arXiv++ Combinatorics

A bigraph $G$ is weakly norming if the $e(G)$th root of the density of $G$ in $\lvert W\rvert$ is a norm in the space of bounded measurable functions $W\colonΩ\timesΛ\to\mathbb{R}$. The only known technique, due to Conlon--Lee, to show that a bigraph $G$ is weakly norming is to present a cut-percolation sequence of $G$. In this paper, we identify a key obstacle for cut-percolation, which we call fold-stability and we show that existence of a cut-percolating of a bigraph $G$ is equivalent to non-existence of non-monochromatic fold-stable colorings of the edges of $G$.

It is often convenient to represent a process for randomly generating a graph as a graphon. (More precisely, these give \emph{vertex exchangeable} processes -- those processes in which each vertex is treated the same way.) Other structures can be treated by generalizations like hypergraphons, permutatons, and, for a very general class, theons. These representations are not unique: different representations can lead to the same probability distribution on graphs. This naturally leads to questions (going back at least to Hoover's proof of the Aldous--Hoover Theorem on the existence of such representations) that ask when quasirandomness properties on the distribution guarantee the existence of particularly simple representations. We extend the usual theon representation by adding an additional datum of a random permutation to each tuple, which we call a $\ast$-representation. We show that if a process satisfies the \emph{unique coupling} property UCouple[$\ell$], which says roughly that all $\ell$-tuples of vertices ``look the same'', then the process is $\ast$-$\ell$-independent: there is a $\ast$-representation that does not make use of any random information about $\ell$-tuples (including tuples of length $<\ell$). Simple examples show that the use of $\ast$-representations is necessary. This resolves a question of Coregliano and Razborov, since it easily follows that UCouple[l] implies Independence[\ell'] (the existence of an $\ell'$-independent ordinary representation) for $\ell'<\ell$.

The Rado Graph, sometimes also known as the (countable) Random Graph, can be generated almost surely by putting an edge between any pair of vertices with some fixed probability $p \in (0, 1)$, independently of other pairs. In this article, we study the influence of allowing different probabilities for each pair of vertices. More specifically, we characterize for which sequences $(p_n)_{n\in \mathbb{N}}$ of values in $[0, 1]$ there exists a bijection f from pairs of vertices in $\mathbb{N}$ to $\mathbb{N}$ such that if we put an edge between $v$ and $w$ with probability $p_{f(\{v,w\})}$, independently of other pairs, then the Random Graph arises almost surely.

Call a hereditary family $\mathcal{F}$ of graphs strongly persistent if there exists a graphon $W$ such that in all subgraphons $W'$ of $W$, $\mathcal{F}$ is precisely the class of finite graphs that have positive density in $W'$. Our first result is a complete characterization of the hereditary families of graphs that are strongly persistent as precisely those that are closed under substitutions. We call graphons with the self-similarity property above weakly random. A hereditary family $\mathcal{F}$ is said to have the weakly random Erdős--Hajnal property (WR) if every graphon that is a limit of graphs in $\mathcal{F}$ has a weakly random subgraphon. Among families of graphs that are closed under substitutions, we completely characterize the families that belong to WR as those with "few" prime graphs. We also extend some of the results above to structures in finite relational languages by using the theory of theons.

A Sidorenko bigraph is one whose density in a bigraphon $W$ is minimized precisely when $W$ is constant. Several techniques of the literature to prove the Sidorenko property consist of decomposing (typically in a tree decomposition) the bigraph into smaller building blocks with stronger properties. One prominent such technique is that of $N$-decompositions of Conlon--Lee, which uses weakly Hölder (or weakly norming) bigraphs as building blocks. In turn, to obtain weakly Hölder bigraphs, it is typical to use the chain of implications reflection bigraph $\implies$ cut-percolating bigraph $\implies$ weakly Hölder bigraph. In an earlier result by the author with Razborov, we provided a generalization of $N$-decompositions, called reflective tree decompositions, that uses much weaker building blocks, called induced-Sidorenko bigraphs, to also obtain Sidorenko bigraphs. In this paper, we show that "left-sided" versions of the concepts of reflection bigraph and cut-percolating bigraph yield a similar chain of implications: left-reflection bigraph $\implies$ left-cut-percolating bigraph $\implies$ induced-Sidorenko bigraph. We also show that under mild hypotheses, the "left-sided" analogue of the weakly Hölder property (which is also obtained via a similar chain of implications) can be used to improve bounds on another result of Conlon--Lee that roughly says that bigraphs with enough vertices on the right side of each realized degree have the Sidorenko property.

