arXiv++ Combinatorics

The nodal edge count of an eigenvector of the Laplacian of a graph is the number of edges on which it changes sign. This quantity extends to any real symmetric $n\times n$ matrix supported on a graph $G$ with $n$ vertices. The average nodal count, averaged over all eigenvectors of a given matrix, is known to be bounded between $\frac{n-1}{2}$ and $\frac{n-1}{2}+β(G)$, where $β(G)$ is the first Betti number of $G$ (a topological quantity), and it was believed that generically the average should be around $\frac{n-1}{2}+β(G)/2$. We prove that this is not the case: the average is bounded between $\frac{n-1}{2}+β(G)/n$ and $\frac{n-1}{2}+β(G)-β(G)/n$, and we provide graphs and matrices that attain the upper and lower bounds for any possible choice of $n$ and $β$. A natural condition on a matrix for defining the nodal count is that it has simple eigenvalues and non-vanishing eigenvectors. For any connected graph $G$, a generic real symmetric matrix supported on $G$ satisfies this nodal count condition. However, the situation for constant diagonal matrices is far more subtle. We completely characterize the graphs $G$ for which this condition is generically true, and show that if this is not the case, then any real symmetric matrix supported on $G$ with constant diagonal has a multiple eigenvalue or an eigenvector that vanishes somewhere. Finally, we discuss what can be said when this nodal count condition fails, and provide examples.

Given a discrete Schrödinger operator $h$ on a finite connected graph $G$ of $n$ vertices, the nodal count $φ(h,k)$ denotes the number of edges on which the $k$-th eigenvector changes sign. A {\em signing} $h'$ of $h$ is any real symmetric matrix constructed by changing the sign of some off-diagonal entries of $h$, and its nodal count is defined according to the signing. The set of signings of $h$ lie in a naturally defined torus $\mathbb{T}_h$ of ``magnetic perturbations" of $h$. G. Berkolaiko discovered that every signing $h'$ of $h$ is a critical point of every eigenvalue $λ_k:\mathbb{T}_h \to \mathbb{R}$, with Morse index equal to the nodal surplus. We add further Morse theoretic information to this result. We show if $h_α \in \mathbb{T}_h$ is a critical point of $λ_k$ and the eigenvector vanishes at a single vertex $v$ of degree $d$, then the critical point lies in a nondegenerate critical submanifold of dimension $d+n-4$, closely related to the configuration space of a planar linkage. We compute its Morse index in terms of spectral data. The average nodal surplus distribution is the distribution of values of $φ(h',k)-(k-1)$, averaged over all signings $h'$ of $h$. If all critical points correspond to simple eigenvalues with nowhere-vanishing eigenvectors, then the average nodal surplus distribution is binomial. In general, we conjecture that the nodal surplus distribution converges to a Gaussian in a CLT fashion as the first Betti number of $G$ goes to infinity.

It is known that up to certain pathologies, a compact metric graph with standard vertex conditions has a Baire-generic set of choices of edge lengths such that all Laplacian eigenvalues are simple and have eigenfunctions that do not vanish at the vertices. We provide a new notion of strong genericity, using subanalytic sets, that implies both Baire genericity and full Lebesgue measure. We show that the previous genericity results for metric graphs are strongly generic. In addition, we show that generically the derivative of an eigenfunction does not vanish at the vertices either. In fact, we show that generically an eigenfunction fails to satisfy any additional vertex condition. Finally, we show that any two different metric graphs with the same edge lengths do not share any non-zero eigenvalue, for a generic choice of lengths, except for a few explicit cases where the graphs have a common edge-reflection symmetry. The paper concludes by addressing three open conjectures for metric graphs that can benefit from the tools introduced in this paper.