Papers by Pavel Chebotarev
30 paper(s) by this author
· All BibTeX
Matrix-Forest Theorems
The Laplacian matrix of a graph $G$ is $L(G)=D(G)-A(G)$, where $A(G)$ is the adjacency matrix and $D(G)$ is the diagonal matrix of vertex degrees. According to the Matrix-Tree Theorem, the number of spanning trees in $G$ is equal to any cofactor of an entry of $L(G)$. A rooted forest is a union of disjoint rooted trees. We consider the matrix $W(G)=I+L(G)$ and prove that the $(i,j)$-cofactor of $W(G)$ is equal to the number of spanning rooted forests of $G$, in which the vertices $i$ and $j$ belong to the same tree rooted at $i$. The determinant of $W(G)$ equals the total number of spanning rooted forests, therefore the $(i,j)$-entry of the matrix $W^{-1}(G)$ can be considered as a measure of relative ''forest-accessibility'' of vertex $i$ from $j$ (or $j$ from $i$). These results follow from somewhat more general theorems we prove, which concern weighted multigraphs. The analogous theorems for (multi)digraphs are also established. These results provide a graph-theoretic interpretation for the adjugate to the Laplacian characteristic matrix.
From Incomplete Preferences to Ranking via Optimization
Published in A version of this paper was published as: P.Yu.Chebotarev, E.V.Shamis. Constructing an objective function for aggregating incomplete preferences, In: A.Tangian and J.Gruber, eds. Econometric Decision Models: Constructing Scalar-Valued Objective Functions. Lecture Notes in Economics and Mathematical Systems, Springer-Verlag, 1997, P.100-124
• Search Publication
We consider methods for aggregating preferences that are based on the resolution of discrete optimization problems. The preferences are represented by arbitrary binary relations (possibly weighted) or incomplete paired comparison matrices. This incomplete case remains practically unexplored so far. We examine the properties of several known methods and propose one new method. In particular, we test whether these methods obey a new axiom referred to as {\it Self-Consistent Monotonicity}. Some results are established that characterize solutions of the related optimization problems.
Preference fusion when the number of alternatives exceeds two: indirect scoring procedures
Published in Journal of the Franklin Institute, 336 (1999), No.2, 205-226. Erratum: 336 (1999) No.4, 747-748 (http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0016-0032(99)00004-6)
• View Publication
• BIB
We consider the problem of aggregation of incomplete preferences represented by arbitrary binary relations or incomplete paired comparison matrices. For a number of indirect scoring procedures we examine whether or not they satisfy the axiom of self-consistent monotonicity. The class of {\em win-loss combining scoring procedures} is introduced which contains a majority of known scoring procedures. Two main results are established. According to the first one, every win-loss combining scoring procedure breaks self-consistent monotonicity. The second result provides a sufficient condition of satisfying self-consistent monotonicity.
On Proximity Measures for Graph Vertices
Published in Automation and Remote Control 59 (1998), No. 10, Part 2 1443-1459. Erratum: 60 (1999), No. 2, Part 2 297
• Search Publication
We study the properties of several proximity measures for the vertices of weighted multigraphs and multidigraphs. Unlike the classical distance for the vertices of connected graphs, these proximity measures are applicable to weighted structures and take into account not only the shortest, but also all other connections, which is desirable in many applications. To apply these proximity measures to unweighted structures, every edge should be assigned the same weight which determines the proportion of taking account of two routes, from which one is one edge longer than the other. Among the proximity measures we consider path accessibility, route accessibility, relative forest accessibility along with its components, accessibility via dense forests, and connection reliability. A number of characteristic conditions is introduced and employed to characterize the proximity measures. A topological interpretation is obtained for the Moore-Penrose generalized inverse of the Laplacian matrix of a weighted multigraph.
The Matrix-Forest Theorem and Measuring Relations in Small Social Groups
Published in Automation and Remote Control 58 (1997) No. 9 1505-1514
• Search Publication
We propose a family of graph structural indices related to the Matrix-forest theorem. The properties of the basic index that expresses the mutual connectivity of two vertices are studied in detail. The derivative indices that measure "dissociation," "solitariness," and "provinciality" of vertices are also considered. A nonstandard metric on the set of vertices is introduced, which is determined by their connectivity. The application of these indices in sociometry is discussed.
