arXiv++ Combinatorics

Given events $A$ and $B$ on a product space $S=\prod_{i=1}^n S_i$, the set $A \Box B$ consists of all vectors ${\bf x}=(x_1,\ldots,x_n) \in S$ for which there exist disjoint coordinate subsets $K$ and $L$ of $\{1,\ldots,n\}$ such that given the coordinates $x_i, i \in K$ one has that ${\bf x} \in A$ regardless of the values of ${\bf x}$ on the remaining coordinates, and likewise that ${\bf x} \in B$ given the coordinates {$x_j, j \in L$}. For a finite product of discrete spaces endowed with a product measure, the BKR inequality $$ P(A \Box B) \le P(A)P(B) \quad (1) $$ was conjectured by van den Berg and Kesten [3] and proved by Reimer [13]. In [7] inequality (1) was extended to general product probability spaces, replacing $A \Box B$ by the set $A \Box_{11} B$ consisting of those outcomes ${\bf x}$ which only assure with probability one that ${\bf x} \in A$ and ${\bf x} \in B$ based only on the revealed coordinates in $K$ and $L$ as above. A strengthening of the original BKR inequality (1) results, due to the fact that $A \Box B \subseteq A \Box_{11} B$. In particular, it may be the case that $A \Box B$ is empty, while $A \Box_{11} B$ is not. We propose the further extension $A \Box_{st} B$ depending on probability thresholds $s$ and $t$, where $A \Box_{11} B$ is the special case where both $s$ and $t$ take the value one. The outcomes ${\bf x}$ in $A \Box_{st} B$ are those for which disjoint sets of coordinates $K$ and $L$ exist such that given the values of $\bf x$ on the revealed set of coordinates $K$, the probability that $A$ occurs is at least $s$, and given the coordinates of $\bf x$ in $L$, the probability of $B$ is at least $t$. We provide simple examples that illustrate the utility of these extensions.

The BKR inequality conjectured by van den Berg and Kesten in [11], and proved by Reimer in [8], states that for $A$ and $B$ events on $S$, a finite product of finite sets $S_i,i=1,\ldots,n$, and $P$ any product measure on $S$, $$ P(A \Box B) \le P(A)P(B),$$ where the set $A \Box B$ consists of the elementary events which lie in both $A$ and $B$ for `disjoint reasons.' Precisely, with ${\bf n}:=\{1,\ldots,n\}$ and $K \subset {\bf n}$, for ${\bf x} \in S$ letting $[{\bf x}]_K=\{{\bf y} \in S: y_i = x_i, i \in K\}$, the set $A \Box B$ consists of all ${\bf x} \in S$ for which there exist disjoint subsets $K$ and $L$ of ${\bf n}$ for which $[{\bf x}]_K \subset A$ and $[{\bf x}]_L \subset B$. The BKR inequality is extended to the following functional version on a general finite product measure space $(S,\mathbb{S})$ with product probability measure $P$, $$E\left\{ \max_{\stackrel{K \cap L = \emptyset}{K \subset {\bf n}, L \subset {\bf n}}} \underline{f}_K({\bf X})\underline{g}_L({\bf X})\right\} \leq E\left\{f({\bf X})\right\}\,E\left\{g({\bf X})\right\},$$ where $f$ and $g$ are non-negative measurable functions, $\underline{f}_K({\bf x}) = {\rm ess} \inf_{{\bf y} \in [{\bf x}]_K}f({\bf y})$ and $\underline{g}_L({\bf x}) = {\rm ess} \inf_{{\bf y} \in [{\bf x}]_L}g({\bf y}).$ The original BKR inequality is recovered by taking $f({\bf x})={\bf 1}_A({\bf x})$ and $g({\bf x})={\bf 1}_B({\bf x})$, and applying the fact that in general ${\bf 1}_{A \Box B} \le \max_{K \cap L = \emptyset} \underline{f}_K({\bf x}) \underline{g}_L({\bf x})$. Related formulations, and functional versions of the dual inequality on events by Kahn, Saks, and Smyth [6], are also considered. Applications include order statistics, assignment problems, and paths in random graphs.