arXiv++ Combinatorics

We present an average case model of classical problems in combinatorial optimization where there are color constraints. In all cases we seek some (spanning) sub-structure of a complete graph of minimum cost. The edges are randomly colored either red or blue. We bias against the red edges by placing a bound on the number of them that are allowed in our structure. This bound will be lower w.h.p. than what would occur without discrimination. We examine the effect of this bias on the minimum cost of a desired structure. We consider minimum cost spanning trees, shortest paths, minimum cost perfect matchings and the asymmetric traveling salesperson problem.

We present Trellis: an autoformalization system that leverages LLM agents in a deterministically constrained workflow to enforce incremental progress in Lean autoformalization tasks through iterative refinement of natural language proofs. Our approach is motivated by the common mathematician's notion of what it means to have a rigorous proof in the first place: namely, that it would be routine to elaborate any part of the proof in further detail. The result is a system which aims to achieve reliable autoformalization on a modest budget and with generalist agents, with specialization to autoformalization coming not from any task-specific agent training but instead from a meaning-of-rigor inspired workflow enforced by process semantics. We link to an end-to-end Lean formalization of a recent Ramsey theory breakthrough produced by the process.

We discuss the expected minimum cost of rainbow spanning trees and Hamilton cycles in randomly edge colored random graphs.

We introduce and study two Maker-Breaker-like games for constructing planar graphs: the edge drawing game, where two players take turns drawing non-intersecting edges between points in the plane, and the circle packing game, where the players take turns placing disjoint circles in the plane. Both games produce planar graphs: the edge drawing game results in a plane graph drawing, and the circle packing game yields a planar graph via the contact graph of the packing. For both games, we give necessary conditions under which a given planar graph can be constructed. We also show that the two games are indeed different by giving a class of graphs which can be constructed in one but not the other.

We consider some biased Maker-Breaker games. Starting with the complete $k$-uniform hypergraph on $n$ vertices, at each turn Maker claims one edge, and then Breaker claims $b$ edges. Maker's goal is to obtain a set of edges having some increasing property. We consider the case where Maker's desired property is minimum degree $m$, or having a full-rank incidence matrix, or having a Berge Hamilton cycle or having a perfect matching or a Hamilton $\ell$-cycle.

This paper gives a new algorithm for sampling tree-weighted partitions of a large class of planar graphs. Formally, the tree-weighted distribution on $k$-partitions of a graph weights $k$-partitions proportional to the product of the number of spanning trees of each partition class. Recent work on problems in computational redistricting analysis has driven special interest in the conditional distribution where all partition classes have the same size (balanced partitions). One class of Markov chains in wide use aims to sample from balanced tree-weighted $k$-partitions using a sampler for balanced tree-weighted 2-partitions. Previous implementations of this 2-partition sampler would draw a random spanning tree and check whether it contains an edge whose removal produces a balanced 2-component forest; if it does, this 2-partition is accepted, otherwise the algorithm rejects and repeats. In practice, this is a significant computational bottleneck. We show that in fact it is possible to sample from the balanced tree-weighted 2-partition distribution directly, without first sampling a spanning tree; the acceptance and rejection rates are the same as in previous samplers. We prove that on a wide class of planar graphs encompassing network structures typically arising from the geographic data used in computational redistricting, our algorithm takes expected linear time $O(n)$. Notably, this is asymptotically faster than the best known method to generate random trees, which is $O(n \log^2 n)$ for approximate sampling and $O(n^{1 + \log \log \log n / \log \log n})$ for exact sampling. Additionally, we show that a variant of our algorithm also gives a speedup to $O(n \log n)$ for exact sampling of uniformly random trees on these families of graphs, improving the bounds for both exact and approximate sampling.

$Q_{n,p}$, the random subgraph of the $n$-vertex hypercube $Q_n$, is obtained by independently retaining each edge of $Q_n$ with probability $p$. We give precise values for the cover time of $Q_{n,p}$ above the connectivity threshold.

In classical Maker-Breaker games on graphs, Maker and Breaker take turns claiming edges; Maker's goal is to claim all of some structure (e.g., a spanning tree, Hamilton cycle, etc.), while Breaker aims to stop her. The standard question considered is how powerful a Breaker Maker can defeat; i.e., for the $(1:b)$-biased game where Breaker takes $b$ edges per turn, how large can $b$ be for Maker to still have a winning strategy, for various possible goal sets? We introduce a variant of this question in which Breaker is required to choose their multiple edges as the edges of (a subgraph of) a given structure (e.g., a matching, clique, etc.) on each turn. We establish the order of magnitude of the threshold biases for triangle games, connectivity games, and Hamiltonicity games under clique, matching, and star biases respectively. We conclude that in many cases structure imposes major obstruction to Breaker, opening up a set of games whose strategies deviate from the classical biased Maker-Breaker game strategies, and shedding light on the types of Breaker strategies that may or may not work to prove tighter bounds in the classical setting.

