arXiv++ Combinatorics

A well-known fact in linear algebra is that $A^T A$ is always positive semi-definite for any real matrix $A$. We consider a generalization of this fact via the following decision problem. Given a symbolic product of length $k$, consisting of $\ell$ variables and their transposes, such as $ABB^TCA^T$, does there exist an $n\in\mathbb N$ and an assignment of matrices from $\mathbb R^{n\times n}$ such that the resulting matrix product has a negative eigenvalue? We show that this problem is decidable and provide a simple characterization of those symbolic products that have only non-negative real eigenvalues for any assignment of matrices. This characterization can also be understood as a matrix analogue of the positive graph conjecture by Camarena, Csóka, Hubai, Lippner, and Lovász, and the proof relies on this surprising connection to graph theory.

Given a permutation $π$, let $\text{Av}_n(π)$ be the number of permutations of length $n$ that avoid $π$ as a subpermutation. The celebrated resolution of the Stanley-Wilf conjecture by Marcus and Tardos confirmed that the limit $L(π) = \lim_{n \to \infty} |\text{Av}_n(π)|^{1/n}$ exists. A central and challenging question concerns the behavior of $L(π)$ as a function of the pattern length $|π|$. While Fox proved that $L(π)$ is exponential in $|π|$ for almost all permutations, it is known that $L(π)$ grows polynomially for specific structural classes. For instance, $L(π)$ is known to be quadratic in $|π|$ when $π$ is a monotone or a layered permutation. In this paper, we address this question for {\it blockable} permutations $π$.

As a directed analog of Sidorenko's conjecture in extremal graph theory, Fox, Himwich, Zhou, and the second author defined an oriented graph $H$ to be tournament Sidorenko (anti-Sidorenko) if the random tournament asymptotically minimizes (maximizes) the number of copies of $H$ among all tournaments. We prove new inequalities of this form for oriented trees and cycles, considering both local and global notions of the Sidorenko property. We make progress on a conjecture of the aforementioned authors that every tree has an anti-Sidorenko direction, and give a characterization of short paths. For long paths we show that orientations are split symmetrically between being locally Sidorenko and anti-Sidorenko, yet almost all orientations are not globally Sidorenko. Finally, we give algorithms characterizing the local Sidorenko status of paths and cycles when the number of vertices is not divisible by four.

Jacob Fox, C. Seshadhri, Tim Roughgarden, Fan Wei, and Nicole Wein introduced the model of $c$-closed graphs--a distribution-free model motivated by triadic closure, one of the most pervasive structural signatures of social networks. While enumerating maximal cliques in general graphs can take exponential time, it is known that in $c$-closed graphs, maximal cliques and maximal complete bipartite subgraphs can always be enumerated in polynomial time. These structures correspond to blow-ups of simple patterns: a single vertex or a single edge, with some vertices required to form cliques. In this work, we explore a natural extension: we study maximal blow-ups of arbitrary finite graphs $H$ in $c$-closed graphs. We prove that for any fixed graph $H$, the number of maximal blow-ups of $H$ in an $n$-vertex $c$-closed graph is always bounded by a polynomial in $n$. We further investigate the case of induced blow-ups and provide a precise characterization of the graphs $H$ for which the number of maximal induced blow-ups is also polynomially bounded in $n$. Finally, we study the analogue questions when $H$ ranges over an infinite family of graphs.

Understanding graph density profiles is notoriously challenging. Even for pairs of graphs, complete characterizations are known only in very limited cases, such as edges versus cliques. This paper explores a relaxation of the graph density profile problem by examining the homomorphism density domination exponent $C(H_1, H_2)$. This is the smallest real number $c \geq 0$ such that $t(H_1, T) \geq t(H_2, T)^c$ for all target graphs $T$ (if such a $c$ exists) where $t(H,T)$ is the homomorphism density from $H$ to $T$. We demonstrate that infinitely many families of graphs are required to realize $C(H_1, H_2)$ for all connected graphs $H_1$, $H_2$. We derive the homomorphism density domination exponent for a variety of graph pairs, including paths and cycles. As a couple of typical examples, we obtain exact values when $H_1$ is an even cycle and $H_2$ contains a Hamiltonian cycle, and provide asymptotically sharp bounds when both $H_1$ and $H_2$ are odd cycles.

