arXiv++ Combinatorics

We introduce the Random Subsequence Model, a spin glass model on pairs of random strings $(X,Y) \in \{0,1\}^N \times \{0,1\}^M$ whose partition function counts subsequence embeddings of $Y$ into $X$. We study two variants: the null model, where $X$ and $Y$ are independent and uniform, and the planted model, where $X$ is uniform and $Y$ is a uniformly-random length-$M$ subsequence of $X$. We connect the Random Subsequence Model to longstanding problems in various fields, including the best rate achievable by uniformly-random codes in the deletion channel, the longest common subsequence problem between two random strings, and models of directed polymers in statistical physics. In the regime where $N,M\to\infty$ at a fixed ratio $α= M/N \in (0,1)$, we exhibit strict asymptotic separations between the null annealed free energy and the quenched free energies of the null and planted models at all values of the density parameter $α$. This suggests that these models are in a spin glass phase at zero temperature throughout the entire dense regime. As a consequence, we show that uniformly-random codes achieve a positive rate in the deletion channel for all deletion probabilities $p\in [0,1),$ settling multiple conjectures of the second author, Isik and Weissman (2024) and proving the first such positive rate result for the regime $p \geq 1/2$. We also give an exact analytic formula for the annealed free energy of the planted model for all values of the density parameter. This implies a corresponding analytic upper bound on the best rate achievable by uniformly-random codes in the deletion channel, complementing the lower bound from our first result. Our upper and lower bounds for the capacity of the deletion channel under uniform codes are far closer to each other than the best known upper and lower bounds for the capacity of the deletion channel.

Given $n$-vertex simple graphs $X$ and $Y$, the friends-and-strangers graph $\mathsf{FS}(X, Y)$ has as its vertices all $n!$ bijections from $V(X)$ to $V(Y)$, where two bijections are adjacent if and only if they differ on two adjacent elements of $V(X)$ whose mappings are adjacent in $Y$. We consider the setting where $X$ and $Y$ are both edge-subgraphs of $K_{r,r}$: due to a parity obstruction, $\mathsf{FS}(X,Y)$ is always disconnected in this setting. Modestly improving a result of Bangachev, we show that if $X$ and $Y$ respectively have minimum degrees $δ(X)$ and $δ(Y)$ and they satisfy $δ(X) + δ(Y) \geq \lfloor 3r/2 \rfloor + 1$, then $\mathsf{FS}(X,Y)$ has exactly two connected components. This proves that the cutoff for $\mathsf{FS}(X,Y)$ to avoid isolated vertices is equal to the cutoff for $\mathsf{FS}(X,Y)$ to have exactly two connected components. We also consider a probabilistic setup in which we fix $Y$ to be $K_{r,r}$, but randomly generate $X$ by including each edge in $K_{r,r}$ independently with probability $p$. Invoking a result of Zhu, we exhibit a phase transition phenomenon with threshold function $(\log r)/r$: below the threshold, $\mathsf{FS}(X,Y)$ has more than two connected components with high probability, while above the threshold, $\mathsf{FS}(X,Y)$ has exactly two connected components with high probability. Altogether, our results settle a conjecture and completely answer two problems of Alon, Defant, and Kravitz.

Let $A \subseteq \{0,1,\dots,N\}$ be a random set in which each element is included independently with probability $p=p(N)$. Fix an integer $h \geq 2$ and a linear form $$L(x_1,\dots,x_h) := u_1x_1 + \cdots + u_hx_h.$$ We study the random image set \begin{align*} L(A) = \left\{ L(a_1,\dots,a_h) : a_i \in A \right\}, \end{align*} inside the feasible interval of values of $L$ on $\{0,1,\dots,N\}^h$, as well as the associated representation counts. Our results exhibit two distinct threshold scales. First, there is a \emph{global} transition at $p(N) \asymp N^{-(h-1)/h}$ governing the size of $L(A)$: below this scale collisions are rare and $L(A)$ is sparse, while above it $L(A)$ contains nearly all feasible values. We give sharp asymptotics for the size of $L(A)$ in all regimes, including inside the critical window. Second, there is a \emph{local} transition at $p(N)\asymp N^{-(h-2)/(h-1)}$ governing multiplicities: for typical values in the bulk, the number of essentially distinct representations is asymptotically Poisson below this scale, and Poisson behavior fails above it. For $h \geq 3$ these scales are separated, yielding a regime in which $L(A)$ is already globally close to full while local multiplicities remain approximately Poisson. Our framework subsumes the classical sumset and difference-set models, as well as generalized sumsets of the form $sA-dA$, as special cases. Notably, after correcting its formulation, our global theorem settles the 2009 threshold conjecture of Hegarty-Miller on the behavior of these random images.