We consider the length of {\em ordered loose paths} in the random $r$-uniform hypergraph $H=H^{(r)}(n, p)$. A ordered loose path is a sequence of edges $E_1,E_2,\ldots,E_\ell$ where $\max\{j\in E_i\}=\min\{j\in E_{i+1}\}$ for $1\leq i<\ell$. We establish fairly tight bounds on the length of the longest ordered loose path in $H$ that hold with high probability.

We study the intersection of a random geometric graph with an Erdős-Rényi graph. Specifically, we generate the random geometric graph $G(n, r)$ by choosing $n$ points uniformly at random from $D=[0, 1]^2$ and joining any two points whose Euclidean distance is at most $r$. We let $G(n, p)$ be the classical Erdős-Rényi graph, i.e. it has $n$ vertices and every pair of vertices is adjacent with probability $p$ independently. In this note we study $G(n, r, p):=G(n, r) \cap G(n, p)$. One way to think of this graph is that we take $G(n, r)$ and then randomly delete edges with probability $1-p$ independently. We consider the clique number, independence number, connectivity, Hamiltonicity, chromatic number, and diameter of this graph where both $p(n)\to 0$ and $r(n)\to 0$; the same model was studied by Kahle, Tian and Wang (2023) for $r(n)\to 0$ but $p$ fixed.

We study the fixation probability for two versions of the Moran process on the random graph $G_{n,p}$ at the threshold for connectivity. The Moran process models the spread of a mutant population in a network. Throughtout the process there are vertices of two types, mutants and non-mutants. Mutants have fitness $s$ and non-mutants have fitness 1. The process starts with a unique individual mutant located at the vertex $v_0$. In the Birth-Death version of the process a random vertex is chosen proportional to its fitness and then changes the type of a random neighbor to its own. The process continues until the set of mutants $X$ is empty or $[n]$. In the Death-Birth version a uniform random vertex is chosen and then takes the type of a random neighbor, chosen according to fitness. The process again continues until the set of mutants $X$ is empty or $[n]$. The {\em fixation probability} is the probability that the process ends with $X=\emptyset$. We give asymptotically correct estimates of the fixation probability that depend on degree of $v_0$ and its neighbors.,

We prove that a polynomial fraction of the set of $k$-component forests in the $m \times n$ grid graph have equal numbers of vertices in each component, for any constant $k$. This resolves a conjecture of Charikar, Liu, Liu, and Vuong, and establishes the first provably polynomial-time algorithm for (exactly or approximately) sampling balanced grid graph partitions according to the spanning tree distribution, which weights each $k$-partition according to the product, across its $k$ pieces, of the number of spanning trees of each piece. Our result follows from a careful analysis of the probability a uniformly random spanning tree of the grid can be cut into balanced pieces. Beyond grids, we show that for a broad family of lattice-like graphs, we achieve balance up to any multiplicative $(1 \pm \varepsilon)$ constant with constant probability, and up to an additive constant with polynomial probability. More generally, we show that, with constant probability, components derived from uniform spanning trees can approximate any given partition of a planar region specified by Jordan curves. These results imply polynomial time algorithms for sampling approximately balanced tree-weighted partitions for lattice-like graphs. Our results have applications to understanding political districtings, where there is an underlying graph of indivisible geographic units that must be partitioned into $k$ population-balanced connected subgraphs. In this setting, tree-weighted partitions have interesting geometric properties, and this has stimulated significant effort to develop methods to sample them.

The greedy and nearest-neighbor TSP heuristics can both have $\log n$ approximation factors from optimal in worst case, even just for $n$ points in Euclidean space. In this note, we show that this approximation factor is only realized when the optimal tour is unusually short. In particular, for points from any fixed $d$-Ahlfor's regular metric space (which includes any $d$-manifold like the $d$-cube $[0,1]^d$ in the case $d$ is an integer but also fractals of dimension $d$ when $d$ is real-valued), our results imply that the greedy and nearest-neighbor heuristics have \emph{additive} errors from optimal on the order of the \emph{optimal} tour length through \emph{random} points in the same space, for $d>1$.

