arXiv++ Combinatorics

Motivated by the famous Hadwiger's Conjecture, we study the properties of $8$-contraction-critical graphs with no $K_7$ minor; we prove that every $8$-contraction-critical graph with no $K_7$ minor has at most one vertex of degree $8$, where a graph $G$ is $8$-contraction-critical if $G$ is not $7$-colorable but every proper minor of $G$ is $7$-colorable. This is one step in our effort to prove that every graph with no $K_7$ minor is $7$-colorable, which remains open.

Let $G$ be a plane graph with $C$ the boundary of the outer face and let $(L(v):v\in V(G))$ be a family of non-empty sets. By an $L$-coloring of a subgraph $J$ of $G$ we mean a (proper) coloring $φ$ of $J$ such that $φ(v)\in L(v)$ for every vertex $v$ of $J$. Thomassen proved that if $v_1,v_2\in V(C)$ are adjacent, $L(v_1)\ne L(v_2)$, $|L(v)|\ge3$ for every $v\in V(C)\setminus \{v_1,v_2\}$ and $|L(v)|\ge5$ for every $v\in V(G)\setminus V(C)$, then $G$ has an $L$-coloring. As one final application in this last part of our series on $5$-list-coloring, we derive from all of our theory a far-reaching generalization of Thomassen's theorem, namely the generalization of Thomassen's theorem to arbitrarily many such faces provided that the faces are pairwise distance $D$ apart for some universal constant $D>0$.

A cornerstone theorem in the Graph Minors series of Robertson and Seymour is the result that every graph $G$ with no minor isomorphic to a fixed graph $H$ has a certain structure. The structure can then be exploited to deduce far-reaching consequences. The exact statement requires some explanation, but roughly it says that there exist integers $k,n$ depending on $H$ only such that $0<k<n$ and for every $n\times n$ grid minor $J$ of $G$ the graph $G$ has a a $k$-near embedding in a surface $Σ$ that does not embed $H$ in such a way that a substantial part of $J$ is embedded in $Σ$. Here a $k$-near embedding means that after deleting at most $k$ vertices the graph can be drawn in $Σ$ without crossings, except for local areas of non-planarity, where crossings are permitted, but at most $k$ of these areas are attached to the rest of the graph by four or more vertices and inside those the graph is constrained in a different way, again depending on the parameter $k$. The original and only proof so far is quite long and uses many results developed in the Graph Minors series. We give a proof that uses only our earlier paper [A new proof of the flat wall theorem, {\it J.~Combin.\ Theory Ser.\ B \bf 129} (2018), 158--203] and results from graduate textbooks. Our proof is constructive and yields a polynomial time algorithm to construct such a structure. We also give explicit constants for the structure theorem, whereas the original proof only guarantees the existence of such constants.

It is known that $A$-paths of length $0$ mod $m$ satisfy the Erdős-Pósa property if $m=2$ or $m=4$, but not if $m > 4$ is composite. We show that if $p$ is prime, then $A$-paths of length $0$ mod $p$ satisfy the Erdős-Pósa property. More generally, in the framework of undirected group-labelled graphs, we characterize the abelian groups $Γ$ and elements $\ell \in Γ$ for which the Erdős-Pósa property holds for $A$-paths of weight $\ell$.

We prove a refinement of the flat wall theorem of Robertson and Seymour to undirected group-labelled graphs $(G,γ)$ where $γ$ assigns to each edge of an undirected graph $G$ an element of an abelian group $Γ$. As a consequence, we prove that $Γ$-nonzero cycles (cycles whose edges sum to a non-identity element of $Γ$) satisfy the half-integral Erdős-Pósa property, and we also recover a result of Wollan that, if $Γ$ has no element of order two, then $Γ$-nonzero cycles satisfy the Erdős-Pósa property. As another application, we prove that if $m$ is an odd prime power, then cycles of length $\ell \mod m$ satisfy the Erdős-Pósa property for all integers $\ell$. This partially answers a question of Dejter and Neumann-Lara from 1987 on characterizing all such integer pairs $(\ell,m)$.

Robertson and Seymour's celebrated Graph Minor Theorem states that graphs are well-quasi-ordered by the minor relation. Unlike the minor relation, the topological minor relation does not well-quasi-order graphs in general. Among all known infinite antichains with respect to the topological containment, subdivisions of a graph obtained from an arbitrarily long path by duplicating each edge can be found. In the 1980's Robertson conjectured that this is the only obstruction. Formally, he conjectured that for every positive integer $k$, graphs that do not contain the graph obtained from a path of length $k$ by duplicating each edge as a topological minor are well-quasi-ordered by the topological minor relation. The case $k=1$ implies Kruskal's Tree Theorem, and the case $k=2$ implies a conjecture of Vázsonyi on subcubic graphs. This series of papers dedicates a proof of Robertson's conjecture. We prove Robertson's conjecture for graphs of bounded tree-width in this paper. It is an essential step toward the complete proof of Robertson's conjecture, and the machinery developed in this paper will be applied in future papers of the series. This bounded tree-width case proved in this paper implies all known results about well-quasi-ordering graphs by the topological minor relation that can be proved without using the Graph Minor Theorem, and our proof in this paper is self-contained.

