arXiv++ Combinatorics

We establish a superpolynomial lower bound on the range of the permanent function on the set of $n\times n$ matrices with $\pm1$ entries.

Understanding graph density profiles is notoriously challenging. Even for pairs of graphs, complete characterizations are known only in very limited cases, such as edges versus cliques. This paper explores a relaxation of the graph density profile problem by examining the homomorphism density domination exponent $C(H_1, H_2)$. This is the smallest real number $c \geq 0$ such that $t(H_1, T) \geq t(H_2, T)^c$ for all target graphs $T$ (if such a $c$ exists) where $t(H,T)$ is the homomorphism density from $H$ to $T$. We demonstrate that infinitely many families of graphs are required to realize $C(H_1, H_2)$ for all connected graphs $H_1$, $H_2$. We derive the homomorphism density domination exponent for a variety of graph pairs, including paths and cycles. As a couple of typical examples, we obtain exact values when $H_1$ is an even cycle and $H_2$ contains a Hamiltonian cycle, and provide asymptotically sharp bounds when both $H_1$ and $H_2$ are odd cycles.

One of Erdos's conjectures states that every triangle-free graph on $n$ vertices has an induced subgraph on $n/2$ vertices with at most $n^2/50$ edges. We report several partial results towards this conjecture. In particular, we establish the new bound $\frac{27}{1024}n^2$ on the number of edges in general case. We completely prove the conjecture for graphs of girth $\geq 5$, for graphs with independence number $\geq 2n/5$ and for strongly regular graphs. Each of these three classes includes both known (conjectured) extremal configurations, the 5-cycle and the Petersen graph.

We introduce the following combinatorial problem. Let $G$ be a triangle-free regular graph with edge density $ρ$. What is the minimum value $a(ρ)$ for which there always exist two non-adjacent vertices such that the density of their common neighborhood is $\leq a(ρ)$? We prove a variety of upper bounds on the function $a(ρ)$ that are tight for the values $ρ=2/5,\ 5/16,\ 3/10,\ 11/50$, with $C_5$, Clebsch, Petersen and Higman-Sims being respective extremal configurations. Our proofs are entirely combinatorial and are largely based on counting densities in the style of flag algebras. For small values of $ρ$, our bound attaches a combinatorial meaning to Krein conditions that might be interesting in its own right. We also prove that for any $ε>0$ there are only finitely many values of $ρ$ with $a(ρ)\geqε$ but this finiteness result is somewhat purely existential (the bound is double exponential in $1/ε$).

Given $s \ge k\ge 3$, let $h^{(k)}(s)$ be the minimum $t$ such that there exist arbitrarily large $k$-uniform hypergraphs $H$ whose independence number is at most polylogarithmic in the number of vertices and in which every $s$ vertices span at most $t$ edges. Erd\H os and Hajnal conjectured (1972) that $h^{(k)}(s)$ can be calculated precisely using a recursive formula and Erd\H os offered \$500 for a proof of this. For $k=3$ this has been settled for many values of $s$ including powers of three but it was not known for any $k\geq 4$ and $s\geq k+2$. Here we settle the conjecture for all $s \ge k \ge 4$. We also answer a question of Bhat and Rödl by constructing, for each $k \ge 4$, a quasirandom sequence of $k$-uniform hypergraphs with positive density and upper density at most $k!/(k^k-k)$. This result is sharp.

We identify three 3-graphs on five vertices each missing in all known extremal configurations for Turan's (3,4)-problem and prove Turan's conjecture for 3-graphs that are additionally known not to contain any induced copies of these 3-graphs. Our argument is based on an (apparently) new technique of "indirect interpretation" that allows us to retrieve additional structure from hypothetical counterexamples to Turan's conjecture, but in rather loose and limited sense. We also include two miscellaneous calculations in flag algebras that prove similar results about some other additional forbidden subgraphs.

We consider the problem of minimizing the number of triangles in a graph of given order and size and describe the asymptotic structure of extremal graphs. This is achieved by characterizing the set of flag algebra homomorphisms that minimize the triangle density.

The Caccetta-Haggkvist conjecture made in 1978 asserts that every orgraph on n vertices without oriented cycles of length <= l must contain a vertex of outdegree at most (n-1)/l. It has a rather elaborate set of (conjectured) extremal configurations. In this paper we consider the case l=3 that received quite a significant attention in the literature. We identify three orgraphs on four vertices each that are missing as an induced subgraph in all known extremal examples and prove the Caccetta-Haggkvist conjecture for orgraphs missing as induced subgraphs any of these orgraphs, along with cycles of length 3. Using a standard trick, we can also lift the restriction of being induced, although this makes graphs in our list slightly more complicated.

A graph H is called common if the total number of copies of H in every graph and its complement asymptotically minimizes for random graphs. A former conjecture of Burr and Rosta, extending a conjecture of Erdos asserted that every graph is common. Thomason disproved both conjectures by showing that the complete graph of order four is not common. It is now known that in fact the common graphs are very rare. Answering a question of Sidorenko and of Jagger, Stovicek and Thomason from 1996 we show that the 5-wheel is common. This provides the first example of a common graph that is not three-colorable.

Using the formalism of flag algebras, we prove that every triangle-free graph $G$ with $n$ vertices contains at most $(n/5)^5$ cycles of length five. Moreover, the equality is attained only when $n$ is divisible by five and $G$ is the balanced blow-up of the pentagon. We also compute the maximal number of pentagons and characterize extremal graphs in the non-divisible case provided $n$ is sufficiently large. This settles a conjecture made by Erdős in 1984.

In 1941, Turan conjectured that the edge density of any 3-graph without independent sets on 4 vertices (Turan (3,4)-graph) is >= 4/9(1-o(1)), and he gave the first example witnessing this bound. Brown (1983) and Kostochka (1982) found many other examples of this density. Fon-der-Flaass (1988) presented a general construction that converts an arbitrary $\vec C_4$-free orgraph $Γ$ into a Turan (3,4)-graph. He observed that all Turan-Brown-Kostochka examples result from his construction, and proved the bound >= 3/7(1-o(1)) on the edge density of any Turan (3,4)-graph obtainable in this way. In this paper we establish the optimal bound 4/9(1-o(1)) on the edge density of any Turan (3,4)-graph resulting from the Fon-der-Flaass construction under any of the following assumptions on the undirected graph $G$ underlying the orgraph $Γ$: 1. $G$ is complete multipartite; 2. The edge density of $G$ is >= (2/3-epsilon) for some absolute constant epsilon>0. We are also able to improve Fon-der-Flaass's bound to 7/16(1-o(1)) without any extra assumptions on $Γ$.

In the context of proving lower bounds on proof space in k-DNF resolution, [Ben-Sasson and Nordstrom 2009] introduced the concept of minimally unsatisfiable sets of k-DNF formulas and proved that a minimally unsatisfiable k-DNF set with m formulas can have at most O((mk)^(k+1)) variables. They also gave an example of such sets with Omega(mk^2) variables. In this paper we significantly improve the lower bound to Omega(m)^k, which almost matches the upper bound above. Furthermore, we show that this implies that the analysis of their technique for proving time-space separations and trade-offs for k-DNF resolution is almost tight. This means that although it is possible, or even plausible, that stronger results than in [Ben-Sasson and Nordstrom 2009] should hold, a fundamentally different approach would be needed to obtain such results.