arXiv++ Combinatorics

Thomassen proved that every planar graph $G$ on $n$ vertices has at least $2^{n/9}$ distinct $L$-colorings if $L$ is a 5-list-assignment for $G$ and at least $2^{n/10000}$ distinct $L$-colorings if $L$ is a 3-list-assignment for $G$ and $G$ has girth at least five. Postle and Thomas proved that if $G$ is a graph on $n$ vertices embedded on a surface $Σ$ of genus $g$, then there exist constants $ε,c_g > 0$ such that if $G$ has an $L$-coloring, then $G$ has at least $c_g2^{εn}$ distinct $L$-colorings if $L$ is a 5-list-assignment for $G$ or if $L$ is a 3-list-assignment for $G$ and $G$ has girth at least five. More generally, they proved that there exist constants $ε,α>0$ such that if $G$ is a graph on $n$ vertices embedded in a surface $Σ$ of fixed genus $g$, $H$ is a proper subgraph of $G$, and $φ$ is an $L$-coloring of $H$ that extends to an $L$-coloring of $G$, then $φ$ extends to at least $2^{ε(n - α(g + |V(H)|))}$ distinct $L$-colorings of $G$ if $L$ is a 5-list-assignment or if $L$ is a 3-list-assignment and $G$ has girth at least five. We prove the same result if $G$ is triangle-free and $L$ is a 4-list-assignment of $G$, where $ε=\frac{1}{8}$, and $α= 130$.

Kostochka and Yancey proved that every 5-critical graph G satisfies: |E(G)|>= (9/4)|V(G)| - 5/4. A construction of Ore gives an infinite family of graphs meeting this bound. We prove that there exists e,d > 0 such that if G is a 5-critical graph, then |E(G)| >= (9/4 + e)|V(G)|- 5/4 - dT(G), where T(G) is the maximum number of vertex-disjoint cliques of size three or four where cliques of size four have twice the weight of a clique of size three. As a corollary, a triangle-free 5-critical graph G satisfies: |E(G)|>=(9/4 + e)|V(G)| - 5/4.

Given a configuration of pebbles on the vertices of a connected graph $G$, a \emph{pebbling move} removes two pebbles from some vertex and places one pebble on an adjacent vertex. The \emph{pebbling number} of a graph $G$ is the smallest integer $k$ such that for each vertex $v$ and each configuration of $k$ pebbles on $G$ there is a sequence of pebbling moves that places at least one pebble on $v$. First, we improve on results of Hurlbert, who introduced a linear optimization technique for graph pebbling. In particular, we use a different set of weight functions, based on graphs more general than trees. We apply this new idea to some graphs from Hurlbert's paper to give improved bounds on their pebbling numbers. Second, we investigate the structure of Class 0 graphs with few edges. We show that every $n$-vertex Class 0 graph has at least $\frac53n - \frac{11}3$ edges. This disproves a conjecture of Blasiak et al. For diameter 2 graphs, we strengthen this lower bound to $2n - 5$, which is best possible. Further, we characterize the graphs where the bound holds with equality and extend the argument to obtain an identical bound for diameter 2 graphs with no cut-vertex.

We introduce a new variant of graph coloring called correspondence coloring which generalizes list coloring and allows for reductions previously only possible for ordinary coloring. Using this tool, we prove that excluding cycles of lengths 4 to 8 is sufficient to guarantee 3-choosability of a planar graph, thus answering a question of Borodin.

We prove a conjecture of Dvořák, Král, Nejedlý, and Škrekovski that planar graphs of girth at least five are square $(Δ+2)$-colorable for large enough $Δ$. In fact, we prove the stronger statement that such graphs are square $(Δ+2)$-choosable and even square $(Δ+2)$-paintable.

Let $G$ be a plane graph with outer cycle $C$ and let $(L(v):v\in V(G))$ be a family of sets such that $|L(v)|\ge 5$ for every $v\in V(G)$. By an $L$-coloring of a subgraph $J$ of $G$ we mean a (proper) coloring $φ$ of $J$ such that $φ(v)\in L(v)$ for every vertex $v$ of $J$. We prove a conjecture of Dvorak et al. that if $H$ is a minimal subgraph of $G$ such that $C$ is a subgraph of $H$ and every $L$-coloring of $C$ that extends to an $L$-coloring of $H$ also extends to an $L$-coloring of $G$, then $|V(H)|\le 19|V(C)|$. This is a lemma that plays an important role in subsequent papers, because it motivates the study of graphs embedded in surfaces that satisfy an isoperimetric inequality suggested by this result. Such study turned out to be quite profitable for the subject of list coloring graphs on surfaces.

