-dimensional geometric random graphs is in sharp contrast to the prevalent phenomenon in many other random graphs such as two-dimensional geometric random graphs, Erdős-Rényi graphs, and random intersection graphs, all of which in the asymptotic sense become connected as soon as there is no isolated node.

Uniform random intersection graphs have received much interest and been used in diverse applications. A uniform random intersection graph with $n$ nodes is constructed as follows: each node selects a set of $K_n$ different items uniformly at random from the same pool of $P_n$ distinct items, and two nodes establish an undirected edge in between if and only if they share at least one item. For such graph denoted by $G(n, K_n, P_n)$, we present the following results in this paper. First, we provide an exact analysis on the probabilities of $G(n, K_n, P_n)$ having a perfect matching and having a Hamilton cycle respectively, under $P_n = ω\big(n (\ln n)^5\big)$ (all asymptotic notation are understood with $n \to \infty$). The analysis reveals that just like ($k$-)connectivity shown in prior work, for both properties of perfect matching containment and Hamilton cycle containment, $G(n, K_n, P_n)$ also exhibits phase transitions: for each property above, as $K_n$ increases, the limit of the probability that $G(n, K_n, P_n)$ has the property increases from $0$ to $1$. Second, we compute the phase transition widths of $G(n, K_n, P_n)$ for $k$-connectivity (KC), perfect matching containment (PMC), and Hamilton cycle containment (HCC), respectively. For a graph property $R$ and a positive constant $a < \frac{1}{2}$, with the phase transition width $d_n(R, a)$ defined as the difference between the minimal $K_n$ ensuring $G(n, K_n, P_n)$ having property $R$ with probability at least $1-a$ or $a$, we show for any positive constants $a<\frac{1}{2}$ and $k$: (i) If $P_n=Ω(n)$ and $P_n=o(n\ln n)$, then $d_n(KC, a)$ is either $0$ or $1$ for each $n$ sufficiently large. (ii) If $P_n=Θ(n\ln n)$, then $d_n(KC, a)=Θ(1)$. (iii) If $P_n=ω(n\ln n)$, then $d_n(KC, a)=ω(1)$. (iv) If $P_n=ω\big(n (\ln n)^5\big)$, $d_n(PMC, a)$ and $d_n(HCC, a)$ are both $ω(1)$.

Random intersection graphs have received much attention for nearly two decades, and currently have a wide range of applications ranging from key predistribution in wireless sensor networks to modeling social networks. In this paper, we investigate the strengths of connectivity and robustness in a general random intersection graph model. Specifically, we establish sharp asymptotic zero-one laws for $k$-connectivity and $k$-robustness, as well as the asymptotically exact probability of $k$-connectivity, for any positive integer $k$. The $k$-connectivity property quantifies how resilient is the connectivity of a graph against node or edge failures. On the other hand, $k$-robustness measures the effectiveness of local diffusion strategies (that do not use global graph topology information) in spreading information over the graph in the presence of misbehaving nodes. In addition to presenting the results under the general random intersection graph model, we consider two special cases of the general model, a binomial random intersection graph and a uniform random intersection graph, which both have numerous applications as well. For these two specialized graphs, our results on asymptotically exact probabilities of $k$-connectivity and asymptotic zero-one laws for $k$-robustness are also novel in the literature.

Random $s$-intersection graphs have recently received much interest in a wide range of application areas. Broadly speaking, a random $s$-intersection graph is constructed by first assigning each vertex a set of items in some random manner, and then putting an undirected edge between all pairs of vertices that share at least $s$ items (the graph is called a random intersection graph when $s=1$). A special case of particular interest is a uniform random $s$-intersection graph, where each vertex independently selects the same number of items uniformly at random from a common item pool. Another important case is a binomial random $s$-intersection graph, where each item from a pool is independently assigned to each vertex with the same probability. Both models have found numerous applications thus far including cryptanalysis, and the modeling of recommender systems, secure sensor networks, online social networks, trust networks and small-world networks (uniform random $s$-intersection graphs), as well as clustering analysis, classification, and the design of integrated circuits (binomial random $s$-intersection graphs). In this paper, for binomial/uniform random $s$-intersection graphs, we present results related to $k$-connectivity and minimum vertex degree. Specifically, we derive the asymptotically exact probabilities and zero-one laws for the following three properties: (i) $k$-vertex-connectivity, (ii) $k$-edge-connectivity and (iii) the property of minimum vertex degree being at least $k$.

The Eschenauer--Gligor (EG) random key predistribution scheme has been widely recognized as a typical approach to secure communications in wireless sensor networks (WSNs). However, there is a lack of precise probability analysis on the reliable connectivity of WSNs under the EG scheme. To address this, we rigorously derive the asymptotically exact probability of $k$-connectivity in WSNs employing the EG scheme with unreliable links represented by independent on/off channels, where $k$-connectivity ensures that the network remains connected despite the failure of any $(k-1)$ sensors or links. Our analytical results are confirmed via numerical experiments, and they provide precise guidelines for the design of secure WSNs that exhibit a desired level of reliability against node and link failures.

