arXiv++ Combinatorics

A graph $G$ is \emph{apex} if $G$ has a vertex $v$ such that $G-v$ is planar. We prove that every $2$-connected apex cubic graph is three-edge-colorable. This result gives the final piece of the proof for the well-known Tutte's three-edge-coloring conjecture from 1966 \cite{tutte}. The proof, as well as the result, generalizes that of the Four Color Theorem, which requires computer checks. As in the previous proof of the Four Color Theorem, the proof is constructive. More precisely, given a $2$-connected apex cubic graph $G$ on $n$ vertices, our reducibility and discharging procedure yields a three-edge-coloring of $G$ in $O(n^2)$ time. As an additional reproducibility check for our computer checks, independent implementations reconstructed from the detailed pseudocode (given in the appendix) using generative AI systems reproduced the required computational results. These reconstructions are not part of the mathematical justification of the theorem, but provide additional evidence for the reproducibility of the computations.

The graph minor project contains the most influential results in recent undirected graph theory research. There has been progress in recent years in generalising some of their results to directed graphs, with the directed grid theorem of Kawarabayashi and Kreutzer [STOC '15] and the directed flat wall theorem of Giannopoulou, Kawarabayashi, Kreutzer, and Kwon [SODA '22]. We discuss the two different versions of the existing directed flat wall theorem and their drawbacks. Then, we present an alternative directed flat wall theorem that excludes a different digraph as a butterfly minor. This new theorem lies ``in between'' the two existing ones and, as such, does not have either of these drawbacks. The proof of our flat wall theorem is based on the one by Giannopoulou, Kawarabayashi, Kreutzer, and Kwon [SODA '22], which has been adapted by Giannopoulou and Wiederrecht [STOC~'24]. Here we make further adjustments to match our setting.

We show that every planar graph with $n \geq 3$ vertices admits a 4-coloring in which each color is used on fewer than $n/2$ vertices. This bound is the best possible. Moreover, such a coloring can be found in $O(n \log n)$ time. We also extend these results to five or more colors and to graphs on general surfaces.

The dichromatic number of a digraph is the minimum number of colors needed to partition its vertex set into acyclic subdigraphs. A biclique is a set of vertices inducing all possible pairs of opposite arcs. For a digraph $D$, define $Δ(D) = \max_{v\in V(D)} \sqrt{d^+(v) \cdot d^-(v)}$. We prove that, for every fixed integer $b\in\mathbb{N}$, every digraph $D$ with $Δ(D) = Δ$ being sufficiently large with respect to $b$ either contains a biclique whose size exceeds $Δ-2b$ or has dichromatic number at most $Δ-b$. This extends a classical result of Reed to the directed setting and supports a conjecture of the present authors. Furthermore, the theorem is tight, as for all integers $b$ and $Δ\geq 3b$ there exists a digraph $D$ with $Δ(D)= Δ$, dichromatic number $Δ-b+1$, and whose largest biclique has size $Δ-2b+1$.

For a given subset $S\subseteq V(G)$ of a graph $G$, the pair $(G,S)$ is \emph{knitted} if for every partition of $S$ into non-empty subsets $S_1, S_2, \ldots, S_t$, there exist pairwise disjoint connected subgraphs $C_1, C_2, \ldots, C_t$ in $G$ such that $S_i\subseteq V(C_i)$ for all $1 \le i \le t$. A graph $G$ is \emph{$\ell$-knitted} if $(G,S)$ is knitted for every subset $S\subseteq V(G)$ of size $\ell$. In this paper, we prove that every $8\ell$-connected graph is $\ell$-knitted. We subsequently apply this result to Hadwiger's Conjecture, which states that every $k$-chromatic graph contains a $K_k$-minor. Specifically, we demonstrate that the vertex connectivity of any minimal counterexample to Hadwiger's Conjecture is at least $\lceil k/8 \rceil$, improving upon the previous lower bound of $\lceil 2k/27 \rceil$ established by Kawarabayashi (2007). Our proof corrects a gap in the argument of Kawarabayashi-Yu~(2013) and establishes the claim stated without proof in Liu--Rolek--Yu~(2019).

