Papers by Bo Ning
84 paper(s) by this author
· All BibTeX
On the difference between clique partition and clique covering numbers of graphs
For a graph $G$, let $\cpn(G)$ and $\ccn(G)$ denote the minimum numbers of cliques whose edge sets partition and cover $E(G)$, respectively, and put $f(n)=\max_{|V(G)|=n}\bigl(\cpn(G)-\ccn(G)\bigr).$ In 1983, Erdős, Faudree, and Ordman asked whether there is a sequence of graphs $G_n$ such that $|V(G_n)|=n$ and $\cpn(G_n)-\ccn(G_n)=n^2/4+O(n)$. The question appears as Problem 66 in Chung's survey \cite{ChungProblems} and is also listed on the UCSD Erdős Problems website. Caccetta, Erdős, Ordman, and Pullman proved that $f(n)=n^2/4-o(n^2)$. We prove that $f(n)=\left\lfloor\frac{n^2}{4}\right\rfloor-Θ(n^{4/3}),$ and hence answer the question in the negative.
Kohayakawa's conjecture and clique coverings of complements of paths and cycles
For $s\ge1$, let $G_s$ be the bipartite graph between the $s$-subsets and the $(s-1)$-subsets of $[2s]$, where adjacency means disjointness, and let $w(s)$ be the maximum number of $s$-subsets on an induced path in $G_s$. We prove $w(s)\ge \frac{4^s}{2048s^{5/2}}$ for all $s\geq 6$. This implies $\sup_{s\ge1}w(s)^{1/s}=4$, as conjectured by Kohayakawa (1991). His recursive construction then gives induced paths of order $Ω(4^r/r^{5/2})$ in the Kneser graph $KG(2r+1,r)$ and yields \[
\max\{\cc(\overline{P_n}),\ \cc(\overline{C_n})\}
\le \log_2 n+\frac52\log_2\log_2 n+O(1). \] Together with the known lower bounds, this settles a conjecture of de Caen, Gregory, and Pullman (1985) and gives \[
\cc(\overline{P_n})=\log_2 n+Θ(\log_2\log_2 n),
\qquad
\cc(\overline{C_n})=\log_2 n+Θ(\log_2\log_2 n). \] We also give an independent proof of the latter order estimates. It uses a Hamiltonicity result of Kneser graphs and a key lemma proved by the Lovász local lemma.
Nikiforov's spectral consecutive cycle problem and the connected-matching method
Let $ρ(G)$ denote the adjacency spectral radius of a graph $G$ of order $n$. We determine the sharp constant in an open problem of Nikiforov (2008) on cycles of consecutive lengths. For every $\varepsilon>0$ and all sufficiently large $n$, if $G$ is an $n$-vertex graph with $ρ(G)>\sqrt{\lfloor{n^2/4}\rfloor},$ then $G$ contains a cycle $C_\ell$ for every integer length $3\le \ell\le (\frac{3-\sqrt5}{2}-\varepsilon)n.$ The constant $(3-\sqrt5)/2$ is best possible, as shown by the split graph $K_k\vee\overline K_{n-k}$ with $k\sim(3-\sqrt5)n/4$. Our result improves all previous results [LAA2008, CPC2020, JGT2023, JGT2023, GC2024]. The proof combines the degree form of Szemerédi's regularity lemma, a spectral matching theorem of Feng-Yu-Zhang, Weyl's inequality, a refinement of Łuczak's connected-matching embedding method, and other ideas.
A complete solution to the Boots-Royle/Cao-Vince conjecture
Boots and Royle, and independently Cao and Vince, conjectured that the join of an edge and a path on $n-2$ vertices is the unique planar graph of maximum adjacency spectral radius for $n\geq 9$. Tait and Tobin (JCTB, 2017) proved the conjecture for sufficiently large order. In this paper, we completely resolved the Boots-Royle/Cao-Vince conjecture.
