arXiv++ Combinatorics

The game of i-Mark is an impartial combinatorial game introduced by Sopena (2016). The game is parametrized by two sets of positive integers $S$, $D$, where $\min D\ge 2$. From position $n\ge 0$ one can move to any position $n-s$, $s\in S$, as long as $n-s\ge 0$, as well as to any position $n/d$, $d\in D$, as long as $n>0$ and $d$ divides $n$. The game ends when no more moves are possible, and the last player to move is the winner. Sopena, and subsequently Friman and Nivasch (2021), characterized the Sprague-Grundy sequences of many cases of i-Mark$(S,D)$ with $|D|=1$. Friman and Nivasch also obtained some partial results for the case i-Mark$(\{1\},\{2,3\})$. In this paper we present a convergence technique that gives polynomial-time algorithms for the Sprague-Grundy sequence of many instances of i-Mark with $|D|>1$. In particular, we prove our technique works for all games i-Mark$(\{1\},\{d_1,d_2\})$. Keywords: Combinatorial game, impartial game, Sprague-Grundy function, convergence, dynamic programming.

Erickson defined the fusible numbers as a set $\mathcal F$ of reals generated by repeated application of the function $\frac{x+y+1}{2}$. Erickson, Nivasch, and Xu showed that $\mathcal F$ is well ordered, with order type $\varepsilon_0$. They also investigated a recursively defined function $M\colon \mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{R}$. They showed that the set of points of discontinuity of $M$ is a subset of $\mathcal F$ of order type $\varepsilon_0$. They also showed that, although $M$ is a total function on $\mathbb R$, the fact that the restriction of $M$ to $\mathbb{Q}$ is total is not provable in first-order Peano arithmetic $\mathsf{PA}$. In this paper we explore the problem (raised by Friedman) of whether similar approaches can yield well-ordered sets $\mathcal F$ of larger order types. As Friedman pointed out, Kruskal's tree theorem yields an upper bound of the small Veblen ordinal for the order type of any set generated in a similar way by repeated application of a monotone function $g:\mathbb R^n\to\mathbb R$. The most straightforward generalization of $\frac{x+y+1}{2}$ to an $n$-ary function is the function $\frac{x_1+\cdots+x_n+1}{n}$. We show that this function generates a set $\mathcal F_n$ whose order type is just $\varphi_{n-1}(0)$. For this, we develop recursively defined functions $M_n\colon \mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{R}$ naturally generalizing the function $M$. Furthermore, we prove that for any linear function $g:\mathbb R^n\to\mathbb R$, the order type of the resulting $\mathcal F$ is at most $\varphi_{n-1}(0)$. Finally, we show that there do exist continuous functions $g:\mathbb R^n\to\mathbb R$ for which the order types of the resulting sets $\mathcal F$ approach the small Veblen ordinal.

Let $S$ be a set of positive integers, and let $D$ be a set of integers larger than $1$. The game $i$-Mark$(S,D)$ is an impartial combinatorial game introduced by Sopena (2016), which is played with a single pile of tokens. In each turn, a player can subtract $s \in S$ from the pile, or divide the size of the pile by $d \in D$, if the pile size is divisible by $d$. Sopena partially analyzed the games with $S=[1, t-1]$ and $D=\{d\}$ for $d \not\equiv 1 \pmod t$, but left the case $d \equiv 1 \pmod t$ open. We solve this problem by calculating the Sprague-Grundy function of $i$-Mark$([1,t-1],\{d\})$ for $d \equiv 1 \pmod t$, for all $t,d \geq 2$. We also calculate the Sprague-Grundy function of $i$-Mark$(\{2\},\{2k + 1\})$ for all $k$, and show that it exhibits similar behavior. Finally, following Sopena's suggestion to look at games with $|D|>1$, we derive some partial results for the game $i$-Mark$(\{1\}, \{2, 3\})$, whose Sprague-Grundy function seems to behave erratically and does not show any clean pattern. We prove that each value $0,1,2$ occurs infinitely often in its SG sequence, with a maximum gap length between consecutive appearances.

