arXiv++ Combinatorics

The graph minor project contains the most influential results in recent undirected graph theory research. There has been progress in recent years in generalising some of their results to directed graphs, with the directed grid theorem of Kawarabayashi and Kreutzer [STOC '15] and the directed flat wall theorem of Giannopoulou, Kawarabayashi, Kreutzer, and Kwon [SODA '22]. We discuss the two different versions of the existing directed flat wall theorem and their drawbacks. Then, we present an alternative directed flat wall theorem that excludes a different digraph as a butterfly minor. This new theorem lies ``in between'' the two existing ones and, as such, does not have either of these drawbacks. The proof of our flat wall theorem is based on the one by Giannopoulou, Kawarabayashi, Kreutzer, and Kwon [SODA '22], which has been adapted by Giannopoulou and Wiederrecht [STOC~'24]. Here we make further adjustments to match our setting.

The Graph Minors Series of Robertson and Seymour forms the foundation of algorithmic structural graph theory, yielding fixed-parameter algorithms for problems such as Disjoint Paths, Rooted Minor Checking, and Folio. A key ingredient behind the fixed-parameter tractability of the $k$-Disjoint Paths problem is the irrelevant-vertex technique. This machinery is governed by the Vital Linkage Theorem and the so-called Linkage Function $\ell$. However, despite its foundational role, the best known bounds on the Linkage Function are enormous and are only implicitly understood. The quantitative bounds behind these results have traditionally been so large that the resulting algorithms are regarded as "galactic". Our main result is a general irrelevant-vertex theorem for a common generalisation of $k$-Disjoint Paths and Rooted Minor Checking for graphs of size at most $d,$ commonly called the $(k,d)$-Folio problem. Specifically, we show that for any graph $G$ in which the $k$ terminals are chosen from some set $R,$ if the treewidth of $G$ exceeds $β(k,b,d)\in$ $2^{{\bf poly}(b + d)}$ $\cdot {\bf poly}(k)$ then we can locate an irrelevant vertex for the $(k,d)$-Folio problem. Here, the quantity $b$ is the bidimensionality of $R,$ that is, the largest $b$ for which a $(b\times b)$-grid minor in $G$ can be rooted on $R$. Thus, the exponential component of the irrelevant-vertex threshold is driven by the bound on the bidimensionality, rather than by the number of terminals, and we argue that this dependence is essentially optimal up to polynomial factors. As a consequence, the Linkage Function satisfies $\ell(k) \in 2^{{\bf poly}(k)}$. Beyond its structural significance, our result yields improved parameter dependencies for algorithms for Disjoint Paths and Rooted Minor Checking}, and provides a quantitative improvement for a broad range of graph-minor-based algorithmic frameworks.

We prove that every class of Eulerian directed graphs of bounded carving width (equivalently of bounded degree and treewidth) is well-quasi-ordered by strong immersion. In fact, we prove a stronger result, namely that every class of Eulerian directed graphs of bounded carving width, where every vertex is additionally labeled from a well-quasi-order, fixes a linear order on its incident edges, and may impose further restrictions on how the immersion is allowed to route paths through it, is well-quasi-ordered by an adequate notion of strong immersion. To this extent, we develop a framework seemingly suited to prove well-quasi-ordering for classes of Eulerian directed graphs by (strong) immersion and present a first meta theorem in that direction. We complement our results by observing that the class of Eulerian directed graphs of unbounded degree is \emph{not} well-quasi-ordered by \emph{strong} immersion, even if we assume the treewidth of the class to be at most two. We conclude with a dichotomy result, proving for a very restricted class of Eulerian directed graphs of unbounded degree that it is not well-quasi-ordered by strong immersion, but it is well-quasi-ordered by weak immersion.

In 2015, Kawarabayashi and Kreutzer proved the Directed Grid Theorem - the generalisation of the well-known Excluded Grid Theorem to directed graphs - confirming a conjecture by Reed, Johnson, Robertson, Seymour and Thomas from the mid-nineties. The theorem states that there is a function $f$ such that every digraph of directed treewidth $f(k)$ contains a cylindrical grid of order $k$ as a butterfly minor. However, the given function grows faster than any non-elementary function of the size of the grid minor. More precisely, it is larger than a power tower whose height depends on the size of the grid. In this paper, we present an alternative proof of the Directed Grid Theorem which is conceptually much simpler, more modular in composition and improves the upper bound for the function $f$ to a power tower of height $22$. A key concept of our proof is a new structure called cycles of well-linked sets (CWS). We show that any digraph of large directed treewidth contains a large CWS, which in turn contains a large cylindrical grid.