The largest Laplacian eigenvalue of induced-$K_{1,r}$-free graphs
Let $G$ be a simple graph of maximum degree $d$, and let $μ(G)$ denote the largest eigenvalue of its Laplacian matrix. For a fixed integer $k\geq 2$, Aharoni, Alon, and Berger (2016) asked whether every graph containing no induced copy of $K_{1,k}$ satisfies $μ(G)\leq (2 - \frac{2}{k} + o(1)) d$. We answer this question by proving the stronger sharp bound \[ μ(G)\leq \left(2-\frac{2}{k}\right)(d+1). \] The proof combines a sign decomposition of a Laplacian Rayleigh vector with a weighted local Caro-Wei type inequality for independent sets.
Two problems of Burr, Erd\H os, Graham, and Sós on maximal anti-Ramsey functions for $P_4$
Burr, Erd\H os, Graham, and Sós introduced the maximal anti-Ramsey function $χ_{\mathrm{S}}(n,e,L)$, the minimum number of colors required over all $n$-vertex graphs with at least $e$ edges such that every copy of $L$ is rainbow. In \cite{BEGS1989}, they posed the following two problems: (i) Is it true that there exists $C>0$, such that for all $u\ge 1$, $χ_{\mathrm{S}}\left(n,\lfloor un \rfloor,P_4 \right)<Cu$ holds for all sufficiently large $n$? (ii) Is it true that for all $ε>0$, there exists $c(ε)>0$ such that for all sufficiently large $n$, \\ $χ_{\mathrm{S}}\left(n,\binom{n}{2}-\lfloor n^{2-ε} \rfloor,P_4 \right)>c(ε)n^{2}$? In this note, we give an affirmative answer to the first problem and a negative answer to the second problem.
For the first problem, our proof uses a local density inequality with strong edge-colorings of odd Kneser graphs. In particular, our proof uses the characterization by Lužar, Máčajová, Škoviera, and Soták of~$k$-regular graphs whose strong chromatic index equals~$2k-1$. For the second result, our main tool is the construction of Alon, Moitra, and Sudakov. We show that for every fixed~$0<ε<1/2$ there exist~$γ>0$ and arbitrarily large~$n$ such that~$χ_{\mathrm{S}}\bigl(n,\tbinom{n}{2}-\lfloor n^{2-ε}\rfloor,P_4\bigr)\;\le\; n^{2-γ}=o(n^{2}).$
Rainbow triangles in edge-colored graphs with large minimum color degree
Let $G$ be an edge-colored graph on $n$ vertices, and let $\deltac(G)$ denote its minimum color degree. Li and, independently Li, Ning, Xu, and Zhang, proved that every edge-colored graph on $n$ vertices with $\deltac(G) \ge \frac{n+1}{2}$ contains a rainbow triangle. Let $\rt(G)$ denote the number of rainbow triangles in $G$, and define \[ f(n) = \min\{ \rt(G) : |V(G)| = n,\ \deltac(G) \ge (n+1)/2 \}. \] In \cite{LiNingShiZhang2024}, the following open problem was posed: determine all the values of $f(n)$. In this paper, we determine $f(n)$ completely: $f(n) = (n^2-1)/8$ for odd $n\geq 3$, $f(n) = \frac{n^2}{4} - 1$ for all even $n \ge 6,$ and $f(4) = 4$. This resolves an open problem raised in \cite{LiNingShiZhang2024}.
Counting triangles in graphs with no wheels of order at least five
For a family of graphs $\mathcal F$, a graph $G$ is said to be $\mathcal F$-free if it contains no member of $\mathcal F$ as a subgraph. A wheel graph $W_k$ is a graph on $k+1$ vertices formed by joining a new vertex to all vertices of a $k$-cycle. Given an integer $k\ge 3$, we consider the problem of determining the maximum number of triangles in a $W_{\geq k}$-free graph, where $W_{\geq k}=\{W_\ell: \ell \geq k\}$. The case $k=3$ was raised by Gallai, who proposed a conjecture for this case (see Erdős [5]. Gallai's conjecture was disproved by Zhou [17] and independently by Füredi, Goemans, and Kleitman [9]. In this paper, we study the case $k=4$. Namely, for every integer $n\ge 3$, we determine the maximum number of triangles in an $n$-vertex $W_{\geq 4}$-free graph and characterize all extremal graphs.
