arXiv++ Combinatorics

We study two measures of uncolourability of cubic graphs, their colouring defect and perfect matching index. The colouring defect of a cubic graph $G$ is the smallest number of edges left uncovered by three perfect matchings; the perfect matching index of $G$ is the smallest number of perfect matchings that together cover all edges of $G$. We provide a complete characterisation of cubic graphs with colouring defect $3$ whose perfect matching index is greater or equal to $5$. The result states that every such graph arises from the Petersen graph with a fixed $6$-cycle $C$ by substituting edges or vertices outside $C$ with suitable $3$-edge-colourable cubic graphs. Our research is motivated by two deep and long-standing conjectures, Berge's conjecture stating that five perfect matchings are enough to cover the edges of any bridgeless cubic graph and the shortest cycle cover conjecture of Alon and Tarsi suggesting that every bridgeless graph can have its edges covered with cycles of total length at most $7/5\cdot m$, where $m$ is the number of edges. We apply our characterisation to showing that every cubic graph with colouring defect $3$ admits a cycle cover of length at most $4/3\cdot m +1$, where $m$ is the number of edges, the bound being achieved by the graphs whose perfect matching index equals $5$. We further prove that every snark containing a $5$-cycle with an edge whose endvertices removed yield a $3$-edge-colourable graph has a cycle cover of length at most $4/3\cdot m+1$, as well.

A snark -- connected cubic graph with chromatic index $4$ -- is critical if the graph resulting from the removal of any pair of distinct adjacent vertices is $3$-edge-colourable; it is bicritical if the same is true for any pair of distinct vertices. A snark is strictly critical if it is critical but not bicritical. Very little is known about strictly critical snarks. Computational evidence suggests that strictly critical snarks constitute a tiny minority of all critical snarks. Strictly critical snarks of order $n$ exist if and only if $n$ is even and at least 32, and for each such order there is at least one strictly critical snark with cyclic connectivity $4$. A sparse infinite family of cyclically $5$-connected strictly critical snarks is also known, but those with cyclic connectivity greater than $5$ have not been discovered so far. In this paper we fill the gap by constructing cyclically $6$-connected strictly critical snarks of each even order $n\ge 342$. In addition, we construct cyclically $5$-connected strictly critical snarks of girth 6 for every even $n\ge 66$ with $n\equiv 2\pmod8$.

We prove that a signed graph admits a nowhere-zero $8$-flow provided that it is flow-admissible and the underlying graph admits a nowhere-zero $4$-flow. When combined with the 4-color theorem, this implies that every flow-admissible bridgeless planar signed graph admits a nowhere-zero $8$-flow. Our result improves and generalizes previous results of Li et al. (European J. Combin. 108 (2023), 103627), which state that every flow-admissible signed $3$-edge-colorable cubic graph admits a nowhere-zero $10$-flow, and that every flow-admissible signed hamiltonian graph admits a nowhere-zero $8$-flow.

We introduce a new invariant of a cubic graph - its regular colouring defect - which is defined as the smallest number of edges left uncovered by any collection of three perfect matchings that have no edge in common. This invariant is a modification of colouring defect, an invariant introduced by Steffen (J. Graph Theory 78(2015), 195--206), whose definition does not require the empty intersection condition. In this paper we discuss the relationship of this invariant to the well-known conjectures of Fulkerson (1971) and Fan and Raspaud (1994) and prove that colouring defect and regular colouring defect can be arbitrarily far apart.

A set of vertices of a graph $G$ is said to be decycling if its removal leaves an acyclic subgraph. The size of a smallest decycling set is the decycling number of $G$. Generally, at least $\lceil(n+2)/4\rceil$ vertices have to be removed in order to decycle a cubic graph on $n$ vertices. In 1979, Payan and Sakarovitch proved that the decycling number of a cyclically $4$-edge-connected cubic graph of order $n$ equals $\lceil (n+2)/4\rceil$. In addition, they characterised the structure of minimum decycling sets and their complements. If $n\equiv 2\pmod4$, then $G$ has a decycling set which is independent and its complement induces a tree. If $n\equiv 0\pmod4$, then one of two possibilities occurs: either $G$ has an independent decycling set whose complement induces a forest of two trees, or the decycling set is near-independent (which means that it induces a single edge) and its complement induces a tree. In this paper we strengthen the result of Payan and Sakarovitch by proving that the latter possibility (a near-independent set and a tree) can always be guaranteed. Moreover, we relax the assumption of cyclic $4$-edge-connectivity to a significantly weaker condition expressed through the canonical decomposition of 3-connected cubic graphs into cyclically $4$-edge-connected ones. Our methods substantially use a surprising and seemingly distant relationship between the decycling number and the maximum genus of a cubic graph.

