arXiv++ Combinatorics

A short survey about combinatorics on words and algorithmic methods in a ring. Special attention is given to Shirshov's results. Adopted for undegraduate students.

In 1993 E. I. Zelmanov asked the following question in Dniester Notebook: $"$Suppose that $F_{2,m}$ is a $2$-generated associative ring with the identity $x^m=0$. Is it true, that the nilpotency degree of $F_{2,m}$ has exponential growth?$"$ We show that the nilpotency degree of $l$-generated associative algebra with the identity $x^d=0$ is smaller than $Ψ(d,d,l)$, where $Φ(n,d,l)=l(nd)^{C\log(nd)}$ and $C$ is a constant. We give the definitive answer to E. I. Zelmanov by this result. It is the consequence of one fact, which is based on combinatorics of words. Let $l$, $n$ and $d\ge n$ be positive integers. Then all the words over alphabet of cardinality $l$ which length is greater than $Ψ(n,d,l)$ are either $n$-divided or contain $d$-th power of subword, where a word $W$ is $n$-divided, if it can be represented in the following form $W=W_0W_1\dots W_n$ such that $W_n\succ W_{n-1}\succ\cdots\succ W_1$. The symbol $\succ$ means lexicographical order here. A. I. Shirshov proved that the set of non $n$-divided words over alphabet of cardinality $l$ has bounded height $h$ over the set $Y$ consisting of all the words of degree $<n$. Original Shirshov's estimation was just recursive, in 1982 double exponent was obtained by A. G. Kolotov and in 1993 A. Ya. Belov obtained exponential estimation. We show, that $h<Φ(n,l)$, where $Φ(n,l)=n^{C\log n} l$ and $C$ is a constant. Our proof uses Latyshev idea of Dilworth theorem application.

In 1993 E. I. Zelmanov asked the following question in Dniester Notebook: "Suppose that $F_{2, m}$ is a 2-generated associative ring with the identity $x^m=0$. Is it true, that the nilpotency degree of $F_{2, m}$ has exponential growth?" We show that the nilpotency degree of $l$-generated associative algebra with the identity $x^d=0$ is smaller than $Ψ(d,d,l)$, where $Ψ(n,d,l)=l (nd)^{C \log (nd)}$ and $C$ is a constant. We give the definitive answer to E. I. Zelmanov by this result. It is the consequence of one fact, which is based on combinatorics of words. Let $l, n$ and $d>n$ be positive integers. Then all the words over alphabet of cardinality $l$ which length is greater than $Ψ(n,d,l)$ are either $n$-divided or contain $d$-th power of subword, where a word $W$ is $n$-divided, if it can be represented in the following form $W=W_0 W_1\dots W_n$ such that $W_n \prec W_{n-1}\prec\cdots\prec W_1$. The symbol $\prec$ means lexicographical order here. A. I. Shirshov proved that the set of non $n$-divided words over alphabet of cardinality $l$ has bounded height $h$ over the set $Y$ consisting of all the words of degree $<n$. Original Shirshov's estimation was just recursive, in 1982 double exponent was obtained by A. G. Kolotov and in 1993 A. Ya. Belov obtained exponential estimation. We show, that $h<Phi(n,l)$, where $Phi(n,l) = n^{C \log n} l$ and $C$ is a constant. Our proof uses Latyshev idea of Dilworth theorem application.

Partially ordered sets of type (k, n) are the sets such that a) cardinality of each set is n, b) dimension of each set is two, c) length of the maximal antichain in each set is k. Let α_k(n) be the number of partially ordered sets of type (k, n). We prove that α_k(n)<min{k^{2n}/((k!)^2), (n-k+1)^{2n}/(((n-k)!)^2)}. Denote by ξ_k(n) the number of permutations from S_n such that the maximal decreasing chain of such permutation has length k. We prove that ξ_k(n)<k^{2n}/(((k-1)!)^2). We survey connections among the pairs of linear orders, the pairs Young diagrams, two-dimensional arrays of positive integers and matrices of nonnegative integers. This survey is based on papers of Schensted and Knuth. We show the generating function of ξ_k(n). It was obtained by Gessen in 1990.

