arXiv++ Combinatorics

Minimum-degree thresholds ask when excluding a fixed graph $H$ forces a dense graph to admit a simple global description. For each fixed chromatic number, the chromatic threshold has only three possible values. We show that this finite-spectrum phenomenon is special to chromatic threshold: already among $3$-chromatic graphs, both the homomorphism and VC-dimension thresholds have infinite spectra and are nonmonotone under taking induced subgraphs. For complete tripartite graphs with a singleton part, we prove $δ_{\mathrm{hom}}(K_{1,s,t}) \ge \max\left\{\frac13,\frac{s}{1+s+t}\right\}$, with equality for an infinite range of $s,t$; in particular, $δ_{\mathrm{hom}}(K_{1,s,s})=s/(2s+1)$ for every $s\ge2$. More generally, for every $r\ge3$, the value $(r-2)/(r-1)$ is an accumulation point of the homomorphism thresholds of $r$-chromatic graphs. For maximal $H$-free graphs, we determine the VC-dimension threshold of every complete tripartite graph and prove that it is positive for every nonbipartite $H$, yielding in particular the exact value for every odd cycle. We also classify the chromatic threshold under an a priori VC-dimension bound. Together with known blowup-threshold results, our theorems reveal that $δ_χ,δ_{\mathrm{hom}},δ_{\mathrm{VC}}$, and $δ_{\mathrm B}$ are \emph{pairwise distinct}: bounded colorability, homomorphic compressibility, neighborhood complexity, and exact blowup structure are genuinely different forms of global simplicity. The proofs develop random and grid-based obstructions to bounded homomorphic images, saturated gadgets that preserve high VC-dimension under maximal completion, and a core-orientation method for raising minimum degree while preserving $H$-freeness.

In connection to the Brown-Erdős-Sós conjecture, we give a short local averaging proof of a density theorem for linear uniform hypergraphs. Let $r \ge 3$, $k \ge 3$, and suppose that $n \ge (r-2)(k-2)+1$. If $H$ is a linear $r$-uniform hypergraph on $n$ vertices and \[|E(H)| \geq \frac{k-2}{r^2((r-2)(k-2)+1)}n^2 + \frac{n}{r},\] then $H$ contains $k$ edges spanning at most $(r-2)k+3$ vertices. In the standard linear-density normalization, this gives the asymptotic density threshold $c \geq \frac{r-1}{r} \cdot \frac{k-2}{(r-2)(k-2)+1} + o(1)$. In particular, this yields a simple proof of the large-uniformity form of the Brown-Erdős-Sós theorem, due to Keevash and Long. In the case of triple systems, our bound becomes $c \geq \frac{2(k-2)}{3(k-1)} + o(1)$, improving upon a bound of $\frac{4}{5}$ due to Santos and Tyomkyn.

We study the minimum degree threshold $δ_{r,q}$ guaranteeing the existence of $K_r$-tilings of high discrepancy in any $q$-edge-coloring. Balogh, Csaba, Pluhár and Treglown handled the 2-color case, proving that $δ_{r,2} = \frac{r}{r+1}$ for all $r \geq 3$. Here we determine $δ_{r,q}$ for all $q$ large enough, namely $q \geq \binom{r}{2}$. For example, we show that for $r \geq 4$, $δ_{r,q} = \frac{r}{r+1}$ for $\binom{r}{2} \leq q \leq \binom{r+1}{2}$ and $δ_{r,q} = \frac{r-1}{r}$ for $q \geq \binom{r+1}{2}+2$. Thus, $δ_{r,q}$ has a phase transition at $q = \binom{r+1}{2}$, where it drops from $\frac{r}{r+1}$ and then stabilizes at the existence threshold $\frac{r-1}{r}$. We also show that $δ_{r,q} \leq \frac{r}{r+1}$ for all $r,q$, supplementing and giving a new proof for the result of Balogh, Csaba, Pluhár and Treglown.