Longest cycles and Dirac-type results in highly connected graphs
A classical theorem of Nash-Williams states that if $G$ is a $2$-connected graph on $n$ vertices with minimum degree at least $(n+2)/3$, then for every longest cycle $C$ of $G$, the graph $G-V(C)$ is edgeless. Motivated by a higher-connectivity analogue, Bondy conjectured in 1980 that if $G$ is a $k$-connected graph on $n$ vertices with minimum degree at least $(n+k(k-1))/(k+1)$, then for every longest cycle $C$ of $G$, every path in $G-V(C)$ has at most $k-1$ vertices. This conjecture is known for $k\le 3$ and remains open for all $k\ge 4$.
In this paper, we prove Bondy's conjecture for all sufficiently large graphs. The key ingredient is a new Dirac-type theorem that gives a lower bound on the length of a longest cycle in a $k$-connected graph, which also yields a partial solution to a conjecture of Jung from 1990. Along the way, we develop several new tools, including a DFS lemma and an average-degree analogue of the Bondy--Jackson theorem. We conclude with a discussion of related problems and a counterexample to a conjecture of Voss from 1991.
A Proof of a Conjecture on Positive and Negative Square Energies of Unicyclic Graphs
Let $G$ be a unicyclic graph of order $n$, and let $k$ be the length of the unique cycle of $G$. For the adjacency eigenvalues of $G$, let $s^{+}(G)$ and $s^{-}(G)$ denote the sums of the squares of the positive and negative eigenvalues, respectively. Akbari, Kumar, Mohar, Pragada, and Zhang conjectured that, when $k$ is odd, the value of $k$ modulo $4$ determines which of $s^+(G)$ and $s^-(G)$ is greater than $n$. More precisely, if $k\equiv 3\pmod 4$, then $s^+(G)>n>s^-(G)$; if $k\equiv 1\pmod 4$, then $s^+(G)<n<s^-(G)$. We confirm this conjecture.
On spectral Turán theorems: confirming a conjecture of Guiduli and two problems of Nikiforov
Let $G$ be an $n$-vertex graph, and let $λ(G)$ and $λ_n(G)$ denote the largest and smallest eigenvalues of its adjacency matrix. Write $e(G)$ for the number of edges of $G$, $d(G)=2e(G)/n$ for its average degree, and $T_r(n)$ for the $r$-partite Turán graph on $n$ vertices.
We prove four sharp results in spectral Turán theory. First, we confirm Guiduli's spectral dense-neighborhood conjecture (1996) in a stronger form: if $λ(G)\ge λ(T_r(n))$, then either $G\cong T_r(n)$, or there exists a vertex $v$ such that $λ(G[N(v)]) > λ(T_{r-1}(d(v)))$. Moreover, when $λ(G)>λ(T_r(n))$, every vertex attaining the maximum entry in any nonnegative Perron eigenvector of $G$ has this property. Second, we answer a problem of Nikiforov (2009) by showing that the exact Turán edge threshold is detected by the exact spectral threshold: for every $r\ge 2$ and every $n$, $λ(G)<λ(T_r(n))$, implying $e(G)<e(T_r(n)).$ Our proof also determines the equality cases. Third, we answer another question of Nikiforov (2009) by showing that his least-eigenvalue clique bound \[ ω(G)\ge 1+\frac{2e(G)}{(n-d(G))(d(G)-λ_n(G))} \] does imply the concise form of Turán's theorem. Finally, we discuss an open problem proposed by Ai et al. (2026) in \cite{ALNS26+}.
