arXiv++ Combinatorics

In this paper we prove that whenever a projective plane of odd order n contains an oval, it may be used to construct a triple array with n + 1 rows, n.n columns and n(n + 1) symbols. In particular, for any odd prime power s, we use the projective plane over the field of order s to construct an explicitly given (s + 1) times s.s triple array on s(s + 1) symbols. This is only the third infinite series of triple arrays (up to transposition) to be found. Our construction proves a recent conjecture of Gordeev and Ohman (2025) in the case of odd prime powers.

In this paper we study the structure of cellular pseudomanifolds (aka abstract polytopes). These are natural combinatorial generalisations of polytopal spheres (i.e., boundary complexes of convex polytopes). This class is closed under natural notions of duality and product. We show that they are also closed under an operation of direct product. Any cellular pseudomanifold and it's dual have homeomorphic geometric carriers, while the geometric carrier of the product of two of them is homeomorphic to the product of the carriers of the factors. The excess of a cellular pseudomanifold is defined as the non-negative integer $n - d - 2$ where $d$ is the dimension and $n$ is the number of vertices. We completely classify the cellular pseudo manifolds of excess $< 2$, and make some progress towards classifying those of excess 2.

A remarkable theorem due to Peter Dembowski states that if $I$ is an inversive plane of even order $q$ then $q$ must be a power of two and $I$ must be the incidence system of points versus plane ovals in an ovoid in the projective $3$-space over the field of order $q$. In this paper we present a short and self-contained proof of this result. Our proof depends on the classification due to Benson of the symmetric and regular finite generalized quadrangles. Included here is a deduction of Benson's Theorem from the Dembowski-Wagner combinatorial characterization of finite projective geometries.

In this paper, we attach several new invariants to connected strongly regular graphs (excepting conference graphs on non-square number of vertices) : one invariant called the discriminant, and a p-adic invariant corresponding to each prime number p. We prove parametric restrictions on quasi-symmetric 2-designs with a given connected block graph $G$ and a given defect (absolute difference of the two intersection numbers) solely in terms of the defect and the parameters of $G$, including these new invariants. This is a natural analogue of Schutzenberger's Theorem and the Shrikhande-Chowla-Ryser theorem. This theorem is effective when these graph invariants can be explicitly computed. We do this for complete multipartite graphs, co-triangular graphs, symplectic non-orthogonality graphs (over the field of order $2$) and the Steiner graphs, yielding explicit restrictions on the parameters of quasi-symmetric 2-designs whose block graphs belong to any of these four classes.

An outstanding folklore conjecture asserts that, for any prime $p$, up to isomorphism the projective plane $PG(2,\mathbb{F}_p)$ over the field $\mathbb{F}_p := \mathbb{Z}/p\mathbb{Z}$ is the unique projective plane of order $p$. Let $π$ be any projective plane of order $p$. For any partial linear space ${\cal X}$, define the inclusion number $i({\cal X},π)$ to be the number of isomorphic copies of ${\cal X}$ in $π$. In this paper we prove that if ${\cal X}$ has at most $\log_2 p$ lines, then $i({\cal X},π)$ can be written as an explicit rational linear combination (depending only on ${\cal X}$ and $p$) of the coefficients of the complete weight enumerator (c.w.e.) of the $p$-ary code of $π$. Thus, the c.w.e. of this code carries an enormous amount of structural information about $π$. In consequence, it is shown that if $p > 2^ 9=512$, and $π$ has the same c.w.e. as $PG(2,\mathbb{F}_p)$, then $π$ must be isomorphic to $PG(2,\mathbb{F}_p)$. Thus, the uniqueness conjecture can be approached via a thorough study of the possible c.w.e. of the codes of putative projective planes of prime order.

Let $p$ be a prime and let $C_p$ denote the $p$-ary code of the projective plane over ${\mathbb Z}/p\mathbb{Z}$. It is well known that the minimum weight of non-zero words in $C_p$ is $p+1$, and Chouinard proved that, for $p \geq 3$, the second and third minimum weights are $2p$ and $2p+1$. In 2007, Fack et. al. determined, for $p\geq 5$, all words of $C_p$ of these three weights. In this paper we recover all these results and also prove that, for $p \geq 5$, the fourth minimum weight of $C_p$ is $3p-3$. The problem of determining all words of weight $3p-3$ remains open.

