arXiv++ Combinatorics

A difference set with parameters $(v, k, λ)$ is a subset $D$ of cardinality $k$ in a finite group $G$ of order $v$, such that the number $λ$ of occurrences of $g \in G$ as the ratio $d^{-1}d'$ in distinct pairs $(d, d')\in D\times D$ is independent of $g$. We prove the nonexistence of $(120, 35, 10)$-difference sets, which has been an open problem for 70 years since Bruck introduced the notion of nonabelian difference sets. Our main tools are 1. a generalization of the category of finite groups to that of association schemes (actually, to that of relation partitions), 2. a generalization of difference sets to equi-distributed functions and its preservation by pushouts along quotients, 3. reduction to a linear programming in the nonnegative integer lattice with quadratic constraints.

A wreath product is a method to construct an association scheme from two association schemes. We determine the automorphism group of a wreath product. We show a known result that a wreath product is Schurian if and only if both components are Schurian, which yields large families of non-Schurian association schemes and non-Schurian $S$-rings. We also study iterated wreath products. Kernel schemes by Martin and Stinson are shown to be iterated wreath products of class-one association schemes. The iterated wreath products give examples of projective systems of non-Schurian association schemes, with an explicit description of primitive idempotents.

We show that taking the set of primitive idempotents of commutative association schemes is a functor from the category of commutative association schemes with surjective morphisms to the category of finite sets with surjective partial functions. We then consider projective systems of commutative association schemes consisting of surjections (which we call profinite association schemes), for which Bose-Mesner algebra is defined, and describe a Delsarte theory on such schemes. This is another method for generalizing association schemes to those on infinite sets, related with the approach by Barg and Skriganov. Relation with $(t,m,s)$-nets and $(t,s)$-sequences is studied. We reprove some of the results of Martin-Stinson from this viewpoint.

Let $\mathcal C$ be the category of finite graphs. Lovàsz shows that the semi-ring of isomorphism classes of $\mathcal C$ (with coproduct as sum, and product as multiplication) is embedded into the direct product of the semi-ring of natural numbers. Our aim is to generalize this result to other categories. For this, one crucial property is that every object decomposes to a finite coproduct of connected objects. We show that a locally-finite extensive category satisfies this condition. Conversely, a category where any object is decomposed into a finite coproduct of connected objects is shown to be extensive. The decomposition turns out to be unique. Using these results, we give some sufficient conditions that the semi-ring (the ring) of isomorphism classes of a locally finite category embeds to the direct product of natural numbers (integers, respectively). Such a construction of rings from a category is a most primitive form of Burnside rings and Grothendieck rings.

Let ${\mathcal C}$ be the category of finite graphs. Lovàsz (1967) shows that if $|\mathrm{Hom}(X,A)|=|\mathrm{Hom}(X,B)|$ holds for any $X$, then $A$ is isomorphic to $B$. Pultr (1973) gives a categorical generalization using a similar argument. Both proofs assume that each object has a finite number of isomorphism classes of subobjects. Generalizations without this assumption are given by Dawar, Jakl, and Reggio (2021) and Regio (2021). Here another generalization without this assumption is given, with a shorter proof. Examples of categories are given, for which our theorem is applicable, but the existing theorems are not.

Let $G$ be a finite group and $f:G \to {\mathbb C}$ be a function. For a non-empty finite subset $Y\subset G$, let $I_Y(f)$ denote the average of $f$ over $Y$. Then, $I_G(f)$ is the average of $f$ over $G$. Using the decomposition of $f$ into irreducible components of ${\mathbb C}^G$ as a representation of $G\times G$, we define non-negative real numbers $V(f)$ and $D(Y)$, each depending only on $f$, $Y$, respectively, such that an inequality of the form $|I_G(f)-I_Y(f)|\leq V(f)\cdot D(Y)$ holds. We give a lower bound of $D(Y)$ depending only on $\#Y$ and $\#G$. We show that the lower bound is achieved if and only if $\#\{(x,y)\in Y^2 \mid x^{-1}y \in [a]\}/\#[a]$ is independent of the choice of the conjugacy class $[a]\subset G$ for $a \neq 1$. We call such a $Y\subset G$ as a pre-difference set in $G$, since the condition is satisfied if $Y$ is a difference set. If $G$ is abelian, the condition is equivalent to that $Y$ is a difference set. We found a non-trivial pre-difference set in the dihedral group of order 16, where no non-trivial difference set exists. The pre-difference sets in non-abelian groups of order 16 are classified. A generalization to commutative association schemes is also given.