arXiv++ Combinatorics

We construct an infinite family of Neumaier graphs of coherent rank five, answering the existence question at the smallest possible coherent rank beyond the strongly regular case. For every prime power $q\geqslant7$ with $q\equiv3\pmod4$, set $n=q+1$. Each graph in our construction has precisely five distinct eigenvalues, Neumaier parameters \[ \left( n(n-1)(n-3), \frac{n^2(n-3)}2, \frac{n(n^2-n-8)}4; \frac{(n-2)^2}{2}, (n-1)(n-3) \right), \] and its adjacency matrix lies in the Bose--Mesner algebra of the four-class association scheme of Holzmann, Kharaghani, and Suda. Paley Hadamard matrices and Desarguesian mutually orthogonal Latin squares yield an infinite family whose smallest member has parameters $(280,160,96;18,35)$.

Anti-Latin squares were introduced in connection with non-linear secure network coding, and the extremal problem for large mutually orthogonal families is motivated by that setting. We study the maximum size $N_A(d)$ of a family of mutually orthogonal anti-Latin squares of order $d$. We prove that $N_L(d)+1\le N_A(d)\le N_L(d)+2$ for every $d\ge 3$, where $N_L(d)$ denotes the classical maximum size of a family of mutually orthogonal Latin squares of order $d$, and we show that in fact $N_A(3)=N_L(3)+1$ whereas $N_A(d)=N_L(d)+2$ for every $d\ge 4$. The upper bound is obtained by passing through balanced matrices, while the lower bound is given by a deterministic permutation argument. For all $d\ge 8$, and also for the exceptional order $d=6$, the upper bound is shown to be attainable by a general probabilistic construction. On the structural side, we show that a saturated family of size $d+1$ induces an affine plane of order $d$, and that the saturated case is characterized by the existence of an anti-coordinate grid decomposition; after transporting this condition to the fixed cell set $[d]^2$, it becomes a direction-completeness condition on the corresponding row-blocks and column-blocks. The remaining small orders are treated separately: $d=3$ is handled by direct analysis and classification of orthogonal triples, $d=4$ by an explicit saturated construction and an analysis of its finite-geometric structure, and $d=5$ and $d=7$ by explicit saturated examples arising from the random-grid framework. Thus $N_A(d)$ is determined in terms of $N_L(d)$ for every $d\ge3$, and its numerical value is obtained explicitly for every $3\le d\le9$.

The Zarankiewicz number z(43;2) is the largest number of edges in a four-cycle-free bipartite graph with two parts of size 43. Reiman's bound gives z(43;2) <= 301, with equality only for the incidence graph of a projective plane of order six; no such plane exists, so z(43;2) <= 300. We prove z(43;2) <= 299. The argument is elementary and uses no computer search: a counting identity for the leave of the configuration shows that a hypothetical 300-edge graph admits one of exactly twenty-seven degree profiles per side, of which only four combinations are locally compatible. Three force two vertices to share six neighbours; the fourth forces a transversal design TD(6,6), hence four mutually orthogonal Latin squares of order six, contradicting Tarry's theorem. We also give an explicit 284-edge construction inside PG(2,7), so that 284 <= z(43;2) <= 299.

We examine combinatorial structures which generalize $(k,n)$-nets, orthogonal arrays, and mutually orthogonal Latin squares. By a reticulation we mean of a point set and two collections (types) of families of lines such that two lines of different types meet in exactly one point and each family of lines partitions the point set. The number of points incident with any line depends only upon the type of the line, and every point is incident with the same number of lines of a given type. Each choice of one line family of each type leads to an arrangement of the points into a rectangular grid. Recording the line containing a given point in the corresponding position of an array gives to a generalization of sets of mutually orthogonal Latin squares, dubbed a cooperative system. A cooperative system consists of a collection of column-Latin matrices and a collection of row-Latin matrices such that each column-Latin matrix is orthogonal to each row-Latin matrix. Recording lines which contain a given point as a tuple gives a generalization of certain orthogonal arrays, dubbed semi-orthogonal arrays. Notions of parastrophy and isotopy for cooperative systems, corresponding to permuting families of lines and lines within each family, are introduced. Constructions of small reticulations and three recursive constructions of larger reticulations are given.