Inspired by a mathematical riddle involving fuses, we define the "fusible numbers" as follows: $0$ is fusible, and whenever $x,y$ are fusible with $|y-x|<1$, the number $(x+y+1)/2$ is also fusible. We prove that the set of fusible numbers, ordered by the usual order on $\mathbb R$, is well-ordered, with order type $\varepsilon_0$. Furthermore, we prove that the density of the fusible numbers along the real line grows at an incredibly fast rate: Letting $g(n)$ be the largest gap between consecutive fusible numbers in the interval $[n,\infty)$, we have $g(n)^{-1} \ge F_{\varepsilon_0}(n-c)$ for some constant $c$, where $F_α$ denotes the fast-growing hierarchy. Finally, we derive some true statements that can be formulated but not proven in Peano Arithmetic, of a different flavor than previously known such statements: PA cannot prove the true statement "For every natural number $n$ there exists a smallest fusible number larger than $n$." Also, consider the algorithm "$M(x)$: if $x<0$ return $-x$, else return $M(x-M(x-1))/2$." Then $M$ terminates on real inputs, although PA cannot prove the statement "$M$ terminates on all natural inputs."

It is known that for every dimension $d\ge 2$ and every $k<d$ there exists a constant $c_{d,k}>0$ such that for every $n$-point set $X\subset \mathbb R^d$ there exists a $k$-flat that intersects at least $c_{d,k} n^{d+1-k} - o(n^{d+1-k})$ of the $(d-k)$-dimensional simplices spanned by $X$. However, the optimal values of the constants $c_{d,k}$ are mostly unknown. The case $k=0$ (stabbing by a point) has received a great deal of attention. In this paper we focus on the case $k=1$ (stabbing by a line). Specifically, we try to determine the upper bounds yielded by two point sets, known as the "stretched grid" and the "stretched diagonal". Even though the calculations are independent of $n$, they are still very complicated, so we resort to analytical and numerical software methods. We provide strong evidence that, surprisingly, for $d=4,5,6$ the stretched grid yields better bounds than the stretched diagonal (unlike for all cases $k=0$ and for the case $(d,k)=(3,1)$, in which both point sets yield the same bound). Our experiments indicate that the stretched grid yields $c_{4,1}\leq 0.00457936$, $c_{5,1}\leq 0.000405335$, and $c_{6,1}\leq 0.0000291323$.

Let $T(d,r) = (r-1)(d+1)+1$ be the parameter in Tverberg's theorem, and call a partition $\mathcal I$ of $\{1,2,\ldots,T(d,r)\}$ into $r$ parts a "Tverberg type". We say that $\mathcal I$ "occurs" in an ordered point sequence $P$ if $P$ contains a subsequence $P'$ of $T(d,r)$ points such that the partition of $P'$ that is order-isomorphic to $\mathcal I$ is a Tverberg partition. We say that $\mathcal I$ is "unavoidable" if it occurs in every sufficiently long point sequence. In this paper we study the problem of determining which Tverberg types are unavoidable. We conjecture a complete characterization of the unavoidable Tverberg types, and we prove some cases of our conjecture for $d\le 4$. Along the way, we study the avoidability of many other geometric predicates. Our techniques also yield a large family of $T(d,r)$-point sets for which the number of Tverberg partitions is exactly $(r-1)!^d$. This lends further support for Sierksma's conjecture on the number of Tverberg partitions.

Given a finite point set $P\subset\mathbb{R}^d$, we call a multiset $A$ a one-sided weak $\varepsilon$-approximant for $P$ (with respect to convex sets), if $|P\cap C|/|P|-|A\cap C|/|A|\leq\varepsilon$ for every convex set $C$. We show that, in contrast with the usual (two-sided) weak $\varepsilon$-approximants, for every set $P\subset \mathbb{R}^d$ there exists a one-sided weak $\varepsilon$-approximant of size bounded by a function of $\varepsilon$ and $d$.

Grinblat (2002) asks the following question in the context of algebras of sets: What is the smallest number $\mathfrak v = \mathfrak v(n)$ such that, if $A_1, \ldots, A_n$ are $n$ equivalence relations on a common finite ground set $X$, such that for each $i$ there are at least $\mathfrak v$ elements of $X$ that belong to $A_i$-equivalence classes of size larger than $1$, then $X$ has a rainbow matching---a set of $2n$ distinct elements $a_1, b_1, \ldots, a_n, b_n$, such that $a_i$ is $A_i$-equivalent to $b_i$ for each $i$? Grinblat has shown that $\mathfrak v(n) \le 10n/3 + O(\sqrt{n})$. He asks whether $\mathfrak v(n) = 3n-2$ for all $n\ge 4$. In this paper we improve the upper bound (for all large enough $n$) to $\mathfrak v(n) \le 16n/5 + O(1)$.