A brick is a 3-connected graph such that the graph obtained from it by deleting any two distinct vertices has a perfect matching. A brick is minimal if for every edge e the deletion of e results in a graph that is not a brick. We prove a generation theorem for minimal bricks and two corollaries: (1) for n>4, every minimal brick on 2n vertices has at most 5n-7 edges, and (2) every minimal brick has at least three vertices of degree three.

We prove two results: 1. A graph $G$ on at least seven vertices with a vertex $v$ such that $G-v$ is planar and $t$ triangles satisfies $|E(G)| \leq 3|V(G)|- 9 + t/3$. 2. For $p=2,3,\ldots,9$, a triangle-free graph $G$ on at least $2p-5$ vertices with no $K_p$-minor satisfies $|E(G)|\leq (p-2)|V(G)| - (p-2)^2$.

Let $P$ be a graph with a vertex $v$ such that $P\backslash v$ is a forest, and let $Q$ be an outerplanar graph. We prove that there exists a number $p=p(P,Q)$ such that every 2-connected graph of path-width at least $p$ has a minor isomorphic to $P$ or $Q$. This result answers a question of Seymour and implies a conjecture of Marshall and Wood. The proof is based on a new property of tree-decompositions.

Let $G=(V,E)$ be a finite undirected graph. If $P$ is an oriented path from $r_1\in V$ to $r_2\in V$, we define $\partial(P) = r_2-r_1$. If $R, S\subseteq V$, we denote by $P(G; R, S)$ the span of the set of all $\partial P\otimes \partial Q$ with $P$ and $Q$ disjoint oriented paths of $G$ connecting vertices in $R$ and $S$, respectively. By $L(R, S)$, we denote the submodule of $\mathbb{Z}\langle R\rangle\otimes\mathbb{Z}\langle S\rangle$ consisting all $\sum_{r\in R, s\in S} c(r,s)r\otimes s$ such that $c(r,r) = 0$ for all $r\in R\cap S$, $\sum_{r\in R} c(r, s) = 0$ for all $s\in S$, and $\sum_{s\in S} c(r, s) = 0$ for all $r\in R$. In this paper, we provide, when $G$ is sufficiently connected, characterizations when $P(G; R, S)$ is a proper subset of $L(R, S)$.

We prove that if a graph has a tree-decomposition of width at most w, then it has a tree-decomposition of width at most w with certain desirable properties. We will use this result in a subsequent paper to show that every 2-connected graph of large path-width has a minor isomorphic to either a large tree with a vertex attached to every vertex of the tree or a large outerplanar graph.

Let $G=(V,E)$ be a finite undirected graph. Orient the edges of $G$ in an arbitrary way. A $2$-cycle on $G$ is a function $d : E^2\to \mathbb{Z}$ such for each edge $e$, $d(e, \cdot)$ and $d(\cdot, e)$ are circulations on $G$, and $d(e, f) = 0$ whenever $e$ and $f$ have a common vertex. We show that each $2$-cycle is a sum of three special types of $2$-cycles: cycle-pair $2$-cycles, Kuratowski $2$-cycles, and quad $2$-cycles. In case that the graph is Kuratowski connected, we show that each $2$-cycle is a sum of cycle-pair $2$-cycles and at most one Kuratowski $2$-cycle. Furthermore, if $G$ is Kuratowski connected, we characterize when every Kuratowski $2$-cycle is a sum of cycle-pair $2$-cycles. A $2$-cycles $d$ on $G$ is skew-symmetric if $d(e,f) = -d(f,e)$ for all edges $e,f\in E$. We show that each $2$-cycle is a sum of two special types of skew-symmetric $2$-cycles: skew-symmetric cycle-pair $2$-cycles and skew-symmetric quad $2$-cycles. In case that the graph is Kuratowski connected, we show that each skew-symmetric $2$-cycle is a sum of skew-symmetric cycle-pair $2$-cycles. Similar results like this had previously been obtained by one of the authors for symmetric $2$-cycles. Symmetric $2$-cycles are $2$-cycles $d$ such that $d(e,f)=d(f,e)$ for all edges $e,f\in E$.

An embedding of a graph in $3$-space is linkless if for every two disjoint cycles there exists an embedded ball that contains one of the cycles and is disjoint from the other. We prove that every bipartite linklessly embeddable (simple) graph on $n\ge5$ vertices has at most $3n-10$ edges, unless it is isomorphic to the complete bipartite graph $K_{3,n-3}$.

