arXiv++ Combinatorics

We provide a definitive analysis of the number of correct guesses in the complete-feedback card guessing game after an asymmetric single-shelf shuffle with parameter $p\in (0, 1)$. We explicitly describe the optimal strategy that maximizes the expected number of correct guesses. We study the number of correct guesses, under an optimal strategy, using methods from analytic combinatorics. In addition, we find the explicit distribution for the number of correct guesses, and thus find the mean and the variance for the number of correct guesses. We show that the distribution of the number of correct guesses is log-concave. We also study the limiting behaviour of the number of correct guesses as the number of cards goes to infinity. In particular, we prove a (local) central limit theorem and a large deviation principle with an explicit rate function. We also prove phase transitions for the number of correct guesses near $p=0$ and $p=1$. Prior to this work, only the optimal strategy and the expected number of correct guesses under the optimal strategy were known for the special case of $p=1/2$.

We prove limit theorems for the number of fixed points, descents, and inversions of iterated random-to-top shuffles in two limiting cases. Our proofs are analytical and rely on novel combinatorial decompositions of each statistic into randomly indexed statistics of uniformly random permutations. New combinatorial proofs of the expected number of fixed points and inversions are given. Our results answer questions of Diaconis, Fulman, and Pehlivan.

We prove central limit theorems for the number of descents and the number of inversions after a shelf-shuffle. In particular, we bound the convergence rate for the number of inversions independently of the number of shelves. Along the way, we determine the mean and variance for the number of inversions after a shelf shuffle, which was also an open problem. We also suggest ways to extend our results to biased shelf-shuffles.

We investigate a one-time single shelf shuffle by establishing the position matrix explicitly. In some cases, we prove a no-feedback optimal guessing strategy. A general no-feedback strategy is conjectured, and asymptotics for the expected reward are given. For the complete-feedback case, we give a guessing strategy, prove that it is optimal and unique, and find the expected reward. Our results prove a conjecture of Diaconis, Fulman, and Holmes in a special case.