Everywhere-$δ$-dense graphs are defined as graphs on $n$ vertices in which every vertex has degree at least $δn$ for some constant $δ> 0$. Approximation schemes are vital for handling NP-hard optimization problems, but for many graph cut problems, existing PTAS algorithms often suffer from running times of $n^{f(1/\varepsilon)}$. In this paper, we bring PTASs down to EPTASs for several fundamental minimization problems on everywhere-$Ω(1)$-dense graphs. Specifically, we present the first Efficient Polynomial-Time Approximation Scheme (EPTAS), running in time $f(1/\varepsilon)n^{O(1)}$, for the ConstrainedMinCut problem under a global constraint on vertex weights, a problem that captures BalancedSeparator and SmallSetExpansion. Moreover, we give the first EPTASs for MinQuotientCut and ProductSparsestCut on everywhere-$δ$-dense graphs with integer-valued dense vertex weights; these problems generalize the four well-known problems UniformSparsestCut, EdgeExpansion, Conductance, and NormalizedCut. Our main technical contribution is an EPTAS for ConstrainedMinCut, based on the weak regularity lemma and sampling and estimation techniques. We then obtain EPTASs for MinQuotientCut and ProductSparsestCut via a unified reduction that invokes this algorithm as a subroutine. In contrast, previous works giving PTASs for these problems on everywhere-$δ$-dense graphs typically rely on powerful tools such as the Lasserre hierarchy or specific integer programming technique, which we avoid.

We prove that every class of Eulerian directed graphs of bounded carving width (equivalently of bounded degree and treewidth) is well-quasi-ordered by strong immersion. In fact, we prove a stronger result, namely that every class of Eulerian directed graphs of bounded carving width, where every vertex is additionally labeled from a well-quasi-order, fixes a linear order on its incident edges, and may impose further restrictions on how the immersion is allowed to route paths through it, is well-quasi-ordered by an adequate notion of strong immersion. To this extent, we develop a framework seemingly suited to prove well-quasi-ordering for classes of Eulerian directed graphs by (strong) immersion and present a first meta theorem in that direction. We complement our results by observing that the class of Eulerian directed graphs of unbounded degree is \emph{not} well-quasi-ordered by \emph{strong} immersion, even if we assume the treewidth of the class to be at most two. We conclude with a dichotomy result, proving for a very restricted class of Eulerian directed graphs of unbounded degree that it is not well-quasi-ordered by strong immersion, but it is well-quasi-ordered by weak immersion.

As part of the graph minor project, Robertson and Seymour showed in 1990 that the class of graphs that can be embedded in a given surface can be characterized by a finite set of minimal excluded minors. However, their proof, because existential, provides no explicit information about these excluded minors. In 1993, Seymour established the first upper bound on the order of such minimal excluded minors. Very recently, Houdaigoui and Kawarabayashi improved this result by deriving a quasi-polynomial upper bound. Despite this progress, the gap between this bound and the known linear lower bound $Ω(g)$ (where $g$ denotes the genus) remains substantial. In particular, they conjectured that a polynomial upper bound should hold. In this paper, we confirm this conjecture by showing that the order of the minimal excluded minors for a surface of genus $g$ is $O(g^{8+\varepsilon})$ for every $\varepsilon >0$. This result significantly narrows the gap between the known lower and upper bounds, bringing the asymptotic behavior much closer to the conjectured optimum. Our approach introduces a new forbidden structure of minimal excluded minors. Let $G$ be a minimal excluded minor for a surface of Euler genus $g$. Houdaigoui and Kawarabayashi showed that $G$ contains $O(\log g)$ pairwise disjoint cycles that are contractible and nested in some embedding of $G$. We strengthen this result by proving a separator-based variant: for any contractible subgraph $H \subseteq G$ with a separator of size $s$ (with $H$ completely contained in one side), the subgraph $H$ contains $O(\log s)$ disjoint cycles that are contractible and nested in some embedding of $G$. This allows us to replace a genus-dependent bound with a separator-dependent one, which is the main new ingredient in deriving our polynomial bound.

