arXiv++ Combinatorics

It is shown that any subset $E$ of a plane over a finite field $\F_q$, of cardinality $|E|>q$ determines not less than $\frac{q-1}{2}$ distinct areas of triangles, moreover once can find such triangles sharing a common base. It is also shown that if $|E|\geq 64q\log_2 q$, then there are more than $\frac{q}{2}$ distinct areas of triangles sharing a common vertex. The result follows from a finite field version of the Beck theorem for large subsets of $\F_q^2$ that we prove. If $|E|\geq 64q\log_2 q$, there exists a point $z\in E$, such that there are at least $\frac{q}{4}$ straight lines incident to $z$, each supporting the number of points of $E$ other than $z$ in the interval between $\frac{|E|}{2q}$ and $\frac{2|E|}{q}.$ This is proved by combining combinatorial and Fourier analytic techniques. We also discuss higher-dimensional implications of these results in light of recent developments.

We study multilinear generalized Radon transforms using a graph-theoretic paradigm that includes the widely studied linear case. These provide a general mechanism to study Falconer-type problems involving $(k+1)$-point configurations in geometric measure theory, with $k \ge 2$, including the distribution of simplices, volumes and angles determined by the points of fractal subsets $E \subset {\Bbb R}^d$, $d \ge 2$. If $T_k(E)$ denotes the set of noncongruent $(k+1)$-point configurations determined by $E$, we show that if the Hausdorff dimension of $E$ is greater than $d-\frac{d-1}{2k}$, then the ${k+1 \choose 2}$-dimensional Lebesgue measure of $T_k(E)$ is positive. This compliments previous work on the Falconer conjecture (\cite{Erd05} and the references there), as well as work on finite point configurations \cite{EHI11,GI10}. We also give applications to Erdös-type problems in discrete geometry and a fractal regular value theorem, providing a multilinear framework for the results in \cite{EIT11}.

We prove that if $E \subset {\mathbb F}_q^2$, $q \equiv 3 \mod 4$, has size greater than $Cq^{7/4}$, then $E$ determines a positive proportion of all congruence classes of triangles in ${\mathbb F}_q^2$. The approach in this paper is based on the approach to the Erd\H os distance problem in the plane due to Elekes and Sharir, followed by an incidence bound for points and lines in ${\mathbb F}_q^3$. We also establish a weak lower bound for a related problem in the sense that any subset $E$ of ${\mathbb F}_q^2$ of size less than $cq^{4/3}$ definitely does not contain a positive proportion of {\bf translation} classes of triangles in the plane. This result is a special case of a result established for $n$-simplices in ${\mathbb F}_q^d$. Finally, a necessary and sufficient condition on the lengths of a triangle for it to exist in $\mathbb{F}^2$ for any field $\mathbb F$ of characteristic not equal to 2 is established as a special case of a result for $d$-simplices in ${\mathbb F}^d$.

Given $E \subset {\Bbb R}^d$, define the \emph{volume set} of $E$, ${\mathcal V}(E)= \{det(x^1, x^2, ... x^d): x^j \in E\}$. In $\R^3$, we prove that ${\mathcal V}(E)$ has positive Lebesgue measure if either the Hausdorff dimension of $E\subset \Bbb R^3$ is greater than 13/5, or $E$ is a product set of the form $E=B_1\times B_2\times B_3$ with $B_j\subset\R,\, dim_{\mathcal H}(B_j)>2/3,\, j=1,2,3$. We show that the same conclusion holds for $\V(E)$ of Salem subsets $E\subset\R^d$ with $\hde>d-1$, and give applications to discrete combinatorial geometry.

We prove that if the Hausdorff dimension of a compact subset of ${\mathbb R}^d$ is greater than $\frac{d+1}{2}$, then the set of angles determined by triples of points from this set has positive Lebesgue measure. Sobolev bounds for bi-linear analogs of generalized Radon transforms and the method of stationary phase play a key role. These results complement those of V. Harangi, T. Keleti, G. Kiss, P. Maga, P. Mattila and B. Stenner in (\cite{HKKMMS10}). We also obtain new upper bounds for the number of times an angle can occur among $N$ points in ${\mathbb R}^d$, $d \ge 4$, motivated by the results of Apfelbaum and Sharir (\cite{AS05}) and Pach and Sharir (\cite{PS92}). We then use this result to establish sharpness results in the continuous setting. Another sharpness result relies on the distribution of lattice points on large spheres in higher dimensions.