Latin squares are $n\times n$ matrices containing $n$ symbols, where each symbol appears exactly once in each row and column. They were studied by Euler, later popularized through Sudoku, and remain a rich source of difficult combinatorial search problems. Two Latin squares are orthogonal mates if, when overlaid, no ordered pair of symbols repeats. Pairs of orthogonal Latin squares exist for every order except 2 and 6, but finding orthogonal Latin squares computationally can be challenging. Satisfiability (SAT) solvers are strong at combinatorial search and have been used to resolve a number of various kinds of orthogonal Latin square problems. On the other hand, SAT solvers lack domain knowledge about Latin squares, such as the Euler-Parker algorithm for orthogonal mate construction. In this paper, we propose a hybrid method combining a SAT solver with the Euler-Parker algorithm (implemented using a Diophantine system solver) and show that the resulting solver is effective at finding certain kinds of orthogonal Latin squares. For example, certain pairs of $10\times10$ orthogonal Latin squares whose existence was unknown for over 25 years were recently found by Bright, Keita, and Stevens using a SAT solver. The hardest cases could not be solved by the SAT solver CaDiCaL within seven days, but CaDiCaL augmented with an external Euler-Parker algorithm solves these cases in a median of around 5,100 seconds.

We prove that the existence of finite combinatorial objects such as affine planes, mutually orthogonal Latin squares, and resolvable balanced incomplete block designs can be reformulated as the existence of certain algorithmic reductions between problems related to the pigeonhole principle. We then study the latter using counting arguments and computability theory. In particular, we demonstrate that computability theoretic techniques can be used to refine and prove new results in finite combinatorics.

We consider threshold secret sharing schemes based on cellular automata (CA) that allows for anonymous reconstruction, meaning that the secret can be recovered only as a function of the shares, without knowing the participants' identities. To this end, we revisit the basic characterization of $(2,n)$ threshold schemes based on CA in terms of Mutually Orthogonal Latin Squares (MOLS), and redefine the secret space as the MOLS family itself, showing that the new resulting scheme enables anonymous reconstruction of secret CA rules. Finally, we discuss the trade-off between the number of secret CA that can be shared and the computational complexity of the recovery phase.

There exist pairs of orthogonal Latin squares of any order n except if n=2 or n=6 [Bose, Shrikhande and Parker, 1960]. In particular, the problem of Euler's thirty-six officers does not have a solution. However, it has a "quantum solution": there exist so-called entangled quantum Latin squares of order six [Rather et al., 2022]. We prove that mutually orthogonal quantum Latin squares of order six do not exist if entanglement is not allowed.

In this paper, we present new constructions of $q$-ary Singleton-optimal locally repairable codes (LRCs) with minimum distance $d=6$ and locality $r=3$, based on combinatorial structures from finite geometry. By exploiting the well-known correspondence between a complete set of mutually orthogonal Latin squares (MOLS) of order $q$ and the affine plane $\mathrm{AG}(2,q)$, We systematically construct families of disjoint 4-arcs in the projective plane $\mathrm{PG}(2,q)$, such that the union of any two distinct 4-arcs forms an 8-arc. These 4-arcs form what we call 4-local arcs, and their existence is equivalent to that of the desired codes. For any prime power $q\ge 7$, our construction yields codes of length $n = 2q$, $2q-2$, or $2q-6$ depending on whether $q$ is even, $q\equiv 3 \pmod{4}$, or $q\equiv 1 \pmod{4}$, respectively.

We investigate MacNeish's conjecture (known to be false in general) in the setting of what we call "transitive" Mutually Orthogonal Latin Squares (MOLS). When we restrict our attention to "simply transitive" MOLS, we find that the conjecture holds. We provide some partial results towards the transitive case, as well as the outcome of a computer search, which introduces a new construction of MOLS. In particular, we were unable to find any transitive large (conjecture-violating) sets of MOLS in the literature.

