arXiv++ Combinatorics

We study the parabolic variant of the Erd\H os--Falconer distance problem in finite fields. That is, if $q$ is odd, we seek size thresholds beyond which any subset $E\subset \mathbb F_q^2$ will determine many distinct parabolic distances. This problem has a rich history because the parabolic distance functional shares many properties with the standard distance functional, but exhibits many distinct behaviors. Here we begin with rather standard Fourier analytic arguments, but diverge into additive combinatorics to handle the central obstructions. We provide a suite of positive results and corresponding sharpness examples.

We establish a sharp point-sphere incidence bound in finite fields for point sets exhibiting controlled additive structure. Working in the framework of \((4,s)\)-Salem sets, which quantify pseudorandomness via fourth-order additive energy, we prove that if \(P\subset \mathbb{F}_q^d\) is a \((4,s)\)-Salem set with \(s\in \big( \frac{1}{4}, \frac{1}{2} \big]\) and \(|P|\ll q^{ \frac{d}{4s}}\), then for any finite family \(S\) of spheres in \(\mathbb{F}_q^d\), \[ \bigg| I(P,S)-\frac{|P||S| }{q} \bigg| \ll q^{\frac{d}{4}}\,|P|^{1-s}\,|S|^{\frac{3}{4}}. \] This estimate improves the classical point-sphere incidence bounds for arbitrary point sets across a broad parameter range. The proof combines additive energy estimates with a lifting argument that converts point-sphere incidences into point-hyperplane incidences in one higher dimension while preserving the \((4,s)\)-Salem property. As applications, we derive refined bounds for unit distances and sum-product type phenomena, and we extend the method to \((u,s)\)-Salem sets for even moments \(u\ge4\).

We show that the graph of a bent function is a Salem set in an appropriate sense. We also establish a simple result that quantifies redundancies in the difference operators of a function, which applies to bent functions over fields of odd characteristic via their equivalence to perfect non-linear functions in that setting. We end by demonstrating, by entirely elementary means, that the distance between two distinct planar functions must be at least two.

We explain the triangular gaps observed experimentally in the most popular sizes of the $h$-fold iterated sumset, $hA,$ when $A$ is a randomly chosen four-element subset of the first $q$ natural numbers, for $q$ much larger than $h.$

We introduce Frostman conditions for bivariate random variables and study discretized entropy sum-product phenomena in both independent and dependent settings. Fix $0 < s < 1$, and let $(X,Y)$ be a bivariate real random variable with bounded support, whose distribution satisfies a Frostman condition of dimension $s$. Let $φ(x,y)$ be a polynomial obtained from a diagonal polynomial $ρ_1(x)+ρ_2(y)\in \mathbb{R}[x, y]$ of degree $d\ge 2$ by applying an invertible rational linear change of variables in $(x,y)$. We show that there exists $ε= ε(φ,s)>0$ such that $$ \max\{H_n(X+Y), H_n(φ(X,Y))\} \geq n(s+ε) $$ for all sufficiently large $n$, where the precise assumptions on $(X,Y)$ depend on the Frostman level. The proof introduces a novel multi-step entropy framework, combining the submodularity formula, the discretized entropy Balog-Szemerédi-Gowers theorem, and state-of-the-art results on the Falconer distance problem, to reduce general forms to a diagonal core case. As an application, we obtain discretized sum-product type estimates. In particular, for a $δ$-separated set $A\subseteq [0, 1]$ of cardinality $δ^{-s}$, satisfying certain non-concentration conditions, and a dense subset $G\subseteq A\times A$, there exists $ε=ε(s, φ)>0$ such that $$ E_δ(A+_GA) + E_δ(φ_G(A, A)) \ggδ^{-ε}(\#A) $$ for all $δ$ small enough. Here $E_δ(A)$ denotes the $δ$-covering number of $A$, $A+_GA:=\{x+y\colon (x, y)\in G\}$, and $φ_G(A,A):=\{φ(x, y)\colon (x, y)\in G\}$.