Given a 2-edge-coloring $f : E(K_n) \rightarrow \{\pm 1\}$, the discrepancy of a subgraph $F \subseteq K_n$ is defined as $\left| \sum_{e \in E(F)} f(e) \right|$. Erdős, Füredi, Loebl and Sós showed that if $F$ is an $n$-vertex tree with maximum degree at most $(1-\varepsilon)n$, then every 2-coloring of $K_n$ has a copy of $F$ with discrepancy $Ω(\varepsilon)n$. We extend this result by showing that the same conclusion holds for every $n$-vertex graph with maximum degree at most $(1-\varepsilon)n$ and no isolated vertices. We also show that for every $d$-regular $n$-vertex graph $F$ with $d \leq (1-\varepsilon)n$, every 2-coloring of $K_n$ has a copy of $F$ with discrepancy $Ω(\sqrt{\varepsilon d}) \cdot n$. The dependence on $d$ and $n$ is best possible. Finally, we consider specific graphs $F$, namely $K_r$-factors and 2-factors. For each such graph $F$, we determine the optimal constant $λ$ such that every 2-coloring of $K_n$ has a copy of $F$ with discrepancy at least $(λ+ o(1))n$.

The study of extremal problems for set mappings has a long history. It was introduced in 1958 by Erdős and Hajnal, who considered the case of cliques in graphs and hypergraphs. Recently, Caro, Patkós, Tuza and Vizer revisited this subject, and initiated the systematic study of set mapping problems for general graphs. In this paper, we prove the following result, which answers one of their questions. Let $G$ be a graph with $m$ edges and no isolated vertices and let $f : E(K_N) \rightarrow E(K_N)$ such that $f(e)$ is disjoint from $e$ for all $e \in E(K_N)$. Then for some absolute constant $C$, as long as $N \geq C m$, there is a copy $G^*$ of $G$ in $K_N$ such that $f(e)$ is disjoint from $V(G^*)$ for all $e \in E(G^*)$. The bound $N = O(m)$ is tight for cliques and is tight up to a logarithmic factor for all $G$.

Property testers are fast, randomized "election polling"-type algorithms that determine if an input (e.g., graph or hypergraph) has a certain property or is $\varepsilon$-far from the property. In the dense graph model of property testing, it is known that many properties can be tested with query complexity that depends only on the error parameter $\varepsilon$ (and not on the size of the input), but the current bounds on the query complexity grow extremely quickly as a function of $1/\varepsilon$. Which properties can be tested efficiently, i.e., with $\mathrm{poly}(1/\varepsilon)$ queries? This survey presents the state of knowledge on this general question, as well as some key open problems.

While Szemerédi's graph regularity lemma is an indispensable tool for studying extremal problems in graph theory, using it comes with a hefty price, since a worst-case graph may only have regular partitions of tower-type size. It is thus sensible to ask if there is some natural restriction which forces graphs to have much smaller regular partitions. A celebrated result of this type, due to Alon-Fischer-Newman and Lovász-Szegedy, states that for graphs of bounded VC dimension, one can reduce the tower-type bounds to polynomial. The graph regularity lemma has been extended to the setting of $k$-graphs by Gowers, Nagle-Rödl-Schacht-Skokan, and Tao. Unfortunately, these lemmas come with even larger Ackermann-type bounds. Chernikov-Starchenko and Fox-Pach-Suk considered a strong notion of $k$-graph VC dimension and proved that $k$-graphs of bounded VC dimension have regular partitions of polynomial size. Shelah introduced a weaker and combinatorially natural notion of dimension, called VC$_2$ dimension, which has since been extensively studied. In particular, Chernikov, Towsner, Terry, and Wolf asked if one can improve the worst case bounds for 3-graph regularity when the 3-graph has bounded VC$_2$ dimension. Our main result in this paper answers this question positively in the following strong sense: in the setting of bounded VC$_2$ dimension, one can reduce the bounds for 3-graph regularity by one level in Ackermann hierarchy. Furthermore, our new bound is best possible. Our proof has two key steps. We first introduce a new method for designing regularity lemmas for graphs of bounded VC dimension, based on the cylinder regularity lemma. We then prove a hypergraph version of the cylinder regularity lemma, which allows us to extend this method to hypergraphs. We also highlight a few other applications of this cylinder regularity lemma, which we expect to find many other uses.

