arXiv++ Combinatorics

The Game of Poker Chips, Dominoes and Survival fosters team building and high level cooperation in large groups, and is a tool applied in management training exercises. Each player, initially given two colored poker chips, is allowed to make exchanges with the game coordinator according to two rules, and must secure a domino before time is called in order to `survive'. Though the rules are simple, it is not evident by their form that the survival of the entire group requires that they cooperate at a high level. From the point of view of the game coordinator, the difficulty of the game for the group can be controlled not only by the time limit, but also by the initial distribution of chips, in a way we make precise by a time complexity type argument. That analysis also provides insight into good strategies for group survival, those taking the least amount of time. In addition, coordinators may also want to be aware of when the game is `solvable', that is, when their initial distribution of chips permits the survival of all group members if given sufficient time to make exchanges. It turns out that the game is solvable if and only if the initial distribution contains seven chips that have one of two particular color distributions. In addition to being a lively game to play in management training or classroom settings, the analysis of the game after play can make for an engaging exercise in any basic discrete mathematics course to give a basic introduction to elements of game theory, logical reasoning, number theory and the computation of algorithmic complexities.

Applying an inductive technique for Stein and zero bias couplings yields Berry-Esseen theorems for normal approximation for two new examples. The conditions of the main results do not require that the couplings be bounded. Our two applications, one to the Erdős-Rényi, random graph with a fixed number of edges, and one to Jack measure on tableaux, demonstrate that the method can handle non-bounded variables with non-trivial global dependence, and can produce bounds in the Kolmogorov metric with the optimal rate.

Given events $A$ and $B$ on a product space $S=\prod_{i=1}^n S_i$, the set $A \Box B$ consists of all vectors ${\bf x}=(x_1,\ldots,x_n) \in S$ for which there exist disjoint coordinate subsets $K$ and $L$ of $\{1,\ldots,n\}$ such that given the coordinates $x_i, i \in K$ one has that ${\bf x} \in A$ regardless of the values of ${\bf x}$ on the remaining coordinates, and likewise that ${\bf x} \in B$ given the coordinates {$x_j, j \in L$}. For a finite product of discrete spaces endowed with a product measure, the BKR inequality $$ P(A \Box B) \le P(A)P(B) \quad (1) $$ was conjectured by van den Berg and Kesten [3] and proved by Reimer [13]. In [7] inequality (1) was extended to general product probability spaces, replacing $A \Box B$ by the set $A \Box_{11} B$ consisting of those outcomes ${\bf x}$ which only assure with probability one that ${\bf x} \in A$ and ${\bf x} \in B$ based only on the revealed coordinates in $K$ and $L$ as above. A strengthening of the original BKR inequality (1) results, due to the fact that $A \Box B \subseteq A \Box_{11} B$. In particular, it may be the case that $A \Box B$ is empty, while $A \Box_{11} B$ is not. We propose the further extension $A \Box_{st} B$ depending on probability thresholds $s$ and $t$, where $A \Box_{11} B$ is the special case where both $s$ and $t$ take the value one. The outcomes ${\bf x}$ in $A \Box_{st} B$ are those for which disjoint sets of coordinates $K$ and $L$ exist such that given the values of $\bf x$ on the revealed set of coordinates $K$, the probability that $A$ occurs is at least $s$, and given the coordinates of $\bf x$ in $L$, the probability of $B$ is at least $t$. We provide simple examples that illustrate the utility of these extensions.

Let $λ$ be the second largest eigenvalue in absolute value of a uniform random $d$-regular graph on $n$ vertices. It was famously conjectured by Alon and proved by Friedman that if $d$ is fixed independent of $n$, then $λ=2\sqrt{d-1} +o(1)$ with high probability. In the present work we show that $λ=O(\sqrt{d})$ continues to hold with high probability as long as $d=O(n^{2/3})$, making progress towards a conjecture of Vu that the bound holds for all $1\le d\le n/2$. Prior to this work the best result was obtained by Broder, Frieze, Suen and Upfal (1999) using the configuration model, which hits a barrier at $d=o(n^{1/2})$. We are able to go beyond this barrier by proving concentration of measure results directly for the uniform distribution on $d$-regular graphs. These come as consequences of advances we make in the theory of concentration by size biased couplings. Specifically, we obtain Bennett-type tail estimates for random variables admitting certain unbounded size biased couplings.

