arXiv++ Combinatorics

A finite simple graph $G$ is called a cograph if it does not contain the path on four vertices $P_4$ as an induced subgraph. It is classically known that the family of cographs are well-quasi-ordered by the induced subgraph relation \cite{D}. In preceding work of Knudsen and the third author \cite[Theorem 7.2]{KR}, it was shown that this well-quasi-order statement admitted a categorification, which allowed those authors to prove universal finite generation statements about the homology groups of configuration spaces on cographs \cite[Theorem 1.5]{KR}. In this work, we expand \cite[Theorem 7.2]{KR} to be compatible with the family of polynomial rings on the vertex sets of cographs. By consequence, we are able to prove a number of universality results related with edge and toric ideals of these polynomial ring, partially generalizing and expanding upon work of Kahle \cite{kahle2019binomial}. We also conclude strong restrictions on the kinds of topologies that can arise from graph complexes and anchored configuration spaces associated to cographs, as well as combinatorial constraints on the possible combinatorics of hyperplane arrangements of cographs.

A graph class is $k$-WQO if its $k$-labeled graphs are well-quasi-ordered under label-preserving induced subgraph embeddings. We show that every hereditary graph class that is $2$-WQO has bounded clique-width. Combined with the recent result of Dumas and Lopez, this confirms a long-standing conjecture of Pouzet: A hereditary graph class is $2$-WQO if and only if it is $k$-WQO for all $k\geq 2$, if and only if it is $\forall$-WQO, that is, its labeled graphs are well-quasi-ordered for every possible well-quasi-ordered label set. Our proof builds on a recent structure/non-structure dichotomy for the model theoretic notion of monadic dependence by Dreier, Mählmann, and Toruńczyk. Through the non-structure characterization by forbidden induced subgraphs, we show that every hereditary $2$-WQO graph class is monadically dependent. Leveraging the Ramsey-theoretic structural properties provided by monadic dependence, we then establish bounded clique-width by ruling out the existence of large well-linked sets, which are the canonical obstructions for clique-width.

We prove that every class of Eulerian directed graphs of bounded carving width (equivalently of bounded degree and treewidth) is well-quasi-ordered by strong immersion. In fact, we prove a stronger result, namely that every class of Eulerian directed graphs of bounded carving width, where every vertex is additionally labeled from a well-quasi-order, fixes a linear order on its incident edges, and may impose further restrictions on how the immersion is allowed to route paths through it, is well-quasi-ordered by an adequate notion of strong immersion. To this extent, we develop a framework seemingly suited to prove well-quasi-ordering for classes of Eulerian directed graphs by (strong) immersion and present a first meta theorem in that direction. We complement our results by observing that the class of Eulerian directed graphs of unbounded degree is \emph{not} well-quasi-ordered by \emph{strong} immersion, even if we assume the treewidth of the class to be at most two. We conclude with a dichotomy result, proving for a very restricted class of Eulerian directed graphs of unbounded degree that it is not well-quasi-ordered by strong immersion, but it is well-quasi-ordered by weak immersion.

We study the well-quasi-order (wqo) consisting of the set of finite trees with leaf labels coming from an arbitrary wqo $Q$, ordered by tree homomorphisms which respect the order on the labels. This is a variant of the usual Kruskal tree ordering without infima preservation. We calculate the precise maximal order types of this class of wqos as a function of the maximal order type of the labels $Q$. In the process, we sharpen some recent results of Friedman and Weiermann. Furthermore, we show a correspondence with indecomposable transfinite sequences with finite range, over elements of the wqo $Q$, of length less than $ω^ω$. Nash-Williams proved that arbitrary transfinite sequences with finite range are also well-quasi-ordered, but there are no known methods to extract bounds on the maximal order type from the proof. More concrete proofs for sequences of length less than $α$ for some $α< ω^ω$ were given by Erdős and Rado. Using the correspondence, we obtain precise bounds for the entire collection of transfinite sequences with finite range of length less than $ω^ω$.