An exponentially small gap of the Perron vector on independent sets
A classical result of Cioabă states that if $G$ is a connected graph with the unit Perron vector $\mathbf{x}$, then any independent set $S$ of $G$ satisfies $\sum_{v\in S} x_v^2 \le \frac{1}{2}$, with equality if and only if $G$ is a bipartite graph and $S$ is one of the partite sets. Let $χ(G)= k $ be the chromatic number of $G$. A well-known conjecture of Gregory asserts that any independent set $S$ of $G$ satisfies $\frac{1}{2} - \sum_{v\in S}x_v^2 = Ω((k/n)^{1/2})$. Recently, Liu and Ning [J. Combin. Theory Ser. B 176 (2026)] disproved Gregory's conjecture by constructing a graph $G$ and an independent set $S$ such that $\frac{1}{2}- \sum_{v\in S}x_v^2 = O(k^5/n^3)$. Furthermore, they conjectured that this bound is tight up to a constant factor. In this paper, we first show that any cycle $C_n$ with odd integer $n\ge 7$ provides a simple counterexample to Gregory's conjecture. Second, we establish that for any independent set $S$, we have $\frac{1}{2} - \sum_{v\in S}x_v^2 = \frac{q}{4λ-2q}$, where $λ$ is the spectral radius of $G$, and $q$ is the Rayleigh quotient of $\mathbf{x}$ restricted to $\bar{S} :=V(G)\setminus S$. Third, we construct a graph with arbitrarily large chromatic number and find an independent set $S$ such that $\sum_{v\in S}x_v^2$ can be arbitrarily close to $\frac{1}{2}$, with an exponentially small gap. Our construction shows that there is no universal lower bound of the form $Ω(k^α/n^β)$ for any $α, β>0$. This settles both Gregory's original conjecture and the modified conjecture of Liu and Ning in the negative. Finally, we show the tightness of our construction and provide some local weighted lower bounds.
On Scott's odd induced subgraph conjecture and a related problem
For a graph $G$, let $f_o(G)$ denote the maximum order of an induced subgraph of $G$ all of whose vertices have odd degree, and let $χ(G)$ denote the chromatic number of $G$. Scott (CPC, 1992) proved that $f_o(G) \ge |V(G)|/(2χ(G))$ for every graph without isolated vertices, and conjectured that the factor $2$ can be removed. Wang and Wu (JGT, 2024) showed that this conjecture fails for bipartite graphs, but holds for line graphs. In this article, we confirm Scott's conjecture for claw-free graphs without isolated vertices, thereby strengthening the result of Wang and Wu. We also construct $K_{1,r}$-free graphs of arbitrarily large order to show that the conjecture fails for this broader class, for every integer $r \ge 4$.
Wang and Wu also asked whether $f_o(L(G)) \ge n/2$ holds for every connected regular graph $G$ of order $n \ge 3$. We show that $C_5$ is the smallest counterexample to this problem. On the positive side, we prove that if $G$ is a connected $k$-regular $C_5$-free graph on $n$ vertices with $k \ge 2$, then $f_o(L(G)) \ge n/2$.
On derivatives and higher-order derivatives of chromatic polynomials
Let \( G \) be a graph of order \( n \) with maximum degree $Δ$, and let $P(G,x)$ denote its chromatic polynomial. We investigate several properties of $P(G,x)$ related to its derivatives and higher-order derivatives. First, we study the monotonicity of $P(G,x)/x^n$. Dong proved that $(x-1)^nP(G,x)\geq x^nP(G,x-1)$ for all real $x\geq n$. In particular, taking $x=n$ establishes the Bartels-Welsh ``shameful conjecture" that $P(G,n)/P(G,n-1)>e$. Fadnavis later showed that the same inequality holds for all real $x\geq 36Δ^{\frac{3}{2}}$. We improve this bound by proving that it already holds for all real $x\geq 10Δ^{\frac{3}{2}}$. We then consider a conjecture of Dong, Ge, Gong, Ning, Ouyang, and Tay asserting that \( \frac{d^k}{dx^k} \bigl( \ln[(-1)^n P(G, x)] \bigr) < 0 \) for all \( k \geq 2 \) and \( x \in (-\infty, 0) \). We establish this conjecture for all \( k \geq 2 \) and \( x\leq -2.99Δk \).
On the chromatic profile for tripartite graphs and beyond
Let $H$ be a graph and let $δ_χ(H,r)$ denote the infimum of $c$ such that every $H$-free graph with minimum degree at least $cn$ is $r$-colorable. The \textit{chromatic profile} of $H$ is defined to be the values of $δ_χ(H,r)$ as $r$ varies. Erdős and Simonovits described this graph parameter as ``too complicated", and Allen, Böttcher, Griffiths, Kohayakawa, and Morris posed its determination for every graph $H$ as an open problem \cite[Problem~45]{ABGKM2013}, emphasizing its expected difficulty.
