arXiv++ Combinatorics

An \emph{antilattice} is an algebraic structure based on the same set of axioms as a lattice except that the two commutativity axioms for $\land$ and $\lor$ are replaced by anticommutative counterparts. In this paper we study certain classes of antilattices, including elementary (no nontrivial subantilattices), odd (no subantilattices of order $2$), simple (no nontrivial congruences) and irreducible (not expressible as a direct product). In the finite case, odd antilattices are the same as Leech's \emph{Latin} antilattices which arise from the construction of semimagic squares from pairs of orthogonal Latin squares.

In an earlier paper by three of the present authors and Csaba Schneider, it was shown that, for $m\ge2$, a set of $m+1$ partitions of a set $Ω$, any $m$ of which are the minimal non-trivial elements of a Cartesian lattice, either form a Latin square (if $m=2$), or generate a join-semilattice of dimension $m$ associated with a diagonal group over a base group $G$. In this paper we investigate what happens if we have $m+r$ partitions with $r\geq 2$, any $m$ of which are minimal elements of a Cartesian lattice. If $m=2$, this is just a set of mutually orthogonal Latin squares. We consider the case where all these squares are isotopic to Cayley tables of groups, and give an example to show the groups need not be all isomorphic. For $m>2$, things are more restricted. Any $m+1$ of the partitions generate a join-semilattice admitting a diagonal group over a group $G$. It may be that the groups are all isomorphic, though we cannot prove this. Under an extra hypothesis, we show that $G$ must be abelian and must have three fixed-point-free automorphisms whose product is the identity. Under this hypothesis, such a structure gives an orthogonal array, and conversely in some cases. If the group is cyclic of prime order $p$, then the structure corresponds exactly to an arc of cardinality $m+r$ in the $(m-1)$-dimensional projective space over the field with $p$ elements, so all known results about arcs are applicable. More generally, arcs over a finite field of order $q$ give examples where $G$ is the elementary abelian group of order $q$. These examples can be lifted to non-elementary abelian groups using $p$-adic techniques.

We study incidence properties among cosets of finite loops, with emphasis on well-structured varieties such as antiautomorphic loops and Bol loops. While cosets in groups are either disjoint or identical, we find that the incidence structure in general loops can be much richer. Every symmetric design, for example, can be realized as a canonical collection of cosets of a finite loop. We show that in the variety of antiautomorphic loops the poset formed by set inclusion among intersections of left cosets is isomorphic to that formed by right cosets. We present an algorithm that, given a finite Bol loop $S$, can in some cases determine whether $|S|$ divides $|Q|$ for all finite Bol loops $Q$ with $S \le Q$, and even whether there is a selection of left cosets of $S$ that partitions $Q$. This method results in a positive confirmation of Lagrange's Theorem for Bol loops for a few new cases of subloops. Finally, we show that in a left automorphic Moufang loop $Q$ (in particular, in a commutative Moufang loop $Q$), two left cosets of $S\le Q$ are either disjoint or they intersect in a set whose cardinality equals that of some subloop of $S$.

It was shown by van Rees \cite{vR} that a latin square of order $n$ has at most $n^2(n-1)/18$ latin subsquares of order $3$. He conjectured that this bound is only achieved if $n$ is a power of $3$. We show that it can only be achieved if $n\equiv3\bmod6$. We also state several conditions that are equivalent to achieving the van Rees bound. One of these is that the Cayley table of a loop achieves the van Rees bound if and only if every loop isotope has exponent $3$. We call such loops \emph{van Rees loops} and show that they form an equationally defined variety. We also show that (1) In a van Rees loop, any subloop of index 3 is normal, (2) There are exactly 6 nonassociative van Rees loops of order $27$ with a non-trivial nucleus and at least 1 with all nuclei trivial, (3) Every commutative van Rees loop has the weak inverse property and (4) For each van Rees loop there is an associated family of Steiner quasigroups.

A nearlattice is a join semilattice such that every principal filter is a lattice with respect to the induced order. Hickman and later Chajda et al independently showed that nearlattices can be treated as varieties of algebras with a ternary operation satisfying certain axioms. Our main result is that the variety of nearlattices is 2-based, and we exhibit an explicit axiom system of two independent identities. We also show that the original axiom systems of Hickman and of Chajda et al are, respectively, dependent.

Let $S$ be a finite non-commutative semigroup. The commuting graph of $S$, denoted $\cg(S)$, is the graph whose vertices are the non-central elements of $S$ and whose edges are the sets $\{a,b\}$ of vertices such that $a\ne b$ and $ab=ba$. Denote by $T(X)$ the semigroup of full transformations on a finite set $X$. Let $J$ be any ideal of $T(X)$ such that $J$ is different from the ideal of constant transformations on $X$. We prove that if $|X|\geq4$, then, with a few exceptions, the diameter of $\cg(J)$ is 5. On the other hand, we prove that for every positive integer $n$, there exists a semigroup $S$ such that the diameter of $\cg(S)$ is $n$. We also study the left paths in $\cg(S)$, that is, paths $a_1-a_2-...-a_m$ such that $a_1\ne a_m$ and $a_1a_i=a_ma_i$ for all $i\in \{1,\ldot, m\}$. We prove that for every positive integer $n\geq2$, except $n=3$, there exists a semigroup whose shortest left path has length $n$. As a corollary, we use the previous results to solve a purely algebraic old problem posed by B.M. Schein.