arXiv++ Combinatorics

A multiloop with $s\in \mathbb{N}$ strands is a generic immersion $γ\colon \sqcup_1^s \mathbb{S}^1 \looparrowright Σ$ of the union of $s$ circles into a surface $Σ$, considered up to homeomorphisms. A pinning set of $γ$ is a set of points $P\subset Σ\setminus \operatorname{im}(γ)$, such that in the punctured surface $Σ\setminus P$, the immersion $γ$ has the minimal number of double points in its homotopy class. Its pinning number $\varpi(γ)$ is the minimum cardinal of its pinning sets. In any fixed orientable surface $Σ$, the pinning problem which given a multiloop $γ$ and $k\in \mathbb{N}$ decides whether $\varpi(γ)\le k$ has been show to be NP-complete, even in restrictions to loops (with $s=1$ strand). In this work we study the complexity of the pinning problem in restriction to multiloops whose strands are simple (embedded circles). We show that in any fixed oriented surface $Σ$, the problem is in P when $s\leq 3$ and NP-complete when $s\geq 20$, and present some follow-up questions and conjectures.

A multiloop $γ\colon \sqcup_1^s \mathbb{S}^1 \looparrowright \mathbb{F}$ is a generic immersion of a finite union of circles into an oriented surface, considered up to homeomorphisms. A pinning set is a set of points $P\subset \mathbb{F}\setminus \operatorname{im}(γ)$, such that in the punctured surface $\mathbb{F} \setminus P$, the immersion $γ$ has the minimal number of double points in its homotopy class. The collection of pinning sets of $γ$ forms a poset under inclusion called the pinning ideal $\mathcal{PI}(γ)$ which is endowed with the cardinal function whose minimum defines the pinning number $\varpi(γ)$. We show that the decision problem associated to computing the pinning number of a multiloop is \textsf{NP}-complete, even for loops in the sphere. We give two proofs that it is \textsf{NP}: First, we implement a polynomial algorithm to check if a point-set is pinning, adapting methods of Birman--Series and Cohen--Lustig for computing intersection numbers of curves in surfaces. Second, for loops in the sphere we reduce the problem in polynomial time to a variant of boolean satisfiability by applying a theorem of Hass--Scott characterizing taut loops, and adapting algorithms of Blank and Shor--Van Wyk which decide when a curve in the plane bounds an immersed disc. To show that it is \textsf{NP}-hard we reduce the vertex cover problem for graphs to the pinning problem for plane loops. We use our algorithms to compute the pinning ideals for $\approx 1000$ of the smallest multiloops in the sphere, available in the online catalog LooPindex.