In this paper, we resolve the case $r=2$ for every graph $H$ with $χ(H)=3$. We show that the set of possible values of $δ_χ(H,2)$ with $χ(H)=3$ is finite and discrete: $$\{δ_χ(H,2):χ(H)=3\}=\left\{\frac{1}{2},\frac{2}{5},\frac{2}{7},\frac{1}{4},\frac{2}{9},\frac{1}{5},\frac{2}{11},\frac{1}{6}\right\}.$$ Furthermore, we provide a complete structural characterization of the graphs $H$ associated with each threshold value. Moreover, we extend the classical chromatic profile result for triangle to color-critical graphs $H$ with $g_{\mathrm{odd}}(H)=χ(H)=3$.
Our approach introduces a useful auxiliary parameter. Motivated by the notion of vertex-extendability of Liu, Mubayi, and Reiher \cite{liu2023unified}, we define the {\it vertex-extendable threshold} of $H$, denoted by $δ_{\mathrm{ext}}(H,r)$, as the infimum of $c\in (0,1)$ so that for every $H$-free graph $G$ on $n$ vertices, the existence of a vertex $v \in V(G)$ with $χ(G - v) \leq r$ combined with $δ(G)\ge cn$ implies that $G$ is $r$-colorable. A key structural consequence is that $δ_χ(H,2) = \max\left\{δ_χ(C_{2k+1},2),δ_{\mathrm{ext}}(H,2)\right\},$ where $H$ is a color-critical graph with $χ(H)=3$ and $g_{\mathrm{odd}}(H)=2k+1$ for $k\geq 2$.
Extensions of Erdős's 1962 theorem on non-Hamiltonian graphs
For a positive integer $k$, a graph property $\mathcal{H}$, and a graph parameter $\mathcal{P}$, let $\operatorname{ex}_{\mathcal{P}}(n, \mathcal{H}; δ\geq k)$ denote the maximum value of $\mathcal{P}$ over all $n$-vertex graphs with minimum degree at least $k$ that do not possess the property $\mathcal{H}$. The corresponding extremal families are denoted by $\operatorname{EX}_{\mathcal{P}}(n, \mathcal{H}; δ\geq k)$. For two disjoint graphs $H_1$ and $H_2$, let $H_1 \cup H_2$ denote their (disjoint) union, i.e., the graph with vertex set $V(H_1) \cup V(H_2)$ and edge set $E(H_1) \cup E(H_2)$; and let $H_1 \vee H_2$ denote their join.
In 1962, Erdős established a classical theorem on the maximum number of edges in a non-Hamiltonian graph of given order and minimum degree. Motivated by recent work on feasible graph parameters in \cite{Ai2023}, we prove several extensions of Erdős's 1962 theorem on non-Hamiltonian graphs.
The first result gives a common generalization of the extremal theorem due to Erdős and its spectral analogs. As direct applications, we obtain complete solutions to open problems raised in the literature since 2016, thereby improving nearly all related prior results in this direction. Our proof technique differs somewhat from those in \cite{MR3539577,MR3556876}. We also prove an analog theorem for the Hamiltonian-connected property and obtain a result which extends the theorem of Füredi, Kostochka, and Luo \cite{MR3843180} on Hamilton cycles.
A short proof of a perturbation inequality for the spectral radius
Let $G$ be a simple graph, and denote by $λ(G)$ its spectral radius. Sun and Das (2020) established that for any non-isolated vertex $v$ with degree $d(v)$, \[ λ(G)\leq \sqrt{λ(G-v)^2 + 2d(v) - 1}, \] which is a conjecture original posed by Guo, Wang, and Li (2019). Sun and Das's proof uses several tools from spectral graph theory. In this short note, we provide a concise and self-contained proof of this inequality using matrix analysis.
