arXiv++ Combinatorics

We study a distributed consensus problem on a complete communication network of $n$ vertices, each holding one of two opinions. The vertices communicate in rounds, possibly in the presence of adversarial noise, and exchange information until they all agree on a single opinion. We consider a general class of protocols, where the vertices randomly sample neighbors and update their own opinion according to an update function $f$ depending on the sampled opinions. A prominent example is the $k$-maj protocol, where every vertex adopts the majority opinion of $k$ randomly sampled neighbors. We consider the runtime $R_n$ that is the number of rounds until all vertices agree on the same opinion, which we call the dominating opinion $D_n$. In our main result we describe the limiting distributions of these two key quantities for a large class of update functions $f$, for arbitrary initial configurations and under the presence of an adversary who may alter the opinions of up to $o(\sqrt{n})$ vertices in each round. We show that there are $f$-specific constants $γ, m > 0$ such that $R_n$ centers around $μ_n = \frac{1}{2}\log_γn + \log_m\ln n$, and we describe the asymptotic distribution of $R_n - μ_n$. In particular, we show that it does not converge, and that it becomes asymptotically periodic both in the $\log n$ as well as the $\log\log n$ scale. Applied to $k$-maj, our results show, among other things, that $γ_{k\text{-maj}} = \binom{k-1}{\lfloor k/2 \rfloor}2^{1-k}k \sim ({2k}/π)^{1/2}$.

A graph $G$ is universal for a class of graphs $\mathcal{C}$, if, up to isomorphism, $G$ contains every graph in $\mathcal{C}$ as a subgraph. In 1978, Chung and Graham asked for the minimal number $s(n)$ of edges in a graph with $n$ vertices that is universal for all trees with $n$ vertices. The currently best bounds assert that $n\ln n-O(n)\le s(n) \le C n\ln n+O(n)$, where $C = \frac{14}{5\ln 2} \approx 4.04$. Here, we improve the upper bound to $c n\ln n + O(n)$, where $c = \frac{19}{6\ln 3} \approx 2.88$. We develop in the proof a strategy that, broadly speaking, is based on separating trees into three parts, thus enabling us to embed them in a structure that originates from ternary trees. Our method also applies to graphs that are close to being trees, measured by their treewidth. Let $s_w(n)$ be the minimum number of edges in a $n$-vertex graph that is universal for graphs with treewidth $w$. By performing a graph blow-up to our universal structure and counting necessary edges carefully, we establish that $nw \ln(n/w) -O(nw) \leq s_w(n) \leq \frac{19}{6\ln3} n (w+1) \ln(n/w) + O(nw)$.