We give a near-linear time 4-coloring algorithm for planar graphs, improving on the previous quadratic time algorithm by Robertson et al. from 1996. Such an algorithm cannot be achieved by the known proofs of the Four Color Theorem (4CT). Technically speaking, we show the following significant generalization of the 4CT: every planar triangulation contains linearly many pairwise non-touching reducible configurations or pairwise non-crossing obstructing cycles of length at most 5 (which all allow for making effective 4-coloring reductions). The known proofs of the 4CT only show the existence of a single reducible configuration or obstructing cycle in the above statement. The existence is proved using the discharging method based on combinatorial curvature. It identifies reducible configurations in parts where the local neighborhood has positive combinatorial curvature. Our result significantly strengthens the known proofs of 4CT, showing that we can also find reductions in large ``flat" parts where the curvature is zero, and moreover, we can make reductions almost anywhere in a given planar graph. An interesting aspect of this is that such large flat parts are also found in large triangulations of any fixed surface. From a computational perspective, the old proofs allowed us to apply induction on a problem that is smaller by some additive constant. The inductive step took linear time, resulting in a quadratic total time. With our linear number of reducible configurations or obstructing cycles, we can reduce the problem size by a constant factor. Our inductive step takes $O(n\log n)$ time, yielding a 4-coloring in $O(n\log n)$ total time. In order to efficiently handle a linear number of reducible configurations, we need them to have certain robustness that could also be useful in other applications. All our reducible configurations are what is known as D-reducible.

As part of their graph minor project, Robertson and Seymour showed in 1990 that the class of graphs that can be embedded in a given surface can be characterized by a finite set of minimal excluded minors. However, their proof, because existential, does not provide any information on these excluded minors. Seymour proved in 1993 the first and, until now, only known upper bound on the order of the minimal excluded minors for a given surface. This bound is double exponential in the Euler genus $g$ of the surface and, therefore, very far from the $Ω(g)$ lower bound on the maximal order of minimal excluded minors for a surface and most likely far from the best possible bound. More than thirty years later, this paper finally makes progress in lowering this bound to a quasi-polynomial in the Euler genus of the surface. The main catalyzer to reach a quasi-polynomial bound is a breakthrough on the characteristic size of a forbidden structure for a minimal excluded minor $G$ for a surface of Euler genus $g$: although it is not hard to show that $G$ does not contain $O(g)$ disjoint cycles that are contractible and nested in some embedding of $G$ as demonstrated by Seymour, this bound can be lowered to $O(\log g)$ which is essential to obtain the quasi-polynomial bound in this paper. As subsidiary results, we also improve the current bound on the treewidth of a minimal excluded minor $G$ for a surface by improving the first and, until now, only known bound provided by Seymour.

We show that any planar graph $G=(V,E)$ has a 5-coloring such that one color class contains at most $|V|/6$ vertices. In other words, there exists a partition of $V$ into five independent sets $\{V_1, \cdots, V_5\}$ such that $|V_5| \leq |V| / 6$. Our proof yields an $O(|V|^2)$-time algorithm to find such a partition, and unlike the Four Color Theorem, our proof is fully verifiable without computer assistance.