For a field $\mathbb{F}$, the notion of $\mathbb{F}$-tightness of simplicial complexes was introduced by Kühnel. Kühnel and Lutz conjectured that any $\mathbb{F}$-tight triangulation of a closed manifold is the most economic of all possible triangulations of the manifold. The boundary of a triangle is the only $\mathbb{F}$-tight triangulation of a closed 1-manifold. A triangulation of a closed 2-manifold is $\mathbb{F}$-tight if and only if it is $\mathbb{F}$-orientable and neighbourly. In this paper we prove that a triangulation of a closed 3-manifold is $\mathbb{F}$-tight if and only if it is $\mathbb{F}$-orientable, neighbourly and stacked. In consequence, the Kühnel-Lutz conjecture is valid in dimension $\leq 3$.

Tightness is a generalisation of the notion of convexity: a space is tight if and only if it is "as convex as possible", given its topological constraints. For a simplicial complex, deciding tightness has a straightforward exponential time algorithm, but efficient methods to decide tightness are only known in the trivial setting of triangulated surfaces. In this article, we present a new polynomial time procedure to decide tightness for triangulations of $3$-manifolds -- a problem which previously was thought to be hard. Furthermore, we describe an algorithm to decide general tightness in the case of $4$-dimensional combinatorial manifolds which is fixed parameter tractable in the treewidth of the $1$-skeletons of their vertex links, and we present an algorithm to decide $\mathbb{F}_2$-tightness for weak pseudomanifolds $M$ of arbitrary but fixed dimension which is fixed parameter tractable in the treewidth of the dual graph of $M$.

It is well known that a triangulation of a closed 2-manifold is tight with respect to a field of characteristic two if and only if it is neighbourly; and it is tight with respect to a field of odd characteristic if and only if it is neighbourly and orientable. No such characterization of tightness was previously known for higher dimensional manifolds. In this paper, we prove that a triangulation of a closed 3-manifold is tight with respect to a field of odd characteristic if and only if it is neighbourly, orientable and stacked. In consequence, the Kühnel-Lutz conjecture is valid in dimension three for fields of odd characteristic. Next let $\mathbb{F}$ be a field of characteristic two. It is known that, in this case, any neighbourly and stacked triangulation of a closed 3-manifold is $\mathbb{F}$-tight. For triangulated closed 3-manifolds with at most 71 vertices or with first Betti number at most 188, we show that the converse is true. But the possibility of an $\mathbb{F}$-tight non-stacked triangulation on a larger number of vertices remains open. We prove the following upper bound theorem on such triangulations. If an $\mathbb{F}$-tight triangulation of a closed 3-manifold has $n$ vertices and first Betti number $β_1$, then $(n-4)(617n- 3861) \leq 15444β_1$. Equality holds here if and only if all the vertex links of the triangulation are connected sums of boundary complexes of icosahedra.

In a recent work [2] with Datta, we introduced the mu vector (with respect to a given field) of simplicial complexes and used it to study tightness and lower bounds. In this paper, we modify the definition of mu vectors. With the new definition, most results of [2] become correct without the hypothesis of 2-neighbourliness. In particular, the combinatorial Morse inequalities of [2] are now true of all simplicial complexes. As an application, we prove the following generalized lower bound theorem (GLBT) for connected locally tame combinatorial manifolds. If $M$ is such a manifold of dimension $d$, then for $1 \leq \ell \leq \frac{d-1}{2}$ and any field $\mathbb{F}, ~ g_{\ell+1} (M) \geq \binom{d+2}{\ell+1} \sum\limits_{i=1}^\ell (-1)^{\ell-i} β_i (M;\mathbb{F})$. Equality holds here if and only if $M$ is $\ell$-stacked. We conjecture that, more generally, this theorem is true of all triangulated connected and closed homology manifolds. A conjecture on the sigma vectors of triangulated homology spheres is proposed, whose validity will imply this GLB Conjecture for homology manifolds. We also prove the GLBC for all connected and closed combinatorial 3-manifolds. Thus, any connected closed combinatorial manifold $M$ of dimension three satisfies $g_2 (M) \geq 10 β_1 (M;\mathbb{F})$, with equality iff $M$ is 1-stacked. This result settles a question of Novik and Swartz [6] in the affirmative.

