arXiv++ Combinatorics

We recall definitions of linking numbers and Wu--Simon numbers for spatial graphs. We expose a `converse' to the Conway--Gordon--Sachs theorem (i.e. description of linking functions for embeddings $K_6\to\mathbb{R}^3$), and some results on Wu--Simon numbers. We conjecture and discuss a generalization of the Conway--Gordon--Sachs theorem to multiple linking. The exposition is based on plane diagrams, so no knowledge of spatial geometry is required.

The Netflix problem (from machine learning) asks the following. Given a ratings matrix in which each entry $(i,j)$ represents the rating of movie $j$ by customer $i$, if customer $i$ has watched movie $j$, and is otherwise missing, we would like to predict the remaining entries in order to make good recommendations to customers on what to watch next. The remaining entries are predicted so as to minimize the {\it rank} of the completed matrix. In this survey we study a more general problem, in which instead of knowing specific matrix elements, we know linear relations on such elements. We describe applications of these results to embeddings of graphs in surfaces (more precisely, embeddings with rotation systems, and embeddings modulo 2).

In this survey we motivate studies of the invariants from the title. A graph drawing in the plane is called an almost embedding if the images of any two non-adjacent simplices (i.e. vertices or edges) are disjoint. We introduce integer invariants of almost embeddings: winding number, cyclic and triodic Wu numbers. We prove some relations between the invariants. We demonstrate connection of these relations to homology of the deleted product of a graph. We construct almost embeddings realizing some values of these invariants. This paper is accessible to mathematicians not specialized in the area (and to students). All the necessary definitions are recalled. We present some ideas of algebraic and geometric topology in a language accessible to non-topologists. However elementary, this paper is motivated by frontline of research; there are some conjectures and an open problem.

A graph drawing in the plane is called an almost embedding if images of any two non-adjacent simplices (i.e. vertices or edges) are disjoint. We introduce integer invariants of almost embeddings: winding number, cyclic and triodic Wu numbers. We construct almost embeddings realizing some values of these invariants. We prove some relations between the invariants. We study values realizable as invariants of some almost embedding, but not of any embedding. This paper is expository and is accessible to mathematicians not specialized in the area (and to students). However elementary, this paper is motivated by frontline of research.

In this expository paper we present some ideas of algebraic topology (more precisely, of homology theory) in a language accessible to non-specialists in the area. A $1$-cycle in a graph is a set $C$ of edges such that every vertex is contained in an even number of edges from $C$. It is easy to check that the sum (modulo $2$) of $1$-cycles is a $1$-cycle. We start from the following problems: to find $\bullet$ the number of all $1$-cycles in a given graph; $\bullet$ a small number of $1$-cycles in a given graph such that any $1$-cycle is the sum of some of them. We consider generalizations (of these problems) to graphs with symmetry, to $2$-cycles in $2$-dimensional hypergraphs, and to certain configuration spaces of graphs (namely, to the square and the deleted square).

In this expository note we show how combinatorial Nullstellensatz by N. Alon naturally appears in solutions of elementary problems. Simple ideas gradually and naturally appear in such solutions, thus bringing a reader to generalizations. The note is accessible to mathematicians not specialized in the area, and to students familiar with polynomials.

This is an expository paper. A $1$-cycle in a graph is a set $C$ of edges such that every vertex is contained in an even number of edges from $C$. E.g., a cycle in the sense of graph theory is a $1$-cycle, but not vice versa. It is easy to check that the sum (modulo $2$) of $1$-cycles is a $1$-cycle. In this text we study the following problems: to find $\bullet$ the number of all 1-cycles in a given graph; $\bullet$ a small number of 1-cycles in a given graph such that any 1-cycle is the sum of some of them. We also consider generalizations (of these problems) to graphs with symmetry, and to $2$-cycles in $2$-dimensional hypergraphs.

A general position map $f:K\to M$ of a $k$-dimensional simplicial complex to a $2k$-dimensional manifold (for $k=1$, of a graph to a surface) is a $\mathbb Z_2$-embedding if $|fσ\cap fτ|$ is even for any non-adjacent $k$-faces $σ,τ$. We present criteria for $\mathbb Z_2$-embeddability of certain $k$-dimensional complex (for $k=1$, of any graph) to $2k$-dimensional manifolds. These criteria are $\bullet$ a `Kuratowski-type' version of the Fulek-Kynčl-Bikeev criteria (for $k=1$), and $\bullet$ a converse to the Dzhenzher-Skopenkov necessary condition (for $k>1$). Our higher-dimensional criterion allows us to reduce the modulo 2 Kühnel problem on embeddings to a purely algebraic problem. Our proof is interplay between geometric topology, combinatorics and linear algebra. It is based on calculation of generators in the homology of certain configuration space (the deleted product) of certain complex (joinpower).