A partition of a (hyper)graph is $\varepsilon$-homogenous if the edge densities between almost all clusters are either at most $\varepsilon$ or at least $1-\varepsilon$. Suppose a $3$-graph has the property that the link of every vertex has an $\varepsilon$-homogenous partition of size $\text{poly}(1/\varepsilon)$. Does this guarantee that the $3$-graph also has a small homogenous partition? Terry and Wolf proved that such a $3$-graph has an $\varepsilon$-homogenous partition of size given by a wowzer-type function. Terry recently improved this to a double exponential bound, and conjectured that this bound is tight. Our first result in this paper disproves this conjecture by giving an improved (single) exponential bound, which is best possible. We further obtain an analogous result for $k$-graphs of all uniformities $k \geq 3$. The above problem is part of a much broader programme which seeks to understand the conditions under which a (hyper)graph has small $\varepsilon$-regular partitions. While this problem is fairly well understood for graphs, the situation is (as always) much more involved already for $3$-graphs. For example, it is natural to ask if one can strengthen our first result by only requiring each link to have $\varepsilon$-regular partitions of size $\text{poly}(1/\varepsilon)$. Our second result shows that surprisingly the answer is `no', namely, a $3$-graph might only have regular partitions of tower-type size, even though the link of every vertex has an $\varepsilon$-regular partition of polynomial size.

The number of spanning trees of a graph $G$, denoted $τ(G)$, is a well studied graph parameter with numerous connections to other areas of mathematics. In a recent remarkable paper, answering a question of Sedláček from 1969, Chan, Kontorovich and Pak showed that $τ(G)$ takes at least $1.1103^n$ different values across simple (and planar) $n$-vertex graphs $G$, for large enough $n$. We give a very short, purely combinatorial proof that at least $1.55^n$ values are attained. We also prove that exponential growth can be achieved with regular graphs, determining the growth rate in another problem first raised by Sedláček in the late 1960's. We further show that the following modular dual version of the result holds. For any integer $N$ and any $u < N$ there exists a planar graph on $O(\log N)$ vertices whose number of spanning trees is $u$ modulo $N$.

In this paper, we initiate the study of discrepancy questions for combinatorial designs. Specifically, we show that, for every fixed $r\ge 3$ and $n\equiv 1,3 \pmod{6}$, any $r$-colouring of the triples on $[n]$ admits a Steiner triple system of order $n$ with discrepancy $Ω(n^2)$. This is not true for $r=2$, but we are able to asymptotically characterise all $2$-colourings which do not contain a Steiner triple system with high discrepancy. The key step in our proofs is a characterization of 3-uniform hypergraphs avoiding a certain natural type of induced subgraphs, contributing to the structural theory of hypergraphs.

For $\ell \geq 3$, an $\ell$-uniform hypergraph is disperse if the number of edges induced by any set of $\ell+1$ vertices is 0, 1, $\ell$ or $\ell+1$. We show that every disperse $\ell$-uniform hypergraph on $n$ vertices contains a clique or independent set of size $n^{Ω_{\ell}(1)}$, answering a question of the first author and Tomon. To this end, we prove several structural properties of disperse hypergraphs.

Confirming a conjecture of Erdős on the chromatic number of Kneser hypergraphs, Alon, Frankl and Lovász proved that in any $q$-colouring of the edges of the complete $r$-uniform hypergraph, there exists a monochromatic matching of size $\lfloor \frac{n+q-1}{r+q-1}\rfloor$. In this paper, we prove a transference version of this theorem. More precisely, for fixed $q$ and $r$, we show that with high probability, a monochromatic matching of approximately the same size exists in any $q$-colouring of a random hypergraph, already when the average degree is a sufficiently large constant. In fact, our main new result is a defect version of the Alon--Frankl--Lovász theorem for almost complete hypergraphs. From this, the transference version is obtained via a variant of the weak hypergraph regularity lemma. The proof of the defect version uses tools from extremal set theory developed in the study of the Erdős matching conjecture.