We introduce the class $Σ_k(d)$ of $k$-stellated (combinatorial) spheres of dimension $d$ ($0 \leq k \leq d + 1$) and compare and contrast it with the class ${\cal S}_k(d)$ ($0 \leq k \leq d$) of $k$-stacked homology $d$-spheres. We have $Σ_1(d) = {\cal S}_1(d)$, and $Σ_k(d) \subseteq {\cal S}_k(d)$ for $d \geq 2k - 1$. However, for each $k \geq 2$ there are $k$-stacked spheres which are not $k$-stellated. The existence of $k$-stellated spheres which are not $k$-stacked remains an open question. We also consider the class ${\cal W}_k(d)$ (and ${\cal K}_k(d)$) of simplicial complexes all whose vertex-links belong to $Σ_k(d - 1)$ (respectively, ${\cal S}_k(d - 1)$). Thus, ${\cal W}_k(d) \subseteq {\cal K}_k(d)$ for $d \geq 2k$, while ${\cal W}_1(d) = {\cal K}_1(d)$. Let $\bar{\cal K}_k(d)$ denote the class of $d$-dimensional complexes all whose vertex-links are $k$-stacked balls. We show that for $d\geq 2k + 2$, there is a natural bijection $M \mapsto \bar{M}$ from ${\cal K}_k(d)$ onto $\bar{\cal K}_k(d + 1)$ which is the inverse to the boundary map $\partial \colon \bar{\cal K}_k(d + 1) \to {\cal K}_k(d)$.

We introduce the $k$-stellated spheres and consider the class ${\cal W}_k(d)$ of triangulated $d$-manifolds all whose vertex links are $k$-stellated, and its subclass ${\cal W}^{\ast}_k(d)$ consisting of the $(k+1)$-neighbourly members of ${\cal W}_k(d)$. We introduce the mu-vector of any simplicial complex and show that, in the case of 2-neighbourly simplicial complexes, the mu-vector dominates the vector of its Betti numbers componentwise; the two vectors are equal precisely for tight simplicial complexes. We are able to estimate/compute certain alternating sums of the components of the mu-vector of any 2-neighbourly member of ${\cal W}_k(d)$ for $d\geq 2k$. As one consequence of this theory, we prove a lower bound theorem for such triangulated manifolds, as well as determine the integral homology type of members of ${\cal W}^{\ast}_k(d)$ for $d \geq 2k+2$. As another application, we prove that, when $d \neq 2k+1$, all members of ${\cal W}^{\ast}_k(d)$ are tight. We also characterize the tight members of ${\cal W}^{\ast}_k(2k + 1)$ in terms of their $k^{\rm th}$ Betti numbers. These results more or less answer a recent question of Effenberger, and also provide a uniform and conceptual tightness proof for all except two of the known tight triangulated manifolds. We also prove a lower bound theorem for triangulated manifolds in which the members of ${\cal W}_1(d)$ provide the equality case. This generalises a result (the $d=4$ case) due to Walkup and Kuehnel. As a consequence, it is shown that every tight member of ${\cal W}_1(d)$ is strongly minimal, thus providing substantial evidence in favour of a conjecture of Kuehnel and Lutz asserting that tight triangulated manifolds should be strongly minimal.