The colouring defect of a cubic graph is the smallest number of edges left uncovered by any set of three perfect matchings. While $3$-edge-colourable graphs have defect $0$, those that cannot be $3$-edge-coloured (that is, snarks) are known to have defect at least $3$. In this paper we focus on the structure and properties of snarks with defect $3$. For such snarks we develop a theory of reductions similar to standard reductions of short cycles and small cuts in general snarks. We prove that every snark with defect $3$ can be reduced to a snark with defect $3$ which is either nontrivial (cyclically $4$-edge-connected and of girth at least $5$) or to one that arises from a nontrivial snark of defect greater than $3$ by inflating a vertex lying on a suitable $5$-cycle to a triangle. The proofs rely on a detailed analysis of Fano flows associated with triples of perfect matchings leaving exactly three uncovered edges. In the final part of the paper we discuss application of our results to the conjectures of Berge and Fulkerson, which provide the main motivation for our research.

A long-standing conjecture of Berge suggests that every bridgeless cubic graph can be expressed as a union of at most five perfect matchings. This conjecture trivially holds for $3$-edge-colourable cubic graphs, but remains widely open for graphs that are not $3$-edge-colourable. The aim of this paper is to verify the validity of Berge's conjecture for cubic graphs that are in a certain sense close to $3$-edge-colourable graphs. We measure the closeness by looking at the colouring defect, which is defined as the minimum number of edges left uncovered by any collection of three perfect matchings. While $3$-edge-colourable graphs have defect $0$, every bridgeless cubic graph with no $3$-edge-colouring has defect at least $3$. In 2015, Steffen proved that the Berge conjecture holds for cyclically $4$-edge-connected cubic graphs with colouring defect $3$ or $4$. Our aim is to improve Steffen's result in two ways. We show that all bridgeless cubic graphs with defect $3$ satisfy Berge's conjecture irrespectively of their cyclic connectivity. If, additionally, the graph in question is cyclically $4$-edge-connected, then four perfect matchings suffice, unless the graph is the Petersen graph. The result is best possible as there exists an infinite family of cubic graphs with cyclic connectivity $3$ which have defect $3$ but cannot be covered with four perfect matchings.

The aim of this paper is to classify all snarks up to order $36$ and explain the reasons of their uncolourability. The crucial part of our approach is a computer-assisted structural analysis of cyclically $5$-connected critical snarks, which is justified by the fact that every other snark can be constructed from them by a series of simple operations while preserving uncolourability. Our results reveal that most of the analysed snarks are built up from pieces of the Petersen graph and can be naturally distributed into a small number of classes having the same reason for uncolourability. This sheds new light on the structure of all small snarks. Based on our analysis, we generalise certain individual snarks to infinite families and identify a rich family of cyclically $5$-connected critical snarks.

The colouring defect of a cubic graph, introduced by Steffen in 2015, is the minimum number of edges that are left uncovered by any set of three perfect matchings. Since a cubic graph has defect $0$ if and only if it is $3$-edge-colourable, this invariant can measure how much a cubic graph differs from a $3$-edge-colourable graph. Our aim is to examine the relationship of colouring defect to oddness, an extensively studied measure of uncolourability of cubic graphs, defined as the smallest number of odd circuits in a $2$-factor. We show that there exist cyclically $5$-edge-connected snarks (cubic graphs with no $3$-edge-colouring) of oddness $2$ and arbitrarily large colouring defect. This result is achieved by means of a construction of cyclically $5$-edge-connected snarks with oddness $2$ and arbitrarily large girth. The fact that our graphs are cyclically $5$-edge-connected significantly strengthens a similar result of Jin and Steffen (2017), which only guarantees graphs with cyclic connectivity at most $3$. At the same time, our result improves Kochol's original construction of snarks with large girth (1996) in that it provides infinitely many nontrivial snarks of any prescribed girth $g\ge 5$, not just girth at least~$g$.

A proper edge coloring of a graph is strong if it creates no bichromatic path of length three. It is well known that for a strong edge coloring of a $k$-regular graph at least $2k-1$ colors are needed. We show that a $k$-regular graph admits a strong edge coloring with $2k-1$ colors if and only if it covers the Kneser graph $K(2k-1,k-1)$. In particular, a cubic graph is strongly $5$-edge-colorable whenever it covers the Petersen graph. One of the implications of this result is that a conjecture about strong edge colorings of subcubic graphs proposed by Faudree et al. [Ars Combin. 29 B (1990), 205--211] is false.