The Matrix of Maximum Out Forests of a Digraph and Its Applications
Published in Automation and Remote Control 61 (2000) 1424--1450
• Search Publication
We study the maximum out forests of a (weighted) digraph and the matrix of maximum out forests. A maximum out forest of a digraph G is a spanning subgraph of G that consists of disjoint diverging trees and has the maximum possible number of arcs. If a digraph contains any out arborescences, then maximum out forests coincide with them. We provide a new proof to the Markov chain tree theorem saying that the matrix of Ces`aro limiting probabilities of an arbitrary stationary finite Markov chain coincides with the normalized matrix of maximum out forests of the weighted digraph that corresponds to the Markov chain. We discuss the applications of the matrix of maximum out forests and its transposition, the matrix of limiting accessibilities of a digraph, to the problems of preference aggregation, measuring the vertex proximity, and uncovering the structure of a digraph.
Spanning Forests of a Digraph and Their Applications
Published in Automation and Remote Control 62 (2001) No.3 443-466
• View Publication
• BIB
We study spanning diverging forests of a digraph and related matrices. It is shown that the normalized matrix of out forests of a digraph coincides with the transition matrix in a specific observation model for Markov chains related to the digraph. Expression are given for the Moore-Penrose generalized inverse and the group inverse of the Kirchhoff (Laplacian) matrix. These expressions involve the matrix of maximum out forest of the digraph. Every matrix of out forests with a fixed number of arcs and the normalized matrix of out forests are represented as polynomials in the Kirchhoff matrix; with the help of these identities new proofs are given for the matrix-forest theorem and some other statements. A connection is specified between the forest dimension of a digraph and the degree of an annihilating polynomial for the Kirchhoff (Laplacian) matrix. Some accessibility measures for digraph vertices are considered. These are based on the enumeration of spanning forests.
On the spectra of nonsymmetric Laplacian matrices
Published in Linear Algebra and Its Applications. 2005. V. 399. 157--168
• View Publication
• BIB
A Laplacian matrix is a square real matrix with nonpositive off-diagonal entries and zero row sums. As a matrix associated with a weighted directed graph, it generalizes the Laplacian matrix of an ordinary graph. A standardized Laplacian matrix is a Laplacian matrix with the absolute values of the off-diagonal entries not exceeding 1/n, where n is the order of the matrix. We study the spectra of Laplacian matrices and relations between Laplacian matrices and stochastic matrices. We prove that the standardized Laplacian matrices are semiconvergent. The multiplicities of 0 and 1 as the eigenvalues of a standardized Laplacian matrix are equal to the in-forest dimension of the corresponding digraph and one less than the in-forest dimension of the complementary digraph, respectively. These eigenvalues are semisimple. The spectrum of a standardized Laplacian matrix belongs to the meet of two closed disks, one centered at 1/n, another at 1-1/n, each having radius 1-1/n, and two closed angles, one bounded with two half-lines drawn from 1, another with two half-lines drawn from 0 through certain points. The imaginary parts of the eigenvalues are bounded from above by 1/(2n) cot(pi/2n); this maximum converges to 1/pi as n goes to infinity.
Keywords: Laplacian matrix; Laplacian spectrum of graph; Weighted directed graph; Forest dimension of digraph; Stochastic matrix
Forest matrices around the Laplacian matrix
Published in Linear Algebra and Its Applications. 2002. V. 356. 253--274
• View Publication
• BIB
We study the matrices Q_k of in-forests of a weighted digraph G and their connections with the Laplacian matrix L of G. The (i,j) entry of Q_k is the total weight of spanning converging forests (in-forests) with k arcs such that i belongs to a tree rooted at j. The forest matrices, Q_k, can be calculated recursively and expressed by polynomials in the Laplacian matrix; they provide representations for the generalized inverses, the powers, and some eigenvectors of L. The normalized in-forest matrices are row stochastic; the normalized matrix of maximum in-forests is the eigenprojection of the Laplacian matrix, which provides an immediate proof of the Markov chain tree theorem. A source of these results is the fact that matrices Q_k are the matrix coefficients in the polynomial expansion of adj(a*I+L). Thereby they are precisely Faddeev's matrices for -L.
Keywords: Weighted digraph; Laplacian matrix; Spanning forest; Matrix-forest theorem; Leverrier-Faddeev method; Markov chain tree theorem; Eigenprojection; Generalized inverse; Singular M-matrix
Matrices of Forests and the Analysis of Digraphs
The matrices of spanning rooted forests are studied as a tool for analysing the structure of digraphs and measuring their characteristics. The problems of revealing the basis bicomponents, measuring vertex proximity, and ranking from preference relations / sports competitions are considered. It is shown that the vertex accessibility measure based on spanning forests has a number of desirable properties. An interpretation for the normalized matrix of out-forests in terms of information dissemination is given.
Keywords: Laplacian matrix, spanning forest, matrix-forest theorem, proximity measure, bicomponent, ranking, incomplete tournament, paired comparisons