A $k$-net($n$) is a combinatorial design equivalent to $k-2$ mutually orthogonal Latin squares of order $n$. A relation in a net is a linear dependency over $\mathbb{F}_2$ in the incidence matrix of the net. A computational enumeration of all orthogonal pairs of Latin squares of order 10 whose corresponding nets have at least two nontrivial relations was achieved by Delisle in 2010 and verified by an independent search of Myrvold. In this paper, we confirm the correctness of their exhaustive enumerations with a satisfiability (SAT) solver approach instead of using custom-written backtracking code. Performing the enumeration using a SAT solver has at least three advantages. First, it reduces the amount of trust necessary, as SAT solvers produce independently-verifiable certificates that their enumerations are complete. These certificates can be checked by formal proof verifiers that are relatively simple pieces of software, and therefore easier to trust. Second, it is typically more straightforward and less error-prone to use a SAT solver over writing search code. Third, it can be more efficient to use a SAT-based approach, as SAT solvers are highly optimized pieces of software incorporating backtracking-with-learning for improving the efficiency of the backtracking search. For example, the SAT solver completely enumerates all orthogonal pairs of Latin squares of order ten with two nontrivial relations in under 2 hours on a desktop machine, while Delisle's 2010 search used 11,700 CPU hours. Although computer hardware was slower in 2010, this alone cannot explain the improvement in the efficiency of our SAT-based search.

Resolvable combinatorial designs including Resolvable Balanced Incomplete Block Designs, Resolvable Group Divisible Designs, Uniformly Resolvable Designs and Mutually Orthogonal Latin Squares and Rectangles are used to construct optimal solutions to the Social Golfer problem (SGP) and the Social Golfer problem with adjacent group sizes (SGA). An algorithm is presented to find an optimal solution in general, and a complete set of solutions is provided for up to 150 players.

Cellular Automata (CA) are commonly investigated as a particular type of dynamical systems, defined by shift-invariant local rules. In this paper, we consider instead CA as algebraic systems, focusing on the combinatorial designs induced by their short-term behavior. Specifically, we review the main results published in the literature concerning the construction of mutually orthogonal Latin squares via bipermutive CA, considering both the linear and nonlinear cases. We then survey some significant applications of these results to cryptography, and conclude with a discussion of open problems to be addressed in future research on CA-based combinatorial designs.

We characterize the permutations of $\mathbb{F}_q$ whose graph minimizes the number of collinear triples and describe the lexicographically-least one, affirming a conjecture of Cooper-Solymosi. This question is closely connected to Dudeney's No-3-in-a-Line problem, the Heilbronn triangle problem, and the structure of finite plane Kakeya sets. We discuss a connection with complete sets of mutually orthogonal latin squares and state a few open problems primarily about general finite affine planes.

We will show that there are at least 8, 10 and 9 mutually orthogonal Latin squares (MOLS) of orders $n=54$, $96$ and $108$. The cases $n=54$ and $96$ are obtained by constructing separable permutation codes consisting of $8 \times 54$ and $10 \times 96$ codeword respectively; in addition, these codes respectively have lengths $54$, $96$ and minimum distances $53$, $95$. Here we will follow exactly the procedure given in \cite{JS2019}. The case $n=108$ is obtained by constructing a $(108,10,1)$ difference matrix. Also, an error in \cite{ACD} for $n=45$ will be corrected.

We obtain a correspondence between pairs of $N\times N$ orthogonal Latin squares and pairs of disconnected maximal cliques in the derangement graph with $N$ symbols. Motivated by methods in spectral clustering, we also obtain modular conditions on fixed point counts of certain permutation sums for the existence of collections of mutually disconnected maximal cliques. We use these modular obstructions to analyze the structure of maximal cliques in $X_N$ for small values of $N$. We culminate in a short, elementary proof of the nonexistence of a solution to Euler's $36$ Officer Problem.

