arXiv++ Combinatorics

A theorem of Dougherty--Jackson--Kechris states that any equivalence relation generated by a single Borel function is hypersmooth. A well-known open problem is whether this can be generalized to equivalence relations generated by countable families of pairwise commuting Borel functions. We give an affirmative answer in the case where the functions are bounded-to-one. This generalizes the theorem of Gao--Jackson on Borel actions of countable abelian groups.

Let $G$ be a locally finite multigraph that is bipartite and "unbalanced," meaning that it has a nontrivial bipartition $(A,B)$ with $°(x) > °(y)$ for all $x \in A$ and $y \in B$. We explore matchings in such graphs through the lens of descriptive set theory. In particular, we show that when $G$ is Borel and $μ$ is a Borel probability measure on its vertex set, there is a Borel matching in $G$ that covers $μ$-almost every vertex in $A$. This was previously known only under the assumption that $μ$ is $G$-invariant, which we eliminate using a novel probabilistic approach. We also describe various extra conditions that imply the existence of a Borel matching covering every vertex in $A$. Along the way, we confirm a conjecture of the first and third named authors concerning the existence of Borel independent complete sections in Borel graphs of finite asymptotic separation index. In addition to their intrinsic interest, our results have applications to various other topics, such as edge-colorings, balanced orientations, and equidecomposition theory for group actions. For example, we show that the measurable edge-chromatic number of every Borel multigraph with finite maximum degree $Δ$ is at most $\lfloor\frac{3Δ}{2}\rfloor$, matching Shannon's optimal bound for finite multigraphs. Another example is that paradoxical Borel group actions with finite asymptotic separation index admit paradoxical decompositions with Borel pieces. This refines a result of Marks and Unger.

We answer a recent question of Csóka and Vidnyánszky [arXiv:2407.10006] and give an alternate proof of one of their results. The subject of both is which finite graphs admit factor of i.i.d. homomorphisms from the 3-regular tree. We then give yet another proof of the result in the Borel setting which leads to the following: For each $d > 2$ and $k \in \mathbb{N}$, there is a Borel hyperfinite $d$-regular forest $G$ and a finite graph with chromatic number $k$, $H$, so that $G$ does not admit a Borel homomorphism to $H$. All of this is tied together by a focus on the case when the target graph $H$ is a (subgraph of a) Kneser graph.

A locally checkable labeling problem (LCL) on a group $Γ$ asks one to find a labeling of the Cayley graph of $Γ$ satisfying a fixed, finite set of "local" constraints. Typical examples include proper coloring and perfect matching problems. In descriptive combinatorics, one often considers the existence of solutions to LCLs in the setting of descriptive set theory. For example, given a free action of $Γ$ on a Polish space $X$, we might be interested in solving a given LCL on each orbit in a continuous, Borel, measurable, etc. way. In an attempt to understand more finely the gap between Borel and continuous combinatorics, we consider the existence of Baire class $m$ solutions to LCLs. For all $n > 1$ and $m \in ω$, we produce an LCL on $\mathbb{F}_n$ which always admits Baire class $m+1$ solutions, but not necessarily Baire class $m$ solutions.

We show that a circle and square of the same area in $\mathbb{R}^2$ are equidecomposable by translations using $\mathbfΔ^0_2$ pieces. That is, pieces which are simultaneously $F_σ$ and $G_δ$ sets. This improves a result of Máthé-Noel-Pikhurko and is the best possible complexity in terms of the Borel hierarchy. More generally we show that bounded sets $A,B \subseteq \mathbb{R}^n$ with small enough boundaries and the same nonzero Lebesgue measure are equidecomposable with pieces that are countable unions of finite Boolean combinations of translates of $A,B$, and open sets. The improvement comes from constructions of low complexity toasts and related objects which should be independently useful within Borel combinatorics.

We study the complexity of locally checkable labeling (LCL) problems on $\mathbb{Z}^n$ from the point of view of descriptive set theory, computability theory, and factors of i.i.d. Our results separate various complexity classes that were not previously known to be distinct and serve as counterexamples to a number of natural conjectures in the field.

We show that every $d$-regular bipartite Borel graph admits a Baire measurable $k$-regular spanning subgraph if and only if $d$ is odd or $k$ is even. This gives the first example of a locally checkable coloring problem which is known to have a Baire measurable solution on Borel graphs but not a computable solution on highly computable graphs. We also prove the analogous result in the measure setting for hyperfinite graphs.

Asymptotic separation index is a parameter that measures how easily a Borel graph can be approximated by its subgraphs with finite components. In contrast to the more classical notion of hyperfiniteness, asymptotic separation index is well-suited for combinatorial applications in the Borel setting. The main result of this paper is a Borel version of the Lovász Local Lemma -- a powerful general-purpose tool in probabilistic combinatorics -- under a finite asymptotic separation index assumption. As a consequence, we show that locally checkable labeling problems that are solvable by efficient randomized distributed algorithms admit Borel solutions on bounded degree Borel graphs with finite asymptotic separation index. From this we derive a number of corollaries, for example a Borel version of Brooks's theorem for graphs with finite asymptotic separation index.

We study the position of the computable setting in the "common theory of locality" developed in arXiv:2106.02066 and arXiv:2204.09329 for local problems on $Δ$-regular trees, $Δ\in ω$. We show that such a problem admits a computable solution on every highly computable $Δ$-regular forest if and only if it admits a Baire measurable solution on every Borel $Δ$-regular forest. We also show that if such a problem admits a computable solution on every computable maximum degree $Δ$ forest then it admits a continuous solution on every maximum degree $Δ$ Borel graph with appropriate topological hypotheses, though the converse does not hold.

We introduce new types of local algorithms, which we call "ASI Algorithms", and use them to demonstrate a link between descriptive and computable combinatorics. This allows us to unify arguments from the two fields, and also sometimes to port arguments from one field to the other. As an example, we generalize a computable combinatorics result of Kierstead and use it to get within one color of the Baire measurable analogue of Vizing's Theorem. We also improve Kierstead's result for multigraphs along the way.

Let $X$ be a Polish space with Borel probability measure $μ,$ and let $G$ be a Borel graph on $X$ with no odd cycles and maximum degree $Δ(G).$ We show that the Baire measurable edge chromatic number of $G$ is at most $Δ(G)+1$, and if $G$ is $μ$-hyperfinite then the $μ$-measurable edge chromatic number obeys the same bound. More generally, we show that $G$ has Borel edge chromatic number at most $Δ(G)$ plus its asymptotic separation index.