arXiv++ Combinatorics

Understanding the structure of the Internet graph is a crucial step for building accurate network models and designing efficient algorithms for Internet applications. Yet, obtaining its graph structure is a surprisingly difficult task, as edges cannot be explicitly queried. Instead, empirical studies rely on traceroutes to build what are essentially single-source, all-destinations, shortest-path trees. These trees only sample a fraction of the network's edges, and a recent paper by Lakhina et al. found empirically that the resuting sample is intrinsically biased. For instance, the observed degree distribution under traceroute sampling exhibits a power law even when the underlying degree distribution is Poisson. In this paper, we study the bias of traceroute sampling systematically, and, for a very general class of underlying degree distributions, calculate the likely observed distributions explicitly. To do this, we use a continuous-time realization of the process of exposing the BFS tree of a random graph with a given degree distribution, calculate the expected degree distribution of the tree, and show that it is sharply concentrated. As example applications of our machinery, we show how traceroute sampling finds power-law degree distributions in both delta-regular and Poisson-distributed random graphs. Thus, our work puts the observations of Lakhina et al. on a rigorous footing, and extends them to nearly arbitrary degree distributions.

We find the asymptotic number of connected graphs with $k$ vertices and $k-1+l$ edges when $k,l$ approach infinity, reproving a result of Bender, Canfield and McKay. We use the {\em probabilistic method}, analyzing breadth-first search on the random graph $G(k,p)$ for an appropriate edge probability $p$. Central is analysis of a random walk with fixed beginning and end which is tilted to the left.

In this paper we study random graphs with independent and identically distributed degrees of which the tail of the distribution function is regularly varying with exponent $τ\in (2,3)$. The number of edges between two arbitrary nodes, also called the graph distance or hopcount, in a graph with $N$ nodes is investigated when $N\to \infty$. When $τ\in (2,3)$, this graph distance grows like $2\frac{\log\log N}{|\log(τ-2)|}$. In different papers, the cases $τ>3$ and $τ\in (1,2)$ have been studied. We also study the fluctuations around these asymptotic means, and describe their distributions. The results presented here improve upon results of Reittu and Norros, who prove an upper bound only.

The unit ball random geometric graph $G=G^d_p(λ,n)$ has as its vertices $n$ points distributed independently and uniformly in the $d$-dimensional unit ball, with two vertices adjacent if and only if their $l_p$-distance is at most $λ$. Like its cousin the Erdos-Renyi random graph, $G$ has a connectivity threshold: an asymptotic value for $λ$ in terms of $n$, above which $G$ is connected and below which $G$ is disconnected (and in fact has isolated vertices in most cases). In the connected zone, we determine upper and lower bounds for the graph diameter of $G$. Specifically, almost always, $\diam_p(\mathbf{B})(1-o(1))/λ\leq \diam(G) \leq \diam_p(\mathbf{B})(1+O((\ln \ln n/\ln n)^{1/d}))/λ$, where $\diam_p(\mathbf{B})$ is the $\ell_p$-diameter of the unit ball $\mathbf{B}$. We employ a combination of methods from probabilistic combinatorics and stochastic geometry.

Although the ``scale-free'' literature is large and growing, it gives neither a precise definition of scale-free graphs nor rigorous proofs of many of their claimed properties. In fact, it is easily shown that the existing theory has many inherent contradictions and verifiably false claims. In this paper, we propose a new, mathematically precise, and structural definition of the extent to which a graph is scale-free, and prove a series of results that recover many of the claimed properties while suggesting the potential for a rich and interesting theory. With this definition, scale-free (or its opposite, scale-rich) is closely related to other structural graph properties such as various notions of self-similarity (or respectively, self-dissimilarity). Scale-free graphs are also shown to be the likely outcome of random construction processes, consistent with the heuristic definitions implicit in existing random graph approaches. Our approach clarifies much of the confusion surrounding the sensational qualitative claims in the scale-free literature, and offers rigorous and quantitative alternatives.