We study variants of the Erd\H os distance problem and dot products problem in the setting of the integers modulo $q$, where $q = p^{\ell}$ is a power of an odd prime.

We prove that if $φ: {\Bbb R}^d \times {\Bbb R}^d \to {\Bbb R}$, $d \ge 2$, is a homogeneous function, smooth away from the origin and having non-zero Monge-Ampere determinant away from the origin, then $$ R^{-d} # \{(n,m) \in {\Bbb Z}^d \times {\Bbb Z}^d: |n|, |m| \leq CR; R \leq φ(n,m) \leq R+δ\} \lesssim \max \{R^{d-2+\frac{2}{d+1}}, R^{d-1} δ\}.$$ This is a variable coefficient version of a result proved by Lettington in \cite{L10}, extending a previous result by Andrews in \cite{A63}, showing that if $B \subset {\Bbb R}^d$, $d \ge 2$, is a symmetric convex body with a sufficiently smooth boundary and non-vanishing Gaussian curvature, then $$ # \{k \in {\mathbb Z}^d: dist(k, R \partial B) \leq δ\} \lesssim \max \{R^{d-2+\frac{2}{d+1}}, R^{d-1} δ\}. (*)$$ Furthermore, we shall see that the same argument yields a non-isotropic analog of $(*)$, one for which the exponent on the right hand side is, in general, sharp, even in the infinitely smooth case. This sheds some light on the nature of the exponents and their connection with the conjecture due to Wolfgang Schmidt on the distribution of lattice points on dilates of smooth convex surfaces in ${\Bbb R}^d$.

We prove that for some universal $c$, a non-collinear set of $N>\frac{1}{c}$ points in the Euclidean plane determines at least $c \frac{N}{\log N}$ distinct areas of triangles with one vertex at the origin, as well as at least $c \frac{N}{\log N}$ distinct dot products. This in particular implies a sum-product bound $$ |A\cdot A\pm A\cdot A|\geq c\frac{|A|^2}{\log |A|} $$ for a discrete $A \subset {\mathbb R}$.

We prove that if ${\mathcal E} \subset {\Bbb R}^{2d}$, $d \ge 2$, is an Ahlfors-David regular product set of sufficiently large Hausdorff dimension, denoted by $dim_{\mathcal H}({\mathcal E})$, and $φ$ is a sufficiently regular function, then the upper Minkowski dimension of the set $$ \{w \in {\mathcal E}: φ_l(w)=t_l; 1 \leq l \leq m \}$$ does not exceed $dim_{\mathcal H}({\mathcal E})-m$, in line with the regular value theorem from the elementary differential geometry. Our arguments are based on the mapping properties of the underlying Fourier Integral Operators and are intimately connected with the Falconer distance conjecture in geometric measure theory. We shall see that our results are in general sharp in the sense that if the Hausdorff dimension is smaller than a certain threshold, then the dimensional inequality fails in a quantifiable way. The constructions used to demonstrate this are based on the distribution of lattice points on convex surfaces and have connections with combinatorial geometry.

We prove that if a subset of a $d$-dimensional vector space over a finite field with $q$ elements has more than $q^{d-1}$ elements, then it determines all the possible directions. If a set has more than $q^k$ elements, it determines a $k$-dimensional set of directions. We prove stronger results for sets that are sufficiently random. This result is best possible as the example of a $k$-dimensional hyperplane shows. We can view this question as an Erd\H os type problem where a sufficiently large subset of a vector space determines a large number of configurations of a given type. For discrete subsets of ${\Bbb R}^d$, this question has been previously studied by Pach, Pinchasi and Sharir.

We show that if $E \subset \mathbb{F}_q^d$, the $d$-dimensional vector space over the finite field with $q$ elements, and $|E| \geq ρq^d$, where $ q^{-\frac{1}{2}}\ll ρ\leq 1$, then $E$ contains an isometric copy of at least $c ρ^{d-1} q^{d+1 \choose 2}$ distinct $(d+1)$-point configurations.

