arXiv++ Combinatorics

In 1965, Wegner conjectured that every finite family \(\mathcal R\) of axis-parallel rectangles in the plane satisfies \(τ(\mathcal R) \le 2ν(\mathcal R)-1\), where \(τ(\mathcal R)\) denotes the minimum number of points needed to pierce all rectangles in \(\mathcal R\), and \(ν(\mathcal R)\) denotes the maximum size of a pairwise disjoint subfamily. Over the last six decades, the conjecture has motivated a long line of work: it has been verified for several special classes of rectangle families, and the best known general upper bounds have been progressively improved, but the conjecture itself had remained open. We give an explicit counterexample. More precisely, we construct a triangle-free rectangle-intersection graph on \(n\) vertices whose independence number is at most \(n/4\). Since the graph is triangle-free, no point of the plane can lie in three rectangles; hence every piercing point hits at most two rectangles. Consequently, \(τ(\mathcal R) \ge n/2 \ge 2ν(\mathcal R)\), contradicting Wegner's conjectured bound. We also give a slightly more general construction for which \(τ(\mathcal R) \ge 2.21ν(\mathcal R)\). This shows that the standard point relaxation, equivalently the clique relaxation, for the Maximum Independent Set of Rectangles problem has integrality gap at least \(2.21\).

We study the existence and construction of sparse supports for hypergraphs derived from subgraphs of a graph $G$. For a hypergraph $(X,\mathcal{H})$, a support $Q$ is a graph on $X$ s.t. $Q[H]$, the graph induced on vertices in $H$ is connected for every $H\in\mathcal{H}$. We consider \emph{primal}, \emph{dual}, and \emph{intersection} hypergraphs defined by subgraphs of a graph $G$ that are \emph{non-piercing}, (i.e., each subgraph is connected, their pairwise differences remain connected). If $G$ is outerplanar, we show that the primal, dual and intersection hypergraphs admit supports that are outerplanar. For a bounded treewidth graph $G$, we show that if the subgraphs are non-piercing, then there exist supports for the primal and dual hypergraphs of treewidth $O(2^{tw(G)})$ and $O(2^{4tw(G)})$ respectively, and a support of treewidth $2^{O(2^{tw(G)})}$ for the intersection hypergraph. We also show that for the primal and dual hypergraphs, the exponential blow-up of treewidth is sometimes essential. All our results are algorithmic and yield polynomial-time algorithms (when the treewidth is bounded). The existence and construction of sparse supports is a crucial step in the design and analysis of PTASs and/or sub-exponential time algorithms for several packing and covering problems.

Let $(X,\mathcal{E})$ be a hypergraph. A support is a graph $Q$ on $X$ such that for each $E\in\mathcal{E}$, the subgraph of $Q$ induced on the elements in $E$ is connected. We consider the problem of constructing a support for hypergraphs defined by connected subgraphs of a host graph. For a graph $G=(V,E)$, let $\mathcal{H}$ be a set of connected subgraphs of $G$. Let the vertices of $G$ be partitioned into two sets the \emph{terminals} $\mathbf{b}(V)$ and the \emph{non-terminals} $\mathbf{r}(V)$. We define a hypergraph on $\mathbf{b}(V)$, where each $H\in\mathcal{H}$ defines a hyperedge consisting of the vertices of $\mathbf{b}(V)$ in $H$. We also consider the problem of constructing a support for the \emph{dual hypergraph} - a hypergraph on $\mathcal{H}$ where each $v\in \mathbf{b}(V)$ defines a hyperedge consisting of the subgraphs in $\mathcal{H}$ containing $v$. In fact, we construct supports for a common generalization of the primal and dual settings called the \emph{intersection hypergraph}. As our main result, we show that if the host graph $G$ has bounded genus and the subgraphs in $\mathcal{H}$ satisfy a condition of being \emph{cross-free}, then there exists a support that also has bounded genus. Our results are a generalization of the results of Raman and Ray (Rajiv Raman, Saurabh Ray: Constructing Planar Support for Non-Piercing Regions. Discret. Comput. Geom. 64(3): 1098-1122 (2020)). Our techniques imply a unified analysis for packing and covering problems for hypergraphs defined on surfaces of bounded genus. We also describe applications of our results for hypergraph colorings.

Let $\mathcal{H}=(X,\mathcal{E})$ be a hypergraph. A support is a graph $Q$ on $X$ such that for each $E\in\mathcal{E}$, the subgraph of $Q$ induced on the elements in $E$ is connected. In this paper, we consider hypergraphs defined on a host graph. Given a graph $G=(V,E)$, with $c:V\to\{\mathbf{r},\mathbf{b}\}$, and a collection of connected subgraphs $\mathcal{H}$ of $G$, a primal support is a graph $Q$ on $\mathbf{b}(V)$ such that for each $H\in \mathcal{H}$, the induced subgraph $Q[\mathbf{b}(H)]$ on vertices $\mathbf{b}(H)=H\cap c^{-1}(\mathbf{b})$ is connected. A \emph{dual support} is a graph $Q^*$ on $\mathcal{H}$ s.t. for each $v\in X$, the induced subgraph $Q^*[\mathcal{H}_v]$ is connected, where $\mathcal{H}_v=\{H\in\mathcal{H}: v\in H\}$. We present sufficient conditions on the host graph and hyperedges so that the resulting support comes from a restricted family. We primarily study two classes of graphs: $(1)$ If the host graph has genus $g$ and the hypergraphs satisfy a topological condition of being \emph{cross-free}, then there is a primal and a dual support of genus at most $g$. $(2)$ If the host graph has treewidth $t$ and the hyperedges satisfy a combinatorial condition of being \emph{non-piercing}, then there exist primal and dual supports of treewidth $O(2^t)$. We show that this exponential blow-up is sometimes necessary. As an intermediate case, we also study the case when the host graph is outerplanar. Finally, we show applications of our results to packing and covering, and coloring problems on geometric hypergraphs.