arXiv++ Combinatorics

In 1965, Wegner conjectured that every finite family \(\mathcal R\) of axis-parallel rectangles in the plane satisfies \(τ(\mathcal R) \le 2ν(\mathcal R)-1\), where \(τ(\mathcal R)\) denotes the minimum number of points needed to pierce all rectangles in \(\mathcal R\), and \(ν(\mathcal R)\) denotes the maximum size of a pairwise disjoint subfamily. Over the last six decades, the conjecture has motivated a long line of work: it has been verified for several special classes of rectangle families, and the best known general upper bounds have been progressively improved, but the conjecture itself had remained open. We give an explicit counterexample. More precisely, we construct a triangle-free rectangle-intersection graph on \(n\) vertices whose independence number is at most \(n/4\). Since the graph is triangle-free, no point of the plane can lie in three rectangles; hence every piercing point hits at most two rectangles. Consequently, \(τ(\mathcal R) \ge n/2 \ge 2ν(\mathcal R)\), contradicting Wegner's conjectured bound. We also give a slightly more general construction for which \(τ(\mathcal R) \ge 2.21ν(\mathcal R)\). This shows that the standard point relaxation, equivalently the clique relaxation, for the Maximum Independent Set of Rectangles problem has integrality gap at least \(2.21\).

We study the class of edge-coloured graphs arising from the graph-theoretic representation of quantum photonic experiments that generate multipartite W-states. Abstracting away physical amplitudes and phases, we introduce W-state graphs: matching-covered graphs equipped with a half-edge 2-colouring such that every perfect matching contains exactly one bichromatic edge and every vertex is incident with a red half-edge. Our main contribution is a complete structural characterization of W-state graphs. We show that a graph is a W-state graph if and only if each of its 3-connected components is a W-cone, a simple and rigid building block defined by a universal vertex and a factor-critical base. This characterization implies that no W-state graph is simple and yields a recognition algorithm running as fast as verifying whether a graph is matching-covered. We also show that the natural generalization to Dicke states encounters a complexity barrier: verifying one of the two Dicke state conditions is itself coNP-complete, resolving an open problem of Vardi and Zhang [IJCAI 2023]. Our results place W-state graphs firmly within classical matching theory and precisely delineate the combinatorial structures capable of realizing idealized W-states in the experiment-graph framework.

Christoph, Draganić, Girão, Hurley, Michel, and Müyesser conjectured that, when $d\mid n$, the expected number of cycles in a uniformly random cycle-factor of a directed $d$-regular graph on $n$ vertices is uniquely maximised by the disjoint union of $n/d$ copies of the complete looped digraph $K_d^\circ$, with value $(n/d)H_d$ [FOCS 2025]. We disprove this conjecture in the strongest possible range. For every $d\ge 3$ and every multiple $n=kd$ with $k\ge 2$, we construct a directed $d$-regular graph on $n$ vertices whose uniformly random cycle-factor has expected cycle count strictly larger than $kH_d$. We also show that the conjectured extremal picture is correct in degree $d=2$, giving a sharp dichotomy between degree two and all higher degrees.

Model counting is a fundamental problem that consists of determining the number of satisfying assignments for a given Boolean formula. The weighted variant, which computes the weighted sum of satisfying assignments, has extensive applications in probabilistic reasoning, network reliability, statistical physics, and formal verification. A common approach for solving weighted model counting is to reduce it to unweighted model counting, which raises an important question: {\em What is the minimum number of terms (or clauses) required to construct a DNF (or CNF) formula with exactly $k$ satisfying assignments?} In this paper, we establish both upper and lower bounds on this question. We prove that for any natural number $k$, one can construct a monotone DNF formula with exactly $k$ satisfying assignments using at most $O(\sqrt{\log k}\log\log k)$ terms. This construction represents the first $o(\log k)$ upper bound for this problem. We complement this result by showing that there exist infinitely many values of $k$ for which any DNF or CNF representation requires at least $Ω(\log\log k)$ terms or clauses. These results have significant implications for the efficiency of model counting algorithms based on formula transformations.

Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) states are quantum states involving at least three entangled particles. They are of fundamental interest in quantum information theory, and the construction of such states of high dimension has various applications in quantum communication and cryptography. They are of fundamental interest in quantum information theory, and the construction of such states of high dimension has various applications in quantum communication and cryptography. Krenn, Gu and Zeilinger discovered a correspondence between a large class of quantum optical experiments which produce GHZ states and edge-weighted edge-coloured multi-graphs with some special properties called the \emph{GHZ graphs}. On such GHZ graphs, a graph parameter called \emph{dimension} can be defined, which is the same as the dimension of the GHZ state produced by the corresponding experiment. Krenn and Gu conjectured that the dimension of any GHZ graph with more than $4$ vertices is at most $2$. An affirmative resolution of the Krenn-Gu conjecture has implications for quantum resource theory. On the other hand, the construction of a GHZ graph on a large number of vertices with a high dimension would lead to breakthrough results. In this paper, we study the existence of GHZ graphs from the perspective of the Krenn-Gu conjecture and show that the conjecture is true for graphs of vertex connectivity at most 2 and for cubic graphs. We also show that the minimal counterexample to the conjecture should be $4$-connected. Such information could be of great help in the search for GHZ graphs using existing tools like PyTheus. While the impact of the work is in quantum physics, the techniques in this paper are purely combinatorial, and no background in quantum physics is required to understand them.

The Heilbronn triangle problem asks for the placement of $n$ points in a unit square that maximizes the smallest area of a triangle formed by any three of those points. In $1972$, Schmidt considered a natural generalization of this problem. He asked for the placement of $n$ points in a unit square that maximizes the smallest area of the convex hull formed by any four of those points. He showed a lower bound of $Ω(n^{-3/2})$, which was improved to $Ω(n^{-3/2}\log{n})$ by Leffman. A trivial upper bound of $3/n$ could be obtained, and Schmidt asked if this could be improved asymptotically. However, despite several efforts, no asymptotic improvement over the trivial upper bound was known for the last $50$ years, and the problem started to get the tag of being notoriously hard. Szemer{é}di posed the question of whether one can, at least, improve the constant in this trivial upper bound. In this work, we answer this question by proving an upper bound of $2/n+o(1/n)$. We also extend our results to any convex hulls formed by $k\geq 4$ points.

Krenn, Gu and Zeilinger initiated the study of PMValid edge-colourings because of its connection to a problem from quantum physics. A graph is defined to have a PMValid $k$-edge-colouring if it admits a $k$-edge-colouring (i.e. an edge colouring with $k$-colours) with the property that all perfect matchings are monochromatic and each of the $k$ colour classes contain at least one perfect matching. The matching index of a graph $G$, $μ(G)$ is defined as the maximum value of $k$ for which $G$ admits a PMValid $k$-edge-colouring. It is easy to see that $μ(G)\geq 1$ if and only if $G$ has a perfect matching (due to the trivial $1$-edge-colouring which is PMValid). Bogdanov observed that for all graphs non-isomorphic to $K_4$, $μ(G)\leq 2$ and $μ(K_4)=3$. However, the characterisation of graphs for which $μ(G)=1$ and $μ(G)=2$ is not known. In this work, we answer this question. Using this characterisation, we also give a fast algorithm to compute $μ(G)$ of a graph $G$. In view of our work, the structure of PMValid $k$-edge-colourable graphs is now fully understood for all $k$. Our characterisation, also has an implication to the aforementioned quantum physics problem. In particular, it settles a conjecture of Krenn and Gu for a sub-class of graphs.