arXiv++ Combinatorics

In this corrigendum to arXiv:2305.02973, we justify that the motivation behind Conjecture 5.1 is based on a mistaken notion. Moreover, we prove a stronger theorem that disproves the conjecture, and obtain an optimal gradient vector field on the matching complex of the complete graph of order 7.

Bouc (1992) first studied the topological properties of $M_n$, the matching complex of the complete graph of order $n$, in connection with Brown complexes and Quillen complexes. Björner et al. (1994) showed that $M_n$ is homotopically $(ν_n-1)$-connected, where $ν_n=\lfloor{\frac{n+1}{3}}\rfloor-1$, and conjectured that this connectivity bound is sharp. Shareshian and Wachs (2007) settled the conjecture by inductively showing that the $ν_n$-dimensional homology group of $M_n$ is nontrivial, with Bouc's calculation of $H_1(M_7)$ serving as the pivotal base step. In general, the topology of $M_n$ is not very well-understood, even for a small $n$. In the present article, we look into the topology of $M_n$, and $M_7$ in particular, in the light of discrete Morse theory as developed by Forman (1998). We first construct a gradient vector field on $M_n$ (for $n \ge 5$) that doesn't admit any critical simplices of dimension up to $ν_n-1$, except one unavoidable $0$-simplex, which also leads to the aforementioned $(ν_n-1)$-connectedness of $M_n$ in a purely combinatorial way. However, for an efficient homology computation by discrete Morse theoretic techniques, we are required to work with a gradient vector field that admits a low number of critical simplices, and also allows an efficient enumeration of gradient paths. An optimal gradient vector field is one with the least number of critical simplices, but the problem of finding an optimal gradient vector field, in general, is an NP-hard problem (even for $2$-dimensional complexes). We improve the gradient vector field constructed on $M_7$ in particular to a much more efficient (near-optimal) one, and then with the help of this improved gradient vector field, compute the homology groups of $M_7$ in an efficient and algorithmic manner. We also augment this near-optimal gradient vector field to one that we conjecture to be optimal.

We denote the matching complex of the complete graph with $n$ vertices by $M_n$. Bouc first studied the topological properties of $M_n$ in connection with the Quillen complex. Later Björner, Lovász, Vrećica, and Živaljević showed that $M_n$ is homotopically $(ν_n-1)$-connected, where $ν_n=\lfloor{\frac{n+1}{3}}\rfloor-1$, but in general the topology of $M_n$ is not very well-understood even for smaller natural numbers. Forman developed discrete Morse theory, which has various applications in diverse fields of studies. In this article, we develop a discrete Morse theoretic technique to capture deeper structural topological properties of $M_n$. We show that $M_n$ is \emph{geometrically} $(ν_n-1)$-connected, where the notion of geometrical $k$-connectedness as defined in this article, is stronger than that of homotopical $k$-connectedness. Previously, Björner et al. showed that $M_8$ is simply connected, but not 2-connected. The technique developed here helped us determine that $M_8$ is in fact homotopy equivalent to a wedge of 132 spheres of dimension 2.

Dorpalen-Barry et al. proved Elser's conjecture about sign of Elser's number by interpreting them as certain sums of reduced Euler characteristics of an abstract simplicial complex known as $U$-nucleus complex. We prove a conjecture posed by them regarding the homology of $U$-nucleus complex.