We prove that for every surface $Σ$, the class of Eulerian directed graphs that are Eulerian embeddable into $Σ$ (in particular they have degree at most $4$) is well-quasi-ordered by strong immersion. This result marks one of the most versatile directed graph classes (besides tournaments) for which we are aware of a positive well-quasi-ordering result regarding a well-studied graph relation. Our result implies that the class of bipartite circle graphs is well-quasi-ordered under the pivot-minor relation. Furthermore, this also yields two other interesting applications, namely, a polynomial-time algorithm for testing immersion closed properties of Eulerian-embeddable graphs into a fixed surface, and a characterisation of the Erdős-Pósa property for Eulerian digraphs of maximum degree four. Further, in order to prove the mentioned result, we prove that Eulerian digraphs of carving width bounded by some constant $k$ (which correspond to Eulerian digraphs with bounded treewidth and additionally bounded degree) are well-quasi-ordered by strong immersion. We actually prove a stronger result where we allow for vertices of the Eulerian digraphs to be labeled by elements of some well-quasi-order $Ω$. We complement these results with a proof that the class of Eulerian planar digraphs of treewidth at most $3$ is not well-quasi-ordered by strong immersion, noting that any antichain of bounded treewidth cannot have bounded degree.

The classic result by Fortune, Hopcroft, and Wyllie [TCS~'80] states that the directed disjoint paths problem is NP-complete even for two pairs of terminals. Extending this well-known result, we show that the directed disjoint paths problem is NP-complete for any constant congestion $c \geq 1$ and~$k \geq 3c-1$ pairs of terminals. This refutes a conjecture by Giannopoulou et al. [SODA~'22], which says that the directed disjoint paths problem with congestion two is polynomial-time solvable for any constant number $k$ of terminal pairs. We then consider the cases that are not covered by this hardness result. The first nontrivial case is $c=2$ and $k = 3$. Our second main result is to show that this case is polynomial-time solvable.

Butterfly minors are a generalisation of the minor containment relation for undirected graphs to directed graphs. Many results in directed structural graph theory use this notion as a central tool next to directed treewidth, a generalisation of the width measure treewidth to directed graphs. Adler [JCTB'07] showed that the directed treewidth is not closed under taking butterfly minors. Over the years, many alternative definitions for directed treewidth appeared throughout the literature, equivalent to the original definition up to small functions. In this paper, we consider the major ones and show that not all of them share the problem identified by Adler.

We prove that there exist four operations such that given any two strongly $2$-connected digraphs $H$ and $D$ where $H$ is a butterfly-minor of $D$, there exists a sequence $D_0,\dots, D_n$ where $D_0=H$, $D_n=D$ and for every $0\leq i\leq n-1$, $D_i$ is a strongly $2$-connected butterfly-minor of $D_{i+1}$ which is obtained by a single application of one of the four operations. As a consequence of this theorem, we obtain that every strongly $2$-connected digraph can be generated from a concise family of strongly $2$-connected digraphs by using these four operations.

In 1996, Reed, Robertson, Seymour and Thomas [Combinatorica 1996] proved Younger's Conjecture, which states that, for all directed graphs $D$, there exists a function $f$ such that, if $D$ does not contain $k$ disjoint cycles, then $D$ contains a feedback vertex set, i.e.~a subset of vertices whose deletion renders the graph acyclic, of size bounded by $f(k)$. However, the function obtained by Reed, Robertson, Seymour and Thomas in their paper is enormous and, in fact, not even elementary. We prove the first elementary upper bound for the function $f$ above, showing it is upper-bounded by a power tower of height 8. Our proof is inspired by the breakthrough result of Chekuri and Chuzhoy [J.~ACM 2016], who proved a polynomial bound for the Excluded Grid Theorem for undirected graphs. We translate a key concept of their proof to directed graphs by introducing \emph{paths of well-linked sets (PWS)}, and show that any digraph of large directed treewidth contains a large PWS, which in turn contains a large fence. We believe that the theoretical tools developed in this work may find applications beyond the results above, in a similar way as the path-of-sets-system framework due to Chekuri and Chuzhoy [J.~ACM 2016] did for undirected graphs (see, for example, Hatzel, Komosa, Pilipczuk and Sorge [Discret.~Math.~Theor.~Comput.~Sci.~2022], Chekuri and Chuzhoy [SODA 2015] and Chuzhoy and Nimavat [arXiv 2019]). Indeed, in a follow-up paper, we apply this framework to improve the bounds of the Directed Grid Theorem.

