arXiv++ Combinatorics

Godsil and Sun asked whether, for a strongly regular graph $X$ and any two different edges $e$ and $f$, the edge-deleted graphs $X\setminus e$ and $X\setminus f$ are degree-similar. We give an affirmative answer to the problem of Godsil and Sun. In fact, we prove the stronger statement that if $X$ is a $1$-walk-regular graph, then for any two edges $e$ and $f$ of $X$, the graphs $X\setminus e$ and $X\setminus f$ are orthogonally degree-similar. The proof is based on an edge version of the orthogonal-intertwiner method: the equality of the Gram matrices of the projected endpoint vectors in every eigenspace yields an orthogonal matrix commuting with the adjacency matrix and sending one pair of ordered endpoint vectors to the other.

Let $L_μ(G)=A(G)-μD(G)$ be the generalized $μ$-adjacency matrix of a finite graph $G$. Fan, Xing, Zhang, and Wang constructed pairs of non-degree-similar trees for which the Smith normal forms of the matrices $tI-L_μ(G)$ over $\mathbb{Q}(μ)[t]$ coincide, and conjectured that their construction remains valid when the attached rooted path is replaced by an arbitrary rooted tree. We prove this conjecture as a consequence of a more general coalescence theorem: if a finite graph $H$ has two vertices $u$ and $v$ that are cospectral for $L_μ(H)$, then, for every finite rooted graph $R$ with root $r$, the matrices \[ tI-L_μ(R(r)\odot H(u)) \quad\text{and}\quad tI-L_μ(R(r)\odot H(v)) \] have the same Smith normal form over $\mathbb{Q}(μ)[t]$, where $\odot$ denotes coalescence of rooted graphs. The proof uses an orthogonal intertwiner over a real closed extension field.