We study classes of graphs with bounded clique-width that are well-quasi-ordered by the induced subgraph relation, in the presence of labels on the vertices. We prove that, given a finite presentation of a class of graphs, one can decide whether the class is labelled-well-quasi-ordered. This solves an open problem raised by Daligault, Rao and Thomassé in 2010, and answers positively to two conjectures of Pouzet in the restricted case of bounded clique-width classes. Namely, we prove that being labelled-well-quasi-ordered by a set of size 2 or by a well-quasi-ordered infinite set are equivalent conditions, and that in such cases, one can freely assume that the graphs are equipped with a total ordering on their vertices. Finally, we provide a structural characterization of those classes as those that are of bounded clique-width and do not existentially transduce the class of all finite paths.

In the aftermath of the Robertson--Seymour Graph Minor Theorem, Thomas conjectured that the countable graphs are well-quasi-ordered under the minor relation. We prove that this conjecture, when restricted to graphs with no infinite paths (rays), is equivalent to the statement that the finite graphs are better-quasi-ordered, another well-known open problem. Even more, we prove that the latter implies that the countable rayless graphs are better-quasi-ordered. We prove several other statements to be equivalent to the above, one of which being that the rayless countable graphs of rank $α$ can be decomposed into exactly $\aleph_0$ minor-twin classes for every ordinal $α<ω_1$. By restricting the latter statement to trees, and combining it with Nash-Williams' theorem that the infinite trees are well-quasi-ordered, we deduce as a side result that a minor-closed family of N-labelled rayless forests is Borel -- in the Tychonoff product topology -- if and only if it does not contain all rayless forests. As another side-result, we prove Seymour's self-minor conjecture for rayless graphs of any cardinality.

We prove that for every surface $Σ$, the class of Eulerian directed graphs that are Eulerian embeddable into $Σ$ (in particular they have degree at most $4$) is well-quasi-ordered by strong immersion. This result marks one of the most versatile directed graph classes (besides tournaments) for which we are aware of a positive well-quasi-ordering result regarding a well-studied graph relation. Our result implies that the class of bipartite circle graphs is well-quasi-ordered under the pivot-minor relation. Furthermore, this also yields two other interesting applications, namely, a polynomial-time algorithm for testing immersion closed properties of Eulerian-embeddable graphs into a fixed surface, and a characterisation of the Erdős-Pósa property for Eulerian digraphs of maximum degree four. Further, in order to prove the mentioned result, we prove that Eulerian digraphs of carving width bounded by some constant $k$ (which correspond to Eulerian digraphs with bounded treewidth and additionally bounded degree) are well-quasi-ordered by strong immersion. We actually prove a stronger result where we allow for vertices of the Eulerian digraphs to be labeled by elements of some well-quasi-order $Ω$. We complement these results with a proof that the class of Eulerian planar digraphs of treewidth at most $3$ is not well-quasi-ordered by strong immersion, noting that any antichain of bounded treewidth cannot have bounded degree.

We prove that every interval order $P$ with no infinite antichain has a Gallai decomposition. That is, $P$ is a lexicographical sum of proper interval orders over a chain, an antichain or a prime interval order. This is a consequence of the fact that the tree decomposition of a graph into robust modules, as introduced by Courcelle and Delhommé (Theoretical Computer Science \textbf{394} (2008) 1--38), is chain finite whenever the graph has no infinite independent sets. Next, we prove that every prime interval order with no infinite antichain is at most countable and scattered. Furthermore, for each countable ordinal $α$ we exhibit an example of a well-quasi-ordered prime interval order $P_α$ whose chain of maximal antichains has Hausdorff rank $α$.

We investigate which classes of infinite graphs have the Erdős-Pósa property (EPP). In addition to the usual EPP, we also consider the following infinite variant of the EPP: a class $\mathcal{G}$ of graphs has the $κ$-EPP, where $κ$ is an infinite cardinal, if for any graph $Γ$ there are either $κ$ disjoint graphs from $\mathcal{G}$ in $Γ$ or there is a set $X$ of vertices of $Γ$ of size less than $κ$ such that $Γ- X$ contains no graph from $\mathcal{G}$. In particular, we study the ($κ$-)EPP for classes consisting of a single infinite graph $G$. We obtain positive results when the set of induced subgraphs of $G$ is labelled well-quasi-ordered, and negative results when $G$ is not a proper subgraph of itself (both results require some additional conditions). As a corollary, we obtain that every graph which does not contain a path of length $n$ for some $n \in \mathbb{N}$ has the EPP and the $κ$-EPP. Furthermore, we show that the class of all subdivisions of any tree $T$ has the $κ$-EPP for every uncountable cardinal $κ$, and if $T$ is rayless, also the $\aleph_0$-EPP and the EPP.