The recent successes of large language models (LLMs) have led to a surge of theoretical research into language generation. A recent line of work proposes an abstract view, called language generation in the limit, where generation is seen as a game between an adversary and an algorithm: the adversary generates strings from an unknown language $K$, chosen from a countable collection of candidate languages, and after seeing a finite set of these strings, the algorithm must generate new strings from $K$ that it has not seen before. This formalism highlights a key tension: the trade-off between validity (the algorithm should only produce strings from the language) and breadth (it should be able to produce many strings from the language). This trade-off is central in applied language generation as well, where it appears as a balance between hallucination (generating invalid utterances) and mode collapse (generating only a restricted set of outputs). Despite its importance, this trade-off has been challenging to study quantitatively. We develop ways to quantify this trade-off by formalizing breadth using measures of density. Existing algorithms for language generation in the limit produce output sets that can have zero density in the true language, and this important failure of breadth might seem unavoidable. We show, however, that such a failure is not necessary: we provide an algorithm for language generation in the limit whose outputs have strictly positive density in $K$. We also study the internal representations built by these algorithms, specifically the sequence of hypothesized candidate languages they consider, and show that achieving the strongest form of breadth may require oscillating indefinitely between high- and low-density representations. Our analysis introduces a novel topology on language families, with notions of convergence and limit points playing a key role.

Many fundamental problems in extremal combinatorics are equivalent to proving certain polynomial inequalities in graph homomorphism densities. In 2011, a breakthrough result by Hatami and Norine showed that it is undecidable to verify polynomial inequalities in graph homomorphism densities. Recently, Blekherman, Raymond and Wei extended this result by showing that it is also undecidable to determine the validity of polynomial inequalities in homomorphism densities for weighted graphs with edge weights taking real values. These two results resolved a question of Lovász. In this paper, we consider the problem of determining the validity of polynomial inequalities in digraph homomorphism densities for tournaments. We prove that the answer to this problem is also undecidable.

Alon and Shikhelman initiated the systematic study of a generalization of the extremal function. Motivated by algorithmic applications, the study of the extremal function $\text{ex}(n, K_k, K_t\text{-minor})$, i.e., the number of cliques of order $k$ in $K_t$-minor free graphs on $n$ vertices, has received much attention. In this paper, we determine essentially sharp bounds on the maximum possible number of cliques of order $k$ in a $K_t$-minor free graph on $n$ vertices. More precisely, we determine a function $C(k,t)$ such that for each $k < t$ with $t-k\gg \log_2 t$, every $K_t$-minor free graph on $n$ vertices has at most $ n C(k, t)^{1+o_t(1)}$ cliques of order $k$. We also show this bound is sharp by constructing a $K_t$-minor-free graph on $n$ vertices with $C(k, t) n$ cliques of order $k$. This bound answers a question of Wood and Fox-Wei asymptotically up to $o_t(1)$ in the exponent except the extreme values when $k$ is very close to $t$.

For a finite graph $F$ and a value $p \in [0,1]$, let $I(F,p)$ denote the largest $y$ for which there is a sequence of graphs of edge density approaching $p$ so that the induced $F$-density of the sequence approaches $y$. We show that for all $F$ on at least three vertices and all $p \in (0,1)$, the binomial random graph $G(n,p)$ has induced $F$-density strictly less than $I(F,p).$ This provides a negative answer to a problem posed by Liu, Mubayi and Reiher. Our approach is in the limiting setting of graphons, and we in fact show a stronger result: the binomial random graph is never a \emph{local} maximum in the space of graphons of edge density $p$. This is done by finding a sequence of balanced perturbations of arbitrarily small norm that increase the $F$-density.

We prove that for each $d \geq 3$ the set of all limit points of the second largest eigenvalue of growing sequences of $d$-regular graphs is $[2\sqrt{d-1},d]$. A similar argument shows that the set of all limit points of the smallest eigenvalue of growing sequences of $d$-regular graphs with growing (odd) girth is $[-d, -2 \sqrt{d-1}]$. The more general question of identifying all vectors which are limit points of the vectors of the top $k$ eigenvalues of sequences of $d$-regular graphs is considered as well. As a by product, in the study of discrete counterpart of the "scarring" phenomenon observed in the investigation of quantum ergodicity on manifolds, our technique provides a method to construct $d$-regular almost Ramanujan graphs with large girth and localized eigenvectors corresponding to eigenvalues larger than $2\sqrt{d-1}$, strengthening a result of Alon, Ganguly, and Srivastava.

Let $G$ be a multipartite graph with partition $V_1, V_2,\ldots, V_k$ of $V(G)$. Let $d_{i,j}$ denote the edge density of the pair $(V_i, V_j)$. An independent transversal is an independent set of $G$ with exactly one vertex in each $V_i$. In this paper, we prove an asymptotically sharp upper bound on the maximum number of independent transversals given the $d_{i,j}$'s.