Given a set $ξ=\{H_1,H_2,...\}$ of connected non acyclic graphs, a $ξ$-free graph is one which does not contain any member of $% ξ$ as copy. Define the excess of a graph as the difference between its number of edges and its number of vertices. Let ${\gr{W}}_{k,ξ}$ be theexponential generating function (EGF for brief) of connected $ξ$-free graphs of excess equal to $k$ ($k \geq 1$). For each fixed $ξ$, a fundamental differential recurrence satisfied by the EGFs ${\gr{W}}_{k,ξ}$ is derived. We give methods on how to solve this nonlinear recurrence for the first few values of $k$ by means of graph surgery. We also show that for any finite collection $ξ$ of non-acyclic graphs, the EGFs ${\gr{W}}_{k,ξ}$ are always rational functions of the generating function, $T$, of Cayley's rooted (non-planar) labelled trees. From this, we prove that almost all connected graphs with $n$ nodes and $n+k$ edges are $ξ$-free, whenever $k=o(n^{1/3})$ and $|ξ| < \infty$ by means of Wright's inequalities and saddle point method. Limiting distributions are derived for sparse connected $ξ$-free components that are present when a random graph on $n$ nodes has approximately $\frac{n}{2}$ edges. In particular, the probability distribution that it consists of trees, unicyclic components, $...$, $(q+1)$-cyclic components all $ξ$-free is derived. Similar results are also obtained for multigraphs, which are graphs where self-loops and multiple-edges are allowed.

For a random graph on n vertices where the edges appear with individual rates, we give exact formulas for the expected time at which the number of components has gone down to k and the expected length of the corresponding minimal spanning forest. For a random bipartite graph we give a formula for the expected time at which a k-assignment appears. This result has bearing upon the random assignment problem.

Motivated by Bourque and Pevzner's simulation study of the parsimony method for studying genome rearrangement, Berestycki and Durrett used techniques from random graph theory to prove that the minimum parsimony distance after iterating the random transposition shuffle undergoes a transition from Poisson to normal behavior. This paper establishes an analogous result for minimum parsimony distance after iterates of riffle shuffles or iterates of riffle shuffles and cuts. The analysis is elegant and uses different tools: Stein's method and generating functions. A useful technique which emerges is that of making a problem more tractable by adding extra symmetry, then using Stein's method to exploit the symmetry in the modified problem, and from this deducing information about the original problem.

We show that if a sequence of dense graphs has the property that for every fixed graph F, the density of copies of F in these graphs tends to a limit, then there is a natural ``limit object'', namely a symmetric measurable 2-variable function on [0,1]. This limit object determines all the limits of subgraph densities. We also show that the graph parameters obtained as limits of subgraph densities can be characterized by ``reflection positivity'', semidefiniteness of an associated matrix. Conversely, every such function arises as a limit object. Along the lines we introduce a rather general model of random graphs, which seems to be interesting on its own right.

One of the fundamental problems in distributed computing is how to efficiently perform routing in a faulty network in which each link fails with some probability. This paper investigates how big the failure probability can be, before the capability to efficiently find a path in the network is lost. Our main results show tight upper and lower bounds for the failure probability which permits routing, both for the hypercube and for the $d-$dimensional mesh. We use tools from percolation theory to show that in the $d-$dimensional mesh, once a giant component appears -- efficient routing is possible. A different behavior is observed when the hypercube is considered. In the hypercube there is a range of failure probabilities in which short paths exist with high probability, yet finding them must involve querying essentially the entire network. Thus the routing complexity of the hypercube shows an asymptotic phase transition. The critical probability with respect to routing complexity lies in a different location then that of the critical probability with respect to connectivity. Finally we show that an oracle access to links (as opposed to local routing) may reduce significantly the complexity of the routing problem. We demonstrate this fact by providing tight upper and lower bounds for the complexity of routing in the random graph $G_{n,p}$.