We explore two constructions of oligomorphic Jordan permutation groups preserving a `limit of betweenness relations' and a `limit of $D$-relations', from \cite{bhattmacph2006jordan} and \cite{almazaydeh2021jordan} respectively. Several issues left open in \cite{almazaydeh2021jordan} are resolved. In particular it is shown that the `limit of $D$-relations' is not homogeneous in the given language, but is `homogenizable', that is, there is a homogeneous structure over a finite relational language with the same universe and the same automorphism group. The structure is NIP, but not monadically NIP, its age is not well-quasi-ordered under embeddability, and the growth rate of the sequence enumerating orbits on $k$-sets grows faster than exponentially. The automorphism group is maximal-closed in the symmetric group. Similar results are shown for the construction in \cite{bhattmacph2006jordan}.

Lettericity is a graph parameter responsible for many attractive structural properties. In particular, graphs of bounded lettericity have bounded linear clique-width and they are well-quasi-ordered by induced subgraphs. The latter property implies that any hereditary class of graphs of bounded lettericity can be described by finitely many forbidden induced subgraphs. This, in turn, implies, in a non-constructive way, polynomial-time recognition of such classes. However, no constructive algorithms and no specific bounds on the size of forbidden graphs are available up to date. In the present paper, we develop an algorithm that recognizes $n$-vertex graphs of lettericity at most $k$ in time $f(k)n^3$ and show that any minimal graph of lettericity more than $k$ has at most $2^{O(k^2\log k)}$ vertices.

An Eulerian-minor of an Eulerian graph is obtained from an Eulerian subgraph of the Eulerian graph by contraction. The Eulerian-minor operation preserves Eulerian properties of graphs and moreover Eulerian graphs are well-quasi-ordered under Eulerian-minor relation. In this paper, we characterize Eulerian, planar and outer-planar Eulerian graphs by means of excluded Eulerian-minors, and provide a concise recursive characterization to 4-regular planar graphs.

The juxtaposition of permutation classes $\mathcal{C}$ and $\mathcal{D}$ is the class of all permutations formed by concatenations $στ$, such that $σ$ is order isomorphic to a permutation in $\mathcal{C}$, and $τ$ to a permutation in $\mathcal{D}$. We give simple necessary and sufficient conditions on the classes $\mathcal{C}$ and $\mathcal{D}$ for their juxtaposition to be labelled well-quasi-ordered (lwqo): namely that both $\C$ and $\DDD$ must themselves be lwqo, and at most one of $\mathcal{C}$ or $\mathcal{D}$ can contain arbitrarily long zigzag permutations. We also show that every class without long zigzag permutations has a growth rate which must be integral.

We consider the posets of equivalence relations on finite sets under the standard embedding ordering and under the consecutive embedding ordering. In the latter case, the relations are also assumed to have an underlying linear order, which governs consecutive embeddings. For each poset we ask the well quasi-order and atomicity decidability questions: Given finitely many equivalence relations $ρ_1,\dots,ρ_k$, is the downward closed set Av$(ρ_1,\dots,ρ_k)$ consisting of all equivalence relations which do not contain any of $ρ_1,\dots,ρ_k$: (a) well-quasi-ordered, meaning that it contains no infinite antichains? and (b) atomic, meaning that it is not a union of two proper downward closed subsets, or, equivalently, that it satisfies the joint embedding property?

We construct an uncountable family of well-quasi-ordered permutation classes, each with a distinct enumeration sequence. This disproves a conjecture that all well-quasi-ordered permutation classes have algebraic generating functions, and in fact shows that many such classes lack D-finite or D-algebraic generating functions. Our construction is based on an uncountably large collection of factor-closed, well-quasi-ordered binary languages due to Pouzet.

