arXiv++ Combinatorics

A conjecture of Komlós states that the combinatorial discrepancy of any matrix $A\in\mathbb R^{m\times n}$ whose columns have Euclidean norm at most one is bounded by a universal constant. We prove that the combinatorial discrepancy of every such matrix is at most $O((\log n)^{1/4}(\log\log n)^{7/4})$. This is the first asymptotic improvement over the $O(\sqrt{\log n})$ bound established by Banaszczyk [Banaszczyk, Random Struct.\ Algorithms, 1998], and it refutes a conjecture of Hajela [Hajela, European J.\ Combin., 1988] that a lower bound of order $Ω(\sqrt{\log n})$ should hold.

The Beck-Fiala Conjecture [Discrete Appl. Math, 1981] asserts that any set system of $n$ elements with degree $k$ has combinatorial discrepancy $O(\sqrt{k})$. A substantial generalization is the Komlós Conjecture, which states that any $m \times n$ matrix with unit length columns has discrepancy $O(1)$. In this work, we resolve the Beck-Fiala Conjecture for $k \geq \log^2 n$. We also give an $\widetilde{O}(\sqrt{k} + \sqrt{\log n})$ bound for $k \leq \log^2 n$, where $\widetilde{O}(\cdot)$ hides $\mathsf{poly}(\log \log n)$ factors. These bounds improve upon the $O(\sqrt{k \log n})$ bound due to Banaszczyk [Random Struct. Algor., 1998]. For the Komlos problem, we give an $\widetilde{O}(\log^{1/4} n)$ bound, improving upon the previous $O(\sqrt{\log n})$ bound [Random Struct. Algor., 1998]. All of our results also admit efficient polynomial-time algorithms. To obtain these results, we exploit a new technique of ``decoupling via affine spectral-independence'' in designing rounding algorithms. In particular, our algorithms obtain the desired colorings via a discrete Brownian motion, guided by a semidefinite program (SDP). Besides standard constraints used in prior works, we add some extra affine spectral-independence constraints, which effectively decouple the evolution of discrepancies across different rows, and allow us to better control how many rows accumulate large discrepancies at any point during the process. This new technique is quite general and may be of independent interest.

In 1981, Beck and Fiala [Discrete Appl. Math, 1981] conjectured that given a set system $A \in \{0,1\}^{m \times n}$ with degree at most $k$ (i.e., each column of $A$ has at most $k$ non-zeros), its combinatorial discrepancy $\mathsf{disc}(A) := \min_{x \in \{\pm 1\}^n} \|Ax\|_\infty$ is at most $O(\sqrt{k})$. Previously, the best-known bounds for this conjecture were either $O(k)$, first established by Beck and Fiala [Discrete Appl. Math, 1981], or $O(\sqrt{k \log n})$, first proved by Banaszczyk [Random Struct. Algor., 1998]. We give an algorithmic proof of an improved bound of $O(\sqrt{k \log\log n})$ whenever $k \geq \log^5 n$, thus matching the Beck-Fiala conjecture up to $O(\sqrt{\log \log n})$ for almost the full regime of $k$.

We give a simple proof of the matrix Spencer conjecture up to poly-logarithmic rank: given symmetric $d \times d$ matrices $A_1,\ldots,A_n$ each with $\|A_i\|_{\mathsf{op}} \leq 1$ and rank at most $n/\log^3 n$, one can efficiently find $\pm 1$ signs $x_1,\ldots,x_n$ such that their signed sum has spectral norm $\|\sum_{i=1}^n x_i A_i\|_{\mathsf{op}} = O(\sqrt{n})$. This result also implies a $\log n - Ω( \log \log n)$ qubit lower bound for quantum random access codes encoding $n$ classical bits with advantage $\gg 1/\sqrt{n}$. Our proof uses the recent refinement of the non-commutative Khintchine inequality in [Bandeira, Boedihardjo, van Handel, 2022] for random matrices with correlated Gaussian entries.

The well-known Komlós conjecture states that given $n$ vectors in $\mathbb{R}^d$ with Euclidean norm at most one, there always exists a $\pm 1$ coloring such that the $\ell_{\infty}$ norm of the signed-sum vector is a constant independent of $n$ and $d$. We prove this conjecture in a smoothed analysis setting where the vectors are perturbed by adding a small Gaussian noise and when the number of vectors $n =ω(d\log d)$. The dependence of $n$ on $d$ is the best possible even in a completely random setting. Our proof relies on a weighted second moment method, where instead of considering uniformly randomly colorings we apply the second moment method on an implicit distribution on colorings obtained by applying the Gram-Schmidt walk algorithm to a suitable set of vectors. The main technical idea is to use various properties of these colorings, including subgaussianity, to control the second moment.