Many important results in extremal graph theory can be roughly summarised as "if a triangle-free graph $G$ has certain properties, then it has a homomorphism to a triangle-free graph $Γ$ of bounded size". For example, bounds on homomorphism thresholds give such a statement if $G$ has sufficiently high minimum degree, and the approximate homomorphism theorem gives such a statement for all $G$, if one weakens the notion of homomorphism appropriately. In this paper, we study asymmetric versions of these results, where the assumptions on $G$ and $Γ$ need not match. For example, we prove that if $G$ is a graph with odd girth at least $9$ and minimum degree at least $δ|G|$, then $G$ is homomorphic to a triangle-free graph whose size depends only on $δ$. Moreover, the odd girth assumption can be weakened to odd girth at least $7$ if $G$ has bounded VC dimension or bounded domination number. This gives a new and improved proof of a result of Huang et al. We also prove that in the asymmetric approximate homomorphism theorem, the bounds exhibit a rather surprising ``double phase transition'': the bounds are super-exponential if $G$ is only assumed to be triangle-free, they become exponential if $G$ is assumed to have odd girth $7$ or $9$, and become linear if $G$ has odd girth at least $11$. Our proofs use a wide variety of techniques, including entropy arguments, the Frieze--Kannan weak regularity lemma, properties of the generalised Mycielskian construction, and recent work on abundance and the asymmetric removal lemma.

For a fixed graph $F$, let $ex_F(G)$ denote the size of the largest $F$-free subgraph of $G$. Computing or estimating $ex_F(G)$ for various pairs $F,G$ is one of the central problems in extremal combinatorics. It is thus natural to ask how hard is it to compute this function. Motivated by an old problem of Yannakakis from the 80's, Alon, Shapira and Sudakov [ASS'09] proved that for every non-bipartite graph $F$, computing $ex_F(G)$ is NP-hard. Addressing a conjecture of Ailon and Alon (2007), we prove a hypergraph analogue of this theorem, showing that for every $k \geq 3$ and every non-$k$-partite $k$-graph $F$, computing $ex_F(G)$ is NP-hard. Furthermore, we conjecture that our hardness result can be extended to all $k$-graphs $F$ other than a matching of fixed size. If true, this would give a precise characterization of the $k$-graphs $F$ for which computing $ex_F(G)$ is NP-hard, since we also prove that when $F$ is a matching of fixed size, $ex_F(G)$ is computable in polynomial time. This last result can be considered an algorithmic version of the celebrated Erdős-Ko-Rado Theorem. The proof of [ASS'09] relied on a variety of tools from extremal graph theory, one of them being Turán's theorem. One of the main challenges we have to overcome in order to prove our hypergraph extension is the lack of a Turán-type theorem for $k$-graphs. To circumvent this, we develop a completely new graph theoretic approach for proving such hardness results.

The canonical Ramsey theorem of Erdős and Rado implies that for any graph $H$, any edge-coloring (with an arbitrary number of colors) of a sufficiently large complete graph $K_N$ contains a monochromatic, lexicographic, or rainbow copy of $H$. The least such $N$ is called the Erdős-Rado number of $H$, denoted by $ER(H)$. Erdős-Rado numbers of cliques have received considerable attention, and in this paper we extend this line of research by studying Erdős-Rado numbers of sparse graphs. For example, we prove that if $H$ has bounded degree, then $ER(H)$ is polynomial in $|V(H)|$ if $H$ is bipartite, but exponential in general. We also study the closely-related problem of constrained Ramsey numbers. For a given tree $S$ and given path $P_t$, we study the minimum $N$ such that every edge-coloring of $K_N$ contains a monochromatic copy of $S$ or a rainbow copy of $P_t$. We prove a nearly optimal upper bound for this problem, which differs from the best known lower bound by a function of inverse-Ackermann type.