In this paper, we provide a family of dynamic programming based algorithms to sample nearly-shortest self avoiding walks between two points of the integer lattice $\mathbb{Z}^2$. We show that if the shortest path of between two points has length $n$, then we can sample paths (self-avoiding-walks) of length $n+O(n^{1-δ})$ in polynomial time. As an example of an application, we will show that the Glauber dynamics Markov chain for partitions of the Aztec Diamonds in $\mathbb{Z}^2$ into two contiguous regions with nearly tight perimeter constraints has exponential mixing time, while the algorithm provided in this paper can be used be used to uniformly (and exactly) sample such partitions efficiently.

We discuss the existence of Hamilton cycles in the random graph $G_{n,p}$ where there are restrictions caused by (i) coloring sequences, (ii) a subset of vertices must occur in a specific order and (iii) there is a bound on the number of inversions in the associated permutation.

We study the intersecting family process initially studied in \cite{BCFMR}. Here $k=k(n)$ and $E_1,E_2,\ldots,E_m$ is a random sequence of $k$-sets from $\binom{[n]}{k}$ where $E_{r+1}$ is uniformly chosen from those $k$-sets that are not already chosen and that meet $E_i,i=1,2,\ldots,r$. We prove some new results for the case where $k=cn^{1/3}$ and for the case where $k\gg n^{1/2}$.

We consider the problem of generating uniformly random partitions of the vertex set of a graph such that every piece induces a connected subgraph. For the case where we want to have partitions with linearly many pieces of bounded size, we obtain approximate sampling algorithms based on Glauber dynamics which are fixed-parameter tractable with respect to the bandwidth of $G$, with simple-exponential dependence on the bandwidth. For example, for rectangles of constant or logarithmic width this gives polynomial-time sampling algorithms. More generally, this gives sub-exponential algorithms for bounded-degree graphs without large expander subgraphs (for example, we obtain $O(2^{\sqrt n})$ time algorithms for square grids). In the case where we instead want partitions with a small number of pieces of linear size, we show that Glauber dynamics can have exponential mixing time, even just for the case of 2 pieces, and even for 2-connected subgraphs of the grid with bounded bandwidth.

Given a connected graph $G=(V,E)$ and a length function $\ell:E\to {\mathbb R}$ we let $d_{v,w}$ denote the shortest distance between vertex $v$ and vertex $w$. A $t$-spanner is a subset $E'\subseteq E$ such that if $d'_{v,w}$ denotes shortest distances in the subgraph $G'=(V,E')$ then $d'_{v,w}\leq t d_{v,w}$ for all $v,w\in V$. We study the size of spanners in the following scenario: we consider a random embedding of $G_{n,p}$ into the unit square with Euclidean edge lengths. For $ε>0$ constant, we prove the existence w.h.p. of $(1+ε)$-spanners for ${\mathcal X}_p$ that have $O_ε(n)$ edges. These spanners can be constructed in $O_ε(n^2\log n)$ time. (We will use $O_ε$ to indicate that the hidden constant depends on $ε$.) There are constraints on $p$ preventing it going to zero too quickly.

Let $N=\binom{n}{2}$ and $s\geq 2$. Let $e_{i,j},\,i=1,2,\ldots,N,\,j=1,2,\ldots,s$ be $s$ independent permutations of the edges $E(K_n)$ of the complete graph $K_n$. A {\em MultiTree} is a set $I\subseteq [N]$ such that the edge sets $E_{I,j}$ induce spanning trees for $j=1,2,\ldots,s$. In this paper we study the following question: what is the smallest $m=m(n)$ such that w.h.p. $[m]$ contains a MultiTree. We prove a hitting time result for $s=2$ and an $O(n\log n)$ bound for $s\geq 3$.

Given a connected graph $G=(V,E)$ and a length function $\ell:E\to {\mathbb R}$ we let $d_{v,w}$ denote the shortest distance between vertex $v$ and vertex $w$. A $t$-spanner is a subset $E'\subseteq E$ such that if $d'_{v,w}$ denotes shortest distances in the subgraph $G'=(V,E')$ then $d'_{v,w}\leq t d_{v,w}$ for all $v,w\in V$. We show that for a large class of graphs with suitable degree and expansion properties with independent exponential mean one edge lengths, there is w.h.p.~a 1-spanner that uses $\approx \frac12n\log n$ edges and that this is best possible. In particular, our result applies to the random graphs $G_{n,p}$ for $np\gg \log n$.