The q-composite key predistribution scheme [1] is used prevalently for secure communications in large-scale wireless sensor networks (WSNs). Prior work [2]-[4] explores topological properties of WSNs employing the q-composite scheme for q = 1 with unreliable communication links modeled as independent on/off channels. In this paper, we investigate topological properties related to the node degree in WSNs operating under the q-composite scheme and the on/off channel model. Our results apply to general q and are stronger than those reported for the node degree in prior work even for the case of q being 1. Specifically, we show that the number of nodes with certain degree asymptotically converges in distribution to a Poisson random variable, present the asymptotic probability distribution for the minimum degree of the network, and establish the asymptotically exact probability for the property that the minimum degree is at least an arbitrary value. Numerical experiments confirm the validity of our analytical findings.

We study the secure and reliable connectivity of wireless sensor networks. Security is assumed to be ensured by the random pairwise key predistribution scheme of Chan, Perrig, and Song, and unreliable wireless links are represented by independent on/off channels. Modeling the network by an intersection of a random $K$-out graph and an Erdős-Rényi graph, we present scaling conditions (on the number of nodes, the scheme parameter $K$, and the probability of a wireless channel being on) such that the resulting graph contains no nodes with degree less than $k$ with high probability, when the number of nodes gets large. Results are given in the form of zero-one laws and are shown to improve the previous results by Yağan and Makowski on the absence of isolated nodes (i.e., absence of nodes with degree zero). Via simulations, the established zero-one laws are shown to hold also for the property of $k$-connectivity; i.e., the property that graph remains connected despite the deletion of any $k-1$ nodes or edges.

Random key graphs form a class of random intersection graphs and are naturally induced by the random key predistribution scheme of Eschenauer and Gligor for securing wireless sensor network (WSN) communications. Random key graphs have received much interest recently, owing in part to their wide applicability in various domains including recommender systems, social networks, secure sensor networks, clustering and classification analysis, and cryptanalysis to name a few. In this paper, we study connectivity properties of random key graphs in the presence of unreliable links. Unreliability of the edges are captured by independent Bernoulli random variables, rendering edges of the graph to be on or off independently from each other. The resulting model is an intersection of a random key graph and an Erdos-Renyi graph, and is expected to be useful in capturing various real-world networks; e.g., with secure WSN applications in mind, link unreliability can be attributed to harsh environmental conditions severely impairing transmissions. We present conditions on how to scale this model's parameters so that i) the minimum node degree in the graph is at least k, and ii) the graph is k-connected, both with high probability as the number of nodes becomes large. The results are given in the form of zeroone laws with critical thresholds identified and shown to coincide for both graph properties. These findings improve the previous results by Rybarczyk on the k-connectivity of random key graphs (with reliable links), as well as the zero-one laws by Yagan on the 1-connectivity of random key graphs with unreliable links.

We investigate the secure connectivity of wireless sensor networks under the random key distribution scheme of Eschenauer and Gligor. Unlike recent work which was carried out under the assumption of full visibility, here we assume a (simplified) communication model where unreliable wireless links are represented as on/off channels. We present conditions on how to scale the model parameters so that the network i) has no secure node which is isolated and ii) is securely connected, both with high probability when the number of sensor nodes becomes large. The results are given in the form of full zero-one laws, and constitute the first complete analysis of the EG scheme under non-full visibility. Through simulations these zero-one laws are shown to be valid also under a more realistic communication model, i.e., the disk model. The relations to the Gupta and Kumar's conjecture on the connectivity of geometric random graphs with randomly deleted edges are also discussed.

We investigate the secure connectivity of wireless sensor networks under the pairwise key distribution scheme of Chan et al.. Unlike recent work which was carried out under the assumption of full visibility, here we assume a (simplified) communication model where unreliable wireless links are represented as on/off channels. We present conditions on how to scale the model parameters so that the network i) has no secure node which is isolated and ii) is securely connected, both with high probability when the number of sensor nodes becomes large. The results are given in the form of zero-one laws, and exhibit significant differences with corresponding results in the full visibility case. Through simulations these zero-one laws are shown to be valid also under a more realistic communication model, i.e., the disk model.

Random key graphs are random graphs induced by the random key predistribution scheme of Eschenauer and Gligor under the assumption of full visibility. For this class of random graphs we show the existence of a zero-one law for the appearance of triangles, and identify the corresponding critical scaling. This is done by applying the method of first and second moments to the number of triangles in the graph.

The random key graph is a random graph naturally associated with the random key predistribution scheme of Eschenauer and Gligor for wireless sensor networks. For this class of random graphs we establish a new version of a conjectured zero-one law for graph connectivity as the number of nodes becomes unboundedly large. The results reported here complement and strengthen recent work on this conjecture by Blackburn and Gerke. In particular, the results are given under conditions which are more realistic for applications to wireless sensor networks.