A well-known result of Banaszczyk in discrepancy theory concerns the prefix discrepancy problem (also known as the signed series problem): given a sequence of $T$ unit vectors in $\mathbb{R}^d$, find $\pm$ signs for each of them such that the signed sum vector along any prefix has a small $\ell_\infty$-norm? This problem is central to proving upper bounds for the Steinitz problem, and the popular Komlós problem is a special case where one is only concerned with the final signed sum vector instead of all prefixes. Banaszczyk gave an $O(\sqrt{\log d+ \log T})$ bound for the prefix discrepancy problem. We investigate the tightness of Banaszczyk's bound and consider natural generalizations of prefix discrepancy: We first consider a smoothed analysis setting, where a small amount of additive noise perturbs the input vectors. We show an exponential improvement in $T$ compared to Banaszczyk's bound. Using a primal-dual approach and a careful chaining argument, we show that one can achieve a bound of $O(\sqrt{\log d+ \log\!\log T})$ with high probability in the smoothed setting. Moreover, this smoothed analysis bound is the best possible without further improvement on Banaszczyk's bound in the worst case. We also introduce a generalization of the prefix discrepancy problem where the discrepancy constraints correspond to paths on a DAG on $T$ vertices. We show that an analog of Banaszczyk's $O(\sqrt{\log d+ \log T})$ bound continues to hold in this setting for adversarially given unit vectors and that the $\sqrt{\log T}$ factor is unavoidable for DAGs. We also show that the dependence on $T$ cannot be improved significantly in the smoothed case for DAGs. We conclude by exploring a more general notion of vector balancing, which we call combinatorial vector balancing. We obtain near-optimal bounds in this setting, up to poly-logarithmic factors.

A classic conjecture of Füredi, Kahn and Seymour (1993) states that given any hypergraph with non-negative edge weights $w(e)$, there exists a matching $M$ such that $\sum_{e \in M} (|e|-1+1/|e|)\, w(e) \geq w^*$, where $w^*$ is the value of an optimum fractional matching. We show the conjecture is true for rank-3 hypergraphs, and is achieved by a natural iterated rounding algorithm. While the general conjecture remains open, we give several new improved bounds. In particular, we show that the iterated rounding algorithm gives $\sum_{e \in M} (|e|-δ(e))\, w(e) \geq w^*$, where $δ(e) = |e|/(|e|^2+|e|-1)$, improving upon the baseline guarantee of $\sum_{e \in M} |e|\,w(e) \geq w^*$.

In the stochastic online vector balancing problem, vectors $v_1,v_2,\ldots,v_T$ chosen independently from an arbitrary distribution in $\mathbb{R}^n$ arrive one-by-one and must be immediately given a $\pm$ sign. The goal is to keep the norm of the discrepancy vector, i.e., the signed prefix-sum, as small as possible for a given target norm. We consider some of the most well-known problems in discrepancy theory in the above online stochastic setting, and give algorithms that match the known offline bounds up to $\mathsf{polylog}(nT)$ factors. This substantially generalizes and improves upon the previous results of Bansal, Jiang, Singla, and Sinha (STOC' 20). In particular, for the Komlós problem where $\|v_t\|_2\leq 1$ for each $t$, our algorithm achieves $\tilde{O}(1)$ discrepancy with high probability, improving upon the previous $\tilde{O}(n^{3/2})$ bound. For Tusnády's problem of minimizing the discrepancy of axis-aligned boxes, we obtain an $O(\log^{d+4} T)$ bound for arbitrary distribution over points. Previous techniques only worked for product distributions and gave a weaker $O(\log^{2d+1} T)$ bound. We also consider the Banaszczyk setting, where given a symmetric convex body $K$ with Gaussian measure at least $1/2$, our algorithm achieves $\tilde{O}(1)$ discrepancy with respect to the norm given by $K$ for input distributions with sub-exponential tails. Our key idea is to introduce a potential that also enforces constraints on how the discrepancy vector evolves, allowing us to maintain certain anti-concentration properties. For the Banaszczyk setting, we further enhance this potential by combining it with ideas from generic chaining. Finally, we also extend these results to the setting of online multi-color discrepancy.

Given a set system (V,S), V={1,...,n} and S={S1,...,Sm}, the minimum discrepancy problem is to find a 2-coloring of V, such that each set is colored as evenly as possible. In this paper we give the first polynomial time algorithms for discrepancy minimization that achieve bounds similar to those known existentially using the so-called Entropy Method. We also give a first approximation-like result for discrepancy. The main idea in our algorithms is to produce a coloring over time by letting the color of the elements perform a random walk (with tiny increments) starting from 0 until they reach $-1$ or $+1$. At each time step the random hops for various elements are correlated using the solution to a semidefinite program, where this program is determined by the current state and the entropy method.