Let $X$ be a convex curve in the plane (say, the unit circle), and let $\mathcal S$ be a family of planar convex bodies, such that every two of them meet at a point of $X$. Then $\mathcal S$ has a transversal $N\subset\mathbb R^2$ of size at most $1.75\cdot 10^9$. Suppose instead that $\mathcal S$ only satisfies the following "$(p,2)$-condition": Among every $p$ elements of $\mathcal S$ there are two that meet at a common point of $X$. Then $\mathcal S$ has a transversal of size $O(p^8)$. For comparison, the best known bound for the Hadwiger--Debrunner $(p, q)$-problem in the plane, with $q=3$, is $O(p^6)$. Our result generalizes appropriately for $\mathbb R^d$ if $X\subset \mathbb R^d$ is, for example, the moment curve.

In 2008, Bukh, Matousek, and Nivasch conjectured that for every n-point set S in R^d and every k, 0 <= k <= d-1, there exists a k-flat f in R^d (a "centerflat") that lies at "depth" (k+1) n / (k+d+1) - O(1) in S, in the sense that every halfspace that contains f contains at least that many points of S. This claim is true and tight for k=0 (this is Rado's centerpoint theorem), as well as for k = d-1 (trivial). Bukh et al. showed the existence of a (d-2)-flat at depth (d-1) n / (2d-1) - O(1) (the case k = d-2). In this paper we concentrate on the case k=1 (the case of "centerlines"), in which the conjectured value for the leading constant is 2/(d+2). We prove that 2/(d+2) is an *upper bound* for the leading constant. Specifically, we show that for every fixed d and every n there exists an n-point set in R^d for which no line in R^d lies at depth larger than 2n/(d+2) + o(n). This point set is the "stretched grid"---a set which has been previously used by Bukh et al. for other related purposes. Hence, in particular, the conjecture is now settled for R^3.

A set N is called a "weak epsilon-net" (with respect to convex sets) for a finite set X in R^d if N intersects every convex set that contains at least epsilon*|X| points of X. For every fixed d>=2 and every r>=1 we construct sets X in R^d for which every weak (1/r)-net has at least Omega(r log^{d-1} r) points; this is the first superlinear lower bound for weak epsilon-nets in a fixed dimension. The construction is a "stretched grid", i.e., the Cartesian product of d suitable fast-growing finite sequences, and convexity in this grid can be analyzed using "stair-convexity", a new variant of the usual notion of convexity. We also consider weak epsilon-nets for the diagonal of our stretched grid in R^d, d>=3, which is an "intrinsically 1-dimensional" point set. In this case we exhibit slightly superlinear lower bounds (involving the inverse Ackermann function), showing that upper bounds by Alon, Kaplan, Nivasch, Sharir, and Smorodinsky (2008) are not far from the truth in the worst case. Using the stretched grid we also improve the known upper bound for the so-called "second selection lemma" in the plane by a logarithmic factor: We obtain a set T of t triangles with vertices in an n-point set in the plane such that no point is contained in more than O(t^2 / (n^3 log (n^3/t))) triangles of T.

The following result was proved by Barany in 1982: For every d >= 1 there exists c_d > 0 such that for every n-point set S in R^d there is a point p in R^d contained in at least c_d n^{d+1} - O(n^d) of the simplices spanned by S. We investigate the largest possible value of c_d. It was known that c_d <= 1/(2^d(d+1)!) (this estimate actually holds for every point set S). We construct sets showing that c_d <= (d+1)^{-(d+1)}, and we conjecture this estimate to be tight. The best known lower bound, due to Wagner, is c_d >= gamma_d := (d^2+1)/((d+1)!(d+1)^{d+1}); in his method, p can be chosen as any centerpoint of S. We construct n-point sets with a centerpoint that is contained in no more than gamma_d n^{d+1}+O(n^d) simplices spanned by S, thus showing that the approach using an arbitrary centerpoint cannot be further improved. We also prove that for every n-point set S in R^d there exists a (d-2)-flat that stabs at least c_{d,d-2} n^3 - O(n^2) of the triangles spanned by S, with c_{d,d-2}>=(1/24)(1- 1/(2d-1)^2). To this end, we establish an equipartition result of independent interest (generalizing planar results of Buck and Buck and of Ceder): Every mass distribution in R^d can be divided into 4d-2 equal parts by 2d-1 hyperplanes intersecting in a common (d-2)-flat.