The purpose of this short note is to guide a reader to a reliable reference for the following result of S. Parsa: For any $k,l\ge2$ there exist simplicial complexes $K, L$ of dimensions $k,l$ such that $K$ does not embed into $\mathbb R^{2k}$, and $L$ does not embed into $\mathbb R^{2l}$, but the join $K*L$ embeds into $\mathbb R^{2(k+l+1)}$.

The classical Heawood inequality states that if the complete graph $K_n$ on $n$ vertices is embeddable in the sphere with $g$ handles, then $g \ge\dfrac{(n-3)(n-4)}{12}$. A higher-dimensional analogue of the Heawood inequality is the Kühnel conjecture. In a simplified form it states that for every integer $k>0$ there is $c_k>0$ such that if the union of $k$-faces of $n$-simplex embeds into the connected sum of $g$ copies of the Cartesian product $S^k\times S^k$ of two $k$-dimensional spheres, then $g\ge c_k n^{k+1}$. For $k>1$ only linear estimates were known. We present a quadratic estimate $g\ge c_k n^2$. The proof is based on beautiful and fruitful interplay between geometric topology, combinatorics and linear algebra.

Let $K$ be a $k$-dimensional simplicial complex having $n$ faces of dimension $k$, and $M$ a closed $(k-1)$-connected PL $2k$-dimensional manifold. We prove that for $k\ge3$ odd $K$ embeds into $M$ if and only if there are $\bullet$ a skew-symmetric $n\times n$-matrix $A$ with $\mathbb Z$-entries whose rank over $\mathbb Q$ does not exceed $rk H_k(M;\mathbb Z)$, $\bullet$ a general position PL map $f:K\to\mathbb R^{2k}$, and $\bullet$ orientations on $k$-faces of $K$ such that for any nonadjacent $k$-faces $σ,τ$ of $K$ the element $A_{σ,τ}$ equals to the algebraic intersection of $fσ$ and $fτ$. We prove some analogues of this result including those for $\mathbb Z_2$- and $\mathbb Z$-embeddability. Our results generalize the Bikeev-Fulek-Kyn\v cl criteria for the $\mathbb Z_2$- and $\mathbb Z$-embeddability of graphs to surfaces, and are related to the Harris-Krushkal-Johnson-Paták-Tancer criteria for the embeddability of $k$-complexes into $2k$-manifolds.

In this expository note we present simple proofs of the lower bound of Ramsey numbers (Erdös theorem), and of the estimation of discrepancy. Neither statements nor proofs require any knowledge beyond high-school curriculum (except a minor detail). Thus they are accessible to non-specialists, in particular, to students. Our exposition is simpler than the standard exposition because no probabilistic language is used. In order to prove the existence of a `good' object we prove that the number of `bad' objects is smaller than the number of all objects.

We present a motivated exposition of the proof of the following Tverberg Theorem: For every integers $d,r$ any $(d+1)(r-1)+1$ points in $\mathbb R^d$ can be decomposed into $r$ groups such that all the $r$ convex hulls of the groups have a common point. The proof is by well-known reduction to the Bárány Theorem. However, our exposition is easier to grasp because additional constructions (of an embedding $\mathbb R^d\subset\mathbb R^{d+1}$, of vectors $\varphi_{j,i}$ and statement of the Barańy Theorem) are not introduced in advance in a non-motivated way, but naturally appear in an attempt to construct the required decomposition. This attempt is based on rewriting several equalities between vectors as one equality between vectors of higher dimension.

Denote by $Δ_M$ the $M$-dimensional simplex. A map $f\colon Δ_M\to\mathbb R^d$ is an almost $r$-embedding if $fσ_1\cap\ldots\cap fσ_r=\emptyset$ whenever $σ_1,\ldots,σ_r$ are pairwise disjoint faces. A counterexample to the topological Tverberg conjecture asserts that if $r$ is not a prime power and $d\ge2r+1$, then there is an almost $r$-embedding $Δ_{(d+1)(r-1)}\to\mathbb R^d$. This was improved by Blagojević-Frick-Ziegler using a simple construction of higher-dimensional counterexamples by taking $k$-fold join power of lower-dimensional ones. We improve this further (for $d$ large compared to $r$): If $r$ is not a prime power and $N:=(d+1)r-r\Big\lceil\dfrac{d+2}{r+1}\Big\rceil-2$, then there is an almost $r$-embedding $Δ_N\to\mathbb R^d$. For the $r$-fold van Kampen-Flores conjecture we also produce counterexamples which are stronger than previously known. Our proof is based on generalizations of the Mabillard-Wagner theorem on construction of almost $r$-embeddings from equivariant maps, and of the Özaydin theorem on existence of equivariant maps.