Two Latin squares of order $n$ are $r$-orthogonal if, when superimposed, there are exactly $r$ distinct ordered pairs. The spectrum of all values of $r$ for Latin squares of order $n$ is known. A Latin square $A$ of order $n$ is $r$-self-orthogonal if $A$ and its transpose are $r$-orthogonal. The spectrum of all values of $r$ is known for all orders $n\ne 14$. We develop randomized algorithms for computing pairs of $r$-orthogonal Latin squares of order $n$ and algorithms for computing $r$-self-orthogonal Latin squares of order $n$.

We consider the problem of exhaustively visiting all pairs of linear cellular automata which give rise to orthogonal Latin squares, i.e., linear Orthogonal Cellular Automata (OCA). The problem is equivalent to enumerating all pairs of coprime polynomials over a finite field having the same degree and a nonzero constant term. While previous research showed how to count all such pairs for a given degree and order of the finite field, no practical enumeration algorithms have been proposed so far. Here, we start closing this gap by addressing the case of polynomials defined over the field $\F_2$, which corresponds to binary CA. In particular, we exploit Benjamin and Bennett's bijection between coprime and non-coprime pairs of polynomials, which enables us to organize our study along three subproblems, namely the enumeration and count of: (1) sequences of constant terms, (2) sequences of degrees, and (3) sequences of intermediate terms. In the course of this investigation, we unveil interesting connections with algebraic language theory and combinatorics, obtaining an enumeration algorithm and an alternative derivation of the counting formula for this problem.

We discuss the problem of existence of latin squares without a substructure consisting of six elements $(r_1,c_2,l_3)$, $(r_2,c_3,l_1)$, $(r_3,c_1,l_2)$, $(r_2,c_1,l_3)$, $(r_3,c_2,l_1)$, $(r_1,c_3,l_2)$. Equivalently, the corresponding latin square graph does not have an induced subgraph isomorphic to $K_{3,3}$. The exhaustive search [Brouwer, Wanless. Universally noncommutative loops. 2011] says that there are no such latin squares of order $3$--$7$, $9$--$11$ and there are only two $K_{3,3}$-free latin squares of order $8$, up to equivalence. We repeat the search, establishing also the number of latin $m$-by-$n$ rectangles for each $m$ and $n$ less than or equal to $11$. As a switched combination of two orthogonal latin squares of order $8$, we construct a $K_{3,3}$-free (universally noncommutative) latin square of order $16$. We also consider a similar problem for orthogonal latin squares, proving that there are both $K_{4,4}$-free and non-$K_{4,4}$-free linear pairs of orthogonal latin squares for each odd prime-power order larger than~$5$. Keywords: latin square; transversal; trade; pattern avoiding; eigenfunction; universally noncommutative loop.

Most of the approaches published in the literature to construct S-boxes via Cellular Automata (CA) work by either iterating a finite CA for several time steps, or by a one-shot application of the global rule. The main characteristic that brings together these works is that they employ a single CA rule to define the vectorial Boolean function of the S-box. In this work, we explore a different direction for the design of S-boxes that leverages on Orthogonal CA (OCA), i.e. pairs of CA rules giving rise to orthogonal Latin squares. The motivation stands on the facts that an OCA pair already defines a bijective transformation, and moreover the orthogonality property of the resulting Latin squares ensures a minimum amount of diffusion. We exhaustively enumerate all S-boxes generated by OCA pairs of diameter $4 \le d \le 6$, and measure their nonlinearity. Interestingly, we observe that for $d=4$ and $d=5$ all S-boxes are linear, despite the underlying CA local rules being nonlinear. The smallest nonlinear S-boxes emerges for $d=6$, but their nonlinearity is still too low to be used in practice. Nonetheless, we unearth an interesting structure of linear OCA S-boxes, proving that their Linear Components Space (LCS) is itself the image of a linear CA, or equivalently a polynomial code. We finally classify all linear OCA S-boxes in terms of their generator polynomials.