Generalizing a result (the case $k = 1$) due to M. A. Perles, we show that any polytopal upper bound sphere of odd dimension $2k + 1$ belongs to the generalized Walkup class ${\cal K}_k(2k + 1)$, i.e., all its vertex links are $k$-stacked spheres. This is surprising since the $k$-stacked spheres minimize the face-vector (among all polytopal spheres with given $f_0,..., f_{k - 1}$) while the upper bound spheres maximize the face vector (among spheres with a given $f_0$). It has been conjectured that for $d\neq 2k + 1$, all $(k + 1)$-neighborly members of the class ${\cal K}_k(d)$ are tight. The result of this paper shows that, for every $k$, the case $d = 2k +1$ is a true exception to this conjecture.

After a brief discussion of the history of the problem, we propose a generalization of the map colouring problem to higher dimensions.

The symmetric group $S_3$ acts on $S^2 \times S^2 \times S^2$ by coordinate permutation, and the quotient space $(S^2 \times S^2 \times S^2)/S_3$ is homeomorphic to the complex projective space $\CC P^3$. In this paper, we construct an 124-vertex simplicial subdivision $(S^2 \times S^2 \times S^2)_{124}$ of the 64-vertex standard cellulation $S^2_4 \times S^2_4 \times S^2_4$ of $S^2 \times S^2 \times S^2$, such that the $S_3$-action on this cellulation naturally extends to an action on $(S^2 \times S^2 \times S^2)_{124}$. Further, the $S_3$-action on $(S^2 \times S^2 \times S^2)_{124}$ is "good", so that the quotient simplicial complex $(S^2 \times S^2 \times S^2)_{124}/S_3$ is a 30-vertex triangulation $\CC P^3_{30}$ of $\CC P^3$. In other words, we construct a simplicial realization $(S^2 \times S^2 \times S^2)_{124} \to \CC P^3_{30}$ of the branched covering $S^2 \times S^2 \times S^2 \to \CC P^3$. Finally, we apply the BISTELLAR program of Lutz on $\CC P^3_{30}$, resulting in an 18-vertex 2-neighbourly triangulation $\CC P^3_{18}$ of $\CC P^3$. The automorphism group of $\CC P^3_{18}$ is trivial. It may be recalled that, by a result of Arnoux and Marin, any triangulation of $\CC P^3$ requires at least 17 vertices. So, $\CC P^3_{18}$ is close to vertex-minimal, if not actually vertex-minimal. Moreover, no explicit triangulation of $\CC P^3$ was known so far.

We present two constructions in this paper: (a) A 10-vertex triangulation $\CC P^{2}_{10}$ of the complex projective plane $\CC P^{2}$ as a subcomplex of the join of the standard sphere ($S^{2}_4$) and the standard real projective plane ($\RR P^{2}_{6}$, the decahedron), its automorphism group is $A_4$; (b) a 12-vertex triangulation $(S^{2} \times S^{2})_{12}$ of $S^{2} \times S^{2}$ with automorphism group $2S_5$, the Schur double cover of the symmetric group $S_5$. It is obtained by generalized bistellar moves from a simplicial subdivision of the standard cell structure of $S^{2} \times S^{2}$. Both constructions have surprising and intimate relationships with the icosahedron. It is well known that $\CC P^{2}$ has $S^{2} \times S^{2}$ as a two-fold branched cover; we construct the triangulation $\CC P^{2}_{10}$ of $\CC P^{2}$ by presenting a simplicial realization of this covering map $S^{2} \times S^{2} \to \CC P^{2}$. The domain of this simplicial map is a simplicial subdivision of the standard cell structure of $S^{2} \times S^{2}$, different from the triangulation alluded to in (b). This gives a new proof that Kuehnel's $\CC P^{2}_{9}$ triangulates $\CC P^{2}$. It is also shown that $\CC P^{2}_{10}$ and $(S^{2} \times S^{2})_{12}$ induce the standard piecewise linear structure on $\CC P^{2}$ and $S^{2} \times S^{2}$ respectively.