Let $\mathbb{F}_q^d$ be the $d$-dimensional vector space over the finite field with $q$ elements. For a subset $E\subseteq \mathbb{F}_q^d$ and a fixed nonzero $t\in \mathbb{F}_q$, let $\mathcal{H}_t(E)=\{h_y: y\in E\}$, where $h_y$ is the indicator function of the set $\{x\in E: x\cdot y=t\}$. Two of the authors, with Maxwell Sun, showed in the case $d=3$ that if $|E|\geq Cq^{\frac{11}{4}}$ and $q$ is sufficiently large, then the VC-dimension of $\mathcal{H}_t(E)$ is 3. In this paper, we generalize the result to arbitrary dimension and improve the exponent in the case $d=3$.

Zeckendorf proved that any positive integer has a unique decomposition as a sum of non-consecutive Fibonacci numbers, indexed by $F_1 = 1, F_2 = 2, F_{n+1} = F_n + F_{n-1}$. Motivated by this result, Baird, Epstein, Flint, and Miller defined the two-player Zeckendorf game, where two players take turns acting on a multiset of Fibonacci numbers that always sums to $N$. The game terminates when no possible moves remain, and the final player to perform a move wins. Notably, studied the setting of random games: the game proceeds by choosing an available move uniformly at random, and they conjecture that as the input $N \to \infty$, the distribution of random game lengths converges to a Gaussian. We prove that certain sums of move counts is constant, and find a lower bound on the number of shortest games on input $N$ involving the Catalan numbers. The works Baird et al. and Cuzensa et al. determined how to achieve a shortest and longest possible Zeckendorf game on a given input $N$, respectively: we establish that for any input $N$, the range of possible game lengths constitutes an interval of natural numbers: every game length between the shortest and longest game lengths can be achieved. We further the study of probabilistic aspects of random Zeckendorf games. We study two probability measures on the space of all Zeckendorf games on input $N$: the uniform measure, and the measure induced by choosing moves uniformly at random at any given position. Under both measures that in the limit $N \to \infty$, both players win with probability $1/2$. We also find natural partitions of the collection of all Zeckendorf games of a fixed input $N$, on which we observe weak convergence to a Gaussian in the limit $N \to \infty$. We conclude the work with many open problems.

Given a domain $X$ and a collection $\mathcal{H}$ of functions $h:X\to \{0,1\}$, the Vapnik-Chervonenkis (VC) dimension of $\mathcal{H}$ measures its complexity in an appropriate sense. In particular, the fundamental theorem of statistical learning says that a hypothesis class with finite VC-dimension is PAC learnable. Recent work by Fitzpatrick, Wyman, the fourth and seventh named authors studied the VC-dimension of a natural family of functions $\mathcal{H}_t^{'2}(E): \mathbb{F}_q^2\to \{0,1\}$, corresponding to indicator functions of circles centered at points in a subset $E\subseteq \mathbb{F}_q^2$. They showed that when $|E|$ is large enough, the VC-dimension of $\mathcal{H}_t^{'2}(E)$ is the same as in the case that $E = \mathbb F_q^2$. We study a related hypothesis class, $\mathcal{H}_t^d(E)$, corresponding to intersections of spheres in $\mathbb{F}_q^d$, and ask how large $E\subseteq \mathbb{F}_q^d$ needs to be to ensure the maximum possible VC-dimension. We resolve this problem in all dimensions, proving that whenever $|E|\geq C_dq^{d-1/(d-1)}$ for $d\geq 3$, the VC-dimension of $\mathcal{H}_t^d(E)$ is as large as possible. We get a slightly stronger result if $d=3$: this result holds as long as $|E|\geq C_3 q^{7/3}$. Furthermore, when $d=2$ the result holds when $|E|\geq C_2 q^{7/4}$.