The perfect matching index of a cubic graph $G$, denoted by $π(G)$, is the smallest number of perfect matchings that cover all the edges of $G$. According to the Berge-Fulkerson conjecture, $π(G)\le5$ for every bridgeless cubic graph~$G$. The class of graphs with $π\ge 5$ is of particular interest as many conjectures and open problems, including the famous cycle double cover conjecture, can be reduced to it. Although nontrivial examples of such graphs are very difficult to find, a few infinite families are known, all with circular flow number $Φ_c(G)=5$. It has been therefore suggested [Electron. J. Combin. 23 (2016), $\#$P3.54] that $π(G)\ge 5$ might imply $Φ_c(G)\ge 5$. In this article we dispel these hopes and present a family of cyclically $4$-edge-connected cubic graphs of girth at least $5$ (snarks) with $π\ge 5$ and $Φ_c\le 4+\frac23$.

A conjecture of Berge suggests that every bridgeless cubic graph can have its edges covered with at most five perfect matchings. Since three perfect matchings suffice only when the graph in question is $3$-edge-colourable, the rest of cubic graphs falls into two classes: those that can be covered with four perfect matchings, and those that need at least five. Cubic graphs that require more than four perfect matchings to cover their edges are particularly interesting as potential counterexamples to several profound and long-standing conjectures including the celebrated cycle double cover conjecture. However, so far they have been extremely difficult to find. In this paper we build a theory that describes coverings with four perfect match\-ings as flows whose flow values and outflow patterns form a configuration of six lines spanned by four points of the 3-dimensional projective space $\mathbb{P}_3(\mathbb{F}_2)$ in general position. This theory provides powerful tools for investigation of graphs that do not admit such a cover and offers a great variety of methods for their construction. As an illustrative example we produce a rich family of snarks (nontrivial cubic graphs with no $3$-edge-colouring) that cannot be covered with four perfect matchings. The family contains all previously known graphs with this property.

The oddness of a cubic graph is the smallest number of odd circuits in a 2-factor of the graph. This invariant is widely considered to be one of the most important measures of uncolourability of cubic graphs and as such has been repeatedly reoccurring in numerous investigations of problems and conjectures surrounding snarks (connected cubic graphs admitting no proper 3-edge-colouring). In [Ars Math. Contemp. 16 (2019), 277-298] we have proved that the smallest number of vertices of a snark with cyclic connectivity 4 and oddness 4 is 44. We now show that there are exactly 31 such snarks, all of them having girth 5. These snarks are built up from subgraphs of the Petersen graph and a small number of additional vertices. Depending on their structure they fall into six classes, each class giving rise to an infinite family of snarks with oddness at least 4 with increasing order. We explain the reasons why these snarks have oddness 4 and prove that the 31 snarks form the complete set of snarks with cyclic connectivity 4 and oddness 4 on 44 vertices. The proof is a combination of a purely theoretical approach with extensive computations performed by a computer.

A dessin is a 2-cell embedding of a connected $2$-coloured bipartite graph into an orientable closed surface. A dessin is regular if its group of orientation- and colour-preserving automorphisms acts regularly on the edges. In this paper we study regular dessins whose underlying graph is a complete bipartite graph $K_{m,n}$, called $(m,n)$-complete regular dessins. The purpose is to establish a rather surprising correspondence between $(m,n)$-complete regular dessins and pairs of skew-morphisms of cyclic groups. A skew-morphism of a finite group $A$ is a bijection $\varphi\colon A\to A$ that satisfies the identity $\varphi(xy)=\varphi(x)\varphi^{π(x)}(y)$ for some function $π\colon A\to\mathbb{Z}$ and fixes the neutral element of~$A$. We show that every $(m,n)$-complete regular dessin $\mathcal{D}$ determines a pair of reciprocal skew-morphisms of the cyclic groups $\mathbb{Z}_n$ and $\mathbb{Z}_m$. Conversely, $\mathcal{D}$ can be reconstructed from such a reciprocal pair. As a consequence, we prove that complete regular dessins, exact bicyclic groups with a distinguished pair of generators, and pairs of reciprocal skew-morphisms of cyclic groups are all in one-to-one correspondence. Finally, we apply the main result to determining all pairs of integers $m$ and $n$ for which there exists, up to interchange of colours, exactly one $(m,n)$-complete regular dessin. We show that the latter occurs precisely when every group expressible as a product of cyclic groups of order $m$ and $n$ is abelian, which eventually comes down to the condition $\gcd(m,φ(n))=\gcd(φ(m),n)=1$, where $φ$ is Euler's totient function.