Following recent work on the VC-dimension of subsets of various pseudorandom graphs, we study the VC-dimension of Hamming graphs, which have proved somewhat resistant to the standard techniques in the literature. Our methods are elementary, and agree with or improve upon previously known results. In particular, for $H(2,q)$ we show tight bounds on the size of a subset of vertices to guarantee VC-dimension 2 or 3. We also prove an assortment of results for other parameters, with many of these being tight as well.

We study questions inspired by Erd\H os' celebrated distance problems with dot products in lieu of distances, and for more than a single pair of points. In particular, we study point configurations present in large finite point sets in the plane that are described by weighted trees. We give new lower bounds on the number of distinct sets of dot products serving as weights for a given type of tree in any large finite point set. We also as demonstrate the existence of many repetitions of some special sets of dot products occurring in a given type of tree in different constructions, narrowing gap between the best known upper and lower bounds on these configurations.

In a previous article the authors determined the best-known upper bound for the cardinality of the image set for several classes of functions, including planar functions. Here, we show that the upper bound cannot be tight for planar functions over finite fields. This follows from a more general result proving that the upper bound cannot be tight for a much larger class of functions over an abelian group of order $y^n$ with $n>1$. Moreover, the tightness of the upper bound for the larger class of functions is equivalent to the existence of planar difference sets. To obtain better upper bounds, we first completely resolve an optimization problem involving the partitioning of a number into triangular parts. Our solution, which is algorithmic and constructive, allows us to determine tight upper bounds provided the relevant parameters are given explicitly. We also provide a suite of upper bounds which can be applied across a range of parameters. These are established via a well-studied Diophantine equation and are related to class numbers of quadratic number fields.

In this paper, we introduce a new and direct approach to study the solvability of systems of equations generated by bilinear forms. More precisely, let $B (\cdot, \cdot)$ be a non-degenerate bilinear form and $E$ be a set in $\mathbb{F}_q^2$. We prove that if $|E|\gg q^{5/3}$ then the number of triples $(B(x, y), B(y, z), B(z, x))$ with $x, y, z\in E$ is at least $cq^3$ for some positive constant $c$. This significantly improves a result due to the fifth listed author (2009).

We prove some novel multi-parameter point-line incidence estimates in vector spaces over finite fields. While these could be seen as special cases of higher-dimensional incidence results, they outperform their more general counterparts in those contexts. We go on to present a number of applications to illustrate their use in combinatorial problems from geometry and number theory.

Let $G$ be a graph and $U\subset V(G)$ be a set of vertices. For each $v\in U$, let $h_v\colon U\to \{0, 1\}$ be the function defined by \[h_v(u)=\begin{cases} &1 ~\mbox{if}~u\sim v, u\in U\\&0 ~\mbox{if}~u\not\sim v, u\in U\end{cases},\] and set $\mathcal{H}(U):=\{h_v\colon v\in U\}$. The first purpose of this paper is to study the following question: What families of graphs $G$ and what conditions on $U$ do we need so that the VC-dimension of $\mathcal{H}(U)$ can be determined? We show that if $G$ is a pseudo-random graph, then under some mild conditions, the VC dimension of $\mathcal{H}(U)$ can be bounded from below. Specific cases of this theorem recover and improve previous results on VC-dimension of functions defined by the well-studied distance and dot-product graphs over a finite field.

The main purpose of this paper is to prove that the point-line incidence bound due to Vinh (2011) over arbitrary finite fields can be improved in certain ranges by using tools from the VC-dimension theory. As consequences, a number of applications will be discussed in detail.

In this paper, we provide a general framework for counting geometric structures in pseudo-random graphs. As applications, our theorems recover and improve several results on the finite field analog of questions originally raised in the continuous setting. The results present interactions between discrete geometry, geometric measure theory, and graph theory.

The recent breakthrough of Guth, Iosevich, Ou, and Wang (2019) on the Falconer distance problem states that for a compact set $A\subset \mathbb{R}^2$, if the Hausdorff dimension of $A$ is greater than $\frac{5}{4}$, then the distance set $Δ(A)$ has positive Lebesgue measure. In a very recent paper, Murphy, Petridis, Pham, Rudnev, and Stevens (2022) proved the prime field version of this result, namely, for $E\subset\mathbb{F}_p^2$ with $|E|\gg p^{5/4}$, there exist many points $x\in E$ such that the number of distinct distances from $x$ is at least $cp$. The main purpose of this paper is to provide extensions in a very general structure of pinned trees, which is inspired by the recent work due to Ou and Taylor (2021).