This paper is a contribution to the study of hereditary classes of finite graphs. We classify these classes according to the number of prime structures they contain. We consider such classes that are \emph{minimal prime}: classes that contain infinitely many primes but every proper hereditary subclass contains only finitely many primes. We give a complete description of such classes. In fact, each one of these classes is a well-quasi-ordered (w.q.o) age and there are uncountably many of them. Eleven of these ages are almost multichainable; they remain w.q.o when labels in a w.q.o are added, hence have finitely many bounds. Five ages among them are exhaustible. Among the remaining ones, only countably many remain w.q.o when one label is added, and these have finitely many bounds (except for the age of the infinite path and its complement). The others have infinitely many bounds. Except for six examples, members of these ages we characterize are permutation graphs. In fact, every age which is not among the eleven ones is the age of a graph associated to a uniformly recurrent word on the integers. A description of minimal prime classes of posets and bichains is also provided. Our results support the conjecture that if a hereditary class of finite graphs does not remain w.q.o when adding labels from a w.q.o set to these graphs, then it is not w.q.o if we add just two constants to each of these graphs Our description of minimal prime classes uses a description of minimal prime graphs \cite{pouzet-zaguia2009} and previous work by Sobrani \cite{sobranithesis, sobranietat} and the authors \cite{oudrar, pouzettr} on properties of uniformly recurrent words and the associated graphs. The completeness of our description is based on classification results of Chudnovsky, Kim, Oum and Seymour \cite{chudnovsky} and Malliaris and Terry \cite {malliaris}.

This paper is a contribution to the study of hereditary classes of relational structures, these classes being quasi-ordered by embeddability. It deals with the specific case of ordered sets of width two and the corresponding bichains and incomparability graphs. Several open problems about hereditary classes of relational structures which have been considered over the years have positive answer in this case. For example, well-quasi-ordered hereditary classes of finite bipartite permutation graphs, respectively finite 321-avoiding permutations, have been characterized by Korpelainen, Lozin and Mayhill, respectively by Albert, Brignall, Ruškuc and Vatter. We provide another proof of the results mentioned above. It is based on the existence of a countable universal poset of width two, obtained by the first author in 1978, his notion of multichainability (1978) (a kind of analog to letter-graphs), and metric properties of incomparability graphs. Using Laver's theorem (1971) on better-quasi-ordering (bqo) of countable chains we prove that a wqo hereditary class of finite or countable bipartite permutation graphs is necessarily bqo. This gives a positive answer to a conjecture of Nash-Williams (1965) in this case. We extend a previous result of Albert et al. by proving that if a hereditary class of finite, respectively countable, bipartite permutation graphs is wqo, respectively bqo, then the corresponding hereditary classes of posets of width at most two and bichains are wqo, respectively bqo. Several notions of labelled wqo are also considered. We prove that they are all equivalent in the case of bipartite permutation graphs, posets of width at most two and the corresponding bichains. We characterize hereditary classes of finite bipartite permutation graphs which remain wqo when labels from a wqo are added.

The class of quasi-chain graphs is an extension of the well-studied class of chain graphs. This latter class enjoys many nice and important properties, such as bounded clique-width, implicit representation, well-quasi-ordering by induced subgraphs, etc. The class of quasi-chain graphs is substantially more complex. In particular, this class is not well-quasi-ordered by induced subgraphs, and the clique-width is not bounded in it. In the present paper, we show that the universe of quasi-chain graphs is at least as complex as the universe of permutations by establishing a bijection between the class of all permutations and a subclass of quasi-chain graphs. This implies, in particular, that the induced subgraph isomorphism problem is NP-complete for quasi-chain graphs. On the other hand, we propose a decomposition theorem for quasi-chain graphs that implies an implicit representation for graphs in this class and efficient solutions for some algorithmic problems that are generally intractable.

While the theory of labelled well-quasi-order has received significant attention in the graph setting, it has not yet been considered in the context of permutation patterns. We initiate this study here, and show how labelled well quasi order provides a lens through which to view and extend previous well-quasi-order results in the permutation patterns literature. Connections to the graph setting are emphasised throughout. In particular, we establish that a permutation class is labelled well-quasi-ordered if and only if its corresponding graph class is also labelled well-quasi-ordered.

The age $\mathcal{A}(G)$ of a graph $G$ (undirected and without loops) is the collection of finite induced subgraphs of $G$, considered up to isomorphy and ordered by embeddability. It is well-quasi-ordered (wqo) for this order if it contains no infinite antichain. A graph is \emph{path-minimal} if it contains finite induced paths of unbounded length and every induced subgraph $G'$ with this property embeds $G$. We construct $2^{\aleph_0}$ path-minimal graphs whose ages are pairwise incomparable with set inclusion and which are wqo. Our construction is based on uniformly recurrent sequences and lexicographical sums of labelled graphs.