arXiv++ Combinatorics

Given two $n$-vertex graphs $G_1$ and $G_2$ of bounded treewidth, is there an $n$-vertex graph $G$ of bounded treewidth having subgraphs isomorphic to $G_1$ and $G_2$? Our main result is a negative answer to this question, in a strong sense: we show that the answer is no even if $G_1$ is a binary tree and $G_2$ is a ternary tree. We also provide an extensive study of cases where such `gluing' is possible. In particular, we prove that if $G_1$ has treewidth $k$ and $G_2$ has pathwidth $\ell$, then there is an $n$-vertex graph of treewidth at most $k + 3 \ell + 1$ containing both $G_1$ and $G_2$ as subgraphs.

In this paper we study syntactic branching programs of bounded repetition representing CNFs of bounded treewidth. For this purpose we introduce two new structural graph parameters $d$-pathwidth and clique preserving $d$-pathwidth denoted by $d-pw(G)$ and $d-cpw(G)$ where $G$ is a graph. We show that $2-cpw(G) \leq O(tw(G) Δ(G))$ where $tw(G)$ and $Δ(G)$ are, respectively the treewidth and maximal degree of $G$. Using this upper bound, we demonstrate that each CNF $ψ$ can be represented as a conjunction of two OBDDs of size $2^{O(Δ(ψ)*tw(ψ)^2)}$ where $tw(ψ)$ is the treewidth of the primal graph of $ψ$ and each variable occurs in $ψ$ at most $Δ(ψ)$ times. Next we use $d$-pathwdith to obtain lower bounds for monotone branching programs. In particular, we consider the monotone version of syntactic nondeterministic read $d$ times branching programs (just forbidding negative literals as edge labels) and introduce a further restriction that each computational path can be partitioned into at most $d$ read-once subpaths. We call the resulting model separable monotone read $d$ times branching programs and abbreviate them $d$-SMNBPs. For each graph $G$ without isolated vertices, we introduce a CNF $ψ(G)$ whsose clauses are $(u \vee e \vee v)$ for each edge $e=\{u,v\}$ of $G$. We prove that a $d$-SMNBP representing $ψ(G)$ is of size at least $Ω(c^{d-pw(G)})$ where $c=(8/7)^{1/12}$. We use this 'generic' lower bound to obtain an exponential lower bound for a 'concrete' class of CNFs $ψ(K_n)$. In particular, we demonstrate that for each $0<a<1$, the size of $n^{a}$-SMNBP representing $ψ(K_n)$ is at least $c^{n^b}$ where $b$ is an arbitrary constant such that $a+b<1$. This lower bound is tight in the sense $ψ(K_n)$ can be represented by a poly-sized $n$-SMNBP.

We introduce a new graph parameter called linear upper maximum induced matching width \textsc{lu-mim width}, denoted for a graph $G$ by $lu(G)$. We prove that the smallest size of the \textsc{obdd} for $\varphi$, the monotone 2-\textsc{cnf} corresponding to $G$, is sandwiched between $2^{lu(G)}$ and $n^{O(lu(G))}$. The upper bound is based on a combinatorial statement that might be of an independent interest. We show that the bounds in terms of this parameter are best possible.

We prove that the tree-width of graphs in a hereditary class defined by a finite set $F$ of forbidden induced subgraphs is bounded if and only if $F$ includes a complete graph, a complete bipartite graph, a tripod (a forest in which every connected component has at most 3 leaves) and the line graph of a tripod.

It is known that a positive Boolean function f depending on n variables has at least n + 1 extremal points, i.e. minimal ones and maximal zeros. We show that f has exactly n + 1 extremal points if and only if it is linear read-once. The class of linear read-once functions is known to be the intersection of the classes of read-once and threshold functions. Generalizing this result we show that the class of linear read-once functions is the intersection of read-once and Chow functions. We also find the set of minimal read-once functions which are not linear read-once and the set of minimal threshold functions which are not linear read-once. In other words, we characterize the class of linear read-once functions by means of minimal forbidden subfunctions within the universe of read-once and the universe of threshold functions. Within the universe of threshold functions the importance of linear read-once func- tions is due to the fact that they attain the minimum value of the specification number, which is n + 1 for functions depending on n variables. In 1995 Anthony et al. conjec- tured that for all other threshold functions the specification number is strictly greater than n + 1. We disprove this conjecture by exhibiting a threshold non-linear read-once function depending on n variables whose specification number is n + 1.