The family of snarks -- connected bridgeless cubic graphs that cannot be 3-edge-coloured -- is well-known as a potential source of counterexamples to several important and long-standing conjectures in graph theory. These include the cycle double cover conjecture, Tutte's 5-flow conjecture, Fulkerson's conjecture, and several others. One way of approaching these conjectures is through the study of structural properties of snarks and construction of small examples with given properties. In this paper we deal with the problem of determining the smallest order of a nontrivial snark (that is, one which is cyclically 4-edge-connected and has girth at least 5) of oddness at least 4. Using a combination of structural analysis with extensive computations we prove that the smallest order of a snark with oddness at least 4 and cyclic connectivity 4 is 44. Formerly it was known that such a snark must have at least 38 vertices [J. Combin. Theory Ser. B 103 (2013), 468--488] and one such snark on 44 vertices was constructed by Lukot'ka et al. [Electron. J. Combin. 22 (2015), #P1.51]. The proof requires determining all cyclically 4-edge-connected snarks on 36 vertices, which extends the previously compiled list of all such snarks up to 34 vertices [J. Combin. Theory Ser. B, loc. cit.]. As a by-product, we use this new list to test the validity of several conjectures where snarks can be smallest counterexamples.

Over the past twenty years, critical and bicritical snarks have been appearing in the literature in various forms and in different contexts. Two main variants of criticality of snarks have been studied: criticality with respect to the non-existence of a $3$-edge-colouring and criticality with respect to the non-existence of a nowhere-zero $4$-flow. In this paper we show that these two kinds of criticality coincide, thereby completing previous partial results of de Freitas et al. [Electron. Notes Discrete Math. 50 (2015), 199--204] and Fiol et al. [ arXiv:1702.07156v1 (2017)].

We prove that an eulerian graph $G$ admits a decomposition into $k$ closed trails of odd length if and only if and it contains at least $k$ pairwise edge-disjoint odd circuits and $k\equiv |E(G)|\pmod{2}$. We conjecture that a connected $2d$-regular graph of odd order with $d\ge 1$ admits a decomposition into $d$ odd closed trails sharing a common vertex and verify the conjecture for $d\le 3$. The case $d=3$ is crucial for determining the flow number of a signed eulerian graph which is treated in a separate paper (arXiv:1408.1703v2). The proof of our conjecture for $d=3$ is surprisingly difficult and calls for the use of signed graphs as a convenient technical tool.

The maximum genus $γ_M(G)$ of a graph G is the largest genus of an orientable surface into which G has a cellular embedding. Combinatorially, it coincides with the maximum number of disjoint pairs of adjacent edges of G whose removal results in a connected spanning subgraph of G. In this paper we prove that removing pairs of adjacent edges from G arbitrarily while retaining connectedness leads to at least $γ_M(G)/2$ pairs of edges removed. This allows us to describe a greedy algorithm for the maximum genus of a graph; our algorithm returns an integer k such that $γ_M(G)/2\le k \le γ_M(G)$, providing a simple method to efficiently approximate maximum genus. As a consequence of our approach we obtain a 2-approximate counterpart of Xuong's combinatorial characterisation of maximum genus.

In 1982, Zaslavsky introduced the concept of a proper vertex colouring of a signed graph $G$ as a mapping $φ\colon V(G)\to \mathbb{Z}$ such that for any two adjacent vertices $u$ and $v$ the colour $φ(u)$ is different from the colour $σ(uv)φ(v)$, where is $σ(uv)$ is the sign of the edge $uv$. The substantial part of Zaslavsky's research concentrated on polynomial invariants related to signed graph colourings rather than on the behaviour of colourings of individual signed graphs. We continue the study of signed graph colourings by proposing the definition of a chromatic number for signed graphs which provides a natural extension of the chromatic number of an unsigned graph. We establish the basic properties of this invariant, provide bounds in terms of the chromatic number of the underlying unsigned graph, investigate the chromatic number of signed planar graphs, and prove an extension of the celebrated Brooks theorem to signed graphs.

This paper is devoted to a detailed study of nowhere-zero flows on signed eulerian graphs. We generalise the well-known fact about the existence of nowhere-zero $2$-flows in eulerian graphs by proving that every signed eulerian graph that admits an integer nowhere-zero flow has a nowhere-zero $4$-flow. We also characterise signed eulerian graphs with flow number $2$, $3$, and $4$, as well as those that do not have an integer nowhere-zero flow. Finally, we discuss the existence of nowhere-zero $A$-flows on signed eulerian graphs for an arbitrary abelian group~$A$.