We prove that for every surface $Σ$, the class of Eulerian directed graphs that are Eulerian embeddable into $Σ$ (in particular they have degree at most $4$) is well-quasi-ordered by strong immersion. This result marks one of the most versatile directed graph classes (besides tournaments) for which we are aware of a positive well-quasi-ordering result regarding a well-studied graph relation. Our result implies that the class of bipartite circle graphs is well-quasi-ordered under the pivot-minor relation. Furthermore, this also yields two other interesting applications, namely, a polynomial-time algorithm for testing immersion closed properties of Eulerian-embeddable graphs into a fixed surface, and a characterisation of the Erdős-Pósa property for Eulerian digraphs of maximum degree four. Further, in order to prove the mentioned result, we prove that Eulerian digraphs of carving width bounded by some constant $k$ (which correspond to Eulerian digraphs with bounded treewidth and additionally bounded degree) are well-quasi-ordered by strong immersion. We actually prove a stronger result where we allow for vertices of the Eulerian digraphs to be labeled by elements of some well-quasi-order $Ω$. We complement these results with a proof that the class of Eulerian planar digraphs of treewidth at most $3$ is not well-quasi-ordered by strong immersion, noting that any antichain of bounded treewidth cannot have bounded degree.

The classic result by Fortune, Hopcroft, and Wyllie [TCS~'80] states that the directed disjoint paths problem is NP-complete even for two pairs of terminals. Extending this well-known result, we show that the directed disjoint paths problem is NP-complete for any constant congestion $c \geq 1$ and~$k \geq 3c-1$ pairs of terminals. This refutes a conjecture by Giannopoulou et al. [SODA~'22], which says that the directed disjoint paths problem with congestion two is polynomial-time solvable for any constant number $k$ of terminal pairs. We then consider the cases that are not covered by this hardness result. The first nontrivial case is $c=2$ and $k = 3$. Our second main result is to show that this case is polynomial-time solvable.

In 1977, Borodin and Kostochka conjectured that every graph with maximum degree $Δ\geq 9$ is $(Δ-1)$-colourable, unless it contains a clique of size $Δ$. In 1999, Reed confirmed the conjecture when $Δ\geq 10^{14}$. We propose different generalisations of this conjecture for digraphs, and prove the analogue of Reed's result for each of them. The chromatic number and clique number are replaced respectively by the dichromatic number and the biclique number of digraphs. If $D$ is a digraph such that $\min(\tildeΔ(D),Δ^+(D)) = Δ\geq 9$, we conjecture that $D$ has dichromatic number at most $Δ-1$, unless either (i) $D$ contains a biclique of size $Δ$, or (ii) $D$ contains a biclique $K$ of size $Δ-2$, a directed $3$-cycle $\vec{C_3}$ disjoint from $K$, and all possible arcs in both directions between $\vec{C_3}$ and $K$. If true, this implies the conjecture of Borodin and Kostochka. We prove it when $Δ$ is large enough, thereby generalising the result of Reed. We finally give a sufficient condition for a digraph $D$ to have dichromatic number at most $Δ_{\min}(D)-1$, assuming that $Δ_{\min}(D)$ is large enough. In particular, this holds when the underlying graph of $D$ has no clique of size $Δ_{\min}(D)$, thus yielding a third independent generalisation of Reed's result. We further give a hardness result witnessing that our sufficient condition is best possible. To obtain these new upper bounds on the dichromatic number, we prove a dense decomposition lemma for digraphs having large maximum degree, which generalises to the directed setting the so-called dense decomposition of graphs due to Molloy and Reed. We believe this may be of independent interest, especially as a tool in various applications.

We prove that every $2$-edge-coloured graph with sufficiently large minimum degree contains a monochromatic induced subgraph whose minimum degree remains large. As a consequence, we deduce that some classes of graphs are degree-bounded. A class $\mathcal{G}$ is {\it degree-bounded} if, for every integer $s$, there exists $d=d(s)$ such that every graph $G\in \mathcal{G}$ either contains $K_{s,s}$ or has minimum degree at most $d$. We obtain that the following classes are degree-bounded: (i) for every $k$, the graphs $G$ whose edge-set can be $k$-coloured such that no even hole of $G$ is monochromatic; (ii) for every fixed antidirected forest $F$, the graphs admitting an orientation without any induced copy of $F$; (iii) for every $\ell\geq 4$, the graphs admitting an orientation without any induced antidirected cycle of length at least $\ell$. For $k=2$, class (i) contains odd-signable graphs. Class (ii) characterises the oriented graphs $H$ such that the class of graphs admitting an orientation without any induced copy of $H$ is degree-bounded. For $\ell=5$, class (iii) contains Burling graphs. In case (i) and case (iii) for $\ell=4$, we further obtain that the classes are polynomially $χ$-bounded.