Many problems and conjectures in extremal combinatorics concern polynomial inequalities between homomorphism densities of graphs where we allow edges to have real weights. Using the theory of graph limits, we can equivalently evaluate polynomial expressions in homomorphism densities on kernels $W$, i.e., symmetric, bounded, and measurable functions $W$ from $[0,1]^2 \to \mathbb{R}$. In 2011, Hatami and Norin proved a fundamental result that it is undecidable to determine the validity of polynomial inequalities in homomorphism densities for graphons (i.e., the case where the range of $W$ is $[0,1]$, which corresponds to unweighted graphs, or equivalently, to graphs with edge weights between $0$ and $1$). The corresponding problem for more general sets of kernels, e.g., for all kernels or for kernels with range $[-1,1]$, remains open. For any $a > 0$, we show undecidability of polynomial inequalities for any set of kernels which contains all kernels with range $\{0,a\}$. This result also answers a question raised by Lovász about finding computationally effective certificates for the validity of homomorphism density inequalities in kernels.

Ramsey's Theorem guarantees for every graph H that any 2-edge-coloring of a sufficiently large complete graph contains a monochromatic copy of H. In 1962, Erdos conjectured that the random 2-edge-coloring minimizes the number of monochromatic copies of K_k, and the conjecture was extended by Burr and Rosta to all graphs. In the late 1980s, the conjectures were disproved by Thomason and Sidorenko, respectively. A classification of graphs whose number of monochromatic copies is minimized by the random 2-edge-coloring, which are referred to as common graphs, remains a challenging open problem. If Sidorenko's Conjecture, one of the most significant open problems in extremal graph theory, is true, then every 2-chromatic graph is common, and in fact, no 2-chromatic common graph unsettled for Sidorenko's Conjecture is known. While examples of 3-chromatic common graphs were known for a long time, the existence of a 4-chromatic common graph was open until 2012, and no common graph with a larger chromatic number is known. We construct connected k-chromatic common graphs for every k. This answers a question posed by Hatami, Hladky, Kral, Norine and Razborov [Combin. Probab. Comput. 21 (2012), 734-742], and a problem listed by Conlon, Fox and Sudakov [London Math. Soc. Lecture Note Ser. 424 (2015), 49-118, Problem 2.28]. This also answers in a stronger form the question raised by Jagger, Stovicek and Thomason [Combinatorica 16, (1996), 123-131] whether there exists a common graph with chromatic number at least four.

Given a simple graph $G$, the {\it irregularity strength} of $G$, denoted $s(G)$, is the least positive integer $k$ such that there is a weight assignment on edges $f: E(G) \to \{1,2,\dots, k\}$ for which each vertex weight $f^V(v):= \sum_{u: \{u,v\}\in E(G)} f(\{u,v\})$ is unique amongst all $v\in V(G)$. In 1987, Faudree and Lehel conjectured that there is a constant $c$ such that $s(G) \leq n/d + c$ for all $d$-regular graphs $G$ on $n$ vertices with $d>1$, whereas it is trivial that $s(G) \geq n/d$. In this short note we prove that the Faudree-Lehel Conjecture holds when $d \geq n^{0.8+ε}$ for any fixed $ε>0$, with a small additive constant $c=28$ for $d$ large enough. Furthermore, we confirm the conjecture asymptotically by proving that for any fixed $β\in(0,1/4)$ there is a constant $C$ such that for all $d$-regular graphs $G$, $s(G) \leq \frac{n}{d}(1+\frac{C}{d^β})+28$, extending and improving a recent result of Przybyło that $s(G) \leq \frac{n}{d}(1+ \frac{1}{\ln^{ε/19}n})$ whenever $d\in [\ln^{1+ε} n, n/\ln^εn]$ and $d$ is large enough.

Given a simple graph $G$, the {\it irregularity strength} of $G$, denoted by $s(G)$, is the least positive integer $k$ such that there is a weight assignment on edges $f: E(G) \to \{1,2,\dots, k\}$ attributing distinct weighted degrees: $\tilde f(v):= \sum_{u: \{u,v\}\in E(G)} f(\{u,v\})$ to all vertices $v\in V(G)$. It is straightforward that $s(G) \geq n/d$ for every $d$-regular graph $G$ on $n$ vertices with $d>1$. In 1987, Faudree and Lehel conjectured in turn that there is an absolute constant $c$ such that $s(G) \leq n/d + c$ for all such graphs. Even though the conjecture has remained open in almost all relevant cases, it is more generally believed that there exists a universal constant $c$ such that $s(G) \leq n/δ+ c$ for every graph $G$ on $n$ vertices with minimum degree $δ\geq 1$ which does not contain an isolated edge. In this paper we confirm that the generalized Faudree-Lehel Conjecture holds for graphs with $δ\geq n^β$ where $β$ is any fixed constant larger than $0.8$. Furthermore, we confirm that the conjecture holds in general asymptotically. That is we prove that for any $\varepsilon\in(0,0.25)$ there exist absolute constants $c_1, c_2$ such that for all graphs $G$ on $n$ vertices with minimum degree %at least $δ\geq 1$ and without isolated edges, $s(G) \leq \frac{n}δ(1+\frac{c_1}{δ^{\varepsilon}})+c_2$, thus extending in various aspects and strengthening a recent result of Przybyło, who showed that $s(G) \leq \frac{n}{d}(1+ \frac{1}{\ln^{ε/19}n})=\frac{n}{d}(1+o(1))$ for $d$-regular graphs with $d\in [\ln^{1+ε} n, n/\ln^εn]$, and improving an earlier general upper bound: $s(G)< 6\frac{n}δ+6$ of Kalkowski, Karoński and Pfender.