We prove the existence of a computable function $f\colon\mathbb{N}\to\mathbb{N}$ such that for every integer $k$ and every digraph $D$ either contains a collection $\mathcal{C}$ of $k$ directed cycles of even length such that no vertex of $D$ belongs to more than four cycles in $\mathcal{C}$, or there exists a set $S\subseteq V(D)$ of size at most $f(k)$ such that $D-S$ has no directed cycle of even length. Moreover, we provide an algorithm that finds one of the two outcomes of this statement in time $g(k)n^{\mathcal{O}(1)}$ for some computable function $g\colon \mathbb{N}\to\mathbb{N}$. Our result unites two deep fields of research from the algorithmic theory for digraphs: The study of the Erdős-Pósa property of digraphs and the study of the Even Dicycle Problem. The latter is the decision problem which asks if a given digraph contains an even dicycle and can be traced back to a question of Pólya from 1913. It remained open until a polynomial time algorithm was finally found by Robertson, Seymour, and Thomas (Ann. of Math. (2) 1999) and, independently, McCuaig (Electron. J. Combin. 2004; announced jointly at STOC 1997). The Even Dicycle Problem is equivalent to the recognition problem of Pfaffian bipartite graphs and has applications even beyond discrete mathematics and theoretical computer science. On the other hand, Younger's Conjecture (1973), states that dicycles have the Erdős-Pósa property. The conjecture was proven more than two decades later by Reed, Robertson, Seymour, and Thomas (Combinatorica 1996) and opened the path for structural digraph theory as well as the algorithmic study of the directed feedback vertex set problem. Our approach builds upon the techniques used to resolve both problems and combines them into a powerful structural theorem that yields further algorithmic applications for other prominent problems.

We present a fixed-parameter tractable algorithm for first-order model checking on interpretations of graph classes with bounded local cliquewidth. Notably, this includes interpretations of planar graphs, and more generally, of classes of bounded genus. To obtain this result we develop a new tool which works in a very general setting of dependent classes and which we believe can be an important ingredient in achieving similar results in the future.

Matching minors are a specialisation of minors fit for the study of graph with perfect matchings. The notion of matching minors has been used to give a structural description of bipartite graphs on which the number of perfect matchings can becomputed efficiently, based on a result of Little, by McCuaig et al. in 1999.In this paper we generalise basic ideas from the graph minor series by Robertson and Seymour to the setting of bipartite graphs with perfect matchings. We introducea version of Erdos-Posa property for matching minors and find a direct link between this property and planarity. From this, it follows that a class of bipartite graphs withperfect matchings has bounded perfect matching width if and only if it excludes aplanar matching minor. We also present algorithms for bipartite graphs of bounded perfect matching width for a matching version of the disjoint paths problem, matching minor containment, and for counting the number of perfect matchings. From our structural results, we obtain that recognising whether a bipartite graphGcontains afixed planar graphHas a matching minor, and that counting the number of perfect matchings of a bipartite graph that excludes a fixed planar graph as a matching minor are both polynomial time solvable.

The canonical tree-decomposition theorem, given by Robertson and Seymour in their seminal graph minors series, turns out to be one of the most important tool in structural and algorithmic graph theory. In this paper, we provide the canonical tree decomposition theorem for digraphs. More precisely, we construct directed tree-decompositions of digraphs that distinguish all their tangles of order $k$, for any fixed integer $k$, in polynomial time. As an application of this canonical tree-decomposition theorem, we provide the following result for the directed disjoint paths problem: For every fixed $k$ there is a polynomial-time algorithm which, on input $G$, and source and terminal vertices $(s_1, t_1), \dots, (s_k, t_k)$, either 1. determines that there is no set of pairwise vertex-disjoint paths connecting each source $s_i$ to its terminal $t_i$, or 2.finds a half-integral solution, i.e., outputs paths $P_1, \dots, P_k$ such that $P_i$ links $s_i$ to $t_i$, so that every vertex of the graph is contained in at most two paths. Given known hardness results for the directed disjoint paths problem, our result cannot be improved for general digraphs, neither to fixed-parameter tractability nor to fully vertex-disjoint directed paths. As far as we are aware, this is the first time to obtain a tractable result for the $k$-disjoint paths problem for general digraphs. We expect more applications of our canonical tree-decomposition for directed results.