We study random graphs with an i.i.d. degree sequence of which the tail of the distribution function $F$ is regularly varying with exponent $τ\in (1,2)$. Thus, the degrees have infinite mean. Such random graphs can serve as models for complex networks where degree power laws are observed. The minimal number of edges between two arbitrary nodes, also called the graph distance or the hopcount, in a graph with $N$ nodes is investigated when $N\to \infty$. The paper is part of a sequel of three papers. The other two papers study the case where $τ\in (2,3)$, and $τ\in (3,\infty),$ respectively. The main result of this paper is that the graph distance converges for $τ\in (1,2)$ to a limit random variable with probability mass exclusively on the points 2 and 3. We also consider the case where we condition the degrees to be at most $N^α$ for some $α>0.$ For $τ^{-1}<α<(τ-1)^{-1}$, the hopcount converges to 3 in probability, while for $α>(τ-1)^{-1}$, the hopcount converges to the same limit as for the unconditioned degrees. Our results give convincing asymptotics for the hopcount when the mean degree is infinite, using extreme value theory.

In this paper we study a random graph with $N$ nodes, where node $j$ has degree $D_j$ and $\{D_j\}_{j=1}^N$ are i.i.d. with $\prob(D_j\leq x)=F(x)$. We assume that $1-F(x)\leq c x^{-τ+1}$ for some $τ>3$ and some constant $c>0$. This graph model is a variant of the so-called configuration model, and includes heavy tail degrees with finite variance. The minimal number of edges between two arbitrary connected nodes, also known as the graph distance or the hopcount, is investigated when $N\to \infty$. We prove that the graph distance grows like $\log_νN$, when the base of the logarithm equals $ν=\expec[D_j(D_j -1)]/\expec[D_j]>1$. This confirms the heuristic argument of Newman, Strogatz and Watts \cite{NSW00}. In addition, the random fluctuations around this asymptotic mean $\log_ν{N}$ are characterized and shown to be uniformly bounded. In particular, we show convergence in distribution of the centered graph distance along exponentially growing subsequences.

We say that a graph G is Class 0 if its pebbling number is exactly equal to its number of vertices. For a positive integer d, let k(d) denote the least positive integer so that every graph G with diameter at most d and connectivity at least k(d) is Class 0. The existence of the function k was conjectured by Clarke, Hochberg and Hurlbert, who showed that if the function k exists, then it must satisfy k(d)=Ω(2^d/d). In this note, we show that k exists and satisfies k(d)=O(2^{2d}). We also apply this result to improve the upper bound on the random graph threshold of the Class 0 property.

We survey results on the pebbling numbers of graphs as well as their historical connection with a number-theoretic question of Erd\H os and Lemke. We also present new results on two probabilistic pebbling considerations, first the random graph threshold for the property that the pebbling number of a graph equals its number of vertices, and second the pebbling threshold function for various natural graph sequences. Finally, we relate the question of the existence of pebbling thresholds to a strengthening of the normal property of posets, and show that the multiset lattice is not supernormal.

Using Talagrand's concentration inequality on the discrete cube {0,1}^m we show that given a real-valued function Z(x)on {0,1}^m that satisfies certain monotonicity conditions one can control the deviations of Z(x) above its median by a local Lipschitz norm of Z(x) at the point x. As one application, we give a simple proof of a nearly optimal deviation inequality for the number of k-cycles in a random graph.

Our work is motivated by Bourque and Pevzner's (2002) simulation study of the effectiveness of the parsimony method in studying genome rearrangement, and leads to a surprising result about the random transposition walk on the group of permutations on $n$ elements. Consider this walk in continuous time starting at the identity and let $D_t$ be the minimum number of transpositions needed to go back to the identity from the location at time $t$. $D_t$ undergoes a phase transition: the distance $D_{cn/2} \sim u(c)n$, where $u$ is an explicit function satisfying $u(c)=c/2$ for $c \le 1$ and $u(c)1$. In other words, the distance to the identity is roughly linear during the subcritical phase, and after critical time $n/2$ it becomes sublinear. In addition, we describe the fluctuations of $D_{cn/2}$ about its mean in each of the threeregimes (subcritical, critical and supercritical). The techniques used involve viewing the cycles in the random permutation as a coagulation-fragmentation process and relating the behavior to the \Erdős-Renyi random graph model.