We suggest two related conjectures dealing with the existence of spanning irregular subgraphs of graphs. The first asserts that any $d$-regular graph on $n$ vertices contains a spanning subgraph in which the number of vertices of each degree between $0$ and $d$ deviates from $\frac{n}{d+1}$ by at most $2$. The second is that every graph on $n$ vertices with minimum degree $δ$ contains a spanning subgraph in which the number of vertices of each degree does not exceed $\frac{n}{δ+1}+2$. Both conjectures remain open, but we prove several asymptotic relaxations for graphs with a large number of vertices $n$. In particular we show that if $d^3 \log n \leq o(n)$ then every $d$-regular graph with $n$ vertices contains a spanning subgraph in which the number of vertices of each degree between $0$ and $d$ is $(1+o(1))\frac{n}{d+1}$. We also prove that any graph with $n$ vertices and minimum degree $δ$ contains a spanning subgraph in which no degree is repeated more than $(1+o(1))\frac{n}{δ+1}+2$ times.

The Ramsey number $r(H)$ of a graph $H$ is the minimum $n$ such that any two-coloring of the edges of the complete graph $K_n$ contains a monochromatic copy of $H$. The threshold Ramsey multiplicity $m(H)$ is then the minimum number of monochromatic copies of $H$ taken over all two-edge-colorings of $K_{r(H)}$. The study of this concept was first proposed by Harary and Prins almost fifty years ago. In a companion paper, the authors have shown that there is a positive constant $c$ such that the threshold Ramsey multiplicity for a path or even cycle with $k$ vertices is at least $(ck)^k$, which is tight up to the value of $c$. Here, using different methods, we show that the same result also holds for odd cycles with $k$ vertices.

The Ramsey number $r(H)$ of a graph $H$ is the minimum integer $n$ such that any two-coloring of the edges of the complete graph $K_n$ contains a monochromatic copy of $H$. While this definition only asks for a single monochromatic copy of $H$, it is often the case that every two-edge-coloring of the complete graph on $r(H)$ vertices contains many monochromatic copies of $H$. The minimum number of such copies over all two-colorings of $K_{r(H)}$ will be referred to as the threshold Ramsey multiplicity of $H$. Addressing a problem of Harary and Prins, who were the first to systematically study this quantity, we show that there is a positive constant $c$ such that the threshold Ramsey multiplicity of a path or an even cycle on $k$ vertices is at least $(ck)^k$. This bound is tight up to the constant $c$. We prove a similar result for odd cycles in a companion paper.

A graph H is k-common if the number of monochromatic copies of H in a k-edge-coloring of K_n is asymptotically minimized by a random coloring. For every k, we construct a connected non-bipartite k-common graph. This resolves a problem raised by Jagger, Stovicek and Thomason [Combinatorica 16 (1996), 123-141]. We also show that a graph H is k-common for every k if and only if H is Sidorenko and that H is locally k-common for every k if and only if H is locally Sidorenko.

Given an infinite family ${\mathcal G}$ of graphs and a monotone property ${\mathcal P}$, an (upper) threshold for ${\mathcal G}$ and ${\mathcal P}$ is a "fastest growing" function $p: \mathbb{N} \to [0,1]$ such that $\lim_{n \to \infty} \Pr(G_n(p(n)) \in {\mathcal P})= 1$ for any sequence $(G_n)_{n \in \mathbb{N}}$ over ${\mathcal G}$ with $\lim_{n \to \infty}\lvert V(G_n) \rvert = \infty$, where $G_n(p(n))$ is the random subgraph of $G_n$ such that each edge remains independently with probability $p(n)$. In this paper we study the upper threshold for the family of $H$-minor free graphs and for the graph property of being $(r-1)$-degenerate, which is one fundamental graph property with many applications. Even a constant factor approximation for the upper threshold for all pairs $(r,H)$ is expected to be very difficult by its close connection to a major open question in extremal graph theory. We determine asymptotically the thresholds (up to a constant factor) for being $(r-1)$-degenerate for a large class of pairs $(r,H)$, including all graphs $H$ of minimum degree at least $r$ and all graphs $H$ with no vertex-cover of size at most $r$, and provide lower bounds for the rest of the pairs of $(r,H)$. The results generalize to arbitrary proper minor-closed families and the properties of being $r$-colorable, being $r$-choosable, or containing an $r$-regular subgraph, respectively.