We prove that every cyclically 4-edge-connected cubic graph that can be embedded in the torus, with the exceptional graph class called "Petersen-like", is 3-edge-colorable. This means every (non-trivial) toroidal snark can be obtained from several copies of the Petersen graph using the dot product operation. The first two snarks in this family are the Petersen graph and one of Blanuša snarks; the rest are exposed by Vodopivec in 2008. This proves a strengthening of the well-known, long-standing conjecture of Grünbaum from 1968. This implies that a 2-connected cubic (multi)graph that can be embedded in the torus is not 3-edge-colorable if and only if it can be obtained from a dot product of copies of the Petersen graph by replacing its vertices with 2-edge-connected planar cubic (multi)graphs. Here, replacing a vertex $v$ in a cubic graph $G$ is the operation that takes a 2-connected planar cubic multigraph $H$ and one of its vertices $u$ of degree 3, unifying $G-v$ and $H-u$ and connecting the neighbors of $v$ in $G-v$ with the neighbors of $u$ in $H-u$ with a matching. This result is a highly nontrivial generalization of the Four Color Theorem, and its proof requires a combination of extensive computer verification and computer-free extension of existing proofs on colorability. An important consequence of this result is a very strong version of the Tutte 4-Flow Conjecture for toroidal graphs. We show that a 2-edge connected graph embedded in the torus admits a nowhere-zero 4-flow unless it is Petersen-like (in which case it does not admit nowhere-zero 4-flows). Observe that this is a vast strengthening over the Tutte 4-Flow Conjecture on the torus, which assumes that the graph does not contain the Petersen graph as a minor because almost all toroidal graphs contain the Petersen graph minor, but almost none are Petersen-like.

Reed in 1998 conjectured that every graph $G$ satisfies $χ(G) \leq \lceil \frac{Δ(G)+1+ω(G)}{2} \rceil$. As a partial result, he proved the existence of $\varepsilon > 0$ for which every graph $G$ satisfies $χ(G) \leq \lceil (1-\varepsilon)(Δ(G)+1)+\varepsilonω(G) \rceil$. We propose an analogue conjecture for digraphs. Given a digraph $D$, we denote by $\vecχ(D)$ the dichromatic number of $D$, which is the minimum number of colours needed to partition $D$ into acyclic induced subdigraphs. We let $\overleftrightarrowω(D)$ denote the size of the largest biclique (a set of vertices inducing a complete digraph) of $D$ and $\tildeΔ(D) = \max_{v\in V(D)} \sqrt{d^+(v) \cdot d^-(v)}$. We conjecture that every digraph $D$ satisfies $\vecχ(D) \leq \lceil \frac{\tildeΔ(D)+1+\overleftrightarrowω(D)}{2} \rceil$, which if true implies Reed's conjecture. As a partial result, we prove the existence of $\varepsilon >0$ for which every digraph $D$ satisfies $\vecχ(D) \leq \lceil (1-\varepsilon)(\tildeΔ(D)+1)+\varepsilon\overleftrightarrowω(D) \rceil$. This implies both Reed's result and an independent result of Harutyunyan and Mohar for oriented graphs. To obtain this upper bound on $\vecχ$, we prove that every digraph $D$ with $\overleftrightarrowω(D) > \frac{2}{3}(Δ_{\max}(D)+1)$, where $Δ_{\max}(D) = \max_{v\in V(D)} \max(d^+(v),d^-(v))$, admits an acyclic set of vertices intersecting each biclique of $D$, which generalises a result of King. We finally give a short proof that all oriented graphs $D$ satisfy $\vecχ(D) \leq \frac{\sqrt{2}}{2} \TildeΔ(D) + 2$, improving on a result of Golowich.