Given a group $G$, we say that a set $A \subseteq G$ has more sums than differences (MSTD) if $|A+A| > |A-A|$, has more differences than sums (MDTS) if $|A+A| < |A-A|$, or is sum-difference balanced if $|A+A| = |A-A|$. A problem of recent interest has been to understand the frequencies of these type of subsets. The seventh author and Vissuet studied the problem for arbitrary finite groups $G$ and proved that almost all subsets $A\subseteq G$ are sum-difference balanced as $|G|\to\infty$. For the dihedral group $D_{2n}$, they conjectured that of the remaining sets, most are MSTD, i.e., there are more MSTD sets than MDTS sets. Some progress on this conjecture was made by Haviland et al. in 2020, when they introduced the idea of partitioning the subsets by size: if, for each $m$, there are more MSTD subsets of $D_{2n}$ of size $m$ than MDTS subsets of size $m$, then the conjecture follows. We extend the conjecture to generalized dihedral groups $D=\mathbb{Z}_2\ltimes G$, where $G$ is an abelian group of size $n$ and the nonidentity element of $\mathbb{Z}_2$ acts by inversion. We make further progress on the conjecture by considering subsets with a fixed number of rotations and reflections. By bounding the expected number of overlapping sums, we show that the collection $\mathcal S_{D,m}$ of subsets of the generalized dihedral group $D$ of size $m$ has more MSTD sets than MDTS sets when $6\le m\le c_j\sqrt{n}$ for $c_j=1.3229/\sqrt{111+5j}$, where $j$ is the number of elements in $G$ with order at most $2$. We also analyze the expectation for $|A+A|$ and $|A-A|$ for $A\subseteq D_{2n}$, proving an explicit formula for $|A-A|$ when $n$ is prime.

Given two graphs $X$ and $Y$ with the same number of vertices, the friends-and-strangers graph $\mathsf{FS}(X, Y)$ has as its vertices all $n!$ bijections from $V(X)$ to $V(Y)$, with bijections $σ, τ$ adjacent if and only if they differ on two elements of $V(X)$, whose mappings are adjacent in $Y$. In this article, we study necessary and sufficient conditions for $\mathsf{FS}(X, Y)$ to be connected for all graphs $X$ from some set. In the setting that we take $X$ to be drawn from the set of all biconnected graphs, we prove that $\mathsf{FS}(X, Y)$ is connected for all biconnected $X$ if and only if $\overline{Y}$ is a forest with trees of jointly coprime size; this resolves a conjecture of Defant and Kravitz. We also initiate and make significant progress toward determining the girth of $\mathsf{FS}(X, \text{Star}_n)$ for connected graphs $X$, and in particular focus on the necessary trajectories that the central vertex of $\text{Star}_n$ takes around all such graphs $X$ to achieve the girth.

Given simple graphs $X$ and $Y$ on the same number of vertices, the friends-and-strangers graph $\mathsf{FS}(X, Y)$ has as its vertices all bijections from $V(X)$ to $V(Y)$, where two bijections are adjacent if and only if they differ on two adjacent elements of $V(X)$ with images adjacent in $Y$. We study the diameters of connected components of friends-and-strangers graphs: the diameter of a component of $\mathsf{FS}(X,Y)$ corresponds to the largest number of swaps necessary to go from one configuration in the component to another. We show that any component of $\mathsf{FS}(\mathsf{Path}_n, Y)$ has $O(n^2)$ diameter and that any component of $\mathsf{FS}(\mathsf{Cycle}_n, Y)$ has $O(n^4)$ diameter, improvable to $O(n^3)$ whenever $\mathsf{FS}(\mathsf{Cycle}_n, Y)$ is connected. These results address an open problem posed by Defant and Kravitz. Using an explicit construction, we show that there exist $n$-vertex graphs $X$ and $Y$ such that $\mathsf{FS}(X,Y)$ has a component with $e^{Ω(n)}$ diameter. This answers a question raised by Alon, Defant, and Kravitz in the negative. As a corollary, we observe that for such $X$ and $Y$, the lazy random walk on this component of $\mathsf{FS}(X,Y)$ has $e^{Ω(n)}$ mixing time. This result deviates from related classical theorems regarding rapidly mixing Markov chains and makes progress on another open problem of Alon, Defant, and Kravitz. We conclude with several suggestions for future research.