We present a short exposition of the following results by S. Parsa. Let $L$ be a graph such that the join $L*\{1,2,3\}$ (i.e. the union of three cones over $L$ along their common bases) piecewise linearly (PL) embeds into $\mathbb R^4$. Then $L$ admits a PL embedding into $\mathbb R^3$ such that any two disjoint cycles have zero linking number. There is $C$ such that every 2-dimensional simplicial complex having $n$ vertices and embeddable into $\mathbb R^4$ contains less than $Cn^{8/3}$ simplices of dimension 2. We also present the analogue of the second result for intrinsic linking.

We present a simplified exposition of some classical and modern results on graph drawings in the plane. These results are chosen so that they illustrate some spectacular recent higher-dimensional results on the border of topology and combinatorics. We define a mod2-valued self-intersection invariant (i.e. the van Kampen number) and its generalizations. We present elementary formulations and arguments accessible to mathematicians not specialized in any of the areas discussed. So most part of this survey could be studied before textbooks on algebraic topology, as an introduction to starting ideas of algebraic topology motivated by algorithmic, combinatorial and geometric problems.

The topological Tverberg conjecture was considered a central unsolved problem of topological combinatorics. The conjecture asserts that for any integers $r,d>1$ and any continuous map $f:Δ\to\mathbb R^d$ of the $(d+1)(r-1)$-dimensional simplex there are pairwise disjoint faces $σ_1,\ldots,σ_r\subsetΔ$ such that $f(σ_1)\cap \ldots \cap f(σ_r)\ne\emptyset$. The conjecture was proved for a prime power $r$. Recently counterexamples for other $r$ were found. Analogously, the $r$-fold van Kampen-Flores conjecture holds for a prime power $r$ but does not hold for other $r$. The arguments form a beautiful and fruitful interplay between combinatorics, algebra and topology. We present a simplified exposition accessible to non-specialists in the area. We also mention some recent developments and open problems.

We study conditions under which a finite simplicial complex $K$ can be mapped to $\mathbb R^d$ without higher-multiplicity intersections. An almost $r$-embedding is a map $f: K\to \mathbb R^d$ such that the images of any $r$ pairwise disjoint simplices of $K$ do not have a common point. We show that if $r$ is not a prime power and $d\geq 2r+1$, then there is a counterexample to the topological Tverberg conjecture, i.e., there is an almost $r$-embedding of the $(d+1)(r-1)$-simplex in $\mathbb R^d$. This improves on previous constructions of counterexamples (for $d\geq 3r$) based on a series of papers by M. Özaydin, M. Gromov, P. Blagojević, F. Frick, G. Ziegler, and the second and fourth present authors. The counterexamples are obtained by proving the following algebraic criterion in codimension 2: If $r\ge3$ and if $K$ is a finite $2(r-1)$-complex then there exists an almost $r$-embedding $K\to \mathbb R^{2r}$ if and only if there exists a general position PL map $f:K\to \mathbb R^{2r}$ such that the algebraic intersection number of the $f$-images of any $r$ pairwise disjoint simplices of $K$ is zero. This result can be restated in terms of cohomological obstructions or equivariant maps, and extends an analogous codimension 3 criterion by the second and fourth authors. As another application we classify ornaments $f:S^3 \sqcup S^3\sqcup S^3\to \mathbb R^5$ up to ornament concordance. It follows from work of M. Freedman, V. Krushkal and P. Teichner that the analogous criterion for $r=2$ is false. We prove a lemma on singular higher-dimensional Borromean rings, yielding an elementary proof of the counterexample.

This note is purely expository and is in Russian. We show how to prove interesting combinatorial results using the local Lovasz lemma. The note is accessible for students having basic knowledge of combinatorics; the notion of independence is defined and the Lovasz lemma is stated and proved. Our exposition follows `Probabilistic methods' of N. Alon and J. Spencer. The main difference is that we show how the proof could have been invented. The material is presented as a sequence of problems, which is peculiar not only to Zen monasteries but also to advanced mathematical education; most problems are presented with hints or solutions.

This paper is purely expositional. The statement of the Kuratowski graph planarity criterion is simple and well-known. However, its classical proof is not easy. In this paper we present the Makarychev proof (with further simplifications by Prasolov, Telishev, Zaslavski and the author) which is possibly the simplest. In the Rusian version before the proof we present all the necessary definitions, and afterwards we state some close results on graphs and more general spaces. The paper is accessible for students familiar with the notion of a graph, and could be an interesting easy reading for mature mathematicians.