We consider the problem of coloring a 3-colorable graph in polynomial time using as few colors as possible. This is one of the most challenging problems in graph algorithms. In this paper using Blum's notion of ``progress'', we develop a new combinatorial algorithm for the following: Given any 3-colorable graph with minimum degree $\ds>\sqrt n$, we can, in polynomial time, make progress towards a $k$-coloring for some $k=\sqrt{n/\ds}\cdot n^{o(1)}$. We balance our main result with the best-known semi-definite(SDP) approach which we use for degrees below $n^{0.605073}$. As a result, we show that $\tO(n^{0.19747})$ colors suffice for coloring 3-colorable graphs. This improves on the previous best bound of $\tO(n^{0.19996})$ by Kawarabayashi and Thorup in 2017.

We prove that every cyclically 4-edge-connected cubic graph that can be embedded in the projective plane, with the single exception of the Petersen graph, is 3-edge-colorable. In other words, the only (non-trivial) snark that can be embedded in the projective plane is the Petersen graph. This implies that a 2-connected cubic (multi)graph that can be embedded in the projective plane is not 3-edge-colorable if and only if it can be obtained from the Petersen graph by replacing each vertex by a 2-edge-connected planar cubic (multi)graph. This result is a nontrivial generalization of the Four Color Theorem, and its proof requires a combination of extensive computer verification and computer-free extension of existing proofs on colorability. An unexpected consequence of this result is a coloring-flow duality statement for the projective plane: A cubic graph embedded in the projective plane is 3-edge-colorable if and only if its dual multigraph is 5-vertex-colorable. Moreover, we show that a 2-edge connected graph embedded in the projective plane admits a nowhere-zero 4-flow unless it is Peteren-like (in which case it does not admit nowhere-zero 4-flows). This proves a strengthening of the Tutte 4-flow conjecture for graphs on the projective plane. Some of our proofs require extensive computer verification. The necessary source codes, together with the input and output files and the complete set of more than 6000 reducible configurations are available on Github (https://github.com/edge-coloring) which can be considered as an Addendum to this paper. Moreover, we provide pseudocodes for all our computer verifications.

We prove the existence of a computable function $f\colon\mathbb{N}\to\mathbb{N}$ such that for every integer $k$ and every digraph $D$ either contains a collection $\mathcal{C}$ of $k$ directed cycles of even length such that no vertex of $D$ belongs to more than four cycles in $\mathcal{C}$, or there exists a set $S\subseteq V(D)$ of size at most $f(k)$ such that $D-S$ has no directed cycle of even length. Moreover, we provide an algorithm that finds one of the two outcomes of this statement in time $g(k)n^{\mathcal{O}(1)}$ for some computable function $g\colon \mathbb{N}\to\mathbb{N}$. Our result unites two deep fields of research from the algorithmic theory for digraphs: The study of the Erdős-Pósa property of digraphs and the study of the Even Dicycle Problem. The latter is the decision problem which asks if a given digraph contains an even dicycle and can be traced back to a question of Pólya from 1913. It remained open until a polynomial time algorithm was finally found by Robertson, Seymour, and Thomas (Ann. of Math. (2) 1999) and, independently, McCuaig (Electron. J. Combin. 2004; announced jointly at STOC 1997). The Even Dicycle Problem is equivalent to the recognition problem of Pfaffian bipartite graphs and has applications even beyond discrete mathematics and theoretical computer science. On the other hand, Younger's Conjecture (1973), states that dicycles have the Erdős-Pósa property. The conjecture was proven more than two decades later by Reed, Robertson, Seymour, and Thomas (Combinatorica 1996) and opened the path for structural digraph theory as well as the algorithmic study of the directed feedback vertex set problem. Our approach builds upon the techniques used to resolve both problems and combines them into a powerful structural theorem that yields further algorithmic applications for other prominent problems.