We study the asymptotics of large, moderate and normal deviations for the connected components of the sparse random graph by the method of stochastic processes. We obtain the logarithmic asymptotics of large deviations of the joint distribution of the number of connected components, of the sizes of the giant components, and of the numbers of the excess edges of the giant components. For the supercritical case, we obtain the asymptotics of normal deviations and the logarithmic asymptotics of large and moderate deviations of the joint distribution of the number of components, of the size of the largest component, and of the number of the excess edges of the largest component. For the critical case, we obtain the logarithmic asymptotics of moderate deviations of the joint distribution of the sizes of connected components and of the numbers of the excess edges. Some related asymptotics are also established. The proofs of the large and moderate deviation asymptotics employ methods of idempotent probability theory. As a byproduct of the results, we provide some additional insight into the nature of phase transitions in sparse random graphs.

We consider {\em monotone} embeddings of a finite metric space into low dimensional normed space. That is, embeddings that respect the order among the distances in the original space. Our main interest is in embeddings into Euclidean spaces. We observe that any metric on $n$ points can be embedded into $l_2^n$, while, (in a sense to be made precise later), for almost every $n$-point metric space, every monotone map must be into a space of dimension $Ω(n)$. It becomes natural, then, to seek explicit constructions of metric spaces that cannot be monotonically embedded into spaces of sublinear dimension. To this end, we employ known results on {\em sphericity} of graphs, which suggest one example of such a metric space - that defined by a complete bipartitegraph. We prove that an $δn$-regular graph of order $n$, with bounded diameter has sphericity $Ω(n/(λ_2+1))$, where $λ_2$ is the second largest eigenvalue of the adjacency matrix of the graph, and $0 < δ\leq \half$ is constant. We also show that while random graphs have linear sphericity, there are {\em quasi-random} graphs of logarithmic sphericity. For the above bound to be linear, $λ_2$ must be constant. We show that if the second eigenvalue of an $n/2$-regular graph is bounded by a constant, then the graph is close to being complete bipartite. Namely, its adjacency matrix differs from that of a complete bipartite graph in only $o(n^2)$ entries. Furthermore, for any $0 < δ< \half$, and $λ_2$, there are only finitely many $δn$-regular graphs with second eigenvalue at most $λ_2$.

It is not hard to write a first order formula which is true for a given graph G but is false for any graph not isomorphic to G. The smallest number $(G) of nested quantifiers in a such formula can serve as a measure for the ``first order complexity'' of G. Here, this parameter is studied for random graphs. We determine it asymptotically when the edge probability p is constant; in fact, D(G) is of order log n then. For very sparse graphs its magnitude is Θ(n). On the other hand, for certain (carefully chosen) values of p the parameter D(G) can drop down to the very slow growing function log^* n, the inverse of the tower-function. The general picture, however, is still a mystery.

We consider a model for random hypergraphs with identifiability, an analogue of connectedness. This model has a phase transition in the proportion of identifiable vertices when the underlying random graph becomes critical. The phase transition takes various forms, depending on the values of the parameters controlling the different types of hyperedges. It may be continuous as in a random graph. (In fact, when there are no higher-order edges, it is exactly the emergence of the giant component.) In this case, there is a sequence of possible sizes of ``components'' (including but not restricted to N^{2/3}). Alternatively, the phase transition may be discontinuous. We are particularly interested in the nature of the discontinuous phase transition and are able to exhibit precise asymptotics. Our method extends a result of Aldous [Ann. Probab. 25 (1997) 812-854] on component sizes in a random graph.