We introduce a new structural graph parameter called \emph{partial matching width}. For each (sufficiently large) integer $k \geq 1$, we introduce a class $\mathcal{G}_k$ of graphs of treewidth at most $k$ and max-degree $7$ such that for each $G \in \mathcal{G}_k$ and each (sufficiently large) $V \subseteq V(G)$, the partial matching width of $V$ is $Ω(k \log |V|)$. We use the above lower bound to establish a lower bound on the size of non-deterministic read-once branching programs (NROBPs). In particular, for each sufficiently large ineteger $k$, we introduce a class ${\bf Φ}_k$ of CNFs of (primal graph) treewidth at most $k$ such that for any $\varphi \in {\bf Φ}_k$ and any Boolean function $F \subseteq \varphi$ and such that $|\varphi|/|F| \leq 2^{\sqrt{n}}$ (here the functions are regarded as sets of assignments on which they are true), a NROBP implementing $F$ is of size $n^{Ω(k)}$. This result significantly generalises an earlier result of the author showing a non-FPT lower bound for NROBPs representing CNFs of bounded treewidth. Intuitively, we show that not only those CNFs but also their arbitrary one side approximations with an exponential ratio still attain that lower bound. The non-trivial aspect of this approximation is that due to a small number of satisfying assignments for $F$, it seems difficult to establish a large bottleneck: the whole function can `sneak' through a single rectangle corresponding to just \emph{one} vertex of the purported bottleneck. We overcome this problem by simultaneously exploring $\sqrt{n}$ bottlenecks and showing that at least one of them must be large. This approach might be useful for establishing other lower bounds for branching programs.

An extremal point of a positive threshold Boolean function $f$ is either a maximal zero or a minimal one. It is known that if $f$ depends on all its variables, then the set of its extremal points completely specifies $f$ within the universe of threshold functions. However, in some cases, $f$ can be specified by a smaller set. The minimum number of points in such a set is the specification number of $f$. It was shown in [S.-T. Hu. Threshold Logic, 1965] that the specification number of a threshold function of $n$ variables is at least $n+1$. In [M. Anthony, G. Brightwell, and J. Shawe-Taylor. On specifying Boolean functions by labelled examples. Discrete Applied Mathematics, 1995] it was proved that this bound is attained for nested functions and conjectured that for all other threshold functions the specification number is strictly greater than $n+1$. In the present paper, we resolve this conjecture negatively by exhibiting threshold Boolean functions of $n$ variables, which are non-nested and for which the specification number is $n+1$. On the other hand, we show that the set of extremal points satisfies the statement of the conjecture, i.e., a positive threshold Boolean function depending on all its $n$ variables has $n+1$ extremal points if and only if it is nested. To prove this, we reveal an underlying structure of the set of extremal points.

We present a hereditary class of graphs of unbounded clique-width which is well-quasi-ordered by the induced subgraph relation. This result provides a negative answer to the question asked by Daligault, Rao and Thomassé in ("Well-quasi-order of relabel functions", Order, 27(3):301--315, 2010).

Recently, Daligault, Rao and Thomassé asked in [3] if every hereditary class which is well-quasi-ordered by the induced subgraph relation is of bounded clique-width. There are two reasons why this questions is interesting. First, it connects two seemingly unrelated notions. Second, if the question is answered affirmatively, this will have a strong algorithmic consequence. In particular, this will mean (through the use of Courcelle theorem [2]), that any problem definable in Monadic Second Order Logic can be solved in a polynomial time on any class well-quasi-ordered by the induced subgraph relation. In the present paper, we answer this question affirmatively for graphs without large bicliques. Thus the above algorithmic consequence is true, for example, for classes of graphs of bounded degree.

In this paper, given a parameter $k$, we demonstrate an infinite class of {\sc cnf}s of treewidth at most $k$ of their primary graphs such that the equivalent nondeterministic read-once branching programs ({\sc nrobp}s) are of size at least $n^{ck}$ for some universal constant $c$. Thus we rule out the possibility of fixed-parameter space complexity of {\sc nrobp}s parameterized by the smallest treewidth of the equivalent {\sc cnf}.