In 1993 E. I. Zelmanov asked the following question in Dniester Notebook: "Suppose that F_{2, m} is a 2-generated associative ring with the identity x^m=0. Is it true, that the nilpotency degree of F_{2, m} has exponential growth?" We show that the nilpotency degree of l-generated associative algebra with the identity x^d=0 is smaller than Psi(d,d,l), where Psi(n,d,l)=2^{18} l (nd)^{3 log_3 (nd)+13}d^2. We give the definitive answer to E. I. Zelmanov by this result. It is the consequence of one fact, which is based on combinatorics of words. Let l, n and d>n be positive integers. Then all the words over alphabet of cardinality l which length is greater than Psi(n,d,l) are either n-divided or contain d-th power of subword, where a word W is n-divided, if it can be represented in the following form W=W_0 W_1...W_n such that W_1 >' W_2>'...>'W_n. The symbol >' means lexicographical order here. A. I. Shirshov proved that the set of non n-divided words over alphabet of cardinality l has bounded height h over the set Y consisting of all the words of degree <n. Original Shirshov's estimation was just recursive, in 1982 double exponent was obtained by A.G.Kolotov and in 1993 A.Ya.Belov obtained exponential estimation. We show, that h<Phi(n,l), where Phi(n,l) = 2^{87} n^{12 log_3 n + 48} l. Our proof uses Latyshev idea of Dilworth theorem application.

Let us recall the well-known Shirshov's Height Theorem. "Let A be a finitely generated algebra of degree d. Then there exists a finite set Y which is the subset of A that A has and an integer h' = h(A) such that A has Shirshov's height h' over set Y. For Y we may take the set of words of length <d. Such Y is called a Shirshov's base of algebra A." Shirshov's original proof was purely combinatorical, but did not provide a reasonable upper estimate for the height. Kolotov obtained an estimate for h(A) < s^(s^m) (m = deg(A), and s is the number of generators) in 1981. I. Zelmanov asked for an exponential bound in the Dniester Notebook. In 2011 Belov and Kharitonov get the estimate 2^87 m^(12 log_3(m)+48) l. This result answered Zelmanov question that in fact Shirshov's height has subexponential growth. As a corollary from Amitzur-Levitsky theorem we have the lower estimate of h(A) which is ((m/2)^2 - 1)(s - 1) + 1 . We consider essential height over the sets of small words to obtain exact estimations of Shirshov's height. Define by n-divisible such word w that may be constructed as w = v u_1 u_2...u_n, where for every i from 2 to n u_(i-1) is lexicographically less than u_i. The main results of the paper are the following: Let M be the set of non-n-dividable words with: 1) finite essential height over the words degree 2, then the number of lexicographically comparable words with period 2 is less than (2l-1)(n-1)(n-2)/2; 2) finite essential height over the words degree 3, then the number of lexicographically comparable words with period 3 is less than (2l-1)(n-1)(n-2); 3) finite essential height over the words degree (n-1), then the number of lexicographically comparable words with period (n-1) is less than (l-2)(n-1). The case of the words of length 2 is synthesized to the proof of the exponential estimation in Shirshov's Height theorem.

In 1993 E. I. Zelmanov asked the following question in Dniester Notebook: "Suppose that F_{2, m} is a 2-generated associative ring with the identity x^m=0. Is it true, that the nilpotency degree of F_{2, m} has exponential growth?" We show that the nilpotency degree of l-generated associative algebra with the identity x^d=0 is smaller than Psi(d,d,l), where Psi(n,d,l)=2^{18} l (nd)^{3 log_3 (nd)+13}d^2. We give the definitive answer to E. I. Zelmanov by this result. It is the consequence of one fact, which is based on combinatorics of words. Let l, n and d>n be positive integers. Then all the words over alphabet of cardinality l which length is greater than Psi(n,d,l) are either n-divided or contain d-th power of subword, where a word W is n-divided, if it can be represented in the following form W=W_0 W_1...W_n such that W_1 >' W_2>'...>'W_n. The symbol >' means lexicographical order here. A. I. Shirshov proved that the set of non n-divided words over alphabet of cardinality l has bounded height h over the set Y consisting of all the words of degree <n. Original Shirshov's estimation was just recursive, in 1982 double exponent was obtained by A.G.Kolotov and in 1993 A.Ya.Belov obtained exponential estimation. We show, that h<Phi(n,l), where Phi(n,l) = 2^{87} n^{12 log_3 n + 48} l. Our proof uses Latyshev idea of Dilworth theorem application.