The celebrated Erdős-Hajnal Conjecture says that in any proper hereditary class of finite graphs we are guaranteed to have a clique or anti-clique of size $n^c$, which is a much better bound than the logarithmic size that is provided by Ramsey's Theorem in general. On the other hand, in uncountable cardinalities, the model-theoretic property of stability guarantees a uniform set much larger than the bound provided by the Erdős-Rado Theorem in general. Even though the consequences of stability in the finite have been much studied in the literature, the countable setting seems a priori quite different, namely, in the countably infinite the notion of largeness based on cardinality alone does not reveal any structure as Ramsey's Theorem already provides a countably infinite uniform set in general. In this paper, we show that the natural notion of largeness given by upper density reveals that these phenomena meet in the countable: a countable graph has an almost clique or anti-clique of positive upper density if and only if it has a positive upper density almost stable set. Moreover, this result also extends naturally to countable models of a universal theory in a finite relational language. Our methods explore a connection with the notion of convergence in the theory of limits of dense combinatorial objects, introducing and studying a natural approximate version of the Erdős-Hajnal property that allows for a negligible error in the edges (in general, predicates) but requires linear-sized uniform sets in convergent sequences of models (this is much stronger than what stable regularity can provide as the error is required to go to zero). Finally, surprisingly, we completely characterize all hereditary classes of finite graphs that have this approximate Erdős-Hajnal property. The proof highlights both differences and similarities with the original conjecture.

Sidorenko's Conjecture says that the minimum density of a bigraph $G$ in a bigraphon $W$ of a given edge density is attained when $W$ is a constant function. A consequence of a result by B. Szegedy is that it is enough to show Sidorenko's Conjecture under the further assumption that $W$ is biregular. In this paper, we retrieve this result with a more elementary proof. With this biregularity result and some ideas of its proof, we also obtain simple proofs of several other results related to Sidorenko's Conjecture. Furthermore, we also show that bigraphs that have a special type of tree decomposition, called reflective tree decomposition, satisfy Sidorenko's conjecture. This both unifies and generalizes the notions of strong tree decompositions and $N$-decompositions from the literature.

The theory of quasirandomness has greatly expanded from its inaugural graph theoretical setting to several different combinatorial objects such as hypergraphs, tournaments, permutations, etc. However, these quasirandomness variants have been done in an ad-hoc case-by-case manner. In this paper, we propose three new hierarchies of quasirandomness properties that can be naturally defined for arbitrary combinatorial objects. Our properties are also "natural" in more formal sense: they are preserved by local combinatorial constructions (encoded by open interpretations). We show that our quasirandomness properties have several different but equivalent characterizations that are similar to hypergraph quasirandomness properties. We also prove several implications and separations comparing them to each other and to what has been known for hypergraphs. The main notion explored by our statements and proofs is that of unique coupleability: two limit objects are uniquely coupleable if there is a unique limit object in the combined theory that is an alignment (i.e., a coupling) of these two objects.

The celebrated Erdős--Stone--Simonovits theorem characterizes the asymptotic maximum edge density in $\mathcal{F}$-free graphs as $1 - 1/(χ(\mathcal{F})-1) + o(1)$, where $χ(\mathcal{F})$ is the minimum chromatic number of a graph in $\mathcal{F}$. In Examples 25 and 31 of [L. N. Coregliano and A. A. Razborov. Semantic limits of dense combinatorial objects. Uspekhi Mat. Nauk, 75(4(454)):45-152, 2020], it was shown that this result can be extended to the general setting of graphs with extra structure: the maximum asymptotic density of a graph with extra structure without some induced subgraphs is $1 - 1/(χ(I) - 1) + o(1)$ for an appropriately defined abstract chromatic number $χ(I)$. As the name suggests, the original formula for the abstract chromatic number is so abstract that its (algorithmic) computability was left open. In this paper, we both extend this result to characterize maximum asymptotic density of $t$-cliques in of graphs with extra structure without some induced subgraphs in terms of $χ(I)$ and we present a more concrete formula for $χ(I)$ that allows us to show its computability when both the extra structure and the forbidden subgraphs can be described by a finitely axiomatizable universal first-order theory. Our alternative formula for $χ(I)$ makes use of a partite version of Ramsey's Theorem for structures on first-order relational languages.

The theory of limits of discrete combinatorial objects has been thriving for the last decade or so. The syntactic, algebraic approach to the subject is popularly known as "flag algebras", while the semantic, geometric one is often associated with the name ``graph limits''. The language of graph limits is generally more intuitive and expressible, but a price that one has to pay for it is that it is better suited for the case of ordinary graphs than for more general combinatorial objects. Accordingly, there have been several attempts in the literature, of varying degree of generality, to define limit objects for more complicated combinatorial structures. This paper is another attempt at a workable general theory of dense limit objects. Unlike previous efforts in this direction (with notable exception of [Ashwini Aroskar and James Cummings. Limits, regularity and removal for finite structures. Technical Report arXiv:1412.2014 [math.LO], arXiv e-print, 2014.]), we base our account on the same concepts from the first-order logic and the model theory as in the theory of flag algebras. We show how our definition naturally encompasses a host of previously considered cases (graphons, hypergraphons, digraphons, permutons, posetons, colored graphs, etc.), and we extend the fundamental properties of existence and uniqueness to this more general case. We also give an intuitive general proof of the continuous version of the Induced Removal Lemma based on the completeness theorem for propositional calculus. We capitalize on the notion of an open interpretation that often allows to transfer methods and results from one situation to another. Again, we show that some previous arguments can be quite naturally framed using this language.

We study the density of fixed strongly connected subtournaments on 5 vertices in large tournaments. We determine the maximum density asymptotically for five tournaments as well as unique extremal sequences for each tournament. As a byproduct we also characterize tournaments that are recursive blow-ups of a 3-cycle as tournaments that avoid three specific tournaments of size 5.