Given $E \subset \mathbb{R}^d$, $d \ge 2$, define ${\mathcal D}(E) \equiv {(x-y)/|x-y|: x,y \in E} \subset S^{d-1},$ the set of directions determined by $E$. We prove that if the Hausdorff dimension of $E$ is greater than $d-1$, then $σ({\mathcal D}(E))>0$, where $σ$ denotes the surface measure on $S^{d-1}$. This result is sharp since the conclusion fails to hold if $E$ is a $(d-1)$-dimensional hyper-plane. This result can be viewed as a continuous analog of a recent result of Pach, Pinchasi, and Sharir (\cite{PPS04}, \cite{PPS07}) on angles determined by finite subsets of $\mathbb{R}^d$. Also define ${\mathcal A}(E)=\{θ(x,y,z): x,y,z \in E\},$ where $θ(x,y,z)$ is the angle between $x-y$ and $y-z$. We use the techniques developed to handle the problem of directions and results on distance sets previously obtained by Wolff and Erdogan to prove that if the Hasudorff dimension of $E$ is greater than $(d-1)/2+1/3$, then the Lebesgue measure of ${\mathcal A}(E)$ is positive. This result can be viewed as a continuous analog of a recent result of Apfelbaum and Sharir (\cite{AS05}). At the end of this paper we show that our continuous results can be used to recover and in some case improve the exponents for the corresponding results in the discrete setting for large classes of finite point sets. In particular, we prove that a finite point set $P \subset {\Bbb R}^d$, $d \ge 3$, satisfying a certain discrete energy condition (Definition \ref{adaptablemama}), determines $\gtrapprox # P$ distinct directions and $\gtrapprox {(# P)}^{6/(3d-1)}$ distinct angles. In two dimensions, the lower bound on the number of angles is $\gtrapprox # P$.

We prove that if the Hausdorff dimension of a compact set $E \subset {\Bbb R}^2$ is greater than 7/4, then the set of {\ag three-point configurations determined by $E$ has positive three-dimensional measure}. We establish this by showing that {\ag a} natural measure on the set of {\ag such configurations} has {\ag Radon-Nikodym derivative} in $L^{\infty}$ if $\dH(E)> 7/4$, and the index 7/4 in this last result cannot, in general, be improved. This problem naturally leads to the study of a bilinear convolution operator, $$ B(f,g)(x)=\int \int f(x-u) g(x-v)\, dK(u,v),$$ where $K$ is surface measure on the set $ \{(u, v) \in\R^2 \times \R^2: |u|=|v|=|u-v|=1\}$, and we prove a scale of estimates that includes $B:L^2_{-1/2}({\Bbb R}^2) \times L^2({\Bbb R}^2) \to L^1({\Bbb R}^2)$ on positive functions. As an application of our main result, it follows that {\ag for finite sets of cardinality $n$ and belonging to a natural class of discrete sets in the plane}, the maximum number of times a given three-point configuration arises is $O(n^{9/7+ε})$ (up to congruence), improving upon the known bound of $O(n^{4/3})$ in this context.

In this paper we prove, for all $d \ge 2$, that for no $s<\frac{d+1}{2}$ does $I_s(μ)<\infty$ imply the canonical Falconer distance problem incidence bound, or the analogous estimate where the Euclidean norm is replaced by the norm generated by a particular convex body $B$ with a smooth boundary and everywhere non-vanishing curvature. Our construction, based on a combinatorial construction due to Pavel Valtr naturally leads us to some interesting connections between the problem under consideration, geometric incidence theorem in the discrete setting and distribution of lattice points in convex domains. We also prove that an example by Mattila can be discretized to produce a set of points and annuli for which the number of incidences is much greater than in the case of the lattice. In particular, we use the known results on the Gauss Circle Problem and a discretized version of Mattila's example to produce a non-lattice set of points and annuli where the number of incidences is much greater than in the case of the standard lattice. Finally, we extend Valtr's example into the setting of vector spaces over finite fields and show that a finite field analog of the key incidence bound is also sharp.