For $d \geq 2$, Walkup's class ${\cal K}(d)$ consists of the $d$-dimensional simplicial complexes all whose vertex-links are stacked $(d-1)$-spheres. Kalai showed that for $d \geq 4$, all connected members of ${\cal K}(d)$ are obtained from stacked $d$-spheres by finitely many elementary handle additions. According to a result of Walkup, the face vector of any triangulated 4-manifold $X$ with Euler characteristic $χ$ satisfies $f_1 \geq 5f_0 - {15/2} χ$, with equality only for $X \in {\cal K}(4)$. Kühnel observed that this implies $f_0(f_0 - 11) \geq -15χ$, with equality only for 2-neighborly members of ${\cal K}(4)$. Kühnel also asked if there is a triangulated 4-manifold with $f_0 = 15$, $χ= -4$ (attaining equality in his lower bound). In this paper, guided by Kalai's theorem, we show that indeed there is such a triangulation. It triangulates the connected sum of three copies of the twisted sphere product $S^3 \times {-2.8mm}_{-} S^1$. Because of Kühnel's inequality, the given triangulation of this manifold is a vertex-minimal triangulation. By a recent result of Effenberger, the triangulation constructed here is tight. Apart from the neighborly 2-manifolds and the infinite family of $(2d+ 3)$-vertex sphere products $S^{d-1} \times S^1$ (twisted for $d$ odd), only fourteen tight triangulated manifolds were known so far. The present construction yields a new member of this sporadic family. We also present a self-contained proof of Kalai's result.

In this paper we present a self-contained combinatorial proof of the lower bound theorem for normal pseudomanifolds, including a treatment of the cases of equality in this theorem. We also discuss McMullen and Walkup's generalised lower bound conjecture for triangulated spheres in the context of the lower bound theorem. Finally, we pose a new lower bound conjecture for non-simply connected triangulated manifolds.

Via a computer search, Altshuler and Steinberg found that there are 1296 +1 combinatorial 3-manifolds on nine vertices, of which only one is non-sphere. This exceptional 3-manifold $K^{3}_{9}$ triangulates the twisted $S^{2}$-bundle over $S^{1}$. It was first constructed by Walkup. In this paper, we present a computer-free proof of the uniqueness of this non-sphere combinatorial 3-manifold. As opposed to the computer-generated proof, ours does not require wading through all the 9-vertex 3-spheres. As a preliminary result, we also show that any 9-vertex combinatorial 3-manifold is equivalent by proper bistellar moves to a 9-vertex neighbourly 3-manifold.

For integers $d \geq 2$ and $ε= 0$ or 1, let $S^{1, d - 1}(ε)$ denote the sphere product $S^{1} \times S^{d - 1}$ if $ε= 0$ and the twisted $S^{d - 1}$ bundle over $S^{1}$ if $ε= 1$. The main results of this paper are: (a) if $d \equiv ε$ (mod 2) then $S^{1, d - 1}(ε)$ has a unique minimal triangulation using $2d + 3$ vertices, and (b) if $d \equiv 1 - ε$ (mod 2) then $S^{1, d - 1}(ε)$ has minimal triangulations (not unique) using $2d + 4$ vertices. The second result confirms a recent conjecture of Lutz. The first result provides the first known infinite family of closed manifolds (other than spheres) for which the minimal triangulation is unique. Actually, we show that while $S^{1, d - 1}(ε)$ has at most one $(2d + 3)$-vertex triangulation (one if $d \equiv ε$ (mod 2), zero otherwise), in sharp contrast, the number of non-isomorphic $(2d + 4)$-vertex triangulations of these $d$-manifolds grows exponentially with $d$ for either choice of $ε$. The result in (a), as well as the minimality part in (b), is a consequence of the following result: (c) for $d \geq 3$, there is a unique $(2d + 3)$-vertex simplicial complex which triangulates a non-simply connected closed manifold of dimension $d$. This amazing simplicial complex was first constructed by Kühnel in 1986. Generalizing a 1987 result of Brehm and Kühnel, we prove that (d) any triangulation of a non-simply connected closed $d$-manifold requires at least $2d + 3$ vertices. The result (c) completely describes the case of equality in (d). The proofs rest on the Lower Bound Theorem for normal pseudomanifolds and on a combinatorial version of Alexander duality.