arXiv++ Combinatorics

Let $s(n)$ be the side length of the smallest square into which $n$ non-overlapping unit squares can be packed. In 2010, the author showed that $s(13)=4$ and $s(46)=7$. Together with the result $s(6)=3$ by Keaney and Shiu, these results strongly suggest that $s(m^2-3)=m$ for $m\ge 3$, in particular for the values $m=5,6$, which correspond to cases that lie in between the previous results. In this article we show that indeed $s(m^2-3)=m$ for $m=5,6$, implying that the most efficient packings of 22 and 33 squares are the trivial ones. To achieve our results, we modify the well-known method of sets of unavoidable points by replacing them with continuously varying families of such sets.

The commuting graph of a finite non-commutative semigroup $S$, denoted $\cg(S)$, is a simple graph whose vertices are the non-central elements of $S$ and two distinct vertices $x,y$ are adjacent if $xy=yx$. Let $\mi(X)$ be the symmetric inverse semigroup of partial injective transformations on a finite set $X$. The semigroup $\mi(X)$ has the symmetric group $\sym(X)$ of permutations on $X$ as its group of units. In 1989, Burns and Goldsmith determined the clique number of the commuting graph of $\sym(X)$. In 2008, Iranmanesh and Jafarzadeh found an upper bound of the diameter of $\cg(\sym(X))$, and in 2011, Doluzan and Oblak claimed (but their proof has a GAP) that this upper bound is in fact the exact value. The goal of this paper is to begin the study of the commuting graph of the symmetric inverse semigroup $\mi(X)$. We calculate the clique number of $\cg(\mi(X))$, the diameters of the commuting graphs of the proper ideals of $\mi(X)$, and the diameter of $\cg(\mi(X))$ when $|X|$ is even or a power of an odd prime. We show that when $|X|$ is odd and divisible by at least two primes, then the diameter of $\cg(\mi(X))$ is either 4 or 5. In the process, we obtain several results about semigroups, such as a description of all commutative subsemigroups of $\mi(X)$ of maximum order, and analogous results for commutative inverse and commutative nilpotent subsemigroups of $\mi(X)$. The paper closes with a number of problems for experts in combinatorics and in group or semigroup theory.