An analog of the Falconer distance problem in vector spaces over finite fields asks for the threshold $α>0$ such that $|Δ(E)| \gtrsim q$ whenever $|E| \gtrsim q^α$, where $E \subset {\Bbb F}_q^d$, the $d$-dimensional vector space over a finite field with $q$ elements (not necessarily prime). Here $Δ(E)=\{{(x_1-y_1)}^2+...+{(x_d-y_d)}^2: x,y \in E\}$. In two dimensions we improve the known exponent to $\tfrac{4}{3}$, consistent with the corresponding exponent in Euclidean space obtained by Wolff. The pinned distance set $Δ_y(E)=\{{(x_1-y_1)}^2+...+{(x_d-y_d)}^2: x\in E\}$ for a pin $y\in E$ has been studied in the Euclidean setting. Peres and Schlag showed that if the Hausdorff dimension of a set $E$ is greater than $\tfrac{d+1}{2}$ then the Lebesgue measure of $Δ_y(E)$ is positive for almost every pin $y$. In this paper we obtain the analogous result in the finite field setting. In addition, the same result is shown to be true for the pinned dot product set $Π_y(E)=\{x\cdot y: x\in E\}$. Under the additional assumption that the set $E$ has cartesian product structure we improve the pinned threshold for both distances and dot products to $\frac{d^2}{2d-1}$. A generalization of the Falconer distance problem is determine the minimal $α>0$ such that $E$ contains a congruent copy of every $k$ dimensional simplex whenever $|E| \gtrsim q^α$. Here the authors improve on known results (for $k>3$) using Fourier analytic methods, showing that $α$ may be taken to be $\frac{d+k}{2}$.

We prove that if a subset of the d-dimensional vector space over a finite field is large enough, then it contains many k-tuples of mutually orthogonal vectors.

We prove that if the cardinality of a subset of the 2-dimensional vector space over a finite field with $q$ elements is $\ge ρq^2$, with $\frac{1}{\sqrt{q}}<<ρ\leq 1$, then it contains an isometric copy of $\ge cρq^3$ triangles.

In this paper we systematically study various properties of the distance graph in ${\Bbb F}_q^d$, the $d$-dimensional vector space over the finite field ${\Bbb F}_q$ with $q$ elements. In the process we compute the diameter of distance graphs and show that sufficiently large subsets of $d$-dimensional vector spaces over finite fields contain every possible finite configurations.

In recent years, sum-product estimates in Euclidean space and finite fields have been studied using a variety of combinatorial, number theoretic and analytic methods. Erdos type problems involving the distribution of distances, areas and volumes have also received much attention. In this paper we prove a relatively straightforward function version of an incidence results for points and planes previously established in \cite{HI07} and \cite{HIKR07}. As a consequence of our methods, we obtain sharp or near sharp results on the distribution of volumes determined by subsets of vector spaces over finite fields and the associated arithmetic expressions. In particular, our machinery enables us to prove that if $E \subset {\Bbb F}_q^d$, $d \ge 4$, the $d$-dimensional vector space over a finite field ${\Bbb F}_q$, of size much greater than $q^{\frac{d}{2}}$, and if $E$ is a product set, then the set of volumes of $d$-dimensional parallelepipeds determined by $E$ covers ${\Bbb F}_q$. This result is sharp as can be seen by taking $E$ to equal to $A \times A \times ... \times A$, where $A$ is a sub-field of ${\Bbb F}_q$ of size $\sqrt{q}$. In three dimensions we establish the same result if $|E| \gtrsim q^{15/8}$. We prove in three dimensions that the set of volumes covers a positive proportion of ${\Bbb F}_q$ if $|E| \ge Cq^{3/2}$. Finally we show that in three dimensions the set of volumes covers a positive proportion of ${\Bbb F}_q$ if $|E| \ge Cq^2$, without any further assumptions on $E$, which is again sharp as taking $E$ to be a 2-plane through the origin shows.

In this paper we study the boundedness of extension operators associated with spheres in vector spaces over finite fields.In even dimensions, we estimate the number of incidences between spheres and points in the translated set from a subset of spheres. As a result, we improve the Tomas-Stein exponents, our previous results. The analytic approach and the explicit formula for Fourier transform of the characteristic function on spheres play an important role to get good bounds for exponential sums.