An Improved Interpolation Theorem and Disproofs of Two Conjectures on 2-Connected Subgraphs
We prove that any \(2\)-connected graph \(G\) on \(n\) vertices with minimum degree \(δ(G) \ge \frac{n}{4}+2\) contains a \(2\)-connected subgraph of order \(k\) for every integer \(k\) with \(4 \le k \le n\). This improves a previous result of Yin and Wu. In \cite{YinWu-DAM-2026}, Yin and Wu proposed two conjectures. The first states that for any \(2\)-connected graph \(G\) of order \(n\) and size \(m\), there exists a \(2\)-connected subgraph of order \(k\) for each \(k \in \{4, \dots, n\}\) whenever \(m \ge \frac{1}{2} n^{3/2}\). The second conjecture asserts that the same conclusion holds under the alternative condition \(δ(G) \ge \sqrt{n}\). In this paper, we construct counterexamples that completely disprove the first conjecture. Furthermore, using the existence of \((v, k, 2)\)-Symmetric Balanced Incomplete Block designs (i.e., SBIBDs), we disprove the second conjecture for all \(n \in \{8, 14, 22, 32, 74, 112, 158\}\). Finally, we propose a conjecture of our own: for any \(2\)-connected graph \(G\) on \(n\) vertices with \(δ(G) \ge \frac{n}{k}\), where \(k \ge 3\) and \(n\) is sufficiently large, \(G\) contains a \(2\)-connected subgraph of every order from \(4\) to \(n\).
Exact Turán numbers of two vertex-disjoint paths
The Turán number of a graph $H$ is the maximum number of edges in any graph of order $n$ that does not contain $H$ as a subgraph. In 1959, Erd\H os and Gallai obtained a sharp upper bound of Turán numbers for a path of arbitrary length. In 1975, Faudree and Schelp, and independently in 1977, Kopylov determined the exact values of Turán numbers of paths with arbitrary length. In this paper, we determine the Turán number of two vertex-disjoint paths of odd order at least 4. Together with previous works, we determine the exact Turán numbers of two vertex-disjoint paths completely. This confirms the first $k=2$ case of a conjecture proposed by Yuan and Zhang in 2021, which generalizes the Turán number formula of paths due to Faudree-Schelp, and Kopylov in a broader setting. Our main tools include a refinement of Pósa's rotation lemma, a stability result of Kopylov's theorem on cycles, and a recent inequality on circumference, minimum degree, and clique number of a 2-connected graph.
A new spectral Turán theorem for weighted graphs and consequences
Confirming a conjecture of Elphick and Edwards and strengthening a spectral theorem of Wilf, Nikiforov proved that for any $K_{r+1}$-free graph $G$, $λ(G)^2 \leq 2 (1 - 1/r) m$, where $λ(G)$ is the spectral radius of $G$, and $m$ is the number of edges of $G$. This result was later improved in \cite{LiuN26}, where it was shown that for any graph $G$, $λ(G)^2 \leq 2 \sum_{e \in E(G)} \frac{\mathrm{cl}(e) - 1}{\mathrm{cl}(e)}$, where $\mathrm{cl}(e)$ denotes the order of the largest clique containing the edge $e$. In this paper, we further extend this inequality to weighted graphs, proving that \[ λ(G)^2 \leq 2 \sum_{e \in E(G)} \frac{\mathrm{cl}(e) - 1}{\mathrm{cl}(e)} w(e)^2, \] and we characterize all extremal graphs attaining this bound. Our main theorem yields several new consequences, including two vertex-based and vertex-degree-based local versions of Turán's theorem, as well as weighted generalizations of the Edwards--Elphick theorem and the Cvetković theorem, and two localized versions of Wilf's theorems. One of these localized Wilf's theorem confirms a conjecture that originates from Probability and Operator Algebras and was proposed by R. Tripathi independently of us. Moreover, our main result unifies and implies numerous earlier ones from spectral graph theory and extremal graph theory, including Stanley's spectral inequality, Hong's inequality, a localized Turán-type theorem, and a recent extremal theorem by Adak and Chandran. Notably, while Nikiforov's earlier spectral inequality implied Stanley's bound, it did not imply Hong's inequality -- a gap that is now bridged by our result. As a key tool, we establish the inequality $\sum_{e \in E(G)} \frac{2}{\mathrm{cl}(e)} \geq n-1$, which complements an upper bound $\sum_{e \in E(G)} \frac{2}{\mathrm{cl}(e)-1} \leq n^2 - 2m$ due to Bradač, and Malec and Tompkins, independently.