arXiv++ Combinatorics

We prove that the path $P_{11}$ does not admit uniform average mixing under any probability distribution on $\mathbb R$, answering a question of Baptista, Coutinho, and Marques in the negative. The proof is exact: we construct an explicit rational symmetric matrix $Y$ such that $\langle Y,M(t)\rangle_F=1$ for every $t\in\mathbb R$, whereas $\langle Y,J/11\rangle_F=12/11$.

We introduce a family of complex-valued edge weights on a finite simple graph $\G$ arising from a continuous-time quantum walk on the line graph $\ell\G$, packaged as the \emph{Schur state}: an $n \times n$ Hermitian matrix encoding the amplitudes of an edge-state walk. The entrywise modulus square induces a real-weighted adjacency matrix $A(e)$ and Laplacian $L(e)$, and time-averaging yields a weighted graph whose spanning-tree count we relate to that of $\G$. Our main result is \[ tn\!\left(\G, \tfrac{1}{m}\right) = \frac{1}{m^{n-1}}\, tn(\G), \] valid whenever the initial edge state is \emph{uniform commutative}, where $n=|V\G|$, $m=|E\G|$, and $tn(\G, w)$ denotes the weighted spanning-tree count. We further identify a structural mechanism -- the $-2$ eigenspace of $\ell\G$ -- providing uniform commutative states beyond the regular case, in particular for line graphs of Eulerian graphs with an even number of edges. As a side result, we establish that commutative states are precisely the states whose von Neumann entropy is preserved under average mixing.