We prove an ear-decomposition theorem for $4$-edge-connected graphs and use it to prove that for every $4$-edge-connected graph $G$ and every $r\in V(G)$, there is a set of four spanning trees of $G$ with the following property. For every vertex in $G$, the unique paths back to $r$ in each tree are edge-disjoint. Our proof implies a polynomial-time algorithm for constructing the trees.

Let $G$ be a graph embedded in a fixed surface $Σ$ of genus $g$ and let $L=(L(v):v\in V(G))$ be a collection of lists such that either each list has size at least five, or each list has size at least four and $G$ is triangle-free, or each list has size at least three and $G$ has no cycle of length four or less. An $L$-coloring of $G$ is a mapping $φ$ with domain $V(G)$ such that $φ(v)\in L(v)$ for every $v\in V(G)$ and $φ(v)\neφ(u)$ for every pair of adjacent vertices $u,v\in V(G)$. We prove * if every non-null-homotopic cycle in $G$ has length $Ω(\log g)$, then $G$ has an $L$-coloring, * if $G$ does not have an $L$-coloring, but every proper subgraph does ("$L$-critical graph"), then $|V(G)|=O(g)$, * if every non-null-homotopic cycle in $G$ has length $Ω(g)$, and a set $X\subseteq V(G)$ of vertices that are pairwise at distance $Ω(1)$ is precolored from the corresponding lists, then the precoloring extends to an $L$-coloring of $G$, * if every non-null-homotopic cycle in $G$ has length $Ω(g)$, and the graph $G$ is allowed to have crossings, but every two crossings are at distance $Ω(1)$, then $G$ has an $L$-coloring, and * if $G$ has at least one $L$-coloring, then it has at least $2^{Ω(|V(G)|)}$ distinct $L$-colorings. We show that the above assertions are consequences of certain isoperimetric inequalities satisfied by $L$-critical graphs, and we study the structure of families of embedded graphs that satisfy those inequalities. It follows that the above assertions hold for other coloring problems, as long as the corresponding critical graphs satisfy the same inequalities.

Let $G$ be a plane graph with outer cycle $C$ and let $(L(v):v\in V(G))$ be a family of non-empty sets. By an $L$-coloring of $G$ we mean a (proper) coloring $φ$ of $G$ such that $φ(v)\in L(v)$ for every vertex $v$ of $G$. Thomassen proved that if $v_1,v_2\in V(C)$ are adjacent, $L(v_1)\ne L(v_2)$, $|L(v)|\ge3$ for every $v\in V(C)-\{v_1,v_2\}$ and $|L(v)|\ge5$ for every $v\in V(G)-V(C)$, then $G$ has an $L$-coloring. What happens when $v_1$ and $v_2$ are not adjacent? Then an $L$-coloring need not exist, but in the first paper of this series we have shown that it exists if $|L(v_1)|,|L(v_2)|\ge2$. Here we characterize when an $L$-coloring exists if $|L(v_1)|\ge1$ and $|L(v_2)|\ge2$. This result is a lemma toward a more general theorem along the same lines, which we will use to prove that minimally non-$L$-colorable planar graphs with two precolored cycles of bounded length are of bounded size. The latter result has a number of applications which we pursue elsewhere.

Gyori and Lovasz independently proved the following beautiful theorem. Let $k\ge2$ be an integer, let $G$ be a $k$-connected graph on $n$ vertices, let $v_1,v_2,\ldots,v_k$ be distinct vertices of $G$ and let $n_1,n_2,\ldots,n_k$ be positive integers with $n_1+n_2+\cdots+n_k=n$. Then $G$ has disjoint connected subgraphs $G_1,G_2,\ldots,G_k$ such that for $i=1,2,\ldots,k$ the graph $G_i$ has $n_i$ vertices and $v_i\in V(G_i)$. We give a self-contained exposition of Gyori's proof.

We give a linear-time algorithm to decide 3-colorability of a triangle-free graph embedded in a fixed surface, and a quadratic-time algorithm to output a 3-coloring in the affirmative case. The algorithms also allow to prescribe the coloring of a bounded number of vertices.

In [Directed tree-width, J. Combin. Theory Ser. B 82 (2001), 138-154] we introduced the notion of tree-width of directed graphs and presented a conjecture, formulated during discussions with Noga Alon and Bruce Reed, stating that a digraph of huge tree-width has a large "cylindrical grid" minor. Here we prove the conjecture for planar digraphs, but many steps of the proof work in general. This is an unedited and unpolished manuscript from October 2001. Since many people asked for copies we are making it available in the hope that it may be useful. The conjecture was proved by Kawarabayashi and Kreutzer in arXiv:1411.5681.

We give a linear-time algorithm to decide 3-colorability (and find a 3-coloring, if it exists) of quadrangulations of a fixed surface. The algorithm also allows to prescribe the coloring for a bounded number of vertices.