A graph G is 5/2-critical if G has no circular 5/2-coloring (or equivalently, homomorphism to C_5), but every proper subgraph of G has one. We prove that every 5/2-critical graph on n>=4 vertices has at least (5n-2)/4 edges, and list all 5/2-critical graphs achieving this bound. This implies that every planar or projective-planar graph of girth at least 10 is 5/2-colorable.

We prove that if G is a 4-critical graph of girth at least five then |E(G)|>=(5|V(G)|+2)/3. As a corollary, graphs of girth at least five embeddable in the Klein bottle or torus are 3-colorable. These are results of Thomas and Walls, and Thomassen respectively. The proof uses the new potential technique developed by Kostochka and Yancey who proved that 4-critical graphs satisfy: |E(G)|>=(5|V(G)|-2)/3.

Dirac introduced the notion of a k-critical graph, a graph that is not (k-1)-colorable but whose every proper subgraph is (k-1)-colorable. Brook's Theorem states that every graph with maximum degree k is k-colorable unless it contains a subgraph isomorphic to K_{k+1} (or an odd cycle for k=2). Equivalently, for all k>=4, the only k-critical graph of maximum degree k-1 is K_k. A natural generalization of Brook's theorem is to consider the Ore-degree of a graph, which is the maximum of d(u)+d(v) over all edges uv. Kierstead and Kostochka proved that for all k>=6 the only k-critical graph with Ore-degree at most 2k-1 is K_k. Kostochka, Rabern and Steibitz proved that the only 5-critical graphs with Ore-degree at most 9 are K_5 and a graph they called O_5. A different generalization of Brook's theorem, motivated by Hajos' construction, is Gallai's conjectured bound on the minimum density of a k-critical graph. Recently, Kostochka and Yancey proved Gallai's conjecture. Their proof for k>=5 implies the above results on Ore-degree. However, the case for k=4 remains open, which is the subject of this paper. Kostochka and Yancey's short but beautiful proof for the case k=4 says that if $G$ is a $4$-critical graph, then |E(G)|>= (5|V(G)|-2)/3. We prove the following bound which is better when there exists a large independent set of degree three vertices: if G is a 4-critical graph G, then |E(G)|>= 1.6 |V(G)| + .2 alpha(D_3(G)) - .6, where D_3(G) is the graph induced by the degree three vertices of G. As a corollary, we characterize the 4-critical graphs with Ore-degree at most seven as precisely the graphs of Ore-degree seven in the family of graphs obtained from K_4 and Ore compositions.

Let G be a plane graph with outer cycle C, let u,v be vertices of C and let (L(x):x in V(G)) be a family of sets such that |L(u)|=|L(v)|=2, L(x) has at least three elements for every vertex x of C-{u,v} and L(x) has at least five elements for every vertex x of G-V(C). We prove a conjecture of Hutchinson that G has a (proper) coloring f such that f(x) belongs to L(x) for every vertex x of G. We will use this as a lemma in subsequent papers.

We answer positively the question of Albertson asking whether every planar graph can be $5$-list-colored even if it contains precolored vertices, as long as they are sufficiently far apart from each other. In order to prove this claim, we also give bounds on the sizes of graphs critical with respect to 5-list coloring. In particular, if G is a planar graph, H is a connected subgraph of G and L is an assignment of lists of colors to the vertices of G such that |L(v)| >= 5 for every v in V(G)-V(H) and G is not L-colorable, then G contains a subgraph with O(|H|^2) vertices that is not L-colorable.

We exhibit an explicit list of nine graphs such that a graph drawn in the Klein bottle is 5-colorable if and only if it has no subgraph isomorphic to a member of the list.

Generalizing a well known theorem for finite matroids, we prove that for every (infinite) connected matroid M there is a unique tree T such that the nodes of T correspond to minors of M that are either 3-connected or circuits or cocircuits, and the edges of T correspond to certain nested 2-separations of M. These decompositions are invariant under duality.

Thomassen conjectured that every triangle-free planar graph on n vertices has exponentially many 3-colorings, and proved that it has at least 2^[n^(1/12)/20000] distinct 3-colorings. We show that it has at least 2^sqrt(n/362) distinct 3-colorings.