For two graphs $F,H$ and a positive integer $n$, the function $f_{F,H}(n)$ denotes the largest $m$ such that every $H$-free graph on $n$ vertices contains an $F$-free induced subgraph on $m$ vertices. This function has been extensively studied in the last 60 years when $F$ and $H$ are cliques and became known as the Erdős-Rogers function. Recently, Balogh, Chen and Luo, and Mubayi and Verstraëte initiated the systematic study of this function in the case where $F$ is a general graph. Answering, in a strong form, a question of Mubayi and Verstraëte, we prove that for every positive integer $r$ and every $K_{r-1}$-free graph $F$, there exists some $\varepsilon_F>0$ such that $f_{F,K_r}(n)=O(n^{1/2-\varepsilon_F})$. This result is tight in two ways. Firstly, it is no longer true if $F$ contains $K_{r-1}$ as a subgraph. Secondly, we show that for all $r\geq 4$ and $\varepsilon>0$, there exists a $K_{r-1}$-free graph $F$ for which $f_{F,K_r}(n)=Ω(n^{1/2-\varepsilon})$. Along the way of proving this, we show in particular that for every graph $F$ with minimum degree $t$, we have $f_{F,K_4}(n)=Ω(n^{1/2-6/\sqrt{t}})$. This answers (in a strong form) another question of Mubayi and Verstraëte. Finally, we prove that there exist absolute constants $0<c<C$ such that for each $r\geq 4$, if $F$ is a bipartite graph with sufficiently large minimum degree, then $Ω(n^{\frac{c}{\log r}})\leq f_{F,K_r}(n)\leq O(n^{\frac{C}{\log r}})$. This shows that for graphs $F$ with large minimum degree, the behaviour of $f_{F,K_r}(n)$ is drastically different from that of the corresponding off-diagonal Ramsey number $f_{K_2,K_r}(n)$.

The celebrated Erdős-Hajnal conjecture says that any graph without a fixed induced subgraph $H$ contains a very large homogeneous set. A direct analog of this conjecture is not true for hypergraphs. In this paper we present two natural variants of this problem which do hold for hypergraphs. We show that for every $r \geq 3$, $m \geq m_0(r)$ and $0 \leq f \leq \binom{m}{r}$, if an $r$-graph $G$ does not contain $m$ vertices spanning exactly $f$ edges, then $G$ contains much bigger homogeneous sets than what is guaranteed to exist in general $r$-graphs. We also prove that if a $3$-graph $G$ does not contain homogeneous sets of polynomial size, then for every $m \geq 3$ there are $Ω(m^3)$ values of $f$ such that $G$ contains $m$ vertices spanning exactly $f$ edges. This makes progress on a problem of Axenovich, Bradač, Gishboliner, Mubayi and Weber.

In this paper, we study discrepancy questions for spanning subgraphs of $k$-uniform hypergraphs. Our main result is that, for any integers $k \ge 3$ and $r \ge 2$, any $r$-colouring of the edges of a $k$-uniform $n$-vertex hypergraph $G$ with minimum $(k-1)$-degree $δ(G) \ge (1/2+o(1))n$ contains a tight Hamilton cycle with high discrepancy, that is, with at least $n/r+Ω(n)$ edges of one colour. The minimum degree condition is asymptotically best possible and our theorem also implies a corresponding result for perfect matchings. Our tools combine various structural techniques such as Turán-type problems and hypergraph shadows with probabilistic techniques such as random walks and the nibble method. We also propose several intriguing problems for future research.

Many well-studied problems in extremal combinatorics deal with the maximum possible size of a family of objects in which every pair of objects satisfies a given restriction. One problem of this type was recently raised by Alon, Gujgiczer, Körner, Milojević and Simonyi. They asked to determine the maximum size of a family $\mathcal{G}$ of graphs on $[n]$, such that for every two $G_1,G_2 \in \mathcal{G}$, the graphs $G_1 \setminus G_2$ and $G_2 \setminus G_1$ are isomorphic. We completely resolve this problem by showing that this maximum is exactly $2^{\frac{1}{2}\big(\binom{n}{2} - \lfloor \frac{n}{2}\rfloor\big)}$ and characterizing all the extremal constructions. We also prove an analogous result for $r$-uniform hypergraphs.