Let $P \subset \mathbb R^2$ be a point set with cardinality $N$. We give an improved bound for the number of dot products determined by $P$, proving that, \[ |\{ p \cdot q :p,q \in P \}| \gg N^{2/3+c}. \] A crucial ingredient in the proof of this bound is a new superquadratic expander involving products and shifts. We prove that, for any finite set $X \subset \mathbb R$, there exist $z,z' \in X$ such that \[ \left|\frac{(zX+1)^{(2)}(z'X+1)^{(2)}}{(zX+1)^{(2)}(z'X+1)}\right| \gtrsim |X|^{5/2}. \] This is derived from a more general result concerning growth of sets defined via convexity and sum sets, and which can be used to prove several other expanders with better than quadratic growth. The proof develops arguments from recent work by the first two listed authors and Misha Rudnev, and uses predominantly elementary methods.

We study a variant of the Erd\H os unit distance problem, concerning angles between successive triples of points chosen from a large finite point set. Specifically, given a large finite set of $n$ points $E$, and a sequence of angles $(α_1,\ldots,α_k)$, we give upper and lower bounds on the maximum possible number of tuples of distinct points $(x_1,\dots, x_{k+2})\in E^{k+2}$ satisfying $\angle (x_j,x_{j+1},x_{j+2})=α_j$ for every $1\le j \le k$ as well as pinned analogues.

We explore variants of Erd\H os' unit distance problem concerning dot products between successive pairs of points chosen from a large finite subset of either $\mathbb F_q^d$ or $\mathbb Z_q^d,$ where $q$ is a power of an odd prime. Specifically, given a large finite set of points $E$, and a sequence of elements of the base field (or ring) $(α_1,\ldots,α_k)$, we give conditions guaranteeing the expected number of $(k+1)$-tuples of distinct points $(x_1,\dots, x_{k+1})\in E^{k+1}$ satisfying $x_j \cdot x_{j+1}=α_j$ for every $1\leq j \leq k$.

We study a family of variants of Erd\H os' unit distance problem, concerning distances and dot products between pairs of points chosen from a large finite point set. Specifically, given a large finite set of $n$ points $E$, we look for bounds on how many subsets of $k$ points satisfy a set of relationships between point pairs based on distances or dot products. We survey some of the recent work in the area and present several new, more general families of bounds.

We study a variant of Erd\H os' unit distance problem, concerning dot products between successive pairs of points chosen from a large finite point set. Specifically, given a large finite set of $n$ points $E$, and a sequence of nonzero dot products $(α_1,\ldots,α_k)$, we give upper and lower bounds on the maximum possible number of tuples of distinct points $(A_1,\dots, A_{k+1})\in E^{k+1}$ satisfying $A_j \cdot A_{j+1}=α_j$ for every $1\leq j \leq k$.

We present a family of sharpness examples for Falconer-type single dot product results. In particular, for $d\geq 2,$ for any $s<\frac{d+1}{2},$ we construct a Borel probability measure $μ$ satisfying the energy estimate $I_s(μ)<\infty,$ yet the estimate \begin{equation} (μ\times μ)\{(x,y):1\leq x\cdot y \leq 1+ε\} \leq Cε\end{equation} does not hold with constants independent of $ε$. It is known (\cite{EIT11}) that such an estimate always holds with $C$ independent of $ε$ if $I_{\frac{d+1}{2}}(μ)<\infty$. Thus our estimate proves the sharpness of the dimensional threshold in this result and generalizes similar results (\cite{Mat95}, \cite{IS16}) established in the case when the dot product $x \cdot y$ is replaced by the Euclidean distance function $|x-y|$, or, more generally, ${||x-y||}_K$, the distance that comes from the norm induced by a symmetric convex body $K$ with a smooth boundary and non-vanishing curvature. Our constructions are partially based on ideas that come from discrete incidence theory.