arXiv++ Combinatorics

We discuss two approaches to a recent question of Loh: must a 3-colored transitive tournament on $N$ vertices have a 1-color-\emph{avoiding} path of vertex-length at least $N^{2/3}$? This question generalizes the Erdős--Szekeres theorem on monotone subsequences. First, we define three canonical transformations on these tournaments called Color, Record, and Dual. We use these to establish a reduction to special tournaments with natural geometric and combinatorial properties. In many cases (including all known tight examples), these tournaments have recursive Gallai decompositions. Not all relevant tournaments have Gallai decompositions, but those that do satisfy the desired $N^{2/3}$ bound by recent work of Wagner, roughly analogous to earlier work of Fox, Grinshpun, and Pach on a similar \emph{undirected} problem. Second, we consider the related geometric problem of bounding \emph{slice-increasing} sets $S\subseteq [n]^3$, which---under an additional ordering hypothesis on $S$---was shown by Loh to be equivalent to the original question. In particular, we establish a rigorous connection from a problem of Szabó and Tardos, raise a stronger $L^2$-question on slice-counts, and mention a surprising overlap with the joints problem.

Fix coprime $s,t\ge1$. We re-prove, without Ehrhart reciprocity, a conjecture of Armstrong (recently verified by Johnson) that the finitely many simultaneous $(s,t)$-cores have average size $\frac{1}{24}(s-1)(t-1)(s+t+1)$, and that the subset of self-conjugate cores has the same average (first shown by Chen--Huang--Wang). We similarly prove a recent conjecture of Fayers that the average weighted by an inverse stabilizer---giving the "expected size of the $t$-core of a random $s$-core"---is $\frac{1}{24}(s-1)(t^2-1)$. We also prove Fayers' conjecture that the analogous self-conjugate average is the same if $t$ is odd, but instead $\frac{1}{24}(s-1)(t^2+2)$ if $t$ is even. In principle, our explicit methods---or implicit variants thereof---extend to averages of arbitrary powers. The main new observation is that the stabilizers appearing in Fayers' conjectures have simple formulas in Johnson's $z$-coordinates parameterization of $(s,t)$-cores. We also observe that the $z$-coordinates extend to parameterize general $t$-cores. As an example application with $t := s+d$, we count the number of $(s,s+d,s+2d)$-cores for coprime $s,d\ge1$, verifying a recent conjecture of Amdeberhan and Leven.