The BKR inequality conjectured by van den Berg and Kesten in [11], and proved by Reimer in [8], states that for $A$ and $B$ events on $S$, a finite product of finite sets $S_i,i=1,\ldots,n$, and $P$ any product measure on $S$, $$ P(A \Box B) \le P(A)P(B),$$ where the set $A \Box B$ consists of the elementary events which lie in both $A$ and $B$ for `disjoint reasons.' Precisely, with ${\bf n}:=\{1,\ldots,n\}$ and $K \subset {\bf n}$, for ${\bf x} \in S$ letting $[{\bf x}]_K=\{{\bf y} \in S: y_i = x_i, i \in K\}$, the set $A \Box B$ consists of all ${\bf x} \in S$ for which there exist disjoint subsets $K$ and $L$ of ${\bf n}$ for which $[{\bf x}]_K \subset A$ and $[{\bf x}]_L \subset B$. The BKR inequality is extended to the following functional version on a general finite product measure space $(S,\mathbb{S})$ with product probability measure $P$, $$E\left\{ \max_{\stackrel{K \cap L = \emptyset}{K \subset {\bf n}, L \subset {\bf n}}} \underline{f}_K({\bf X})\underline{g}_L({\bf X})\right\} \leq E\left\{f({\bf X})\right\}\,E\left\{g({\bf X})\right\},$$ where $f$ and $g$ are non-negative measurable functions, $\underline{f}_K({\bf x}) = {\rm ess} \inf_{{\bf y} \in [{\bf x}]_K}f({\bf y})$ and $\underline{g}_L({\bf x}) = {\rm ess} \inf_{{\bf y} \in [{\bf x}]_L}g({\bf y}).$ The original BKR inequality is recovered by taking $f({\bf x})={\bf 1}_A({\bf x})$ and $g({\bf x})={\bf 1}_B({\bf x})$, and applying the fact that in general ${\bf 1}_{A \Box B} \le \max_{K \cap L = \emptyset} \underline{f}_K({\bf x}) \underline{g}_L({\bf x})$. Related formulations, and functional versions of the dual inequality on events by Kahn, Saks, and Smyth [6], are also considered. Applications include order statistics, assignment problems, and paths in random graphs.

Consider a uniformly chosen random reduced decomposition of the longest element in the symmetric group. It is known that the location of the first transposition in this decomposition converges to the semicircle distribution. In this note we provide a sharp error term for this result, using the "comparison of generators" approach to Stein's method.

With ${\mathcal{Q}}_{q,n}$ the distribution of $n$ minus the rank of a matrix chosen uniformly from the collection of all $n\times(n+m)$ matrices over the finite field $\mathbb{F}_q$ of size $q\ge2$, and ${\mathcal{Q}}_q$ the distributional limit of ${\mathcal{Q}}_{q,n}$ as $n\rightarrow\infty$, we apply Stein's method to prove the total variation bound $\frac{1}{8q^{n+m+1}}\leq\|{\mathcal{Q}}_{q,n}-{\mathcal{Q}}_q\|_{\mathrm{TV}}\leq\frac{3}{q^{n+m+1}}$. In addition, we obtain similar sharp results for the rank distributions of symmetric, symmetric with zero diagonal, skew symmetric, skew centrosymmetric and Hermitian matrices.

The tools of zero biasing are adapted to yield a general result suitable for analyzing the behavior of certain growth processes. The main theorem is applied to prove central limit theorems, with explicit error terms in the L^1 metric, for certain statistics of the Jack measure on partitions and for the number of balls drawn in a Polya-Eggenberger urn process.