We prove that there exists a function $f:\mathbb{N}\rightarrow \mathbb{R}$ such that every directed graph $G$ contains either $k$ directed odd cycles where every vertex of $G$ is contained in at most two of them, or a set of at most $f(k)$ vertices meeting all directed odd cycles. We also give a polynomial-time algorithm for fixed $k$ which outputs one of the two outcomes. Using this algorithmic result, we give a polynomial-time algorithm for fixed $k$ to decide whether such $k$ directed odd cycles exist, or there are no $k$ vertex-disjoint directed odd cycles. This extends the half-integral Erdős-Pósa theorem for undirected odd cycles by Reed [Combinatorica 1999] to directed graphs.

We introduce differential games for FO logic of graphs, a variant of Ehrenfeucht-Fraïssé games in which the game is played on only one graph and the moves of both players restricted. We prove that, in a certain sense, these games are strong enough to capture essential information about graphs from graph classes which are interpretable in nowhere dense graph classes. This, together with the newly introduced notion of differential locality and the fact that the restriction of possible moves by the players makes it easy to decide the winner of the game in some cases, leads to a new approach to the FO model checking problem on interpretations of nowhere dense graph classes.

We study the model-checking problem for first- and monadic second-order logic on finite relational structures. The problem of verifying whether a formula of these logics is true on a given structure is considered intractable in general, but it does become tractable on interesting classes of structures, such as on classes whose Gaifman graphs have bounded treewidth. In this paper we continue this line of research and study model-checking for first- and monadic second-order logic in the presence of an ordering on the input structure. We do so in two settings: the general ordered case, where the input structures are equipped with a fixed order or successor relation, and the order invariant case, where the formulas may resort to an ordering, but their truth must be independent of the particular choice of order. In the first setting we show very strong intractability results for most interesting classes of structures. In contrast, in the order invariant case we obtain tractability results for order-invariant monadic second-order formulas on the same classes of graphs as in the unordered case. For first-order logic, we obtain tractability of successor-invariant formulas on classes whose Gaifman graphs have bounded expansion. Furthermore, we show that model-checking for order-invariant first-order formulas is tractable on coloured posets of bounded width.

The notion of bounded expansion captures uniform sparsity of graph classes and renders various algorithmic problems that are hard in general tractable. In particular, the model-checking problem for first-order logic is fixed-parameter tractable over such graph classes. With the aim of generalizing such results to dense graphs, we introduce classes of graphs with structurally bounded expansion, defined as first-order interpretations of classes of bounded expansion. As a first step towards their algorithmic treatment, we provide their characterization analogous to the characterization of classes of bounded expansion via low treedepth decompositions, replacing treedepth by its dense analogue called shrubdepth.

We introduce the concept of matching connectivity as a notion of connectivity in graph admitting perfect matchings which heavily relies on the structural properties of those matchings. We generalise a result of Robertson, Seymour and Thomas for bipartite graphs with perfect matchings (see [Neil Roberts, Paul D Seymour, and Robin Thomas. Permanents, pfaffian orientations, and even directed curcuits. Annals of Mathematics, 150(2):929-975, 1999]) in order to obtain a concept of alternating paths that turns out to be sufficient for the description of our connectivity parameter. We introduce some basic properties of matching connectivity and prove a Menger-type result for matching n-connected graphs. Furthermore, we show that matching connectivity fills a gap in the investigation of n-extendable graphs and their connectivity properties. To be more precise we show that every n-extendable graph is matching n-connected and for the converse every matching (n+1)-connected graph either is n-extendable, or belongs to a well described class of graphs: the brace h-critical graphs.

We prove that whenever $G$ is a graph from a nowhere dense graph class $\mathcal{C}$, and $A$ is a subset of vertices of $G$, then the number of subsets of $A$ that are realized as intersections of $A$ with $r$-neighborhoods of vertices of $G$ is at most $f(r,ε)\cdot |A|^{1+ε}$, where $r$ is any positive integer, $ε$ is any positive real, and $f$ is a function that depends only on the class $\mathcal{C}$. This yields a characterization of nowhere dense classes of graphs in terms of neighborhood complexity, which answers a question posed by Reidl et al. As an algorithmic application of the above result, we show that for every fixed $r$, the parameterized Distance-$r$ Dominating Set problem admits an almost linear kernel on any nowhere dense graph class. This proves a conjecture posed by Drange et al., and shows that the limit of parameterized tractability of Distance-$r$ Dominating Set on subgraph-closed graph classes lies exactly on the boundary between nowhere denseness and somewhere denseness.

We prove that every digraph has a vertex 4-colouring such that for each vertex $v$, at most half the out-neighbours of $v$ receive the same colour as $v$. We then obtain several results related to the conjecture obtained by replacing 4 by 3.