arXiv++ Combinatorics

Finding a good bound on the maximal edge diameter $Δ(d,n)$ of a polytope in terms of its dimension $d$ and the number of its facets $n$ is one of the basic open questions in polytope theory \cite{BG}. Although some bounds are known, the behaviour of the function $Δ(d,n)$ is largely unknown. The Hirsch conjecture, formulated in 1957 and reported in \cite{GD}, states that $Δ(d,n)$ is linear in $n$ and $d$: $Δ(d,n) \leq n-d$. The conjecture is known to hold in small dimensions, i.e., for $d \leq 3$ \cite{VK}, along with other specific pairs of $d$ and $n$ (Table \ref{before}). However, the asymptotic behaviour of $Δ(d,n)$ is not well understood: the best upper bound -- due to Kalai and Kleitman -- is quasi-polynomial \cite{GKDK}. In this article we will show that $Δ(4,12)=7$ and present strong evidence for $Δ(5,12)=Δ(6,13)=7$. The first of these new values is of particular interest since it indicates that the Hirsch bound is not sharp in dimension 4.