arXiv++ Combinatorics

It is known that a real symmetric circulant matrix with diagonal entries $d\geq0$, off-diagonal entries $\pm1$ and orthogonal rows exists only of order $2d+2$ (and trivially of order $1$) [Turek and Goyeneche 2019]. In this paper we consider a complex Hermitian analogy of those matrices. That is, we study the existence and construction of Hermitian circulant matrices having orthogonal rows, diagonal entries $d\geq0$ and any complex entries of absolute value $1$ off the diagonal. As a particular case, we consider matrices whose off-diagonal entries are 4th roots of unity; we prove that the order of any such matrix with $d$ different from an odd integer is $n=2d+2$. We also discuss a similar problem for symmetric circulant matrices defined over finite rings $\mathbb{Z}_m$. As an application of our results, we show a close connection to mutually unbiased bases, an important open problem in quantum information theory.

Classification of entanglement in multipartite quantum systems is an open problem solved so far only for bipartite systems and for systems composed of three and four qubits. We propose here a coarse-grained classification of entanglement in systems consisting of $N$ subsystems with an arbitrary number of internal levels each, based on properties of orthogonal arrays with $N$ columns. In particular, we investigate in detail a subset of highly entangled pure states which contains all states defining maximum distance separable codes. To illustrate the methods presented, we analyze systems of four and five qubits, as well as heterogeneous tripartite systems consisting of two qubits and one qutrit or one qubit and two qutrits.

We study the existence and construction of circulant matrices $C$ of order $n\geq2$ with diagonal entries $d\geq0$, off-diagonal entries $\pm1$ and mutually orthogonal rows. These matrices generalize circulant conference ($d=0$) and circulant Hadamard ($d=1$) matrices. We demonstrate that matrices $C$ exist for every order $n$ and for $d$ chosen such that $n=2d+2$, and we find all solutions $C$ with this property. Furthermore, we prove that if $C$ is symmetric, or $n-1$ is prime, or $d$ is not an odd integer, then necessarily $n=2d+2$. Finally, we conjecture that the relation $n=2d+2$ holds for every matrix $C$, which generalizes the circulant Hadamard conjecture. We support the proposed conjecture by computing all the existing solutions up to $n=50$.